Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Face it, we are all narcissists now 

Face it, we are all narcissists now

A surfeit of self-love is almost a prerequisite for success now, and the proliferation of egomaniac sites, from Twitter and MySpace to Facebook and YouTube, make the peer pressure to be grandiose and irrationally self-confident almost irresistible.

When Brendan Nelson so deliciously diagnosed his leader, Malcolm Turnbull, last week as being afflicted with the disorder, he spoke not just as a trained medical doctor but as a former Opposition leader with an axe to grind; or, as one internet wag described it, "post-traumatic embitterment syndrome".

After all, Turnbull never gave Nelson a chance. He abused him to his face and undermined him behind his back, as Nelson tells it. He used poor opinion poll ratings to depose Nelson, and then polled lower himself.

Turnbull has "narcissistic personality disorder," Nelson told Peter Hartcher last week. "He says the most appalling things and can't understand why people get upset. He has no empathy.''

Nelson also told me Turnbull was a narcissist, as demonstrated by the yes-men surrounding him. "Whatever judgments he makes, he appears not to make good judgments about people. He can't read people. It's part of his narcissism … There's a risk he'll blow up one day."

According to the psychiatrists' bible, The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, the disorder is characterised by: a grandiose sense of self-importance; preoccupation with fantasies of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty, or ideal love; a belief the person is ''special'' and unique and should only associate with other special people or institutions; a need for excessive admiration; a sense of entitlement; exploitative personal relationships; a lack of empathy; envy; and arrogant, haughty behaviour.

When things end badly for narcissists, they tend to do so spectacularly.

Nelson has good reason to be critical of Turnbull. But his diagnosis could equally apply to most people aged under 30, to politicians, entertainers, lawyers, business people and, no doubt, to a good number of byline-chasing journalists.

Everyone's a potential narcissist these days, as 15 minutes of fame has become a 24/7 proposition. For instance, the average Australian woman is said to spend at least 3 ½ hours looking at herself in the mirror each week, according to a survey last month by the Bureau of Statistics.

The 26-year-old mistress of the recently resigned NSW Health Minister, John Della Bosca, appears to have diagnosed her "spunky" former lover with similar symptoms, telling The Daily Telegraph: ''I now realise … he liked me being in love with him because it was all about ego … It is incredulous [sic] that he thought the way he treated people would not have consequences.''

That's narcissists for you. They never see the karma train coming.

What's more, narcissism is on the increase, becoming a pervasive condition of society, according to two American psychologists, Jean Twenge and W. Keith Campbell, who published a book this year, The Narcissism Epidemic.They include a long-term study of 37,000 American college students, in which the incidence of narcissistic personality traits increased on a scale rivalling obesity, accelerating in the past decade.

In 1982, 15 per cent of students scored highly for narcissistic personality traits. By 2006 the percentage had climbed to 25. Twenge claims only 12 per cent of students in the 1950s agreed with the statement ''I am an important person''; by the late 1980s that percentage had climbed to 80. The reason for the explosion in narcissism in recent years, according to the Melbourne adolescent psychologist Michael Carr-Gregg, is not just the self-esteem movement but poor parenting.

"Parents are becoming increasingly self absorbed [believing] 'the single most important thing in the world is for me to work like a dog to get the house, the car and the holiday house' and don't … realise all their kids want is to be loved and to have one-on-one time with their parents.'' He says an "epidemic of poor parenting" is to blame for a drastic rise in psychological problems in young people. "Generation Y is being ravaged by depression, anxiety disorders and stress disorders."

For narcissistic personality disorder to take root, a person has to be born with a genetic "template" for over-sensitivity and over-reactivity. "Then something has to happen."

Carr-Gregg says parental abandonment, coupled with invalidation of the child's corresponding emotional pain, triggers the disorder. "If you grew up in an environment with time-poor parents, you are brought up in a Lord of the Flies [type of] emotional silo by other disaffected young people. It's the psychologically blind leading the blind.

"I see … kids who are overindulged from a very early age … and become incapable of delayed gratification. When I meet these kids in later life they tend to exaggerate their achievements and talents, tend to believe they are special and unique and interesting. They require excessive amounts of admiration and if they don't get it, they'll wipe you off the face of the planet."

Carr-Gregg - who coincidentally was three years behind Turnbull at Sydney Grammar - won't comment publicly on the Nelson diagnosis.

But, along with the psychometrician Simon Kinsella, he is working on a series of psychological profiles of famous Australians for an upcoming book, to identify personality structure and psychopathology in different professions, from politicians and journalists to creative artists and sports people.

"I would give anything to do Malcolm Turnbull," he says. It's one way for Turnbull to prove Nelson wrong.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
A lot of people just do not have any correct knowledge of what NPD is all about. Those that do, have often commented on MT's Narcissism. Dr. Nelson has just confirmed what's been on the minds of very many people. After all Nelson would have seen a good glimpse of his bad side, which perhaps is kept hidden from some others. Yet MT's known for his bullying tactics and his ruthlessness. It's not self love, it's love of an image they project to gain adoration and attention. They adore the camera's and the attention given to them. Facebook is an example of all the presentation of Photo's being put up, to glean his image of himself and his grandiousy. They seek adoration from their followers. and sympathy from his admirers.
Posted by chavron, 3/09/2009 11:52:22 PM
opportunism&grandstanding, twiddledum&twiddledee, greed&envy, emporerwithrobes and mothergoose -yes we all know who they are . They go to such extravagent lengths to display their oppulance and superiority in such grandious ways - who can miss them? I can't see Turnbull submitting -as he would destroy the tester in any way possible if the finding was adverse - oh the ABC's catalyst program called that the behaviour or a "corporate psycopath" go to the program online and recognise those corporate identities that you knew were dangerous people and see why. oh the more dangerous they are the more important they feel - that becomes meglamania. "Is your boss manipulative? Intimidating? Totally lacking in remorse? Yet superficially charming? Then you could be working with a workplace psychopath. The latest figures suggest one in ten managers are psychopaths" -catalyst 05/05/2005 Some may say 75% in a milder way?
Posted by opportunism&grandstanding, 4/09/2009 9:44:18 AM
As children 'labelled' with Hyper-active Disorders so now the 're-labelling' of adults to a new tag called Narcissist is very close to displaying a hate attitude of anyone and everyone- who achieves. The terminology has grades of hate from just plain jealousy, to a deliberate mis interpretation of anothers personality. How humbling it is when the one who we just 'sized up' proves to be a better and more human and giving person who we self-anniliated their intentions or 'body language'. Some 'Leaders' need to publically criticise the Public Service, and then in the name of 'virtue' - "like for your own good"- finds praiseworthy fawning. This flip flop just stated by our own PM is public humiliation which 'his aims' could have been achieved without upbraiding the whole Public Service and belittle the group. I won't 'label' it as Narcissism- just immaturity and thoughtless cruelty. Such 'groupings' are indeed insulting. I feel for faithful people who have served me well for 12 yrs in Centrelink and helped me along the way, without hurting me. Thankyou to the staff at Centrelink-I appreciate your good work for me.
Posted by adaptapensioner.com, 4/09/2009 1:33:41 PM
"opportunism&grandstanding, twiddledum&twiddledee, greed&envy" Very true. Especially being in a private school amongst the wealth set, coming from a flat ! The need to be seen and photographed with Private School Student's as opposed to high school students which would help their "'illustrious' image." A Power Broker would marry a Trophy wife to help elevate their social status and get them further in the door to more opportunity. To help their careers. "The Power Broker is in love with power. It may be expressed in bullying ways - humiliating and even terrorizing employees. Or it may be cold and bureaucratic. But power is embraced and used in an instrumental fashion. " http://hackvan.com/pub/stig/etext /psychology/narcissism--a-n ine-headed-hydra.htm
Posted by chavron, 7/09/2009 6:36:04 PM
yep, narcissism is alive and well, I have found it prevalent amongst 25 to 35 year olds..maybe I am just having a bad run, by having to work with them lately, but it does seem that it is a look at me, look at me, thing and a need for people to tell them or acknowledge in some way an admiration of their skills. I find it at times amusing and at other times,? annoying and boring...perhaps when a few things go pear shaped they may come around, who knows?. I am 53 and seen the good times and the bad...they have my best wishes but not my friendship which one day they might need.
Posted by suzhousid, 7/09/2009 11:37:59 PM
If Malcolm was rated in the other direction he'd be considered a weak leader with no guts... Agreed, he is trying to hard to discredit the labour party, but thats what the opposition does. Regardless of the party holding power...
Posted by Eric, 12/09/2009 9:06:15 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!

MOST POPULAR

Yourguide to Your Toyota
Red Hot Deals at Eurobodalla! click now
 
James Bond Happy Hour at Flint - click now
 
 
University of Canberra - click here
 
Click here to read See Canberra online!
 
Ready, Set. Drive!
 
Classifieds
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...