Essendon had a "sliding doors" moment when it hired Dean Robinson and Stephen Dank and this set the club and 34 AFL players on the path to ruin, former coach James Hird says.
The Court of Arbitration for sport on Tuesday upheld the World Anti-Doping Agency's appeal against the AFL tribunal decision to clear 34 players of taking the banned substance thymosin-beta 4 while Hird was coach, handing 34 past and present players a 12-month ban from the sport.
Essendon begin planning for difficult season
Coach John Worsfold dismisses suggestions that the Bombers won't win a game this season and says the club has begun appointing its leadership group and will promote the best rookies to the senior list.
In a column published by a News Limited newspaper, Hird revealed that fitness coach Robinson and sports scientist Dank were not the club's first choices in 2011 to run what it thought would be a cutting edge supplements program.
He wrote that the preferred candidate, working in the English Premier League, could not join Essendon until May 2012.
"Had we secured this preferred applicant then the experience of the Essendon Football Club and 34 young men would have been very different," he wrote.
"Instead the sliding door we walked through introduced Essendon to the worlds of Dean Robinson and, at Robinson's suggestion, Stephen Dank."
Hird said he was comfortable with the supplements program if the supplements were AFL- and ASADA-approved, that players would not be harmed and gave informed consent and that club doctor Bruce Reid gave final approval.
"The supplements program then, from my perspective, had sound logic, important goals, the people the club had engaged presented as credible and successful, the structure for the program was right and the protocol for decision-making and player welfare had integrity," he wrote.
"It seems that what transpired was that the protocol we put in place was not always followed."
"Importantly, to our knowledge at that time, this was the scope of the problem, because Dank had assured the club the supplements were compliant.
"He had even presented supporting evidence."
Dank was later sacked, Robinson's role scaled back and the supplements program modified so that only Dr Reid could administer injections.
Should Jobe Watson be stripped of his 2012 Brownlow Medal?
Poll closed 5 Apr, 2016
Disclaimer: These polls are not scientific and reflect the opinion only of visitors who have chosen to participate.