JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Needle exchange trial to go ahead at Canberra jail


Christopher Knaus

Australian first ... prisoners at the Alexander Maconochie Centre in the ACT will have access to a needle exchange program.

Australian first ... prisoners at the Alexander Maconochie Centre in the ACT will have access to a needle exchange program. Photo: Andrew Sheargold

The guards union has warned the government is yet to convince prison officers that the latest needle exchange model alleviates their ‘‘significant’’ concerns.

Chief Minister Katy Gallagher announced this morning a renewed push to introduce a needle and syringe program in the Alexander Maconochie Centre.

That could see prisoners given clean needles to safely inject drugs as early as next year, as the government attempts to combat the spread of hepatitis C among prisoners.

It will be based on a one-for-one model, where prisoners exchange a dirty needle for a clean needle, overseen by medical professionals.

Drug counselling and support will be offered alongside the needle exchange.

The proposed needle exchange has been mired in political limbo for years, facing strident opposition from the guards' union and the opposition.

The government plan will make the ACT the first jurisdiction in Australia and the English-speaking world to have a needle exchange in a prison setting.

An implementation group will now be created and Ms Gallagher hopes to have the needle exchange operational by next year.

But the government is understood to need the agreement of the Community and Public Sector Union, who represent guards, before a needle exchange can go ahead.

The enterprise agreement which covers the workers at the jail says "no needle exchange program ... shall be implemented without prior consultation and agreement by the  Directorate, and union(s)."

CPSU regional secretary Vince McDevitt said that agreement was not yet secured.

But he said the union was working through the latest proposal, and was happy to consult with other stakeholders on the ‘‘complex issue’’.

‘‘Like others in the community CPSU members recognise the serious health issues around blood borne virus transmission,’’ Mr McDevitt said.

‘‘But our members also have legitimate concerns about risks a needle exchange program may have for themselves and for the prisoners they are responsible for,’’ he said.

‘‘These health and safety concerns were not adequately addressed in previous proposals from Government.’’

The union is also concerned the exchange would threaten the success of drug rehabilitation programs, and are reluctant to have prison officers complicit in an illegal activity.

Nine new cases of hepatitis C have been recorded in the jail since it was opened.

Seven of those new cases were recorded since December.

The CPSU has previously threatened strike action if a needle exchange was established in the jail.

Ms Gallagher made the announcement before a Public Health Association of Australia symposium on health and justice and received rapturous applause.

Former prison boss Doug Buchanan was opposed to the needle exchange before his controversial departure in May last year.

But current superintendent Don Taylor has been more circumspect, saying it is not his place to advocate for particular public policy views.

Key election battle

The opposition has warned it remains implacably opposed to a needle and syringe program at the jail in any form.

Opposition corrections spokesman Jeremy Hanson said any needle exchange would lead to a ‘‘proliferation of needles across the jail’’.

He said that would pose risks to guards and to prisoners.

That is despite the government’s claim that the one-for-one model would negate any risk of the further spread of needles in the jail.

Mr Hanson has vowed to fight the government over the issue in the remaining months before the ACT election.

‘‘It becomes quite clear now that as people move to the election in October that they have a clear choice,’’ Mr Hanson told ABC local radio this morning.

‘‘If they vote Labor and Green, they’ll have a needle exchange at the jail,’’ he said.

‘‘If they vote Liberal, they won’t have a needle exchange at the jail.’’

He said the needle exchange would lead to the normalisation and quasi-legalisation of drugs in the jail.

The support of doctors

The Australian Medical Australia ACT branch has welcomed the government’s announcement this morning. The AMA, who represent the doctors who would be responsible for giving prisoners clean needles, said it had become very concerned by the continual delays with the program’s implementation, but recognised it was politically difficult.

AMA ACT’s Andrew Miller said the one-for-one model would minimise the risk against its members.

‘‘Obviously there are concerns about people having pointed implements, potentially infectious pointed implements,’’ Dr Miller said.

‘‘But I think we need to be sensible about it, they’re there already,’’ he said.

‘‘If we can control the situation and ensure that the things that are being used are clean and are being exchanged one-for-one, that it’s done on a confidential basis, that there’s no comeback in terms of retribution, then it would certainly, I’m sure, be successful.’’

But Dr Miller warned that the needle exchange must be free from impediments, or it would fail.

‘‘It needs to be free, it needs to be easy to access, it needs to be confidential, the people involved need to be protected in all senses.’’

World-leading approach

The Chief Minister has proved herself as a politician ‘‘with spine’’ in this morning’s announcement, chief executive officer of the Public Health Association and former Corrections Minister Michael Moore said.

Mr Moore was the author of a key report exploring the possibility of a needle exchange at the jail.

He put forward a number of workable practical options, but none of those were taken up by the government today.

‘‘This is an interpretation of what I suggested, and I’m very happy with it,’’ he said.

