JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Tigers v Demons: no debate now

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Footy Fix: Pies aim to tame Cats

Collingwood needs a big win to get its season back on track, and who's bigger than Geelong?

PT0M0S 620 349

If a week is a long time in football these days, a little over a year is an eternity. And nothing will underline that better than when co-tenants Richmond and Melbourne face-off at their MCG home on Sunday.

For an improving Richmond, eyeing off a long-awaited finals spot, this is not only a chance to jump to within a hair's breadth of the top four, but build some handy percentage in the process. That's because the Demons, should they turn up with the attitude which saw them humbled by Gold Coast last week, will provide all the opposition of a set of training cones.

Aaron Davey, once a best and fairest winner, has lost all form. Ivan Maric, once a fringe ruckman, has become a force.

Aaron Davey, once a best and fairest winner, has lost all form. Ivan Maric, once a fringe ruckman, has become a force. Photo: Getty Images

It's a far cry from when these same teams clashed in round three last year. Back then, as hard as it is to believe now, they were two teams whose developmental curve was constantly being compared, the debate about which would emerge to a position of strength quicker.

Both had finished 2011 with the same records – eight-and-a-half wins apiece. Indeed, that wasn't seen as good enough by the Demons, who'd sacked coach Dean Bailey and replaced him with Mark Neeld. And going into the game, Richmond coach Damien Hardwick was hardly sitting too comfortably either.

The Tigers hadn't been blown away in two losses to Carlton and Collingwood, but some key indicators had plenty at Punt Road concerned about just where their team was headed.

Remember this? Colin Sylvia and Mark Jamar after Melbourne beat Richmond in round 19, 2010.

Remember this? Colin Sylvia and Mark Jamar after Melbourne beat Richmond in round 19, 2010. Photo: Sebastian Costanzo

Richmond, ranked a lowly 16th for clearance differentials (numbers compared to its opposition) at the end of 2011, had slipped to outright last. Its poor rating of 15th for contested possessions had fallen to 17th.

At half-time in round three, little appeared to have changed, Melbourne having hit the front during the second term, and the Tigers just eight points up at the long break. But that would prove the moment the bigger-picture argument about whose long-term prospects were better changed for good.

And so far has the gap widened since then, that for Demon fans, the fact there ever was a debate is another stark reminder of how dire their situation has become.

Richmond turned up the gas that afternoon with a nine-goals-to-one third quarter, the lack of committed opposition as notable as the scores registered, the Tigers eventually cantering to a 59-point win.

Including that Saturday afternoon, Richmond has won 14 and drawn one of 27 games for a winning percentage of nearly 54. Melbourne has won five in the same period at 18 per cent, four of those five victories coming against the fledgling Greater Western Sydney and Gold Coast.

What's changed? Well, the Tigers have picked up a couple more handy recruits, but mostly it's been about effort. Melbourne? The Demons have largely the same personnel, only three who played that afternoon – Clint Bartram, Matthew Bate and Stefan Martin – no longer on the list. But what effort there was seems a distant memory.

Those poor clearance and contested ball rankings for the Tigers have progressed steadily upwards. By the end of last season, the clearance numbers had risen from 18th to third. On contested possession, Richmond climbed from that early low of 17 to outright second. And the numbers have remained steady in 2013.

Melbourne was 15th for contested ball when it took on Richmond in round three last year. It finished the season 16th. Now it's 18th. On the clearance front, the Demons went into that April game 16th. It finished the season 18th. It's still 17th.

Over the last year-and-a-bit, Richmond has been able to concentrate more on ironing out the rough edges in its make-up, finding some goalkicking alternatives to Jack Riewoldt in attack, and improving the quality of its disposal coming out of defence.

Melbourne doesn't have that luxury when it can't even count on making it to football's first base, having a genuine crack.

As Demon recruit Chris Dawes wrote in his column for Fairfax Media on Thursday: “We can't afford to be wasting time coaching one of the fundamentals of any professional endeavour. We need to get better quickly, and a week of remembering how to compete is frustrating because it takes away from time learning how to play finals football.”

And how distant that goal must seem right now. Indeed, if early last season seems a long time ago, consider these words penned by former Melbourne champion Garry Lyon in August 2010, on the eve of another Richmond-Melbourne clash.

“Which of these two young sides, both of which have been so positively embraced by the football community in recent weeks, will further justify the borderline rave reviews bestowed upon them? Lyon asked.

“I think it's fantastic that supporters of both teams can go along tomorrow full of hope and expectation, rather than resignation and despair. I would love to be able to argue with my Richmond mates about the relative merits of our respective lists in the coming years.”

And so would an army of long-suffering Melbourne people, Gaz. But it ain't going to happen. Because this is one football debate well and truly done and dusted.

37 comments so far

  • Sink the boot in Rohan. How are your Bombers going?

    Date and time
    May 16, 2013, 3:39PM
    • 6-1 JD, second on the ladder.......

      Date and time
      May 16, 2013, 4:28PM
    • The truth hurts JD but I understand that MFC supporters would rather not hear it and would prefer to live in the hope they wake up tomorrow to realise it's all been a bad dream. The Bombers are 6 and 1 and the Dee's are 1 and 6. If your referring to the drugs scandal, I would be very careful as an MFC supporter. While the Bombers may have Danked, the Dee's have Tanked and Danked. Rohan makes very good points and while I expect the Dee's to put up more of a fight this week the professionalism of the RFC should see it overcome even the best of Demon efforts. Not to worry, it's only a game, with winners and losers. Most importantly, it coincides with the snow season where supporters can get away from it all......Where will you be this Sunday?

      Date and time
      May 16, 2013, 4:39PM
    • lukaaaaaay, wasn't referring to your (questionable) win/loss.

      Andy, I'm a hawks supporter mate.

      Date and time
      May 16, 2013, 5:56PM
  • I wouldn't crow about Richmond yet. They have a lot to prove and a long way to go. Melbourne had a golden age in the 90's by comparison with where they are today.

    Date and time
    May 16, 2013, 4:14PM
    • Actually Jack, the D's played more finals than any other Vic club bar 1, between 87 and 07. We had our chances

      fact finder
      Date and time
      May 16, 2013, 6:25PM
  • As a long-suffering Tigers fan I expect to see a solid victory against an ordinary Dees outfit.
    But you don't need a long memory to be aware that these are the games we have a history of losing. I reckon we'll be right........................but...

    Punt Road
    Date and time
    May 16, 2013, 4:17PM
    • I also recall a few years ago when the North Melbourne and Richmond coaching jobs were up for grabs, many in the media (Nathan Buckley was one I remember) said that the North job was a much more enticing prospect, based on their list and future possibilities. He was probably right short term, though in the race for an actual Premiership, I'd put Richmond in front of North right now.

      Joe Q
      Date and time
      May 16, 2013, 4:22PM
      • It was only 2 years ago when the Crows and Demons coaching jobs were up for grabs at the same time. Most pundits thought that any one would be made to take the job at th sliding Crows rather than at the on the rise Melbourne. Mid season the Dees had smacked the Crows by 90+ points at the G.

        Either Brenton Sanderson is a genius and Mark Neelde a fool, or most people didn't realise the talent that Matt Rendell had accumulated with years of mediocre draft picks. Adding Dean Bailey's tactical nous and getting rid of Neil Craig's inflexibility didn't hurt either.

        The Crows biggest mistake of recent times was over-valuing and keeping Trigg and under-valuing and sacking Rendell. It might cost them a Premiership.

        Viv R
        Date and time
        May 17, 2013, 10:38AM
      • I read that completely the opposite to you. I thought all the media thought the Tigers job was better, yet I actually think North are closer to a flag than the Tiges.

        Date and time
        May 17, 2013, 12:29PM

    More comments

    Make a comment

    You are logged in as [Logout]

    All information entered below may be published.

    Error: Please enter your screen name.

    Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

    Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

    Error: Please enter your comment.

    Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

    Post to

    You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

    Thank you

    Your comment has been submitted for approval.

    Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

    Related Coverage

    Follow Us on Facebook

    Featured advertisers