JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Canberra student 'collateral damage' in ambassador's expulsion

Date

Staff reporters

Expelled ... Syrian charg d'affaires Jawdat Ali has until 4pm today to leave Australia.

Expelled ... Syrian charg d'affaires Jawdat Ali has until 4pm today to leave Australia. Photo: Andrew Meares

The daughter of expelled Syrian charge d'affaires to Australia Jawdat Ali was effectively thrown out of the country just months before she completed her Year 12 certificate and is  "collateral damage", her teacher says.

The 17-year-old has spent the past four years in Canberra schools, but flew out of city at 5pm today despite one of her teachers making an impassioned plea to the Australian government to allow her to remain in Australia to finish her education. They family is scheduled to fly out of Sydney tonight.

She had to leave because Australia joined an international diplomatic offensive to protest against the Syrian regime's brutal crackdown on civilians earlier this week, delivering a 72-hour ultimatum for the country's top envoy - her father - to leave Australia.

Empty ... the Syrian Embassy was seemingly vacated immediately after the order to leave was given.

Empty ... the Syrian Embassy was seemingly vacated immediately after the order to leave was given. Photo: Penny Bradfield

Canberra College teacher Judy Talberg told ABC radio this morning that the school community has asked Foreign Minister Bob Carr to grant Mr Ali's daughter an exemption from the expulsion so that she can finish her education in Canberra.

"She's 17, nearly 18, she's a few months away from finishing her Year 12 certificate as well as she's already registered for the International Baccalaureate exam," Ms Talberg said.

Mr Ali's daughter has been studying in Canberra for the past four years, at Melrose High and Canberra College.

Diplomatic offensive ... Foreign Minister Bob Carr has been asked to grant the Syrian ambassador's daughter an exemption.

Diplomatic offensive ... Foreign Minister Bob Carr has been asked to grant the Syrian ambassador's daughter an exemption. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

"The majority of her education has been done in Australia. She won't be able to fit into a school in Syria," Ms Talberg said

"It's absolutely tragic that she will not be able to continue on her education."

A spokesman for Senator Carr said the expulsion applied to all members of Mr Ali’s family, because their visas were dependent on his. While a family member of an Israeli ambassador had been allowed to stay for six months after that diplomat was expelled in 2010, the spokesman said there had been no request from Mr Ali’s family for his daughter to be allowed to stay. The spokesman could not say whether a request would have been granted, but said diplomats’ family members had also been forced to leave in a number of other countries, too, after the international push to expel Syrian ambassadors earlier this week.

He said Australians were appalled at the massacres in Syria and the expulsions were a method for the international community to express that outrage.

Ms Talberg said the school community had rallied behind the girl in their attempts to gain an exemption, with classmates' families offering to host her, and the ACT education department willing to make her an international student.

Ms Talberg said the request for an exemption for the girl had been denied.

"Everybody's been in tears," Ms Talberg said. "I don't see how this collateral damage ... is going to make any difference to [Syrian President Bashar] al-Assad."

Her school principal, John Stenhouse, said she had a large group of friends and was a model student, ‘‘one that we are very proud of’’.

The school was trying to support her, without making any comment on the situation in Syria or the diplomatic issues around it, Mr Stenhouse said.

"Other people are better qualified to handle that. Our point of view is that it is a talented young woman who this time last week was on track to finish school with a very promising future in tertiary education and that has now disappeared," he said.

She now looked likely to miss out on completing her studies, her school formal and her graduation. 

 

Her father was given until 5pm today to leave Australia, and they began their journey out of the county then.

The rare move to cut official ties followed the worst violence in the year-long conflict, after more than 100 civilians - including women and children - were massacred when government troops shelled the city of Houla.

"Australians have seen the bodies in Houla and they're appalled," Senator Carr said earlier.

"Appalled that a regime could connive in or organise the execution, the killing, of men, women and children."

Mr Ali was understood to have been grimly resigned after the expulsion order was given but not surprised.

The decision to boot out Syria's two diplomats in Canberra is the strongest measure Australia can take, with no embassy in Damascus to withdraw Australia's representative from.

118 comments

  • While I have sympathy for the girls educational outcome, it's nothing compared to the slaughter.

    A message needs to be sent to Assad in Syria, I'm afraid she is part of that non-violent message.

    Commenter
    yobbo
    Date and time
    June 01, 2012, 9:56AM
    • agree totally. mesage must be sent however perhaps showing we can admit when we are wrong would be a good example.

      Commenter
      Philanthropist
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 10:40AM
    • Sure, what's happening in Syria is bad. Pity, as a lovely place. But the kid's not responsible for it. Is all very fine to say 'they' should do this or that with her. We have a tendency to be a lot more hard-ass when we can hide behind bureaucrats. Bottom-line is: if you personally had the choice to let her stay, would you be prepared to be the one putting her on the plane ...? You prepared to perpetuate the persecution of innocents?

      Commenter
      Enough
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 11:21AM
    • Her teacher should be appealing to the N.S.W. Education authorities to have her finish her schooling online.

      Commenter
      J. Fraser
      Location
      Queensland
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 11:35AM
    • I completely disagree. Of course a strong message needs to be sent, that's why her father and diplomats all around the world are being thrown out. They are clearly instruments of a brutal government. But she should be allowed to stay and finish her schooling, then she can leave.

      Commenter
      Casper
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 11:38AM
    • TOTALLY AGREE. How on earth could we compare the slaughter of innocents with a few months schooling??? Good grief we have lost all sense of proportion.

      Commenter
      luke r
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 11:52AM
    • I agree with yobbo. I feel for the girl but the inconvenience of changing schools is nothing compared to what is going on in Syria. Her father, being a part of the Syrian regime, is tainted and they must leave Australia immediately.

      Ian, we're talking about her leaving the country with her family. It's not quite the same thing as what is happening to the people of Syria. I changed schools many, many times due to my father's work and I'm fine.

      Commenter
      CateO
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 11:59AM
    • Enough....her parents are part of the stinking regime that is killing civilians every week.........how many of her compatriots get these opportunities? Oh that's right, they don't as they are being slaughtered by the same regime, so she isn't really "collateral damage", just ask the mothers mourning the loss of their children what collateral damage really is, and in my book its not missing out on year 12 exams........simple way to stop it.......Assad steps down........

      Commenter
      shemp
      Location
      melb
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 12:00PM
    • @Enough - "Bottom-line is: if you personally had the choice to let her stay, would you be prepared to be the one putting her on the plane"

      Putting her on the plane with her family? Yes, I would do that without a moment's hesitation.

      Commenter
      CateO
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 12:00PM
    • I disagree with yobbo....I have no sympathy for a few months out of one girl's education in this situation. I can't believe this is even a story.

      Commenter
      Pete
      Location
      Marcoola
      Date and time
      June 01, 2012, 12:29PM

More comments

Comments are now closed
Featured advertisers

Special offers

Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo