JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

End this farce


The AFL must act swiftly before the basic premise of the game is altered.

Judgment day: Chris Judd at the AFL tribunal on Tuesday night.

Judgment day: Chris Judd at the AFL tribunal on Tuesday night. Photo: Simon O'Dwyer

POLICING AFL football has never been an easy task. But the administering of the rules of the game and the league's judicial process is in danger of descending into farce.

What began as a sound enough idea to simplify the disciplinary process via a standardised points system, has become an unwieldy, wildly inconsistent and contradictory mess, one which threatens to leave most of the football community completely disillusioned.

The Chris Judd drama only added fuel to the already raging fires of discontent among the playing fraternity and a significant portion of the fan base about the entire system. And the eventual four-game penalty handed to North Melbourne's Jack Ziebell has brought into question allegedly the game's most fundamental premise: winning the ball.

The old stand-alone tribunal certainly meant lots of paperwork and late nights for more people, but at least it usually delivered a reasonably uniform set of findings. Now we're stuck with an overly complex system a vast majority of people can't comprehend, in which penalties seldom reflect the merits of the incident being assessed.

More importantly, a system in which three levels of officialdom - umpires, the match review panel and the tribunal - deliver verdicts regularly in contrast to and effectively undermining each other.

In the Ziebell case, the tribunal backed the review panel, but certainly not umpire Justin Schmitt, who hadn't paid a free kick as two players - Ziebell and Carlton's Aaron Joseph - collided in their pursuit of the ball.

Schmitt told the Carlton players remonstrating with Ziebell: "He was going for the ball. He just went the ball."

Review panel chairman Mark Fraser, in laying a charge, conceded that Ziebell was looking at the ball, and indeed got his hands to the ball, but slapped a "negligent" rating on Ziebell's actions anyway.

The tribunal determined that Ziebell had a "realistic alternative" to contest the ball rather than jumping in the air, but felt no compunction to explain what it actually was.

I certainly can't fathom what it might have been, other than to stand back and let Joseph have first dibs. If that's what players are now going to have to do, then we've just effectively altered the very essence of our game. And not for the better.

The slide tackle incident kerfuffle earlier this season was more convoluted and ludicrous officiating at work.

North Melbourne's Lindsay Thomas won a free kick for high contact by Sydney's Gary Rohan, only to find himself handed a three-match suspension by the review panel for rough conduct. Rohan broke his leg when the two players, coming from opposite directions on slippery turf, made contact.

The tribunal overturned that verdict, arriving at the conclusion that no one but the review panel had seriously challenged, that this was an unfortunate accident. It also overturned the one-match penalty given to Fremantle's Greg Broughton for a slide into Gold Coast's David Swallow, mainly because the Docker had arrived first to the ball.

Fraser's response after that reversal was hardly encouraging on the consistency front. "Obviously the tribunal decisions … will change our thinking a little bit, because the tribunal didn't believe that that was rough conduct," he said.

So, two judicial bodies with wildly conflicting ideas about what is punishable. And, from the sounds of it, doing very little comparing of notes.

The Thomas and Broughton verdicts were just one of a number of review panel findings with which the tribunal has disagreed. It overturned the ridiculously harsh two-match penalty given to Hawthorn's Brendan Whitecross after Geelong skipper Joel Selwood cannoned into him, a rough conduct charge dished out to the Cats' Steve Johnson, while a striking charge on St Kilda's Leigh Montagna was withdrawn. Montagna had been charged after Melbourne's James Magner ended up with a cut eye, found later to have been accidentally caused by Montagna's knee.

Tribunal counsel Jeff Gleeson was told by Fraser: "Had the match review panel been aware that the contact was made by the knee, the [panel] would not have charged Montagna."

Hang on a second. So the review panel wasn't sure what caused the cut, didn't bother to find out, but charged him anyway. Yep, there's a system ticking over beautifully. Not.

Don't we have a major problem if an umpire, on the spot and viewing an incident in real time and in context, can award a free kick, only for the player who wins the free to end up being suspended?

And don't we have an even bigger problem if the AFL's judicial bodies pick and choose who and what they're going to make an example of? You could argue the Judd "chicken wing" effort was a very bad look, and an adequate suspension symbolically important.

But was Josh Hunt's effort in needlessly standing forcefully on Eddie Betts' hand a few weeks ago any less damaging a look? It was just as unrequired, unsportsmanlike and, to be frank, cowardly. Judd got four weeks, fair enough. Hunt got a $1350 fine.

There's just too many contradictions like that going on, from penalty to penalty, between the umpires running the game and those who deliver the verdicts after it, between the verdicts themselves, overloaded with the asterisks and footnotes of loading, discounts and early pleas. And frankly, in the wake of the Ziebell case particularly, between what we know as the spirit of the game, and how it's being policed.

It's one big mess and nobody - players, fans or club officials - is happy. If the AFL is, it's either content with some pretty low standards or in complete denial about a system that has spun way out of control.

175 comments so far

  • well said. the game as a whole is too focused on removing all grey area from officiating. an on field example is the holding the ball rule, with ridiculous free kicks paid to players second to a contest who actively hold the ball in. what's wrong with letting a human expert make a judgement call?

    Date and time
    July 18, 2012, 1:44PM
    • Human expert huh. The umpire didn't award the free kick for the Zeibel incident and 25 odd thousand amateurs all voiced their disbelief. The umpiring was poor at times surpassed only by the attitude of the blues players which was abysmal. You need the MRT to catch umpiring mistakes likely brought on by the continual umpire intereference by the AFL higher ups.

      blue bayou
      Date and time
      July 18, 2012, 4:21PM
    • If we are concerned about player welfare, then how about charging players who injure their own teammates through negligent and reckless attacks on the ball?

      J Dog
      The Yarra
      Date and time
      July 18, 2012, 4:32PM
    • I cannot fathom how Ziebell's infringement, in going for the ball is somehow just as bad as Judd intentionally ripping an arm out of the socket.
      And Judd's claim that he released the arm as soon as he realised that Adams was in pain is bulldust. The only thing stopping Adams from further injury was the fact that his team-mates threw Judd away, which incidentally resulted in Judd receiving a free kick.

      Date and time
      July 18, 2012, 7:15PM
    • I agree J Dog. If a player deliberately injures another player the common assault charges should be laid by the police.

      Doug Small
      Date and time
      July 18, 2012, 11:18PM
    • kozeyekan, they were not judged the same. Judd got 4 weeks. Ziebell would have got 2 weeks if his record was any good, but with the bad record loading and no guilty plea it went up to 4.

      Date and time
      July 19, 2012, 12:51PM
    • I don't think this is well said at all. Rohan totally forgets the reasoning behind the MRP coming in. Before some people were being suspended for 6 weeks and a guy doing the same the next week got 2. There was no consistency. People now disagree with the consistency, but people that commit the same act, with the same outcomes and the same priors get the same penalties. The issue is so many commentators and fans either don't understand the rules, don't agree with the rules or don't understand the impact of priors or guilty pleas on the suspensions.

      Date and time
      July 19, 2012, 12:59PM
  • Nailed it, Rohan. Who knew that the MRP and the Tribunal were separate agencies? I was under the impression the Tribunal dealt with stuff that was too serious for the MRP. Turns out it operates almost entirely independently. So we have Judd's QC and the Tribunal chairman telling the jury to ignore Judd's priors, when for the MRP they have a very heavy bearing on the penalty.
    If the Tribunal's role is to determine guilt or level of charge that's fine but responsibility for the penalty should then go back to the MRP so that at least there is consistency with the penalties.
    I read a report last night which included an alleged quote from Gleeson asking what Judd was prepared to plead guilty to. If this was true, when did plea bargaining come into the process? Why wasn't Ziebel given the option of pleading guilty to negligent but not reckless (or the other way round - whichever is the less serious)?
    As with the bewildering interpretations of holding the ball, in the back, and dropping the ball, which only those behind desks seem to understand and certainly not those playing or paying to watch the games, the MRP/Tribunal imbroglio is yet another fine mess by the AFL. If they didn't have a monopoly, they'd all be on the dole.

    Tom Wills
    Yarra Park
    Date and time
    July 18, 2012, 1:44PM
    • Yeah, you've nailed it, Rohan. How about this scenario - 1st week of the finals, substitute Dane Swan for Ziebell. Swan jumps in the air to contest the ball and collects an opposition player - MRP gives him four weeks. Collingwood go to Tribunal, penalty stands. Collingwood appeal, penalty stands. Ok, now what. Collingwood go to court and blow the whole shootin' match to the sh*t-house! I don't support the Pies, but if it came to this, I'd support their decision. Rohan, your headline says it all - an absolute farce.

      Date and time
      July 18, 2012, 3:32PM
    • Tom, Ziebell was charged with negligent contact (the lowest form of contact worth only 1 activation point), he plead not guilty to this. He had the option to plead guilty, but chose to contest it as he said his eyes were on the ball and erroneously thought that was a valid defence. While it is true his eyes were on the ball, the MRP ruled he had other options to compete for the ball (eg; spoil or tackle when Joseph got the ball), therefore as his actions caused head high contact, he must be suspended per the rules as they are currently written. There is no provision in the rules for: "I was trying to get the ball". If you made head high contact and had another option to contest the ball, then you will get suspended. If that was a kick from Murphy and not a handball he likely would not have got suspended. Rightly or wrongly, these are the way the rules are written to try and limit head high contact.

      Date and time
      July 19, 2012, 12:56PM

More comments

Make a comment

You are logged in as [Logout]

All information entered below may be published.

Error: Please enter your screen name.

Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Please enter your comment.

Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

Post to

You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

Thank you

Your comment has been submitted for approval.

Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

Related Coverage

HuffPost Australia

AFL 2016

Round 1
Thu, 24 MarTimes shown AEDT
RIC vs CAR 19:20MCG
Sat, 26 MarTimes shown AEDT
MEL vs GWS 13:40MCG
GCF vs ESS 16:35MS
NTH vs ADE 19:25ES
SYD vs COL 19:25ANZ
Sun, 27 MarTimes shown AEDT
WBU vs FRE 13:10ES
PTA vs STK 15:20Adelaide Oval
WCE vs BRI 19:40Domain Stadium
Mon, 28 MarTimes shown AEDT
GEE vs HAW 15:20MCG
View All Fixtures
Round 2
Fri, 01 AprTimes shown AEDT
COL vs RIC 19:50MCG
Sat, 02 AprTimes shown AEDT
ADE vs PTA 13:45Adelaide Oval
ESS vs MEL 14:10MCG
BRI vs NTH 16:35G
STK vs WBU 19:25ES
FRE vs GCF 19:40Domain Stadium
Sun, 03 AprTimes shown AEST
GWS vs GEE 13:10SO
HAW vs WCE 15:20MCG
CAR vs SYD 16:40ES
View All Fixtures
Round 3
Fri, 08 AprTimes shown AEST
PTA vs ESS 19:50Adelaide Oval
Sat, 09 AprTimes shown AEST
STK vs COL 13:45MCG
RIC vs ADE 14:10ES
SYD vs GWS 16:35SCG
GCF vs CAR 19:25MS
WCE vs FRE 19:40Domain Stadium
Sun, 10 AprTimes shown AEST
NTH vs MEL 13:10BA
WBU vs HAW 15:20ES
GEE vs BRI 16:40SS
View All Fixtures
Round 4
Fri, 15 AprTimes shown AEST
WCE vs RIC 20:10Domain Stadium
Sat, 16 AprTimes shown AEST
ESS vs GEE 13:45MCG
HAW vs STK 14:10AS
BRI vs GCF 16:35G
CAR vs WBU 19:25ES
ADE vs SYD 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 17 AprTimes shown AEST
GWS vs PTA 13:10SO
COL vs MEL 15:20MCG
NTH vs FRE 16:40ES
View All Fixtures
Round 5
Fri, 22 AprTimes shown AEST
HAW vs ADE 19:50MCG
Sat, 23 AprTimes shown AEST
SYD vs WCE 13:40SCG
GCF vs NTH 16:35MS
WBU vs BRI 19:25ES
PTA vs GEE 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 24 AprTimes shown AEST
STK vs GWS 13:10ES
FRE vs CAR 16:10Domain Stadium
MEL vs RIC 19:10MCG
Mon, 25 AprTimes shown AEST
COL vs ESS 15:20MCG
View All Fixtures
Round 6
Fri, 29 AprTimes shown AEST
NTH vs WBU 19:50ES
Sat, 30 AprTimes shown AEST
MEL vs STK 13:45ES
ADE vs FRE 14:10Adelaide Oval
GWS vs HAW 16:35Spotless Stadium
RIC vs PTA 19:25MCG
GEE vs GCF 19:25SS
Sun, 01 MayTimes shown AEST
BRI vs SYD 13:10G
CAR vs ESS 15:20MCG
WCE vs COL 16:40Domain Stadium
View All Fixtures
Round 7
Fri, 06 MayTimes shown AEST
RIC vs HAW 19:50MCG
Sat, 07 MayTimes shown AEST
COL vs CAR 13:45MCG
GEE vs WCE 14:10SS
SYD vs ESS 16:35ANZ
GCF vs MEL 17:10MS
WBU vs ADE 19:40ES
FRE vs GWS 20:10Domain Stadium
Sun, 08 MayTimes shown AEST
STK vs NTH 15:20ES
PTA vs BRI 16:40Adelaide Oval
View All Fixtures
Round 8
Fri, 13 MayTimes shown AEST
ADE vs GEE 19:50Adelaide Oval
Sat, 14 MayTimes shown AEST
ESS vs NTH 13:45ES
HAW vs FRE 14:10AS
GWS vs GCF 16:35Spotless Stadium
BRI vs COL 19:25G
RIC vs SYD 19:25MCG
Sun, 15 MayTimes shown AEST
CAR vs PTA 13:10ES
MEL vs WBU 15:20MCG
WCE vs STK 16:40Domain Stadium
View All Fixtures
Round 9
Fri, 20 MayTimes shown AEST
HAW vs SYD 19:50MCG
Sat, 21 MayTimes shown AEST
COL vs GEE 13:45MCG
GCF vs ADE 14:10MS
PTA vs WCE 16:35Adelaide Oval
NTH vs CAR 19:25ES
FRE vs RIC 19:40Domain Stadium
Sun, 22 MayTimes shown AEST
MEL vs BRI 13:10MCG
GWS vs WBU 15:20Spotless Stadium
STK vs ESS 16:40ES
View All Fixtures
Round 10
Fri, 27 MayTimes shown AEST
SYD vs NTH 19:50SCG
Sat, 28 MayTimes shown AEST
BRI vs HAW 13:45G
MEL vs PTA 14:10TIO Traeger Park
STK vs FRE 16:35ES
ESS vs RIC 19:25MCG
ADE vs GWS 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 29 MayTimes shown AEST
CAR vs GEE 13:10ES
COL vs WBU 15:20MCG
WCE vs GCF 16:40Domain Stadium
View All Fixtures
Round 11
Fri, 03 JunTimes shown AEST
NTH vs RIC 19:50BA
Sat, 04 JunTimes shown AEST
HAW vs MEL 13:45MCG
CAR vs BRI 14:10ES
GEE vs GWS 16:35SS
GCF vs SYD 19:25MS
FRE vs ESS 19:40Domain Stadium
Sun, 05 JunTimes shown AEST
COL vs PTA 13:10MCG
WBU vs WCE 15:20ES
ADE vs STK 16:40Adelaide Oval
View All Fixtures
Round 12
Fri, 10 JunTimes shown AEST
ESS vs HAW 19:50ES
Sat, 11 JunTimes shown AEST
PTA vs WBU 13:40Adelaide Oval
BRI vs FRE 16:35G
GEE vs NTH 19:25ES
WCE vs ADE 19:40Domain Stadium
Sun, 12 JunTimes shown AEST
STK vs CAR 13:10ES
RIC vs GCF 15:20MCG
GWS vs SYD 16:40Spotless Stadium
Mon, 13 JunTimes shown AEST
MEL vs COL 15:20MCG
View All Fixtures
Round 13
Fri, 17 JunTimes shown AEST
NTH vs HAW 19:50ES
Sat, 18 JunTimes shown AEST
BRI vs WCE 13:40G
FRE vs PTA 16:35Domain Stadium
WBU vs GEE 19:25ES
Sun, 19 JunTimes shown AEST
SYD vs MEL 13:10SCG
ESS vs GWS 16:40ES
View All Fixtures
Round 14
Thu, 23 JunTimes shown AEST
ADE vs NTH 19:50Adelaide Oval
Fri, 24 JunTimes shown AEST
COL vs FRE 19:50MCG
Sat, 25 JunTimes shown AEST
RIC vs BRI 13:40MCG
GWS vs CAR 16:35Spotless Stadium
STK vs GEE 19:25ES
Sun, 26 JunTimes shown AEST
HAW vs GCF 15:20AS
View All Fixtures
Round 15
Thu, 30 JunTimes shown AEST
WCE vs ESS 20:10Domain Stadium
Fri, 01 JulTimes shown AEST
PTA vs RIC 19:50Adelaide Oval
