Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Cherrypicker 
 It's Midnight Oil, nothing else matters 

It's Midnight Oil, nothing else matters

Midnight Oil is the best live band Australia has ever produced, hands down. I saw them maybe 10 times over 20 years and they never delivered a show that was less than brilliant. The Oils are one of the few bands, among the many I've seen from all over the world, that consistently offer real transcendence at a concert. I'm talking about those times when you get so lost in the music you enter a state of euphoria, your tears catch you by surprise, and for an all-too-brief moment nothing else matters.

When it happens, it's as good as the best sex you ever had.

The 'power and passion' description has become a cliché, but it’s perfect for what the band does. Watching the Oils get up a full head of steam in songs like Best of Both Worlds or Read About It is one of the most thrilling experiences in Australian music.

But will it be the same when they play Canberra? Has something slipped permanently out of alignment since Peter Garrett became a federal politician? Will you be able to sing along with US Forces knowing the Australian/US military alliance is a solid part of Labor policy?

Garrett's immersion in realpolitik deeply troubles some people. I know at least one long-time fan who is not going to the Canberra show because he says he won’t be able to enjoy the gig after all the compromises Garrett has made as a Labor minister.

A lot of other people couldn't care less. A common line I used to hear was, "I like their music but not their politics." One of the Oils' contradictions was that many of their fans were on the wrong side of the 'issues' they sang about, such as Aboriginal land rights, or just didn’t give a shit. The contradiction was even starker because the Oils railed at Australian hedonism and apathy: 'Too much of sunshine, too much of sky/ It's just enough to make you want to cry'. The pissed bogans at Oils shows always sang those lines louder than everybody else.

I loved both the music and the message. I LIKED that they were political. I mean, Jesus, did the world really need more love songs?

The Oils spoke to me, and for me. When I heard Short Memories as a 17-year-old it spoke straight to the incomprehension and horror I felt then at what I was learning about Cambodia under Pol Pot, the Holocaust, apartheid and every other blood-soaked blight on human history. The list is a lot longer now, of course.

The Cold War probably seems faintly ludicrous to a generation that didn’t grow up in its shadow, but when I first heard Minutes to Midnight I was regularly having nightmares about dying in a worldwide nuclear war. I'd read The Fate of the Earth and it haunted me right up until the Berlin Wall came down. 'I look at the clock on the wall/ It says three minutes to midnight/ Faith is blind when we're so near'.

This stuff meant something to me. It was real, and it was comforting just to know I wasn't alone in being freaked out by the impending end of the world.

OK, I was a gloomy kid.

I was also a bleeding-heart leftie. Songs like River Runs Red and Progress spoke to my anguish about the state of the environment, while just about everything on Diesel and Dust tapped into my white middle-class guilt about the shocking way the country had treated, and continued to treat, indigenous people.

But it wasn’t empty rhetoric, as some would claim. The Oils toured outback towns and indigenous communities, where they had to learn to turn down their amps and pick up acoustic guitars so they didn’t scare off the locals. They took Indigenous bands such as the Gondwanaland and the Warumpi Band with them as supports. The Oils wanted to find out for themselves what was going on in indigenous Australia, so they reached out with an open mind and wrote eloquently about their journey.

The songs on Diesel and Dust burned with a deep desire for not just land rights - for fairness - but also for a genuine reconciliation between white and indigenous Australians. The way the Oils sang about it, it was more about our common humanity than some vague political idea.

The Oils were prescient on this issue above all the others they sang about. With songs such as The Dead Heart and Beds are Burning Midnight Oil did as much as anybody in raising consciousness about indigenous issues and aspirations among the wider population, and for reconciliation - if that rubbery term means, among other things, simply reaching out to each other. 'We will listen, we'll understand' – it had to go both ways. It seemed apposite that on the day of Rudd's national apology to the Stolen Generation, a profoundly moving moment for so many Australians, Garrett changed out of his suit to join John Butler on stage on the lawns of Parliament House.

The Oils were always described as a 'political' band, but to me their songs were powerful because they translated 'issues' into personal feelings: hope, desire, anger, and despair. It was always about passion and humanity, not some dry polemic. Mostly they threw uncomfortable truths at you and dared you to ignore them. They didn't sing 'save the Franklin'; they sang of rivers running red and black rain falling and asked, will you – will we – let this happen?

'Hope is what you say and do'.

The Oils were unmistakeably Australian, and never self-conscious about it. Peter Garrett sang in an unvarnished Australian accent long before Missy Higgins made it fashionable. The songs were full of Australian references – bindies, cockatoos, Coolangatta, the stars of Warburton - and about our issues. They really were our band, for our time, and I loved them for it.

They had integrity, too. Just the fact that they were prepared to sing about the most contentious of issues, in a country where the rule is that you don't talk about politics in mixed company, was enough. But also, they didn’t play the game Australian bands had to play in their early days, namely sucking up to Molly Meldrum. Although the reason they missed their first Countdown appearance was actually that they turned up late, messing up the show's tight schedule, their subsequent refusal to appear on Molly's menagerie gave them huge street cred.

Ditto for the fact that self-styled arbiters of taste Glenn A Baker and Bruce Elder thought they were rubbish. They really missed the bus (and Baker still doesn’t like them).

What about the music?

For my money, the Oils rocked harder than any Australian band before or since. They could be FEROCIOUS. But it wasn't the dumb plod of The Angels, there was always something interesting going on around the power chords. Check out Best of Both Worlds for the Oils at their baddest, and listen to the way those killer slabs of power chords are peppered with weird transistor beeps, guitar squeals, and off-kilter echoes of the riff.

There's no shortage of great melodies in the catalogue. It was always one of the strengths of the band, from early anthems such as I Don't Want to be the One through to sublime later ballads such as One Country. The melodies lent themselves to the increasingly rich harmonies the band developed during their career, providing the sugar coating to Garrett’s tough medicine.

They understood dynamics, too. The last time I saw the Oils was at the ANU in 2002, just before they announced their break-up. It was not long before the invasion of Iraq, which everybody knew was coming, and it felt like the world was on the verge of something terrible. They started with US Forces, which seemed more relevant than ever. After that lonely little acoustic guitar intro - a tease - the gap seemed to stretch forever. Garrett mischievously let the silence linger, the audience held its breath, and then suddenly he counted down from five to one with his fingers.

'US forces give the nard'.

The guitars kicked in and the whole crowd roared along, bouncing up and down as one in a beautiful moment of release.

'Divided world the C I Aaeeeay!'

It was one of the most cathartic concerts I've ever been to.

In Jim Moginie the band had one of Australia’s finest musicians, equally at home with bone crunching distortion, discordant blasts of sound, and delicately textured acoustic guitars – not to mention what he did with keyboards (check out Outside World). Moginie seemed to be able to pull unexpected textures, melodies and sounds straight out of the air. Live, he was the band’s quiet achiever, standing still and focusing intently while Martin Rotsey played all over the stage.

The sonic weave of Moginie and Rotsey's guitars was a wondrous thing. There were no long and boring guitar solos, rather an irresistible blend of prog rock musical sophistication, hard rock intensity, pop accessibility and punk-ish energy. It was pretty acoustic guitars one minute, butt-ugly distortion the next - or both at the same time. Nobody else sounded like them.

Grounding it all was Rob Hirst's rock solid, gunshot drumming. Hirst sat at the back of the Oils' electrical storm on his riser, usually in a singlet (all the better to show off those rippling muscles, perhaps), his arms flying around the drum kit as if his life depended on it.

And Garrett? One story goes that in their very early days an A & R man from a big record company told the band they’d be great – if they'd just lose the singer.

Garrett is hardly a great singer in the conventional sense, but he was perfect for the Oils: passionate and charismatic. When he sang those songs there was never any doubt - in my mind, anyway - that he meant them, whatever he might have said in his first question time in Parliament. Garrett’s singing was never pretty, but nobody else could have sung those songs as well as he did.

And anyway, who else could have come up with those wild dance moves, now aped by thousands of Oils fans? Garrett’s energy and intensity on stage was always amazing. He moved like a man possessed, gangly limbs flying in all directions, whirling around the stage like a Blackhawk going down. He was mesmerizing.

So I'm going to the concert.

As someone who bought into the Oils' idealism, does it bother me that Garrett is part of the ruthless, faction-riven machine that is the Labor Party? A bit. He'll make decisions I won't like, probably even decisions HE won’t like. But it's the same with the most idealistic in the Labor Left: caucus binds them to the party line. They scream and shout out each other behind closed doors, then have to walk out presenting a united front.

So I'm not sure Garrett should take the blame for Rudd's pissweak carbon targets.

Most of the issues the Oils sang about are as relevant now as they ever were. I think hearing Garrett sing about the plight of indigenous people and the degradation of the environment will be a lot less weird than hearing Roger Daltrey sing 'Hope I die before I get old' in April.

And who among us isn't compromised? What I done lately for the environment? Apart from riding my bicycle into work this morning, not a lot. What have YOU done?

Hope is still what you say and do, and we could all probably use a good kick up the arse.

Or maybe this is all a stretch of a rationalisation, and I really just don't want to miss the chance to see Australia’s best live band, for maybe the last time. Either way, I can't wait.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Ah, but will Peter Garrett really be able to sing "Renaissance Man'' with a clear conscience given his non-stand on Tasmania's forests as environment minister? This is a song that starts with a lot of blather about "the forest and trees and the chlorophyll green'' and moves on to proclain "a new world order has been formed Between the cheque book and the dawn....'' Enough said.
Posted by Swift parrot, 12/03/2009 11:24:44 AM
Sorry Dave, best live band hands down is Cold Chisel. In fact best Australian Band is Cold Chisel. The Oils are superb, AC/DC are fantastic, but Don Walker's songs are the best snap shot of Australia ever taken and delivered with emotion that Garrett and Hurst just couldn't/can't match. I guess it is all a matter of opinion...
Posted by Pork, 12/03/2009 1:29:36 PM
Yes I'll be going (and am very shortly). Why, because Midnight Oil have been a part of my life since their very first album (the blue meanie) and they are legends. I have seen them all, AC/DC when they first started, INXS to a crowd of 20, Cold Chisel when they couldn't pull 20, Hunters & Collectors at their artistic worse The Angels etc. These blokes have been there done that but still believe in the common man. I don't think Petes sold out, at least he is in a position to do something and make a difference, we may not agree but he has stuck his hand up unlike most people in society.
Posted by Luffy, 12/03/2009 5:52:54 PM
Can you forgive the sins of the father for the saintly acts of past. I'm sorry, Peter it would be hypocritical to sing most of your songs given your recent sellout. As for the best live act, The Living End if you would take your balding heads out of the last century.
Posted by Belly, 13/03/2009 2:46:05 AM
Sorry Pork, it is a matter of opinion and you must have a short memory, the Chisels dont match the Oils.
Posted by Snout, 13/03/2009 8:33:08 AM
In terms of tight bands Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds wups their wutever any day...also superiour individual musicianship and substantially more literate. But maybe I'm biased for a raft of reasons. So my vote goes to Dr Nick and his gentlemens club.
Posted by Mizz Deb, 13/03/2009 11:00:15 AM
I just dont get everyones obsession with this band is better than that band. You like it or you love it or you hate it.Its not a footy match people!Anyway having seen the Oils last night in Canberra I can only say if you were not there you missed one very amazing powerful gig. I dont know how they pulled it off but they did.In a huge way. And for the record is Chris Cheney a better guitarist than Jim Moginie? Well it really depends on who YOU like ... doesn't it??
Posted by The Bat, 13/03/2009 5:45:37 PM
Oils rock man, just watched Sound Relief and am sitting here listening to bird noises as I type Rob Hirst & Bones and Jim are the best from a huge fan, oils forever
Posted by Dan, 15/03/2009 12:27:22 AM
Well Sound Relief has come and gone and Midnight Oil gave me goosebumps on the night, they played for real and was no novelty factor here at all in my opinion. From the first few bars of Redneck Wonderland I knew this was something different. To see a band that hasn't played in years tight as a fishes backside, and not to mention a 55 year old politician rock as good as any of the young guns totally alters my perception of getting older!
Posted by Mick, 16/03/2009 1:14:00 PM
I was at the Royal on Friday not sure what to expect from the Oils. Having heard them at Wave Aid I was hoping they'd be better. Boy, we they better. It was as if they'd never stopped. From the opening Lucky country to US Forces - yes they played it! - it was amazing. I sat there bopping with a stupid smile on my face for the two hours or so. I too have been less than impressed with Pete as a minister but we all compromise on various things - doesn't make him less of an entertainer and supreme lead he always was. A night to remember!
Posted by dave, 16/03/2009 10:00:28 PM
1 | 2  |  next >
Cherrypicker
Canberra Times reporter Dave Curry casts a discerning eye over the music world to bring you new and old gems from a variety of genres.
SIMPLY THE BEST: Peter Garrett
SIMPLY THE BEST: Peter Garrett

Most popular articles

LJ Hooker CIty



The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...