JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Bikies will come to regret their actions

Date

If Australia survived being menaced by the Communist Party in the 1950s, an era when the murderous Joseph Stalin commanded all of the resources of a militarised communist superstate, we'll probably survive the modern era of outlaw motorcycle gangs.

Robert Menzies tried to ban the Communist Party of Australia, a law which was struck down by the High Court for being unconstitutional.

Premiers Campbell Newman, Barry O'Farrell and Ted Baillieu might well be tempted to ape his failure, given the hysteria surrounding outlaw biker gangs, a gathering storm of fear and loathing that intensified over the weekend after the shooting at Robina.

Newman hastened to blame the shooting on the ALP, a piece of political satire worthy of Clive 'Titanic' Palmer, except that he knows how politically dangerous it can be to soft-pedal such an incident. A quick glance through the comment threads on brisbanetimes.com.au stories about Robina is enough to recognise the dangerous passions unleashed by unexpected and violent discontinuity.

“In all seriousness, should there be state-sponsored summary assassination of known criminals (such as has allegedly occurred in places like Israel) even if the case against them is not proven at court?” wrote one correspondent from West End.

Others suggested milder, but legally adventurous options such as simply outlawing motorcycle club membership, or perhaps sealing off an island or remote area of the bush to allow the gangs to cowboy up and shoot it out amongst themselves without bothering innocent shoppers.

These people vote. As crazy as their suggestions are - and they are bugshit crazy - the motivations behind them are understandable. Millions of people in southeast Queensland, for instance, would have walked through or stood on the exact spot where Saturday's shooting took place. Often with their kids in tow.

That particular part of Robina is familiar to me, lying as it does astride a well beaten path between the Apple Store and a couple of videogame shops of which I am fond. Rather than putting a bullet into the bicep of an alleged gang rival, the shooter could just as easily have put it through my daughter's head, your husband or wife's throat, a small boy's chest.

In these circumstances, imagination inflames the passions, and the prospect of heavily armed tactical squads kicking down the reinforced gates of outlaw compounds, dealing out the sort of retribution you and I would be incapable of, is an enticing prospect indeed.

But it's not going to happen. Not because we have lost the will to defend ourselves, or neutered the police, or because the Labor Party is in secret league with the Hell's Angels. It's not going to happen like that because mature, sophisticated and powerful states do not behave like, well, outlaw motorcycle gangs..

Allow Assistant Police Commissioner Mike Condon to explain: “When an incident occurs, it is almost a competition about who appears to be the toughest between two groups but when it is over and the reality hits home, there is regret that the incident occurred.”

That reality hits home not from some moral imperative pressing itself upon the warring bikers consideration, but rather from a realistic appraisal of the power imbalance between the modern state and those who would live outside its walls. As violent and savagely Hobbesian as the outlaw world is, it pales next to the insensate violence available to the state.

The reason outlaw gangs operate underground and out of sight for the most part is that they know they cannot survive a head-on clash with Hobbes's Leviathan. They'll be crushed. Not by ridiculous fantasies of unacknowledged wetwork operations, with spies and assassins taking them out in the dead of night, but by law and by the threat of massive, unanswerable state violence that stands behind the law.

Condon was right when he said the groups involved in Saturday's gunplay would come to regret it. But they will regret it because the machinery of the state, a machinery so powerful and destructive it must be constrained by law, will now turn its cold lidless gaze upon them with renewed focus.

They are doomed.

There is no need of extraordinary measures or intemperate legislative changes. What's needed is probably quite simple. Funding and political support for hard, long haul investigative and prosecutorial work that lasts beyond the excitement of the news cycle, and patience enough to let the police bring to bear the resources they require.

67 comments so far

  • "perhaps sealing off an island or remote area of the bush to allow the gangs to cowboy up and shoot it out amongst themselves"...

    Are you saying the Escape_from_New_York option wouldn't work? It would be great TV aren't TV channels shopping around for the next big thing.