‘‘This is a difficult decision, this is the first time in the English-speaking world that we will have a prison with a needle and syringe program.’’

‘‘That is a major step forward, it is brave politics and it shows politics with spine.’’

Mr Moore has visited European jails with needle exchange programs already operating, but only one with the one-for-one model proposed by the government.

Human rights win

The Human Rights Commission has said the needle exchange was something that ‘‘had to happen’’ at the Alexander Maconochie Centre.

The commission has been campaigning for a needle and syringe program at the jail since 2007.

Human Rights Commissioner Helen Watchirs said she was optimistic the needle exchange would be a success, but warned ‘‘commitment is the key’’.

‘‘I’m not surprised that there has been a delay, but I’m delighted that this close to an election, the announcement has been made,’’ she said.


  • Drug counselling would consist of "Good Morning here's your clean needle " As for the 9 cases of Hep B, I am sure it was not contracted within the prison. Time for this Government to go..

    Martin Says
    Date and time
    August 15, 2012, 10:12AM
    • Martin, first of all learn to read and get your facts right. It was 9 cases of Hep C not Hep B and secondly, people like you with your attitude are going and are dying out.
      I have read a few of the comments after the first. Congratulations, it seems that everyone just followed suit to Martins opinion. I say sheep.
      Finally, there is a government of the day that is doing the right thing. European trials of NSPs within prisons have been a great success and eventually, every jail in Australia will have clean injecting equipment. If you people are so concerned with drugs entering the prison system whereby seasoned drug users try to access drugs to make the days go by faster, you should be more concerned with drugs entering the community. It is within the community that we have a vulnerable group of people who we need to protect. These are our kids. The syringe programs existing in the community have saved many lives and it is actually more cost effective to the tax payer to have clean equipment for IDUs and preventing HCV and HIV infections at a saving of $27 for every dollar invested in needle and syringe programs. If you the community want to put people in prison, than you should insist that they have fresh equipment as long as there are drugs in the prisons. It is a fact that prison guards deal drugs to prisoners. If you disagree with this basic info, then I think you should be locked up for denying people a basic human right. You are the real criminals and you make me angry with your ignorance.

      Saade Melki
      Date and time
      August 15, 2012, 7:14PM
    • I would hardly call the 38 other parties involved in this debate followers of mine, maybe they just want to voice there opinions,and since we live in a democracy,people can . Unlike your point of view,which is forced down our throats and when the larger majority complain you treat us like morons ,for having a differing view. .As for people like me with my attitude are dying out,I dought that very much,common sence has prevailed over hundreds of years and will continue to.I was also under the belief that injecting illegal drugs was just that illegal,and as for you allowing it just so prison time can go faster is a joke,these people are criminals,and should be treated that way. And I hope you have some proof that the prison guards are dealing drugs to the prison inmates,or is this just some way of you justifing this shameless rant.BTW its IVDU's not IDU'S.

      Martin Says
      Date and time
      August 16, 2012, 8:55AM
  • This is unbelieveable, injecting drugs was one of the reason the were in jail and now they are given neadles to continue the habit. WHERE ARE WE ???

    Date and time
    August 15, 2012, 10:22AM
    • Are prisoners prisoners these days or not? Seems these days they have more rights and privelages than ever before. Sigh, what a society we live in.

      Canberra, Australia
      Date and time
      August 15, 2012, 10:47AM
      • So much for the CPSU and their EBA. again the government will ride roughshod to get what they want. About time to boot them out.

        Date and time
        August 15, 2012, 10:54AM
        • So, is this correct, that it will become okay to take (illegal?) drugs in jail, all while the police are struggling to clean up the drug scene outside?

          down by the bay
          Date and time
          August 15, 2012, 10:54AM
          • This needle exchange program is the most irresponsible waste of tax payers money this is so typical of their mismanagement of our affairs. Their inability to stop drugs from getting into jail clearly show how irresponsible and incompetent they arte.

            One cannot help wondering what will be their next waste of our taxes; supply them with beer and spitits and government funded prostitues? I would not be surprised

            Date and time
            August 15, 2012, 11:11AM
            • What is the government thinking. It's illegal to take these drugs and instead of making it harder for them to act illegally they say "here is a clean needle for you". Why isn't the government spending more money in stopping the drugs that enter the jail. They should take away their lucky access to have visitors who are no doubt supplying them with the drugs. Get them clean for at least 12 months before they are allowed a visitor through a glass screen. Katy's opinion of health and cleanliness should not be taken into account, we have seen her track record with health. Way to go Katy, all this to get a few extra votes you so desperately need.

              katy needs to go
              Date and time
              August 15, 2012, 11:23AM
              • Why doesn't OHS rules ban needles to protect the guards? Don't they have any rights?

                Date and time
                August 15, 2012, 11:23AM

                More comments

                Comments are now closed

                Related Coverage

                HuffPost Australia

                Follow Us

                Featured advertisers

                Special offers

                Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo