JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

The 2012 AFL national draft

Lachie Whitfield.

Lachie Whitfield. Photo: Wayne Taylor

Emma Quayle, Fairfax Media’s resident expert on the AFL draft, predicts how Thursday night's opening round may pan out.

Give us your thoughts on Emma's predictions — and your personal hopes for your AFL team. Leave a comment here.

(Dandenong Stingrays. 18, 184cm, 77kg)
Smart, versatile onballer with exquisite skill who can shape games.
THE RATIONALE: Whitfield is the best player on offer, and one the Giants have been waiting a long time for.
THE COMPLICATION: None. Whitfield has been locked in at No.1 all year.

Joe Daniher is regarded as a top selection but will go to Essendon as a father-son selection. Click for more photos

The pick of the crop at the AFL draft

Taking a closer look at the best young players who are certain to be selected at the 2012 AFL draft. Photo: Sebastian Costanzo and Joe Armao

(Calder Cannons. 18, 184cm, 73kg)
Ducking, weaving skilful wingman boasting one of the best kicks in the draft.
THE RATIONALE: O’Rourke is one of the best onballers in the draft, with arguably the best kick. Will complement Toby Greene, Dom Tyson and others nicely.
THE COMPLICATION: Lachie Plowman, Jimmy Toumpas and Troy Menzel are others who have been linked to the Giants in the past few weeks.

(Calder Cannons. 18, 192cm, 84kg)
Close-checking, key backman who reads the play brilliantly.
THE RATIONALE: If there’s one area of the Giants’ young list that needs some boosting, it’s their backline. Plowman’s the best defender of the lot and won’t make it to pick 12.
THE COMPLICATION: As mentioned above, O’Rourke, Toumpas and Menzel are also players the Giants like. Do they go two Victorians, two South Australians or a combination?

(Woodville-West Torrens. 18, 182cm, 78kg)
Goal kicking wingman who likes to run.
THE RATIONALE: Toumpas is a class act; a humble, hard-working player able to cut teams up with his skill and scoring ability. He’s just what the Dees need.
THE COMPLICATION: Melbourne has been watching Ollie Wines, a diligent, competitive onballer for a long time. He’d be a good choice here too.

(Oakleigh Chargers. 18, 189cm, 76kg)
Clever, quirky half-forward/midfielder capable of some freaky things.
THE RATIONALE: Macrae is many people’s favourite player in the draft. He has skill, instinct and kicks goals. The Dogs’ young group could do with a bit of polish, and he could help deliver it.
THE COMPLICATION: There are plenty. The Dogs have also been linked with Jake Stringer,  Menzel, O’Rourke and Plowman. Wines is a chance to go here too, should the Demons overlook him.

(Bendigo Pioneers. 18, 191cm, 94kg)
Powerful midfielder who can go forward and take marks.
THE RATIONALE: Stringer has been one of the Dogs’ favourites for a while and is just what coach Brendan McCartney likes: big-bodied and hard at it. Can play as an onballer and take marks in the forward line.
THE COMPLICATION: The Dogs may face a choice between Stringer and Wines, should Melbourne pass on Wines, with Menzel a big chance also.

(Bendigo Pioneers. 18, 188cm, 90kg)
Competitive inside midfielder who plays well no matter what is going on around him.
THE RATIONALE: Wines is a super solid, very reliable midfielder. He always plays well and challenges Melbourne’s father-son pick Jack Viney in the gusto stakes. Port need boosting in most areas but more than that, some desperate competitors.
THE COMPLICATION: Locals Sam Mayes, a midfielder/half-forward, and Brodie Grundy, a ruckman, are also chances here. Should the Bulldogs not take Stringer, he’s a chance to go at this pick too. Macrae is another possibility, if available.

(North Adelaide. 18, 187cm, 78kg)
Smart lead-up forward who is also able to get up and play in the midfield. One of the best few kicks in the draft.
THE RATIONALE: The Lions are looking for both an onballer, and a tall. They are big fans of Mayes, and have been hoping he’d get past Port Adelaide. With pick 24 also up their sleeve, they’ll get another shot at a good tall player.
THE COMPLICATION:  Wines could go here, should he get past the Bulldogs and Power. Kristian Jaksch and  Macrae are others the Lions have shown interest in.

(Northern Knights. 18, 187cm, 86kg)
Determined, hard-at-it midfielder who loves contested footy.
THE RATIONALE: The Tigers have been linked to ‘‘Tigger’’ for a long, long time. He would be another hard, reliable addition to their young midfield group.
THE COMPLICATION: There was some late mail for Brodie Grundy, should Port Adelaide let him through. The Tigers also have some interest in defender Aidan Corr.

(Calder Cannons. 18, 201cm, 89kg)
Tall forward who can also play in the ruck. Arguably the most promising player in the draft pool given his size, competitiveness and overall ability.
THE RATIONALE: The Bombers secured him, the son of former full-back Anthony, as a father-son pick two years ago.
THE COMPLICATION: None. Daniher has already spent much of this year training at Windy Hill while completing his year 12 studies.

(central Districts. 18, 187cm, 78kg)
Highly talented utility who can shape games like few others in the draft.
THE RATIONALE: Menzel just gets too hard to pass up on at this stage. Some clubs with early picks have been scared off by his history of knee injuries (he had LARS surgery at 16) but the risk is worth it at this point, and Carlton is looking for runners rather than talls.
THE COMPLICATION: The Blues would love  Macrae to get through to them and could consider key forward  Jaksch. Nathan Hrovat is another possibility.

12. GWS
(Northern Knights. 18, 195cm, 86kg)
Competitive, key defender able to starve opponents of the ball.
THE RATIONALE: The Giants are big fans, and bringing him in with Plowman allows them to start building some depth in their defensive stocks. Picking Corr here also keeps him out of Gold Coast’s reach.
THE COMPLICATION: Menzel will be picked here, should the Blues overlook him.

(Launceston. 18, 182cm, 91kg)
Powerful, explosive midfielder who can play both inside and outside the packs.
THE RATIONALE: Having lost Caddy, the Suns could do with slotting another inside midfielder into its young team. Lonergan fits the bill.
THE COMPLICATION: Josh Simpson is a player the Gold Coast has been keen on for a long while. Corr, Garner and Hrovat are others who could appeal at this pick.

(Oakleigh Chargers. 18, 194cm, 83kg)
Key forward who can also play back and who boasts a nice, long kick.
THE RATIONALE: With this many picks, this year and last, the Giants won’t be wanting for anything by now. Jaksch would arrive as another versatile tall option who could handle big opponents at either end.
THE COMPLICATION:  Grundy must surely be a consideration here. Also, should the Giants get Menzel at 12, they should be able to draft Corr with this pick.

(Northern Knights. 18, 175cm, 79kg)
Hard-working midfielder, and possibly the best stoppage player the draft.
THE RATIONALE: There has long been mail linking Hrovat to the Roos. He’s an organised, motivated and reliable player who would make a positive addition to their midfield group.
THE COMPLICATION: The availability of Brodie Grundy would make for a massive decision for the Roos. Others to come into the mix will be Taylor Garner and Ben Kennedy.

(Launceston. 18, 189cm, 80kg)
Running defender able to win a lot of the ball and set up play.
THE RATIONALE: Thurlow is one of a handful of players the Cats have been considering for this pick, and would help them continue succession planning for their backline.
THE COMPLICATION: Brodie Grundy will be considered, while others in the mix include Mason Wood, Jesse Lonergan and Josh Simpson.

(East Fremantle. 18, 184cm, 73kg)
A fast and exciting midfielder/forward.
THE RATIONALE: Simpson is super talented, and a player the Dockers have been hoping would reach their pick.
THE COMPLICATION: He may have been picked, with Gold Coast at 13 interested. At least five clubs were waiting to interview him Thursday morning after recently learning he had a child at the start of this year.  Stringer and Tim O’Brien are also in the mix here, as well as Gippsland onballer Nick Graham.

(Glenelg. 18, 193cm, 80kg)
Athletic, marking forward who attacks the ball in the air.
THE RATIONALE: The Pies could do with getting one or two more young talls in. O’Brien could end up playing at either end for them.
THE COMPLICATION: Fremantle or Geelong may have taken him already. With three of their next four picks, the Pies could mix and match a bit.

(Dandenong Stingrays. 18, 187cm, 77kg)
Courageous half-forward capable of unexpected things.
THE RATIONALE: He’s talented and in the mix for a handful of clubs up the order. Is courageous and a competitor, qualities the Collingwood recruiting team likes.
THE COMPLICATION: He may have been snapped up already. Simpson, Kennedy and Lonergan are others who could slot in at this pick.

(Sturt. 18,  202cm, 100kg)
Aggressive, competitive ruckman who can go forward and take marks.
THE RATIONALE: He's simply to good to leave sitting there. As a bonus, the Pies' ruck stocks could do with an addition or two.
THE COMPLICATION: He could have gone anywhere from 14 onwards. If Grundy isn't there, Western Jet Spencer White could be the big bolter. Collingwood would like him at 39, but may get nervous that Richmond will pinch him at 34.

(Glenelg. 18, 174cm, 74kg)
Busy, skilful midfielder/small forward who likes to create play.
THE RATIONALE: Kennedy’s in the Dogs’ mix for this pick and, like Macrae, would add a bit of outside flair and nice ball use to their group of young midfielders.
THE COMPLICATION: Hrovat is a major chance to go at this pick, if available.

(Geelong Falcons. 18, 192cm, 80kg)
A quick-off-the-mark, hard-running, key forward.
THE RATIONALE: He’s one on a list of  several players the Swans have in mind for this pick, and a player the club could afford some time to develop.
THE COMPLICATION: He could be gone, with Geelong in particular interested. Tasmanians  Thurlow and  Lonergan as well as Simpson are chances here too.

(18. 196cm, 87kg)
Tall, close checking defender with good closing speed.
THE RATIONALE: The Lions got their midfielder at pick No.8. Smith would become the tall they're after.
THE COMPLICATION: Others may appeal, with Tom Clurey and Tim Membrey still chances to be on the board.


