JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Accidents do happen, and are often unavoidable


Greg Baum

Mitch Clark injures himself.

Mitch Clark injures himself. Photo: Joe Armao

THE match review panel has developed such a mania for finding not just cause, but also culpability in every heart-in-mouth happening on the football ground, it is a wonder it did not submit a charge of rough conduct against Melbourne's Mitch Clark this week.

Playing the Bulldogs, Clark hurled himself with reckless abandon into an aerial contest, precipitating what might easily have been grave injury, to the head, no less. His own.

Clark, fortunately, suffered no worse consequence from his headlong landing than a stiff neck. He will be playing again long before Sydney's Gary Rohan is even off crutches. But by any measure, Clark's pack-busting leap was far more dangerous to life and limb than Kangaroo Lindsay Thomas' dive at the feet of the unfortunate Rohan.

The least risk that Clark ran was of giving away a free kick. Thomas was PAID a free kick. Perversely, he was also given three matches.

Doubtlessly, the MRP acts only with good intentions. But there is a point at which vigilance becomes vigilantism. In two recent instances - the Whitecross case and the Thomas case - it appeared to refuse to accept that in a chaotic contact sport, played with a random-bouncing ball and at breakneck speed by players who are, by and large, too brave for their own good, not everything can be made to fit perfectly into a matrix of circumstance and responsibility. Accidents do happen.

The MRP's case was based on Adrian Anderson's memo to clubs last November, expressing concern at the emerging problem of players sliding in to take out opponents' legs.

An example was included in the AFL's preseason laws DVD, compulsory viewing for all players. In it, a North Melbourne player launches himself feet-first and at speed at a Port Adelaide player who has the ball but is stationary on the boundary.

''There is a distinct difference,'' the umpire on the spot, Andrew Mitchell, on Sunday told the tribunal.

Sliding conjures up images from soccer: the studs-first tackle, the knees-first goal celebration at the corner flag. Thomas, by his own description, was trying to trap a bobbling ball on a wet ground. He did not so much dive as skid into a turn.

What ensued was a tangle, ''one of those freak acts'', said Thomas. The footage verified it. ''Accidents are going to happen,'' said Thomas' advocate, Tony Burns. ''It's the sad reality of the game.''

Jeff Gleeson, for the AFL, reminded the tribunal an accident still could constitute an offence. Knowing this, the tribunal has been loath to overturn MRP decisions. It has been hardline.

The last thing anyone wants is for accident to become a catch-all alibi. But last night, for the second time in a fortnight, the tribunal did overrule.

A conundrum now applies: what is a player to lead with? His head? Protected by the rules but dangerous. His body? But woe betide if his opponent's head is down. His legs? Last night's verdict notwithstanding, warning has been served.

Thomas did little wrong. Rohan did nothing but emerged momentarily crippled. Perhaps that is the point of this case. The MRP and tribunal are independent but not oblivious of the AFL's imperatives. The sum of their work in this case is to demonstrate that accidents are unavoidable.

It was a kind of reverse show trial.


  • Every time a player slides into a tackle or contest they should be penalised. It would be tricky for umps when opposing players do it at the same time, but the practice would fade once frees were being paid consistently. The AFL does not have a choice here as they are liable and clearly can't rely on the MRP to help fix this urgent problem.

    Ken Grudge
    Date and time
    April 24, 2012, 11:51PM
    • That's quite right Greg, this was not a show trial. That happened last week when Adam Goodes slid and gave opponent a grass burn, but was suspended for not showing enough 'duty of care'. This week the slider in question broke the leg of his opponent, but was cleared of 'rough conduct'.

      I don't condone of condemn either player, but given the outcome of the first incident, the outcome of the second is ridiculous and utterly inconsistent.

      But then this whole match review / tribunal system appears totally inconsistent and even at odds with each other. Of course it can't hurt a Kangaroo's chances if Wayne Schimmelbusch is on the jury!

      BTW Greg, Gary Rohan is a lot more than "momentarily crippled" as you say. His foot was basically broken off at the ankle. There's nothing 'momentary' about his condition or upcoming rehab & recovery. You are making very light of an extremely serious injury.

      Bring the Noise
      Date and time
      April 25, 2012, 12:36AM
      • The difference between Goodes and Thomas is that Thomas appears to only have eyes on the ball and was there first, turning his body away from Gary Rohan but Goodes was looking at the other player and directed his point of contact with his knees and legs into his opponent. The Goodes incident looked really, really bad as a precedent and I'm think the tribunal got it right in both cases. I'm a great admirer of Adam Goodes but he needs to remove that technique from his game.

