JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Ratten runs hot, Hird goes cold

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

A big weekend of AFL upsets

Our footy experts analyse the clash between St Kilda and Essendon, and Carlton's big win over Collingwood.

PT0M0S 620 349

DO COACHES make teams or teams make coaches? It's a perennial football question, one at times that is almost impossible to answer, but one worth pondering again after two crucial and surprising results over round 15.

It was a poor night in the box for James Hird and Mark Thompson, and the next few weeks might prove equally as testing, with the Bombers' run home tough to say the least. 

On Friday night, Carlton's Brett Ratten went from popular whipping boy to hero with the Blues' sizeable fan base with their 23-point win over Collingwood. The greater intent of Ratten's side than in its insipid loss to Hawthorn was clearly a major factor. But so were a couple of shrewd coaching and selection moves.

Grey area: Bomber coach James Hird was caught out by several of the Saints' moves.

Grey area: Bomber coach James Hird was caught out by several of the Saints' moves. Photo: Getty Images

Ratten bit the bullet and gave one of the three ruckmen, Robbie Warnock, the heave-ho. That might have blown up in his face once Shaun Hampson went down, but it proved just the challenge Matthew Kreuzer required, and he responded in the fashion Ratten had predicted all week he would.

The biggest masterstroke was the use of regular backmen Nick Duigan and Dennis Armfield as defensive forwards, the pair not only thwarting Collingwood's trademark rebound, but conjuring five scoring shots and three goals to Duigan.

On Saturday night, Essendon was spanked by a very switched-on St Kilda, the steely focus of the Saints compared to their lacklustre opponent apparent very early. The Bombers had poor players everywhere. But there's an argument they got a pretty ordinary performance from the coaching box as well.

Perhaps no amount of tactical genius would have saved Essendon. But a series of questionable moves, starting at the selection table, didn't seem to help its cause.

With Stewart Crameri out suspended, and St Kilda having lost Jason Blake and Rhys Stanley, the Bombers could have loaded up with height. Having seen the way North Melbourne ran rings around the Saints, they could have opted for a full-on pace assault. In reality, they did neither, no obvious replacement for Crameri picked, and promising small man Corey Dell'Olio dumped, and Travis Colyer still cooling his heels.

Once the game started, Essendon was clearly caught on the hop, St Kilda's coaching smarts coming through in Scott Watters sending Nick Dal Santo to Jobe Watson, which might have been considered a possibility, and Leigh Montagna to Brent Stanton, which clearly no one outside the St Kilda camp had counted on.

Bomber Heath Hocking continued to try to take Dal Santo, the resultant two-on-one giving the Saints the midfield edge, as did Watson starting outside the centre square, which lost all the early drive that had won it last week's game against the Western Bulldogs by quarter-time.

The list of questionable calls grew, as did the the size of St Kilda's lead. David Myers, who has had a career-best run of form in midfield, found himself again stuck, ill-suited, in defence. Michael Hurley, struggling with his hamstrings from the start, got some help from emerging key defender Jake Carlisle.

But that failed on three fronts. Hurley's "string" eventually gave way, a likely month-long absence the result, Carlisle failed to have an impact up forward, and his absence from defence threw out what has been a settled backline.

Dustin Fletcher not allowed to play his usual marshalling role, continually being dragged up the ground as Cale Hooker struggled to cope with Nick Riewoldt.

Nathan Lovett-Murray has been an effective substitute for Essendon. As a four-quarter player against the Saints he was found wanting for impact or stamina.

This week's wearer of the red vest, Ricky Dyson, was also unable to make an impression.

It was a poor night in the box for James Hird and Mark Thompson, and the next few weeks might prove equally as testing, with the Bombers' run home tough to say the least.

Hurley, Crameri and the certain-to-be-suspended Hocking will be key absentees this week, and replacements have to be found with more discretion than seemed the case against the Saints.

These are the sorts of coaching decisions made each week. Most pass with little notice. Except when, like Ratten, you're under so much heat a mere show of animation in the box or bench, let alone a positional switch, is portrayed as some sort of definitive proof you lack the necessary coaching chops.

So credit to him for staring down the mob, pulling a little inspiration from the kitbag, and extracting from his team a victory that not only might have saved his bacon, but turned his team's season around.

Credit, too, to St Kilda's Watters, fast building a reputation, even in his first season, as one of the AFL's more shrewd string-pullers, and his side defying the widespread predictions of its immediate demise.

Essendon's tandem of a couple of the club's greatest names has already achieved plenty and has the Bombers on the right track.

But even a coaching "dream team" can occasionally have a nightmare.


  • Spot on Rohan! The disparity in effort and intensity at the ball aside, Essendon was significantly outcoached by Watters. They executed the 'blueprint' to beat the Bombers beautifully. The 'blueprint' is (and was executed well by Melbourne and Sydney resulting in their wins against the Bombers) quite simple - crowd the Essendon forward line, play 'man-on-man' when not in possession and drag your opponent into the corridor so as to reduce the space for the Essendon midfield. As a result you have your own forward line open which is actually something the Essendon defence struggles with - especially Hooker and Myers who have questionable disposal by foot and need a nearby teammate to handball off to. The Bombers set up their forward forays from the D50, with runners setting up behind the ball carrier about 20-30m out from the defensive goal, and therefore can't do so when most of the players are forward of the ball.

    This is a Bombers fan speaking here - the Dons are still too predictable and will remain pretenders until they can break the shackles of an old-fashioned 'flood'. With such a tough draw to come, I wont be that surprised if the Dons only scrape together just a couple more wins and actually miss out on the finals.

    Date and time
    July 09, 2012, 12:19AM
    • Good summary RC, and good response too DJCJ. Maybe the bombers should get you on their coaching staff? Hird's the problem I think, and I understand he's not one to take much heed from others. The player list however is workable.

      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 10:04AM
    • DJCJ your observations are pretty obvious and don't take into account the subtleties of the game. If coaching & tactics was as simple as you clearly think it is the Bombers wouldn't be 10-4 and would have lost far more games this year.
      Essendon's strength this year and improvement have stemmed from an increased focus on defence, and defensive intensity was lacking on Saturday night - except from the Saints. They were beaten in tackles and contested possessions and the defensive transition was not there - all psychological factors. It has nothing to do with an inability to cope with a 'flood'. Even if the ball is turned over in a choked forward 50 the opposition still needs to get the ball downfield to score.
      Don't give up your day job.

      See Clearly
      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 10:58AM
    • I stand by my comments 101% Sydneysider - and you obviously chose to ignore my first sentence as well. The Bombers simply cannot set up scoring opportunities in a crowded forward line. Against the Dogs they lost the contested possesion count and won by 84 pts! Watch the 'transition' as the mids try to hit up an option - Heppell, Myers, Melksham, even Stanton - all key offenders on Sat night, (as in the Syd and Melb games) where as they carry the ball through the centre square they don't have a running option coming up from behind them especially on the centre-side of the ground, because their teammates are manning up their opponents who have crowded the F50. The minutes leading up to that Riewoldt goal in the mid of 3rdQ is a perfect example.

      Collingwood are experts at holding onto the ball when their F50 is crowded, and allow time for their teammates to clear out their F50 by leading to the flanks or dropping back to the goal square - leaving a hole 30-40m out for forwards to lead into. Hawks and Eagles also are very good at this too. The Dons don't seem able to do it - they don't spread far enough, and end up with dinky ring-a-rosy chipping that is ripe for a turnover OR its a long bomb in the off chance that a Bombers player takes a contested mark amongst 5 or 6 others!

      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 1:52PM
    • @DCDJ - saw the game, and your observations are spot on. Taking away the corrodor completely flummoxed the Bombers, and they had no comeback.

      @ See Clearly of Sydney - you accuse DCDJ of ignoring the subtleties of the game, yet all you can offer is the same, tired, obvious (and very unsubtle) NON-insights of "more defensive intensity and pressure". If you keep using these well worn phrases, maybe YOU SHOULD give up YOUR day job, and join the Sports Cliche Editorial team at the Herald Sun. (And by the way, you left out the words "accountability", "intensity", "in-and-under" and "Plan B" - make sure you include these next time to truly complete your contributions.

      Impartial Fan
      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 3:47PM
  • We had a shocker from Thursday night where we didn't pick a tall to cover a tall, to making Ricky D Sub and playing NatRat 4 quarters, to the bizarre image of Watto running OUTSIDE the square instead of being in it. Shocking "performance" from the Head down; in all aspects'coaching, attitude, selection, desire the works.......and MORE bloody soft tissue injuries.
    Plus Riemo might find himself as TB after passing to Davey surrounded by 3 tall defenders instead of doing what he is paid to do - kick goals. Just doesn't think it through.


    Date and time
    July 09, 2012, 6:50AM
    • Phil, the real shocker was the Bombers new clash strip - the lads looked like they were playing in their PJs.

