JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Collingwood future looks bright with young guns at the ready

The future: Matt Scharenberg and Nathan Freeman will be key players for the Pies.

The future: Matt Scharenberg and Nathan Freeman will be key players for the Pies. Photo: John French

Sunday's clash with Port Adelaide may well be Collingwood's make-or-break game for 2014, but in terms of its prospects beyond this year, it won't be the disaster some people are suggesting if they don't come away with a victory.

Sure, making the finals is a far more preferable alternative, and the legions of Magpie supporters will feel deflated if they are denied the opportunity to descend on a September fixture. And Nathan Buckley and his coaching staff would dearly love to have the chance to assess his playing group in the heat that finals football brings, but a detached view would suggest that the Pies are far from destined for a period of obscurity in the coming years.

What excites me most about Collingwood's list is a combination of what we have all been exposed to in recent years, combined with some elite junior talent that is yet to be unveiled.

Having immersed myself in the under-age championships in recent years, the player who excited me most out of last year's under-18 carnival was Matthew Scharenberg from South Australia. He had a presence and a poise about him that clearly defined him as an outstanding AFL prospect. He controlled games across half-back, delivered the ball beautifully and invariably made the correct decision with the football in his hands.

He is listed as 191 centimetres and 87 kilograms and has spent the vast majority of his initial AFL season recovering from injuries to his feet. He made his long-awaited debut in the VFL last weekend and got through a half of football. It is a lot to suggest the future of Collingwood looks bright on the back of one young man, but the very best judges of under-age footballers will tell you that this is a very special talent we are dealing with, and the prospect of having him complete a full pre-season, injury-free, improves Collingwood's stocks immediately.

Add the name of Nathan Freeman to that list. He was taken by the Pies with pick 10 in last year's draft, yet he has been unsighted all season due to hamstring issues. For those who have enjoyed Lewis Taylor's debut season for the Brisbane Lions, Freeman is every bit as equipped to have a similar impact when he gets his body right. He has genuine, line-breaking speed, loves to run with the ball and take the game on and he has the infectious, cheeky and cocky personality that will endear him to Collingwood supporters immediately.

Tim Broomhead gave us a glimpse of the talent that has the Pies genuinely excited on Sunday against Adelaide. Another first-round draft pick, from 2012, he has had to overcome glandular fever as he waited for his chance at senior level. He has some genuine X-factor about him and, again, with an uninterrupted pre-season, looks extremely capable of slotting into the midfield and making a difference.

In Scharenberg, Freeman and Broomhead, Collingwood has three genuine A-grade prospects at its disposal. And unlike at Melbourne, St Kilda or GWS, where they would be slightly exposed because of the lack of quality, senior footballers around them, they will be offered plenty of support from some of the elite playing talent in the competition.

Scott Pendlebury, Dayne Beams and Steele Sidebottom sit in the very highest category of midfielders in this competition. Dane Swan has owned and dominated the same area of the ground for many years, and we all are waiting with baited breath to see whether he can overcome his injuries and return to those same lofty heights.

That is a magnificent base on which to build a premiership midfield. Freeman and Broomhead will be pushing to join them, Taylor Adams will be better for this year, Ben Kennedy has ambitions to be a part of it and Jamie Elliott has all of the tools to be an on-ball jet.

The average age of those five players is 20. It is a tantalising and exciting prospect for Buckley to look forward to.

Tom Langdon has exceeded all expectations in his debut year. He, too, is just 20 years old and looks capable of filling the sizeable hole left by the retiring Nick Maxwell. Jack Frost is 22 and has played only 19 games of football. He is raw and a powerful athlete, and reminds me of a young Mal Michael, who arrived on the AFL scene very quietly, but retired with three premierships to his name as one of the better full backs of his era.

Lachie Keeffe is also an interesting prospect who has shown that he has the physical attributes to compete as a key back. If he can continue to improve and develop as a footballer, then it helps address one of the Pies' glaring deficiencies.

And in Brodie Grundy they have a 20-year-old ruckman who is as well-placed as any emerging young ruckman in the competition to put his stamp on the game. Don’t be at all alarmed by the fact that Grundy hasn't established himself as the clear No.1 ruckman in this team, after an extremely promising start last year. History is our best teacher, and history tells us that it takes a number of years for these big men to grow into their body, while at the same time they are coming to grips with the nuances of ruck work.