        Northroy Mal
        North Yarra
        Date and time
        April 25, 2012, 9:20AM
    • Spot on, Greg.

      But personally, I think the MRP has been a failure.

      The AFL will argue it has cut down greatly on tribunal hearings - but that's the biggest furphy ever, because most times you get punished with an extra week if you lose at the tribunal now!!!

      With the current situation the player goes to the tribunal pre-judged as guilty. None of this "Innocent until proven guilty."

      The MRP's role should be nothing more than finding incidents that should go to the tribunal. It should have no other power to rule on the status of the alleged offence.

      Date and time
      April 25, 2012, 3:17AM
      • Good to see Schimmelbusch looking after one of his own. So just to be clear you CAN slide into a contest with studs up as long as you aren't looking at your opponent. Goodes mistake was that he was looking in the direction of his opponent. Is there anyone in Football who isn't confused right now?

        Date and time
        April 25, 2012, 10:39AM
        • I assume that the next time there is a pack mark where a player gets clobbered from behind by a knee to the head, neck or back and happens to be badly hurt then the MRP will instantly suspend the "offending" player?

          Honestly, Australian Football is a contact sport with unfortunate outcomes on (very few) occasions, so I found it staggering that the MRP determined that this incident was worthy of a suspension.

          Date and time
          April 25, 2012, 11:19AM
          • Has anyone noticed that changes made by the AFL always become more and more draconian. This is because most administrators love to put their thumbprint on the game one was or another regardless whether it is for the game's betterment.
            I still can;t understand why there is a Rules Committee after playing for 150 years or more. Again; there will always be those who cannot resist the 'thumbprint' syndrome.

            Date and time
            April 25, 2012, 12:17PM
            • Has anyone noticed that changes made by the AFL become more and more draconian. This is because administrators love to put their thumbprint on some, or any, change to the game. Most simply cannot resist this 'thumbprint' syndrome whether is is for the betterment of the game or not. Anyway; why do we need a 'Rules Committee' or a 'Review Conmmittee' after 150 something years of football?

              Date and time
              April 25, 2012, 12:46PM
              • Northroy Mal - stop trying to justify why Adam Goodes should have been suspended - he should not have been and the MRP was forced to basically admit they were wrong to suspend him. Some of the ridiculous things said about Goodsey's tackle last week were quite amazing in their stupidity. It's quite simple - the MRP got it wrong with Goodsey's suspension, and rightfully let Thomas off. How anyone can say that Goodsey's challenge was in any way worse than the Thomas accident beggars belief...

                Oh and just remember that Garry Rohan is the victim in this sorry affair, not Thomas, as unfortunate the situation he was facing was. Get well soon Gazza!

                Date and time
                April 25, 2012, 2:31PM
                • The problem with the tribunal is that they tear apart the actions of players in such mind numbing detail that they look at everything a player does seemingly with the assumption that they have an eternity to weigh up a multitude of factors before going into a contest. It's a contact sport and accidents happen and even if it results in a serious injury it doesn't always mean someone is at fault or negligent.

                  Date and time
                  April 25, 2012, 4:53PM

                  More comments

                  Comments are now closed

                  Related Coverage

                  HuffPost Australia

                  AFL 2015

                  Round 1
                  Thu, 02 AprTimes shown AEDT
                  CAR 78vs RIC 105 Report Stats
                  Sat, 04 AprTimes shown AEDT
                  MEL 115vs GCF 89 Stats
                  SYD 72vs ESS 60 Stats
                  BRI 74vs COL 86 Stats
                  WBU 97vs WCE 87 Stats
                  Sun, 05 AprTimes shown AEST
                  STK 78vs GWS 87 Stats
                  ADE 140vs NTH 63 Stats
                  FRE 75vs PTA 68 Stats
                  Mon, 06 AprTimes shown AEST
                  HAW 123vs GEE 61 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 2
                  Fri, 10 AprTimes shown AEST
                  WCE 131vs CAR 62 Stats
                  Sat, 11 AprTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 66vs WBU 85 Report Stats
                  GWS 101vs MEL 56 Stats
                  COL 63vs ADE 90 Report Stats
                  GCF 76vs STK 104 Stats
                  PTA 44vs SYD 92 Stats
                  Sun, 12 AprTimes shown AEST
                  GEE 60vs FRE 104 Stats
                  ESS 78vs HAW 76 Stats
                  NTH 133vs BRI 51 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 3
                  Fri, 17 AprTimes shown AEST
                  COL 140vs STK 66 Stats
                  Sat, 18 AprTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 84vs ESS 105 Stats
                  ADE 80vs MEL 55 Stats
                  SYD 111vs GWS 90 Report Stats
                  NTH 105vs PTA 113 Stats
                  BRI 58vs RIC 137 Stats
                  Sun, 19 AprTimes shown AEST
                  HAW 127vs WBU 57 Stats
                  GEE 105vs GCF 96 Stats
                  WCE 81vs FRE 111 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 4
                  Fri, 24 AprTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 51vs MEL 83 Stats
                  Sat, 25 AprTimes shown AEST
                  STK 81vs CAR 121 Report Report Stats
                  ESS 49vs COL 69 Report Stats
                  GWS 119vs GCF 53 Stats
                  PTA 99vs HAW 91 Stats
                  FRE 74vs SYD 60 Stats
                  Sun, 26 AprTimes shown AEST
                  BRI 65vs WCE 118 Stats
                  GEE 67vs NTH 83 Stats
                  WBU 125vs ADE 68 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 5
                  Fri, 01 MayTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 45vs COL 120 Stats
                  Sat, 02 MayTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 76vs GEE 85 Stats
                  SYD 73vs WBU 77 Stats
                  GCF 118vs BRI 54 Stats
                  NTH 70vs HAW 130 Stats
                  WCE 120vs GWS 33 Stats
                  Sun, 03 MayTimes shown AEST
                  MEL 50vs FRE 118 Stats
                  STK 80vs ESS 82 Stats
                  ADE 91vs PTA 115 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 6
                  Fri, 08 MayTimes shown AEST
                  COL 59vs GEE 100 Stats
                  Sat, 09 MayTimes shown AEST
                  NTH 109vs RIC 74 Stats
                  WBU 87vs STK 94 Stats
                  GWS 108vs HAW 98 Stats
                  GCF 78vs ADE 119 Stats
                  MEL 50vs SYD 88 Stats
                  FRE 80vs ESS 52 Stats
                  Sun, 10 MayTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 75vs BRI 84 Report Stats
                  PTA 68vs WCE 78 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 7
                  Fri, 15 MayTimes shown AEST
                  ESS 82vs NTH 93 Stats
                  Sat, 16 MayTimes shown AEST
                  ADE 119vs STK 73 Stats
                  HAW 155vs MEL 50 Stats
                  CAR 57vs GWS 135 Stats
                  SYD 120vs GEE 77 Stats
                  WCE 135vs GCF 43 Stats
                  Sun, 17 MayTimes shown AEST
                  WBU 88vs FRE 101 Stats
                  RIC 105vs COL 100 Report Stats
                  BRI 102vs PTA 65 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 8
                  Fri, 22 MayTimes shown AEST
                  GEE 140vs CAR 63 Report Stats
                  Sat, 23 MayTimes shown AEST
                  STK 78vs WCE 131 Report Stats
                  GWS 108vs ADE 84 Report Stats
                  GCF 63vs COL 132 Report Stats
                  HAW 69vs SYD 73 Report Stats
                  FRE 115vs NTH 42 Report Stats
                  Sun, 24 MayTimes shown AEST
                  ESS 136vs BRI 78 Report Stats
                  MEL 103vs WBU 64 Report Stats