Adelaide Crows 3 PICKS 62, 81, 95

Brisbane Lions 5 PICKS 8, 23, 32, 86, 99

Carlton 7 PICKS 11, 35, 54, 69, 74, 89, 102

Collingwood 6 PICKS 18, 19, 20, 38, 80, 94

Essendon 8 PICKS 10*, 34, 51, 53, 73, 88, 101, 106

Fremantle 5 PICKS 17, 36, 39, 78, 93

Geelong 3 PICKS 16, 77, 92

Gold Coast 4 PICKS 13, 55, 57, 58

GWS Giants 10 PICKS 1, 2, 3, 12, 14, 27, 63, 67, 83, 97

Hawthorn 3 PICKS 28, 66, 70

Melbourne 7 PICKS 4, 26*, 48, 52, 68, 71, 72,

North Melbourne 9 PICKS 15, 37, 41, 47, 56, 61, 76, 91, 103

Port Adelaide 5 PICKS 7, 29, 30, 82, 85

Richmond 6 PICKS 9, 31, 33, 42, 87, 100

St Kilda 6 PICKS 24, 25, 40, 43, 75, 90

Sydney 8 PICKS 22, 44, 46, 64, 65, 96, 104, 107

West Coast 4 PICKS 45, 59, 60, 79

Western Bulldogs 8 PICKS 5, 6, 21, 49*, 50, 84, 98, 105

*Father-son pick

31 comments so far

  • wheres the artical?

    Date and time
    November 22, 2012, 8:03AM
    • Daniel Sankey Hi everyone ... we have a technical problem with this piece which means you might not be able to see Emma's interactive graphic if you're using Internet Explorer. If you've got Chrome or Firefox on your computer, try using those browsers instead. In the meantime, we're working on a solution to the problem for IE users right now. Sorry for the inconvenience!

      Daniel Sankey, Editor - The Age Online
      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 9:15AM
    • Here's an idea - fancy graphics are fine but how bout putting in a link to a plain text version too so we can all enjoy Emma's insights? You know, web accessibility and all that....Cheers :)

      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 9:45AM
    • Readers should now be able see all the information contained in the article, regardless of which browser they are using.


      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 10:25AM
  • "Port need boosting in most areas..." Emma not much thought has gone in to this line. Perhaps could you point out the positions that need boosting rather than such a broad statement. Backline looks solid after recent new recruits. Midfield is strong. Probably the weakest area is the forward line. Thanks for your insight.

    Tired of Vic biased reporting...its a national competition
    Date and time
    November 22, 2012, 8:07AM
    • "Port need boosting in most areas..." Emma not much thought has gone in to this line.

      I agree. It should have read "in all areas" ...

      The J Dog
      Gold Coast
      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 8:54AM
    • There's not enough room in this article, let alone a small blurb, to list the positions that need boosting at Port. Why don't you take that frustration out on your shambles of a team rather than a journo just pointing out the facts. Great job Emma, enjoy your work.

      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 9:40AM
    • Actually, it's not "Vic biased reporting" - it's the truth...hopefully the three picks Port has in the first 30 will help.

      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 9:46AM
  • Hi Emma,

    As a Saints fan, I notice you've got Tanner Smith going to Brisbane and Dayle Garlett sliding to the second round. Now that has to be good news for us because I believe Scott Watters is keen to get him. How good is your intel? If we miss out on Smith, we need another tall as a defender. Could we get Clurey instead?

    Date and time
    November 22, 2012, 8:19AM
    • Anyone else unable to load this yarn?

      Date and time
      November 22, 2012, 8:23AM

      More comments

      Make a comment

      You are logged in as [Logout]

      All information entered below may be published.

      Error: Please enter your screen name.

      Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

      Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

      Error: Please enter your comment.

      Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

      Post to

      You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

      Thank you

      Your comment has been submitted for approval.

      Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

      Related Coverage

      Top draftee Jack Viney The pick of the crop at the AFL draft

      Taking a closer look at the best young players who are certain to be selected at the 2012 AFL draft.

      AFL List Manager List Manager: your AFL draft home

      The latest news and analysis from the world of free agency, trading and drafting.

      Adelaide's 'goodwill gesture' costs it draft picks 20 and 54

      Adelaide has taken the extraordinary step of giving up their first two AFL national draft picks as they brace for heavy penalties from the Kurt Tippett saga.

      Emma Quayle's club-by-club guide to the 2012 national draft

      All that you need to know about the clubs and the players up for grabs in the draft.

      Draft countdown: join a live blog with Emma Quayle

      The lead-up to this year's AFL draft has been overshadowed by the dramatic events in the game surrounding Adelaide's alleged draft tampering with Kurt Tippett and the ongoing issue of third party payments to players.

      Sanctions won't push Crows down: coach

      Adelaide coach Brenton Sanderson believes the Crows can continue their upward path even if they have to sit out the early rounds of AFL drafts for the next few years.

      GWS would be good for Tippett: Sheedy

      Greater Western Sydney coach Kevin Sheedy says Kurt Tippett and the Giants can prove a great AFL combination, even if the club have to drag him there.

      Related Coverage

      Follow Us on Facebook

      Featured advertisers