JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

It's time to scrap the match review process

Melbourne's Colin Sylvia about to collect Gold Coast's Jared Brennan with an elbow.

Melbourne's Colin Sylvia about to collect Gold Coast's Jared Brennan with an elbow. Photo: Sebastian Costanzo

Like a lot of people, I was a fan of the concept of the Match Review Panel when it was introduced in 2005. The theory sounded good, a standardised points formula which should by rights deliver more consistent penalties, and save plenty of time wasted on tribunal hearings for frivolous charges. And there's no doubt on the latter score, it's delivered, 25 tribunal sittings held last year as opposed to 125 in the last year of the old system in 2004.

What James Kelly did last Friday night was hardly outside the spirit of the game. He didn’t deserve what he got. What Colin Sylvia did was. He deserved more. 

But theory doesn't always translate to reality. And that is the AFL's judicial system continues to fail its most basic test, to deliver verdicts consistent with the football crimes committed, and which don’t leave the vast bulk of the football world shaking their heads in bewilderment.

There's more head-shaking going on than usual today after the tribunal on Tuesday night upheld the MRP's two-game suspension for Geelong's James Kelly's bump on Essendon’s Brendon Goddard, the Cats' skipper Joel Selwood having tweeted: "Sad day … the bump is dead".

He may well have a case, too, certainly the bump as we've come to know it, Kelly's contact in the midst of a quick passage of play, an attempt to remove the potential tackle on teammate Allen Christensen by the Essendon player, conducted with his arm tucked in, his head turned, his one sin being that his feet ever so slightly left the ground, causing Goddard to be taken high.

A slight misjudgement, perhaps. Malicious? No way. Indeed, Goddard tweeted Kelly soon after the game to tell him: "Good hit last night. Old fashioned shirt front".

That was a genuine thumbs up, and sent long before Goddard appeared on Tuesday night to give evidence which critics of the old system would always argue was concocted under the unofficial players' brotherhood code. The tribunal paid it scant attention, though, and Kelly's two-game penalty remained.

And now for the ultimate contrast. And it is another verdict from last weekend, concerning Melbourne's Colin Sylvia, which is the classic Exhibit A.

Sylvia, frustrated by his side's inept performance against Gold Coast on Sunday, decided to vent his spleen by continuing to run towards Jared Brennan well after the Suns player had dished off a handball, raise both arms, and elbow Brennan to the head. Nobody could rightly argue it was contact made in the context of play. To be blunt, it was a pissweak effort.

Watch the videos of both incidents. Kelly's bump is delivered with a teammate about to pick up the ball, an opponent nearby with the potential to interfere with that aim, and Kelly trying to allow his player free passage, the only slight error one of timing. Goddard is stunned for a moment, but picks himself up and carries on.

Sylvia, in contrast, picks off a player who has already disposed of the ball, knowing he cannot possibly influence the passage of play. He's late to arrive, and when he does, chooses not even to lay a bump to make his presence felt, but collect Brennan with one of the sharpest, boniest bits of the body. Brennan is concussed and stretchered from the ground.

Yet for some inexplicable reason, to me anyway, both Kelly and Sylvia were deemed to have engaged in "reckless conduct". Kelly’s at worst should have been considered "negligent". Sylvia somehow escaped a rating of "intentional".

MRP chairman Mark Fraser, describing the incident in an AFL video, says: "Brennan disposes of the ball, Sylvia continues forward and puts both arms up in an attempt to probably make body contact. Sylvia elbows Brennan in the head, and obviously he was concussed and didn't come back on."

But then, explaining the reckless grading, he adds: "We don't think that Sylvia has intentionally struck him …" Excuse me? So exactly what was he doing charging at an opponent who'd got rid of the ball, with his arms raised and elbow out? Show him a variation on "Gangnam Style"?

There's inconsistency for you. And now to the matter of discounts and loading. Fortunately, Sylvia's bad record didn't allow him 25 per cent off for an early plea, otherwise he would have ended up with exactly the same two-week penalty as Kelly, also stuck with a bad record due to a hardly earth-shattering one-game suspension from last year’s elimination final.

The AFL last summer tweaked the loadings and discounts formula, making it marginally more lenient on previous misdemeanours, and marginally less rewarding for the well-behaved. Yet still, when either is factored into a penalty, the bottom line is too often completely out of whack with the seriousness or otherwise of the report in question.

What James Kelly did last Friday night was hardly outside the spirit of the game. He didn’t deserve what he got. What Colin Sylvia did was. He deserved more.

There's plenty more examples where they came from. And more evidence mounting that points systems, set penalties and clauses which either benefit or punish further players' histories are too often attempting to fit square pegs in round holes.

The Match Review Panel was a good idea which hasn't worked. And I reckon it's time we scrapped it and went back to actually treating each case on its merits, even if it means the blokes on the tribunal have to put it a few more hours each week.

120 comments so far

  • Well said Rowan - Ive been arguing for years that the MRP inconsistency goes as far down to the roots as to what is referred and what isn't.

    Commenter
    Rat Patrol
    Date and time
    May 15, 2013, 8:33AM
    • Rat Patrol, who are you actually arguing to? Directly to the AFL, your mates or just your toughy forum mates?

      Commenter
      Specialness
      Location
      AFL House
      Date and time
      May 15, 2013, 10:47AM
    • oh dear Rohan. you normally write a decent article with reasonable arguments, but really. Surely you remember waking up on a tuesday morning not having any idea what kind of verdict would be handed down by the buffoons that were the AFL tribunal.

      the present system is fine. incidents are graded and can be challenged. it is completely transparent. if the wording of the laws is dubious, that is not the fault of the MRP

      now come Ro - lift your game

      Commenter
      Gaz
      Location
      Yarrawonga
      Date and time
      May 15, 2013, 2:55PM
    • In the Brett Goodes case, he was about to be tacked by Caddy, while Goodes was chasing the ball, and Goodes merely braced himself for contact. Yet he was assessed a 3 week penalty.

      The problem is, we are using the legal system as a model for the MRP. Anyone who has had any experience in the legal system would tell you that's a bad idea if you want to achieve justice.

      Commenter
      The J Dog
      Location
      Docklands
      Date and time
      May 15, 2013, 4:09PM
  • Exactly. And so blantantly unfair that we can only imagine the reasons for it.

    Commenter
    fish
    Date and time
    May 15, 2013, 9:07AM
    • It's not as unfair as Collingwood planting Malthouse at Carlton to make sure they don't make the finals! It's a cunning plan and so far it's working better than Eddie would have dared hope when he and Mick organized it.

      Commenter
      fred
      Date and time
      May 15, 2013, 2:32PM
    • Fred you're half a lemon short of a salt shaker.

      Commenter
      Ed
      Date and time
      May 15, 2013, 9:36PM
  • Rohan in the Sylvia incident I thought that actually Sylvia was slowing down and Brennan kept coming and Sylvia's action was to a degree self protection.Do these two players have previous form against each other.

    Commenter
    peter
    Location
    daintree
    Date and time
    May 15, 2013, 9:13AM
    • Firstly, Sylvia hit Brennan when Brennan was going passed him. What was he defending?
      Secondly, if he were protecting himself he would've push Brennan away, not swing an elbow.

      Commenter
      PeeRod
      Date and time
      May 15, 2013, 10:49AM
  • Rohan, Your last comments regarding the the Tribunal having to put in some extra hours seem very relevant. It appears as though every time the tribunal is called upon, it is inconvenient for them and they prefer to uphold the MRP decision just to punish for the inconvenience.

    Commenter
    Sydney Reader
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    May 15, 2013, 9:30AM

    More comments

    Make a comment

    You are logged in as [Logout]

    All information entered below may be published.

    Error: Please enter your screen name.

    Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

    Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

    Error: Please enter your comment.

    Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

    Post to

    You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

    Thank you

    Your comment has been submitted for approval.

    Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

    Related Coverage

    'Sad day: the bump is dead'

    Favourable evidence from Brendon Goddard does not sway the tribunal.

    AFL bump a fine line: McCartney

    Just centimetres now separate a fair bump and an illegal one in the AFL, according to Western Bulldogs coach Brendan McCartney.

    Coaches urge caution on bump furore

    One coach says the bump isn't dead. One says it is. Yet another says there's only centimetres in it.

    I didn't lie to tribunal, Goddard maintains

    Essendon's Brendon Goddard insists he wasn't lying to the AFL Tribunal when he told them Geelong's James Kelly didn't bump him high.

    Coaches cop bump rule on chin

    Coaches proving themselves more amenable than players to AFL's rationale for, and implementation of, stringent rules to dissuade high contact during bumps.

    Related Coverage

    AFL 2015

    Round 1
    Thu, 02 AprTimes shown AEDT
    CAR 78 vs RIC 105 Report Stats
    Sat, 04 AprTimes shown AEDT
    MEL 115 vs GCF 89 Stats
    SYD 72 vs ESS 60 Stats
    BRI 74 vs COL 86 Stats
    WBU 97 vs WCE 87 Stats
    Sun, 05 AprTimes shown AEST
    STK 78 vs GWS 87 Stats
    ADE 140 vs NTH 63 Stats
    FRE 75 vs PTA 68 Stats
    Mon, 06 AprTimes shown AEST
    HAW 123 vs GEE 61 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 2
    Fri, 10 AprTimes shown AEST
    WCE 131 vs CAR 62 Stats
    Sat, 11 AprTimes shown AEST
    RIC 66 vs WBU 85 Report Stats
    GWS 101 vs MEL 56 Stats
    COL 63 vs ADE 90 Report Stats
    GCF 76 vs STK 104 Stats
    PTA 44 vs SYD 92 Stats
    Sun, 12 AprTimes shown AEST
    GEE 60 vs FRE 104 Stats
    ESS 78 vs HAW 76 Stats
    NTH 133 vs BRI 51 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 3
    Fri, 17 AprTimes shown AEST
    COL 140 vs STK 66 Stats
    Sat, 18 AprTimes shown AEST
    CAR 84 vs ESS 105 Stats
    ADE 80 vs MEL 55 Stats
    SYD 111 vs GWS 90 Report Stats
    NTH 105 vs PTA 113 Stats
    BRI 58 vs RIC 137 Stats
    Sun, 19 AprTimes shown AEST
    HAW 127 vs WBU 57 Stats
    GEE 105 vs GCF 96 Stats
    WCE 81 vs FRE 111 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 4
    Fri, 24 AprTimes shown AEST
    RIC 51 vs MEL 83 Stats
    Sat, 25 AprTimes shown AEST
    STK 81 vs CAR 121 Report Report Stats
    ESS 49 vs COL 69 Report Stats
    GWS 119 vs GCF 53 Stats
    PTA 99 vs HAW 91 Stats
    FRE 74 vs SYD 60 Stats
    Sun, 26 AprTimes shown AEST
    BRI 65 vs WCE 118 Stats
    GEE 67 vs NTH 83 Stats
    WBU 125 vs ADE 68 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 5
    Fri, 01 MayTimes shown AEST
    CAR 45 vs COL 120 Stats
    Sat, 02 MayTimes shown AEST
    RIC 76 vs GEE 85 Stats
    SYD 73 vs WBU 77 Stats
    GCF 118 vs BRI 54 Stats
    NTH 70 vs HAW 130 Stats
    WCE 120 vs GWS 33 Stats
    Sun, 03 MayTimes shown AEST
    MEL 50 vs FRE 118 Stats
    STK 80 vs ESS 82 Stats
    ADE 91 vs PTA 115 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 6
    Fri, 08 MayTimes shown AEST
    COL 59 vs GEE 100 Stats
    Sat, 09 MayTimes shown AEST
    NTH 109 vs RIC 74 Stats
    WBU 87 vs STK 94 Stats
    GWS 108 vs HAW 98 Stats
    GCF 78 vs ADE 119 Stats
    MEL 50 vs SYD 88 Stats
    FRE 80 vs ESS 52 Stats
    Sun, 10 MayTimes shown AEST
    CAR 75 vs BRI 84 Report Stats
    PTA 68 vs WCE 78 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 7
    Fri, 15 MayTimes shown AEST
    ESS 82 vs NTH 93 Stats
    Sat, 16 MayTimes shown AEST
    ADE 119 vs STK 73 Stats
    HAW 155 vs MEL 50 Stats
    CAR 57 vs GWS 135 Stats
    SYD 120 vs GEE 77 Stats
    WCE 135 vs GCF 43 Stats
    Sun, 17 MayTimes shown AEST
    WBU 88 vs FRE 101 Stats
    RIC 105 vs COL 100 Report Stats
    BRI 102 vs PTA 65 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 8
    Fri, 22 MayTimes shown AEST
    GEE 140 vs CAR 63 Report Stats
    Sat, 23 MayTimes shown AEST
    STK 78 vs WCE 131 Report Stats
    GWS 108 vs ADE 84 Report Stats
    GCF 63 vs COL 132 Report Stats
    HAW 69 vs SYD 73 Report Stats
    FRE 115 vs NTH 42 Report Stats
    Sun, 24 MayTimes shown AEST
    ESS 136 vs BRI 78 Report Stats
    MEL 103 vs WBU 64 Report Stats
    PTA 43 vs RIC 76 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 9
    Fri, 29 MayTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs CAR 19:50SCG
    Sat, 30 MayTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs GCF 13:45AS
    MEL vs PTA 14:10TIO Traeger Park
    WBU vs GWS 16:35ES
    RIC vs ESS 19:20MCG
    ADE vs FRE 19:40Adelaide Oval
    Sun, 31 MayTimes shown AEST
    BRI vs STK 13:10G
    COL vs NTH 15:20MCG
    WCE vs GEE 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 10
    Fri, 05 JunTimes shown AEST
    FRE vs RIC 20:10Domain Stadium
    Sat, 06 JunTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs ADE 13:40MCG
    GCF vs SYD 16:35MS
    ESS vs GEE 19:20ES
    PTA vs WBU 19:40Adelaide Oval
    Sun, 07 JunTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs BRI 13:10Spotless Stadium
    NTH vs WCE 15:20BA
    STK vs HAW 16:40ES
    Mon, 08 JunTimes shown AEST
    MEL vs COL 15:20MCG
    View All Fixtures
    Round 11
    Fri, 12 JunTimes shown AEST
    PTA vs GEE 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Sat, 13 JunTimes shown AEST
    GCF vs FRE 13:40MS
    WCE vs ESS 16:35Domain Stadium
    NTH vs SYD 19:20ES
    Sun, 14 JunTimes shown AEST
    COL vs GWS 13:10MCG
    STK vs MEL 16:40ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 12
    Thu, 18 JunTimes shown AEST
    ADE vs HAW 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Fri, 19 JunTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs WCE 19:50MCG
    Sat, 20 JunTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs PTA 13:40MCG
    GWS vs NTH 16:35Spotless Stadium
    WBU vs BRI 19:20ES
    Sun, 21 JunTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs MEL 15:20SS
    View All Fixtures
    Round 13
    Thu, 25 JunTimes shown AEST
    FRE vs COL 20:10Domain Stadium
    Fri, 26 JunTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs RIC 19:50SCG
    Sat, 27 JunTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs ESS 13:40MCG
    BRI vs ADE 16:35G
    STK vs WBU 19:20ES
    Sun, 28 JunTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs GCF 15:20ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 14
    Thu, 02 JulTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs PTA 19:20SCG
    Fri, 03 JulTimes shown AEST
    COL vs HAW 19:50MCG
    Sat, 04 JulTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs GWS 13:40MCG
    GCF vs NTH 16:35MS
    WBU vs CAR 19:20ES
    MEL vs WCE 19:40TIO
    Sun, 05 JulTimes shown AEST
    ESS vs STK 13:10ES
    ADE vs GEE 15:20Adelaide Oval
    FRE vs BRI 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 15
    Thu, 09 JulTimes shown AEST
    PTA vs COL 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Fri, 10 JulTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs CAR 19:50MCG
    Sat, 11 JulTimes shown AEST
    ESS vs MEL 13:40MCG
    WBU vs GCF 16:35CAZ
    NTH vs GEE 19:20ES
    WCE vs ADE 19:40Domain Stadium
    Sun, 12 JulTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs STK 13:10Spotless Stadium
    HAW vs FRE 15:20AS
    BRI vs SYD 16:40G
    View All Fixtures
    Round 16
    Fri, 17 JulTimes shown AEST
    NTH vs ESS 19:50ES
    Sat, 18 JulTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs WBU 13:45SS
    GCF vs GWS 14:10MS
    COL vs WCE 16:35ES
    SYD vs HAW 19:20ANZ
    FRE vs CAR 19:40Domain Stadium
    Sun, 19 JulTimes shown AEST
    MEL vs BRI 13:10MCG
    PTA vs ADE 15:20Adelaide Oval
    STK vs RIC 16:40ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 17
    Fri, 24 JulTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs HAW 19:50ES
    Sat, 25 JulTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs GEE 13:45SO
    ADE vs GCF 14:10Adelaide Oval
    RIC vs FRE 16:35MCG
    ESS vs PTA 19:20ES
    BRI vs NTH 19:20G
    Sun, 26 JulTimes shown AEST
    WBU vs COL 13:10ES
    MEL vs STK 15:20MCG
    WCE vs SYD 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 18
    Fri, 31 JulTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs RIC 19:50MCG
    Sat, 01 AugTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs BRI 13:45SS
    COL vs MEL 14:10MCG
    SYD vs ADE 16:35SCG
    CAR vs NTH 19:20ES
    GCF vs WCE 19:20MS
    Sun, 02 AugTimes shown AEST
    PTA vs STK 13:10Adelaide Oval
    ESS vs WBU 15:20ES
    FRE vs GWS 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 19
    Fri, 07 AugTimes shown AEST
    ADE vs RIC 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Sat, 08 AugTimes shown AEST
    COL vs CAR 13:45MCG
    WBU vs PTA 14:10ES
    BRI vs GCF 16:35G
    GEE vs SYD 19:20SS
    WCE vs HAW 19:40Domain Stadium
    Sun, 09 AugTimes shown AEST
    MEL vs NTH 13:10MCG
    GWS vs ESS 15:20Spotless Stadium
    STK vs FRE 16:40ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 20
    Fri, 14 AugTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs COL 19:50SCG
    Sat, 15 AugTimes shown AEST
    ESS vs ADE 13:45ES
    NTH vs STK 14:10BA
    PTA vs GWS 16:35Adelaide Oval
    GEE vs HAW 19:20MCG
    BRI vs CAR 19:20G
    Sun, 16 AugTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs GCF 13:10MCG
    WBU vs MEL 15:20ES
    FRE vs WCE 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 21
    Fri, 21 AugTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs PTA 19:50ES
    Sat, 22 AugTimes shown AEST
    COL vs RIC 13:45MCG
    GWS vs SYD 14:10Spotless Stadium
    GCF vs ESS 16:35MS
    STK vs GEE 19:20ES
    ADE vs BRI 19:40Adelaide Oval
    Sun, 23 AugTimes shown AEST
    NTH vs FRE 13:10ES
    CAR vs MEL 15:20MCG
    WCE vs WBU 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 22
    Fri, 28 AugTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs COL 19:50MCG
    Sat, 29 AugTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs CAR 13:45Spotless Stadium
    HAW vs BRI 14:10AS
    NTH vs WBU 16:35ES
    ESS vs RIC 19:20MCG
    GCF vs PTA 19:20MS
    Sun, 30 AugTimes shown AEST
    ADE vs WCE 13:10Adelaide Oval
    STK vs SYD 15:20ES
    FRE vs MEL 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 23
    Fri, 04 SepTimes shown AEST
    COL vs ESS 00:00MCG
    RIC vs NTH 00:00ES
    HAW vs CAR 00:00MCG
    GEE vs ADE 00:00SS
    SYD vs GCF 00:00SCG
    MEL vs GWS 00:00ES
    BRI vs WBU 00:00G
    PTA vs FRE 00:30Adelaide Oval
    WCE vs STK 02:00Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    AFL 2015
    Overall standings
    Team P W L D % Pts
    Fremantle 8 8 0 0 155.29 32
    West Coast Eagles 8 6 2 0 158.17 24
    Sydney Swans 8 6 2 0 127.36 24
    GWS Giants 8 6 2 0 118.87 24
    Collingwood 8 5 3 0 129.90 20
    Adelaide Crows 8 5 3 0 116.32 20
    Hawthorn 8 4 4 0 145.81 16
    Richmond 8 4 4 0 107.64 16
    View all
     
    Featured advertisers