With Grundy, Scharenberg, Freeman, Broomhead, Langdon, Kennedy, Frost, Keeffe and Adams all first and second-year players, and Elliott in his third, the future looks full of promise for the Pies.

They will be supported by Pendlebury, Beams, Travis Cloke, Sidebottom, Swan, Reid, Brent Macaffer, Heritier Lumumba and Alan Toovey and the coaching staff will be hoping that Paul Seedsman, Alex Fasolo, Marley Williams and Tyson Goldsack respond to the challenge of these emerging youngsters and lift their output in the process.

If this group of players is able to prepare for 2015 on the back of a finals crusade this year, then that would obviously be advantageous. And once they're there, who knows how far they could proceed.

But if they drop this game against Port Adelaide and eventually miss out on a September appearance, then Buckley has the perfect ammunition to throw at them when they come together for their pre-season campaign.

The list management team will be, right now, desperately looking for the best way to provide Cloke with support, but they can also be well pleased that they have given their senior coach plenty to work with in the next 24 months.

This time next year, they will be contending again. How strongly may depend on how quickly their untapped youngsters emerge from the pack.

8 comments so far

  • It's about time somebody other than Collingwood supporters recognised the potential in this Collingwood list. I just hope they can hang onto Kennedy and Broomhead and not lose them back to South Australia.

    Date and time
    August 01, 2014, 11:22PM
    • Martin not on the list Gary?

      Date and time
      August 02, 2014, 3:51PM
  • An encouraging review for all Collingwood fans but I was surprised you didn't mention the reason Brodie Grundy is not in the side and that is the fantastic efforts of Jarrod Witts. For a giant of a young man so early in his career and not coming from a football background he is a very exciting prospect. He is only 21 and at 209 cms has good skills and is developing his ruckwork with every game he plays. You may even find that because of Witts development and potential Grundy will be looking elsewhere in a couple of years time.
    And you are right about Scharenberg. I watch a lot of the kids coming through and he will be an outstanding player.
    If Bucks can just stop over analyzing his stats sheet and just let his undoubted footy eye watch the game and his players the Pies could have a good future.

    Date and time
    August 01, 2014, 11:25PM
    • Yeah, Witts might be doing ok but he does seem to have a problem reading the ball in flight, he may be able to learn this skill and I hope he can. As for as Grundy looking elsewhere in the future, I don't think so. Ideally they will play both of them.

      Date and time
      August 05, 2014, 2:05PM
  • I think Bucks and the heirarchy have noted the competition around and above them this year and taken the long view. 2016/17 look tantalising if he can orchestrate the fabled 'buy-in' that all premiership sides possess as a collective. September action would certainly make a great bonus this year, though. Take a deep breath, doomsayers, nothing is owed the Pies. I have a good feeling that Bucks is building a group with an insatiable appetite for hard work and that's what wins flags in the end.

    Date and time
    August 01, 2014, 11:55PM
    • I hope you are wrong Garry.

      No No
      Date and time
      August 02, 2014, 8:33AM
      • Finally an article without the hysteria and doom and gloom of the magpies missing the finals for the first time in nigh on 10 years. This was a rebuilding year and they have been great at getting games into kids. injuries or no injuries they were never going to push for a flag this year but 2015 - 2017 they certainly will be. if they can get the kids fit and firing and the stable brigade of pendles, clock, reid, side bottom on the park all year then there could be great things achieved. Nothing is for certain in this game though...

        St Kilda
        Date and time
        August 02, 2014, 11:10AM
        • Great article...very encouraging and objective since it does not come from a Collingwood partisan. Like Jeff, I am surprised that Jarrod Witts isn't mentioned...he is another potential emerging star. I think Collingwood supporters need to relax...this year won't be a Premiership, but this article really elucidates the long term vision that is animating our club.

          Date and time
          August 02, 2014, 1:17PM

          Make a comment

          You are logged in as [Logout]

          All information entered below may be published.

          Error: Please enter your screen name.

          Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

          Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

          Error: Please enter your comment.

          Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

          Post to

          You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

          Thank you

          Your comment has been submitted for approval.

          Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

          Follow Us on Facebook

          Featured advertisers