      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 9:01AM
    • Spot on Phil - Riemers clear inside 50 with a great look at goal and tried to pass to Davey was a shocking error of judgement. I grimace every time players try to pass to Davey on a lead - he's one of the shortest players in the competition! Kyle probably signed the death warrant on his career at the club with that performance.

      See Clearly
      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 11:00AM
    • @crowin' - yes this is the real reason for poor games, these lousy alternate strips. I'm a Blues supporter and our games in "baby blue" are always rubbish, wonder why they did away with a perfectly good white "away" strip?

      Date and time
      July 09, 2012, 1:13PM
  • Bit early calling all this aren;t we? One win for Carlton or one loss for the bombers hardly proves anything.

    the Bush
    Date and time
    July 09, 2012, 7:44AM

    More comments

    Comments are now closed

    Related Coverage

    AFL 2015

    Round 1
    Thu, 02 AprTimes shown AEDT
    CAR 78 vs RIC 105 Report Stats
    Sat, 04 AprTimes shown AEDT
    MEL 115 vs GCF 89 Stats
    SYD 72 vs ESS 60 Stats
    BRI 74 vs COL 86 Stats
    WBU 97 vs WCE 87 Stats
    Sun, 05 AprTimes shown AEST
    STK 78 vs GWS 87 Stats
    ADE 140 vs NTH 63 Stats
    FRE 75 vs PTA 68 Stats
    Mon, 06 AprTimes shown AEST
    HAW 123 vs GEE 61 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 2
    Fri, 10 AprTimes shown AEST
    WCE 131 vs CAR 62 Stats
    Sat, 11 AprTimes shown AEST
    RIC 66 vs WBU 85 Report Stats
    GWS 101 vs MEL 56 Stats
    COL 63 vs ADE 90 Report Stats
    GCF 76 vs STK 104 Stats
    PTA 44 vs SYD 92 Stats
    Sun, 12 AprTimes shown AEST
    GEE 60 vs FRE 104 Stats
    ESS 78 vs HAW 76 Stats
    NTH 133 vs BRI 51 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 3
    Fri, 17 AprTimes shown AEST
    COL 140 vs STK 66 Stats
    Sat, 18 AprTimes shown AEST
    CAR 84 vs ESS 105 Stats
    ADE 80 vs MEL 55 Stats
    SYD 111 vs GWS 90 Report Stats
    NTH 105 vs PTA 113 Stats
    BRI 58 vs RIC 137 Stats
    Sun, 19 AprTimes shown AEST
    HAW 127 vs WBU 57 Stats
    GEE 105 vs GCF 96 Stats
    WCE 81 vs FRE 111 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 4
    Fri, 24 AprTimes shown AEST
    RIC 51 vs MEL 83 Stats
    Sat, 25 AprTimes shown AEST
    STK 81 vs CAR 121 Report Report Stats
    ESS 49 vs COL 69 Report Stats
    GWS 119 vs GCF 53 Stats
    PTA 99 vs HAW 91 Stats
    FRE 74 vs SYD 60 Stats
    Sun, 26 AprTimes shown AEST
    BRI 65 vs WCE 118 Stats
    GEE 67 vs NTH 83 Stats
    WBU 125 vs ADE 68 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 5
    Fri, 01 MayTimes shown AEST
    CAR 45 vs COL 120 Stats
    Sat, 02 MayTimes shown AEST
    RIC 76 vs GEE 85 Stats
    SYD 73 vs WBU 77 Stats
    GCF 118 vs BRI 54 Stats
    NTH 70 vs HAW 130 Stats
    WCE 120 vs GWS 33 Stats
    Sun, 03 MayTimes shown AEST
    MEL 50 vs FRE 118 Stats
    STK 80 vs ESS 82 Stats
    ADE 91 vs PTA 115 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 6
    Fri, 08 MayTimes shown AEST
    COL 59 vs GEE 100 Stats
    Sat, 09 MayTimes shown AEST
    NTH 109 vs RIC 74 Stats
    WBU 87 vs STK 94 Stats
    GWS 108 vs HAW 98 Stats
    GCF 78 vs ADE 119 Stats
    MEL 50 vs SYD 88 Stats
    FRE 80 vs ESS 52 Stats
    Sun, 10 MayTimes shown AEST
    CAR 75 vs BRI 84 Report Stats
    PTA 68 vs WCE 78 Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 7
    Fri, 15 MayTimes shown AEST
    ESS 82 vs NTH 93 Stats
    Sat, 16 MayTimes shown AEST
    ADE 119 vs STK 73 Stats
    HAW 155 vs MEL 50 Stats
    CAR 57 vs GWS 135 Stats
    SYD 120 vs GEE 77 Stats
    WCE 135 vs GCF 43 Stats
    Sun, 17 MayTimes shown AEST
    WBU 88 vs FRE 101 Stats
    RIC 105 vs COL 100 Report Stats
    BRI 102 vs PTA 65 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 8
    Fri, 22 MayTimes shown AEST
    GEE 140 vs CAR 63 Report Stats
    Sat, 23 MayTimes shown AEST
    STK 78 vs WCE 131 Report Stats
    GWS 108 vs ADE 84 Report Stats
    GCF 63 vs COL 132 Report Stats
    HAW 69 vs SYD 73 Report Stats
    FRE 115 vs NTH 42 Report Stats
    Sun, 24 MayTimes shown AEST
    ESS 136 vs BRI 78 Report Stats
    MEL 103 vs WBU 64 Report Stats
    PTA 43 vs RIC 76 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 9
    Fri, 29 MayTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs CAR 19:50SCG
    Sat, 30 MayTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs GCF 13:45AS
    MEL vs PTA 14:10TIO Traeger Park
    WBU vs GWS 16:35ES
    RIC vs ESS 19:20MCG
    ADE vs FRE 19:40Adelaide Oval
    Sun, 31 MayTimes shown AEST
    BRI vs STK 13:10G
    COL vs NTH 15:20MCG
    WCE vs GEE 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 10
    Fri, 05 JunTimes shown AEST
    FRE vs RIC 20:10Domain Stadium
    Sat, 06 JunTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs ADE 13:40MCG
    GCF vs SYD 16:35MS
    ESS vs GEE 19:20ES
    PTA vs WBU 19:40Adelaide Oval
    Sun, 07 JunTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs BRI 13:10Spotless Stadium
    NTH vs WCE 15:20BA
    STK vs HAW 16:40ES
    Mon, 08 JunTimes shown AEST
    MEL vs COL 15:20MCG
    View All Fixtures
    Round 11
    Fri, 12 JunTimes shown AEST
    PTA vs GEE 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Sat, 13 JunTimes shown AEST
    GCF vs FRE 13:40MS
    WCE vs ESS 16:35Domain Stadium
    NTH vs SYD 19:20ES
    Sun, 14 JunTimes shown AEST
    COL vs GWS 13:10MCG
    STK vs MEL 16:40ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 12
    Thu, 18 JunTimes shown AEST
    ADE vs HAW 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Fri, 19 JunTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs WCE 19:50MCG
    Sat, 20 JunTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs PTA 13:40MCG
    GWS vs NTH 16:35Spotless Stadium
    WBU vs BRI 19:20ES
    Sun, 21 JunTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs MEL 15:20SS
    View All Fixtures
    Round 13
    Thu, 25 JunTimes shown AEST
    FRE vs COL 20:10Domain Stadium
    Fri, 26 JunTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs RIC 19:50SCG
    Sat, 27 JunTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs ESS 13:40MCG
    BRI vs ADE 16:35G
    STK vs WBU 19:20ES
    Sun, 28 JunTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs GCF 15:20ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 14
    Thu, 02 JulTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs PTA 19:20SCG
    Fri, 03 JulTimes shown AEST
    COL vs HAW 19:50MCG
    Sat, 04 JulTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs GWS 13:40MCG
    GCF vs NTH 16:35MS
    WBU vs CAR 19:20ES
    MEL vs WCE 19:40TIO
    Sun, 05 JulTimes shown AEST
    ESS vs STK 13:10ES
    ADE vs GEE 15:20Adelaide Oval
    FRE vs BRI 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 15
    Thu, 09 JulTimes shown AEST
    PTA vs COL 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Fri, 10 JulTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs CAR 19:50MCG
    Sat, 11 JulTimes shown AEST
    ESS vs MEL 13:40MCG
    WBU vs GCF 16:35CAZ
    NTH vs GEE 19:20ES
    WCE vs ADE 19:40Domain Stadium
    Sun, 12 JulTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs STK 13:10Spotless Stadium
    HAW vs FRE 15:20AS
    BRI vs SYD 16:40G
    View All Fixtures
    Round 16
    Fri, 17 JulTimes shown AEST
    NTH vs ESS 19:50ES
    Sat, 18 JulTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs WBU 13:45SS
    GCF vs GWS 14:10MS
    COL vs WCE 16:35ES
    SYD vs HAW 19:20ANZ
    FRE vs CAR 19:40Domain Stadium
    Sun, 19 JulTimes shown AEST
    MEL vs BRI 13:10MCG
    PTA vs ADE 15:20Adelaide Oval
    STK vs RIC 16:40ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 17
    Fri, 24 JulTimes shown AEST
    CAR vs HAW 19:50ES
    Sat, 25 JulTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs GEE 13:45SO
    ADE vs GCF 14:10Adelaide Oval
    RIC vs FRE 16:35MCG
    ESS vs PTA 19:20ES
    BRI vs NTH 19:20G
    Sun, 26 JulTimes shown AEST
    WBU vs COL 13:10ES
    MEL vs STK 15:20MCG
    WCE vs SYD 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 18
    Fri, 31 JulTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs RIC 19:50MCG
    Sat, 01 AugTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs BRI 13:45SS
    COL vs MEL 14:10MCG
    SYD vs ADE 16:35SCG
    CAR vs NTH 19:20ES
    GCF vs WCE 19:20MS
    Sun, 02 AugTimes shown AEST
    PTA vs STK 13:10Adelaide Oval
    ESS vs WBU 15:20ES
    FRE vs GWS 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 19
    Fri, 07 AugTimes shown AEST
    ADE vs RIC 19:50Adelaide Oval
    Sat, 08 AugTimes shown AEST
    COL vs CAR 13:45MCG
    WBU vs PTA 14:10ES
    BRI vs GCF 16:35G
    GEE vs SYD 19:20SS
    WCE vs HAW 19:40Domain Stadium
    Sun, 09 AugTimes shown AEST
    MEL vs NTH 13:10MCG
    GWS vs ESS 15:20Spotless Stadium
    STK vs FRE 16:40ES
    View All Fixtures
    Round 20
    Fri, 14 AugTimes shown AEST
    SYD vs COL 19:50SCG
    Sat, 15 AugTimes shown AEST
    ESS vs ADE 13:45ES
    NTH vs STK 14:10BA
    PTA vs GWS 16:35Adelaide Oval
    GEE vs HAW 19:20MCG
    BRI vs CAR 19:20G
    Sun, 16 AugTimes shown AEST
    RIC vs GCF 13:10MCG
    WBU vs MEL 15:20ES
    FRE vs WCE 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 21
    Fri, 21 AugTimes shown AEST
    HAW vs PTA 19:50ES
    Sat, 22 AugTimes shown AEST
    COL vs RIC 13:45MCG
    GWS vs SYD 14:10Spotless Stadium
    GCF vs ESS 16:35MS
    STK vs GEE 19:20ES
    ADE vs BRI 19:40Adelaide Oval
    Sun, 23 AugTimes shown AEST
    NTH vs FRE 13:10ES
    CAR vs MEL 15:20MCG
    WCE vs WBU 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 22
    Fri, 28 AugTimes shown AEST
    GEE vs COL 19:50MCG
    Sat, 29 AugTimes shown AEST
    GWS vs CAR 13:45Spotless Stadium
    HAW vs BRI 14:10AS
    NTH vs WBU 16:35ES
    ESS vs RIC 19:20MCG
    GCF vs PTA 19:20MS
    Sun, 30 AugTimes shown AEST
    ADE vs WCE 13:10Adelaide Oval
    STK vs SYD 15:20ES
    FRE vs MEL 16:40Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    Round 23
    Fri, 04 SepTimes shown AEST
    COL vs ESS 00:00MCG
    RIC vs NTH 00:00ES
    HAW vs CAR 00:00MCG
    GEE vs ADE 00:00SS
    SYD vs GCF 00:00SCG
    MEL vs GWS 00:00ES
    BRI vs WBU 00:00G
    PTA vs FRE 00:30Adelaide Oval
    WCE vs STK 02:00Domain Stadium
    View All Fixtures
    AFL 2015
    Overall standings
    Team P W L D % Pts
    Fremantle 8 8 0 0 155.29 32
    West Coast Eagles 8 6 2 0 158.17 24
    Sydney Swans 8 6 2 0 127.36 24
    GWS Giants 8 6 2 0 118.87 24
    Collingwood 8 5 3 0 129.90 20
    Adelaide Crows 8 5 3 0 116.32 20
    Hawthorn 8 4 4 0 145.81 16
    Richmond 8 4 4 0 107.64 16
    View all
    Featured advertisers