Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Cherrypicker 
 Speaking frankly on Aretha 

Speaking frankly on Aretha

Far be it from me to rain on the parade of the year, maybe the century ... but did Aretha Franklin tank or what?

Like many others, I got up to watch Barack Obama’s inauguration at some unearthly hour on Wednesday morning. True, it was by accident - the dog woke me up - but once I was there on the couch, and able to focus, I was swept up in the power of the moment.

I may even have got something in my eye at one stage, causing an involuntary tear or two to slide down my cheek.

And what could have topped the occasion better than the Queen of Soul, Aretha Franklin, jazzing up "My Country 'Tis of Thee"?

Well, just about anything, it turns out.

Look, I love Aretha. She thoroughly deserved first place in Rolling Stone's latest list of rock'n'roll's greatest singers, in the latest issue. From the feistiness of "Respect" to the raw sexual energy of "I've Never Loved a Man", Aretha's late Sixties oeuvre is unmatched in pure, unadulterated soul. All the artifice of a recorded song becomes irrelevant when that voice starts up, transporting you with its passion, beauty and power - like all great music.

But at Barack Obama's inauguration, it was a different story. I know Aretha's old, and possibly unwell, so maybe she should have just lip-synced – or waved.

Instead, we got a strangled, breathless performance that left me hoping Aretha didn't have a heart attack.

To start with, she broke up the syllables of the opening line, 'my country', in a way that will have puerile teenagers guffawing all over the country. Did she actually forget the opening line? Was she reading from a lyric sheet?

Aretha used to have a three-octave range – now it’s down to two wobbly notes.

And what's with the 'shutup' at 2.17? Was it Aretha’s advice to a heckler, or to herself?

When Roseanne Barr did something similar in 1990, she was nearly lynched.

In 2009, Aretha gets thunderous applause. What gives?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
For me, Aretha rocked. As an American who has suffered for eight years, this day was magical. Aretha moved me. I can't worry about puerile teenagers; they'll ge it someday.
Posted by dee, 22/01/2009 10:18:52 AM
Her performance was horrific! Let's not blur the lines of reality just because it was a great day for America!
Posted by csyp, 22/01/2009 11:33:01 AM
She was great. Very moving. I loved watching her.
Posted by Leangirl, 22/01/2009 2:40:57 PM
Listen, people, try a little graciousness and understanding. It was a frigid day. Vocal chords are very delicate instruments. You try singing for millions of people on such a cold day. For me, Franklin's performance was second only to President Obama's speech as the high point of the day. Sure, I heard what the cold did to her voice, I saw her struggle. But that didnt in the least destroy my enjoyment and emotional thrill of hearing the queen of soul sing our anthem at such an historic hour.
Posted by peter wolf, 22/01/2009 4:33:36 PM
at 340am, who cares Curry?! - gotta love that womans style though, africa meets washington. beautiful!
Posted by lil one, 22/01/2009 4:39:16 PM
I though Aretha was fine. She was definately better than the Poet that followed... Weirdest poem ever...
Posted by Kincuri, 22/01/2009 5:29:31 PM
Aretha Franklin, The voice that funded the Civil Rights Movement. The little girl over fifty years ago that got out of bed in the middle of the night to sing before all of the African American Entertainers such as Dr. King, Mahalia, Lena, from that moment on still entertaining. I thought she was great. Musical enough to adjust to the unfit conditions. You would have to be a singer to understand that..
Posted by musique, 22/01/2009 8:21:04 PM
Leave the lady alone she not that young anymore the hat did it all amazing......no worse than some of the garbage we've had on special occassions. And dont forget it was pretty cold no that great for the voice....
Posted by amro, 23/01/2009 2:02:20 AM
I was there that morning and obviously the writer of this article does NOT understand emotion or soul. It was amazing.
Posted by IWASthere, 23/01/2009 3:29:46 AM
Aretha was awful. I am not a puerile teen but I was horrified by her performance. It was both artistically lazy and overwrought--not nice to listen to. I do not dispute her greatness as an American artist, nor the magic of the day.
Posted by ew54, 23/01/2009 3:32:55 AM
1 | 2 | 3  |  next >
Cherrypicker
Canberra Times reporter Dave Curry casts a discerning eye over the music world to bring you new and old gems from a variety of genres.
Aretha Franklin ... did she tank? Photo: REUTERS
Aretha Franklin ... did she tank? Photo: REUTERS

Most popular articles

Australian Running Festival



The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...