Sat, 02 JulTimes shown AEST
GCF vs STK 13:40MS
SYD vs WBU 16:35SCG
CAR vs COL 19:25MCG
Sun, 03 JulTimes shown AEST
MEL vs ADE 15:20MCG
View All Fixtures
Round 16
Thu, 07 JulTimes shown AEST
PTA vs HAW 19:50Adelaide Oval
Fri, 08 JulTimes shown AEST
GEE vs SYD 19:50SS
Sat, 09 JulTimes shown AEST
GWS vs COL 13:40Spotless Stadium
GCF vs BRI 16:35MS
WBU vs RIC 19:25ES
MEL vs FRE 19:40TIO
Sun, 10 JulTimes shown AEST
CAR vs ADE 13:10MCG
WCE vs NTH 15:20Domain Stadium
ESS vs STK 16:40ES
View All Fixtures
Round 17
Thu, 14 JulTimes shown AEST
SYD vs HAW 19:20SCG
Fri, 15 JulTimes shown AEST
FRE vs GEE 20:10Domain Stadium
Sat, 16 JulTimes shown AEST
RIC vs ESS 13:40MCG
NTH vs PTA 16:35ES
WBU vs GCF 19:25CAZ
ADE vs COL 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 17 JulTimes shown AEST
CAR vs WCE 13:10MCG
STK vs MEL 15:20ES
BRI vs GWS 16:40G
View All Fixtures
Round 18
Fri, 22 JulTimes shown AEST
COL vs NTH 19:50ES
Sat, 23 JulTimes shown AEST
SYD vs CAR 13:45ANZ
GCF vs FRE 14:10MS
WCE vs MEL 16:35Domain Stadium
WBU vs STK 19:25ES
GEE vs ADE 19:25SS
Sun, 24 JulTimes shown AEST
ESS vs BRI 13:10ES
HAW vs RIC 15:20MCG
PTA vs GWS 16:40Adelaide Oval
View All Fixtures
Round 19
Fri, 29 JulTimes shown AEST
GEE vs WBU 19:50SS
Sat, 30 JulTimes shown AEST
GWS vs RIC 13:45SO
HAW vs CAR 14:10AS
COL vs WCE 16:35MCG
BRI vs PTA 19:25G
NTH vs STK 19:25ES
Sun, 31 JulTimes shown AEST
MEL vs GCF 13:10MCG
FRE vs SYD 15:20Domain Stadium
ADE vs ESS 16:40Adelaide Oval
View All Fixtures
Round 20
Fri, 05 AugTimes shown AEST
RIC vs COL 19:50MCG
Sat, 06 AugTimes shown AEST
SYD vs PTA 13:45SCG
MEL vs HAW 14:10MCG
GCF vs GWS 16:35MS
WBU vs NTH 19:25ES
ADE vs BRI 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 07 AugTimes shown AEST
CAR vs STK 13:10MCG
GEE vs ESS 15:20ES
FRE vs WCE 16:40Domain Stadium
View All Fixtures
Round 21
Fri, 12 AugTimes shown AEST
WBU vs COL 19:50ES
Sat, 13 AugTimes shown AEST
BRI vs CAR 13:45G
HAW vs NTH 14:10MCG
GWS vs WCE 16:35Spotless Stadium
STK vs SYD 19:25ES
PTA vs MEL 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 14 AugTimes shown AEST
ESS vs GCF 13:10ES
RIC vs GEE 15:20MCG
FRE vs ADE 16:40Domain Stadium
View All Fixtures
Round 22
Fri, 19 AugTimes shown AEST
WCE vs HAW 20:10Domain Stadium
Sat, 20 AugTimes shown AEST
NTH vs SYD 13:45BA
RIC vs STK 14:10MCG
GWS vs FRE 16:35Spotless Stadium
COL vs GCF 19:25ES
PTA vs ADE 19:40Adelaide Oval
Sun, 21 AugTimes shown AEST
CAR vs MEL 13:10MCG
BRI vs GEE 15:20G
ESS vs WBU 16:40ES
View All Fixtures
Round 23
Sat, 27 AugTimes shown AEST
HAW vs COL 12:00MCG
STK vs BRI 12:00ES
ESS vs CAR 12:00MCG
GCF vs PTA 12:00MS
SYD vs RIC 12:00SCG
NTH vs GWS 12:00ES
GEE vs MEL 12:00SS
ADE vs WCE 12:30Adelaide Oval
FRE vs WBU 14:00Domain Stadium
View All Fixtures
AFL 2015
Overall standings
Team P W L D % Pts
Adelaide Crows 0 0 0 0 - 0
Brisbane Lions 0 0 0 0 - 0
Carlton 0 0 0 0 - 0
Collingwood 0 0 0 0 - 0
Essendon 0 0 0 0 - 0
Fremantle 0 0 0 0 - 0
Geelong Cats 0 0 0 0 - 0
Gold Coast Suns 0 0 0 0 - 0
View all

Follow Us on Facebook

Featured advertisers