    "As violent and savagely Hobbesian as the outlaw world is, it pales next to the insensate violence available to the state". That's a really cool line, and a keen observation nice work.

    Commenter
    Barnesm31@gmail.com
    Location
    Melbourne, waiting, watching prepared
    Date and time
    May 01, 2012, 7:11AM
    • Barnes, I reckon the "Commando" option is more viable. A Schwarzenegger-esque enraged citizen running around the shopping centre, abseiling between levels, ripping phone booths from the floor, sending roughnecks flying over tables in the food court with one crisp backhander. Phew! It'd scare me straight, I'll tell you.

      Commenter
      Big Willie Style
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 7:52AM
    • ms insomniac reckons the sort of element who like shooting at each other should be sent off to afghanistan to shoot at the taliban if they like guns so much, but they'd probably be too chicken

      Commenter
      insomniac
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 8:50AM
    • Big Willie Style I would so watch World Biggest Commando.

      Commenter
      Barnesm
      Location
      Melbourne, waiting for the undead to rise
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 9:17AM
  • I believe lead article on this site is that the person identified from CCTV footage of the incident is under arrest.

    "Funding and political support for hard, long haul investigative and prosecutorial work"
    But don't the police need Orwellian powers of communication inspection. It is what "they" are always telling us. Where "they" are the people who have nothing to hide so nothing to fear.

    Commenter
    tqft
    Date and time
    May 01, 2012, 7:14AM
    • "But they will regret it because the machinery of the state, a machinery so powerful and destructive it must be constrained by law, will now turn its cold lidless gaze upon them with renewed focus"

      The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. There is a fine line to walk between the freedom we allow the state to enforce pax romana and the police state.
      In the Soviet Union, crime and corruption (outside that instituted by the state itself) was almost non-existant. Little old ladies thought nothing of walking home alone in total darkness from their factory shift.
      Today they are nervous walking alone in broad dayight.

      Apart from a few little old ladies however, most Russians prefer the situation today because they dont risk dissappearing for making a political comment to a trusted friend (journalists making public commentary of course are another story).

      You can truelly buy peace if you want it, and all it will cost you is your soul.

      Commenter
      Goresh
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 7:51AM
    • Pretty sure that JB didn't ask for any extra over the top wiretapping or electronic surveillance - his exact words were long haul investigative and prosecutorial work.

      In other words, the hard yards that cops have done and should continue to do, rather than coming to lazily rely on electronic intel for all their investigation. HumInt will always trump SigInt and that's why we need the resources out there for the investigators tasked with stopping the bike gangs inn a legitimate, lawful manner.

      The second we yield to the worst of suggestions about how to deal with the problem is the second we become no better than them and the state loses all legitimacy and starts rotting from within. Of that hasn't already started, of course.

      Commenter
      Nic (Omega Bunny)
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 7:51AM
    • Nic,
      my point was more with than against. Haven't had coffee yet.

      Just because you, me & JB & the a good of the police see no need for the gamut of technological intrusion possible, that won't stop some numpties (Hi Campbell) from calling for it.

      I have a real problem with the "Freedom" of Association Laws propsed. Giving a politician power to ban and sieze assets of any group "identified" scares the crap out of me.

      Commenter
      tqft
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 9:13AM
    • "Little old ladies thought nothing of walking home alone in total darkness.." not just in the Soviet Union. The same applied to old people waling home in SPARTA.

      Commenter
      Barnesm
      Location
      Melbourne, waiting for the undead to rise
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 9:16AM
    • Yes in fact the entire Soviet empire was relatively crime free, but look at it now...good old capitalism!

      Commenter
      treeman
      Location
      the beach
      Date and time
      May 01, 2012, 11:58PM

More comments

Make a comment

You are logged in as [Logout]

All information entered below may be published.

Error: Please enter your screen name.

Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Please enter your comment.

Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

Post to

You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

Thank you

Your comment has been submitted for approval.

Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

Featured advertisers