                  PTA 43vs RIC 76 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 9
                  Fri, 29 MayTimes shown AEST
                  SYD 122vs CAR 62 Report Stats
                  Sat, 30 MayTimes shown AEST
                  HAW 93vs GCF 40 Report Stats
                  MEL 54vs PTA 115 Report Stats
                  WBU 113vs GWS 68 Report Stats
                  RIC 72vs ESS 59 Report Stats
                  ADE 57vs FRE 68 Report Stats
                  Sun, 31 MayTimes shown AEST
                  BRI 86vs STK 108 Report Stats
                  COL 112vs NTH 95 Report Stats
                  WCE 120vs GEE 64 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 10
                  Fri, 05 JunTimes shown AEST
                  FRE 70vs RIC 97 Report Stats
                  Sat, 06 JunTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 90vs ADE 99 Report Stats
                  GCF 41vs SYD 93 Report Stats
                  ESS 53vs GEE 122 Report Stats
                  PTA 100vs WBU 62 Report Stats
                  Sun, 07 JunTimes shown AEST
                  GWS 97vs BRI 67 Report Stats
                  NTH 85vs WCE 75 Report Stats
                  STK 69vs HAW 132 Report Stats
                  Mon, 08 JunTimes shown AEST
                  MEL 85vs COL 110 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 11
                  Fri, 12 JunTimes shown AEST
                  PTA 69vs GEE 92 Report Stats
                  Sat, 13 JunTimes shown AEST
                  GCF 46vs FRE 53 Report Stats
                  WCE 96vs ESS 46 Report Stats
                  NTH 75vs SYD 91 Report Report Stats
                  Sun, 14 JunTimes shown AEST
                  COL 119vs GWS 77 Report Stats
                  STK 85vs MEL 83 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 12
                  Thu, 18 JunTimes shown AEST
                  ADE 85vs HAW 114 Report Stats
                  Fri, 19 JunTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 70vs WCE 90 Report Stats
                  Sat, 20 JunTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 110vs PTA 106 Report Stats
                  GWS 61vs NTH 117 Report Stats
                  WBU 146vs BRI 74 Report Stats
                  Sun, 21 JunTimes shown AEST
                  GEE 89vs MEL 113 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 13
                  Thu, 25 JunTimes shown AEST
                  FRE 80vs COL 73 Report Stats
                  Fri, 26 JunTimes shown AEST
                  SYD 77vs RIC 95 Report Stats
                  Sat, 27 JunTimes shown AEST
                  HAW 114vs ESS 76 Report Stats
                  BRI 69vs ADE 82 Report Stats
                  STK 56vs WBU 62 Report Stats
                  Sun, 28 JunTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 103vs GCF 69 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 14
                  Thu, 02 JulTimes shown AEST
                  SYD 94vs PTA 84 Report Stats
                  Fri, 03 JulTimes shown AEST
                  COL 91vs HAW 101 Report Stats
                  Sat, 04 JulTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 78vs GWS 69 Report Stats
                  GCF 125vs NTH 70 Report Stats
                  WBU 64vs CAR 53 Report Stats
                  MEL 60vs WCE 114 Report Stats
                  Sun, 05 JulTimes shown AEST
                  ESS 52vs STK 162 Stats
                  ADE vs GEE 15:20Adelaide Oval
                  FRE 84vs BRI 48 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 15
                  Thu, 09 JulTimes shown AEST
                  PTA 66vs COL 63 Report Stats
                  Fri, 10 JulTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 71vs CAR 41 Report Stats
                  Sat, 11 JulTimes shown AEST
                  ESS 69vs MEL 60 Report Stats
                  WBU 95vs GCF 73 Report Stats
                  NTH 120vs GEE 79 Report Stats
                  WCE 147vs ADE 91 Report Stats
                  Sun, 12 JulTimes shown AEST
                  GWS 84vs STK 49 Report Stats
                  HAW 115vs FRE 43 Report Stats
                  BRI 49vs SYD 70 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 16
                  Fri, 17 JulTimes shown AEST
                  NTH 93vs ESS 68 Report Stats
                  Sat, 18 JulTimes shown AEST
                  GEE 72vs WBU 64 Report Stats
                  GCF 79vs GWS 94 Report Stats
                  COL 56vs WCE 87 Report Stats
                  SYD 57vs HAW 146 Report Stats
                  FRE 95vs CAR 53 Report Stats
                  Sun, 19 JulTimes shown AEST
                  MEL 60vs BRI 36 Report Stats
                  PTA 113vs ADE 116 Report Stats
                  STK 73vs RIC 89 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 17
                  Fri, 24 JulTimes shown AEST
                  CAR 35vs HAW 173 Report Stats
                  Sat, 25 JulTimes shown AEST
                  GWS 42vs GEE 69 Stats
                  ADE 125vs GCF 80 Stats
                  RIC 78vs FRE 82 Stats
                  ESS 116vs PTA 129 Stats
                  BRI 38vs NTH 110 Report Stats
                  Sun, 26 JulTimes shown AEST
                  WBU 104vs COL 86 Report Stats
                  MEL 46vs STK 83 Report Stats
                  WCE 103vs SYD 51 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 18
                  Fri, 31 JulTimes shown AEST
                  HAW 53vs RIC 71 Report Stats
                  Sat, 01 AugTimes shown AEST
                  GEE 113vs BRI 57 Stats
                  COL 54vs MEL 91 Report Stats
                  SYD 117vs ADE 65 Report Stats
                  CAR 54vs NTH 118 Report Stats
                  GCF 83vs WCE 83 Report Stats
                  Sun, 02 AugTimes shown AEST
                  PTA 112vs STK 49 Report Stats
                  ESS 40vs WBU 127 Report Stats
                  FRE 84vs GWS 63 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 19
                  Fri, 07 AugTimes shown AEST
                  ADE 88vs RIC 52 Report Stats
                  Sat, 08 AugTimes shown AEST
                  COL 105vs CAR 87 Report Stats
                  WBU 128vs PTA 64 Report Stats
                  BRI 100vs GCF 114 Report Stats
                  GEE 95vs SYD 63 Report Stats
                  WCE 74vs HAW 88 Report Stats
                  Sun, 09 AugTimes shown AEST
                  MEL 92vs NTH 127 Report Stats
                  GWS 93vs ESS 61 Report Stats
                  STK 59vs FRE 96 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 20
                  Fri, 14 AugTimes shown AEST
                  SYD 87vs COL 76 Report Stats
                  Sat, 15 AugTimes shown AEST
                  ESS 59vs ADE 171 Report Stats
                  NTH 120vs STK 83 Report Stats
                  PTA 111vs GWS 90 Report Stats
                  GEE 85vs HAW 121 Report Stats
                  BRI 131vs CAR 67 Report Stats
                  Sun, 16 AugTimes shown AEST
                  RIC 138vs GCF 55 Report Stats
                  WBU 153vs MEL 55 Report Stats
                  FRE 80vs WCE 104 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 21
                  Fri, 21 AugTimes shown AEST
                  HAW 86vs PTA 108 Report Stats
                  Sat, 22 AugTimes shown AEST
                  COL 56vs RIC 147 Report Stats
                  GWS 44vs SYD 133 Report Stats
                  GCF 97vs ESS 95 Report Stats
                  STK 97vs GEE 97 Report Stats
                  ADE 131vs BRI 44 Report Stats
                  Sun, 23 AugTimes shown AEST
                  NTH 94vs FRE 83 Report Stats
                  CAR 78vs MEL 55 Report Stats
                  WCE 162vs WBU 85 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 22
                  Fri, 28 AugTimes shown AEST
                  GEE 62vs COL 110 Report Stats
                  Sat, 29 AugTimes shown AEST
                  GWS 132vs CAR 51 Report Stats
                  HAW 134vs BRI 62 Report Stats
                  NTH 73vs WBU 96 Report Stats
                  ESS 47vs RIC 74 Report Stats
                  GCF 51vs PTA 88 Report Stats
                  Sun, 30 AugTimes shown AEST
                  ADE 126vs WCE 69 Report Stats
                  STK 38vs SYD 135 Report Stats
                  FRE 108vs MEL 54 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 23
                  Fri, 04 SepTimes shown AEST
                  RIC ($1.08)vs NTH ($8.00) 19:50ES
                  Sat, 05 SepTimes shown AEST
                  GEE ($2.20)vs ADE ($1.67) 13:05SS
                  BRI ($4.00)vs WBU ($1.25) 13:45G
                  PTA vs FRE 15:50Adelaide Oval
                  HAW ($1.01)vs CAR ($17.00) 16:40MCG
                  SYD ($1.04)vs GCF ($11.00) 19:25SCG
                  WCE ($1.04)vs STK ($11.00) 19:40Domain Stadium
                  Sun, 06 SepTimes shown AEST
                  MEL ($2.45)vs GWS ($1.55) 13:10ES
                  COL ($1.28)vs ESS ($3.70) 15:20MCG
                  View All Fixtures
                  AFL 2015
                  Overall standings
                  Team P W L D % Pts
                  Fremantle 21 17 4 0 125.10 68
                  West Coast Eagles 21 15 5 1 143.00 62
                  Hawthorn 21 15 6 0 156.77 60
                  Sydney Swans 21 15 6 0 124.11 60
                  Richmond 21 14 7 0 121.39 56
                  Western Bulldogs 21 14 7 0 116.76 56
                  Adelaide Crows 20 13 7 0 119.10 54
                  North Melbourne 21 13 8 0 109.08 52
                  View all

                  Follow Us on Facebook

                  Featured advertisers