JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

BlackBerry maker faces tough uphill app battle

RIM CEO Thorsten Heins shows off a prototype device running the company's BlackBerry 10 software at BlackBerry World ...

RIM CEO Thorsten Heins shows off a prototype device running the company's BlackBerry 10 software at BlackBerry World conference in Orlando, Florida.

BlackBerry maker Research in Motion is in a rut. Its market share in smartphones continues to fall in light of strong competition from Apple and Google's Android in both consumer and enterprise markets.

The reality is big corporates are starting to allow employees to bring their own choice of device to work and they are not choosing BlackBerries.

So can the company claw back the market share it desperately needs to survive with its new BlackBerry 10 platform? Or will its new platform go the way of Nokia's almost stillborn MeeGo operating system and HP's WebOS, which were both abandoned relatively soon after being launched?

The new platform, a sneak peak of which was given to a large audience at the company's annual BlackBerry World conference in Orlando, Florida, last week, is sleek. That much is for sure. But it won't be available until later this year on a new set of smartphones RIM is yet to unveil. In the meantime, the question remains as to whether app developers, one of the most important parts of any smartphone's ecosystem, will support it.

Perhaps the most recent indication of whether they will, lies in a March survey from Appcelerator and IDC, which showed that less than 16 per cent of developers were "very interested" in creating programs for RIM devices, compared with 90 per cent for Apple and 80 per cent for Android. That's before they got a sneak peak of what BlackBerry 10 has to offer.

RIM will of course now be hoping to turn that 16 per cent figure around. It showed that it was already working with some of its existing partners to ensure content and apps are available when BlackBerry 10 devices are launched.

To try and make sure other developers support BlackBerry 10 before the big reveal, RIM announced it would be handing out about 2000 prototype devices at its BlackBerry 10 Jam conference, a sister convention running alongside BlackBerry World. Named the “BlackBerry 10 Dev Alpha”, the device didn't contain the final BlackBerry 10 operating system, but a version created for the purpose of testing BlackBerry 10 apps.

Although much of the tech media welcome the device with cynicism because it contained barely any of the new features announced by RIM in BlackBerry 10, it's a smart move by the company to seed the prototype into the hands of developers before the real devices are launched. It will give the developers a chance to port any of the apps they may have made for BlackBerry's PlayBook tablet - which currently boasts about 15,000 apps - to the new smartphone platform and will also give them the time they need to re-create and re-code the apps they may have made for BlackBerry's older smartphone platforms that won't be compatible with the new platform.

RIM also announced it would be guaranteeing developers of certified apps $US10,000 in sales in an app's first year to encourage them to write apps for its new platform, a strategy that echoes Microsoft's move to attract developers to its Windows Phone platform by financing certain versions of well-known apps.

To qualify for the $US10,000 an app must earn a minimum of $US1000 though the developer's own marketing efforts and have met RIM's quality threshold (so no fart apps).

Senior director of BlackBerry's development platform, Christopher Smith, told Fairfax Media that the guarantee was about RIM “standing behind” and supporting developers.

“We're starting with a new subscriber-base [with BlackBerry 10] and we know that developers, when they approach a platform, have choices. They choose to invest their time and energy based on an understanding of a return on their investment,” he said. If certified apps didn't make it to $US10,000 in sales in their first year, RIM would cover the difference, he added.

Two representatives Fairfax spoke to for app development firms in Australia who attended RIM's conference said they couldn't wait to get their hands on the prototype device.

One of them, Michael Fishpool, managing director of Sydney-based Fish Vision, said in the past it was “challenging” to develop apps for BlackBerry smartphones. 

“But now it's becoming more unified and obviously it is going to be a much easier approach, I'm sure,” he said. “You can already see 100 per cent that that is the case.”

He added that transitioning or moving into BlackBerry 10 would potentially be more cost-effective for a company based on the app development tools available.

Fishpool's firm works with companies in Australia to bring their mobile and web app ideas to fruition. He worked on the Fairfax Media's Good Food Guide 2011 app for BlackBerry for the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.

Asked about the take-up rate of the Fairfax app, he said it wasn't enormous. “But that's probably representative of [BlackBerry's] market share in Australia.”

The other Australian app developer Fairfax spoke to, Paul Haenel, works as the tech lead for creating BlackBerry apps at Tiger Spike's office in Melbourne. The firm makes its own entertainment and news apps, as well as bespoke ones for governments and corporations.

He said RIM's new BlackBerry 10 platform was “very fresh” and that he would look to build apps for it. “It's very user-engaging compared to the previous operating system.”

Haenel added he believed RIM will have another shot in the Australia market with its new operating system.

“They have a chance to come back again in that market. It's very iOS and Android-dominated at this stage. But I think they can come back because the trend I have seen in the mobile space in Australia is that it's turning into Android because people want something different than anybody else. iOS is dominating, yes, but the trend is sort of moving to something else and I think Blackberry 10 will definitely play a big role in that.”

This remains to be seen, however, with RIM at last count only securing about 5 per cent of the Australian overall smartphone market in 2011, according to IDC market analyst Aman Bajaj.

Nick Dillon, analyst of devices and platforms at research firm Ovum, believes in order to succeed RIM will need to secure the Top 1000 apps seen on other platforms like Android and iOS.

“The priority is the big brands. That's what you really need to get onboard - the kind of stuff that's going to stop someone buying the device because they can't get an app. The long tail will follow and that's something you can't really get there in time for launch," Dillon said.

Whether or not RIM's BlackBerry 10 platform can secure these top apps is difficult to predict. Smartphones based on it later this year may have the best operating system going around, but if there are no familiar apps on them, RIM will have a difficult time convincing people to buy one.

The writer travelled to BlackBerry World in Orlando, Florida as a guest of RIM.

twitter  Follow IT Pro on Twitter


  • There are many things at play here, not just the app market, I think RIM has let itself down by not creating the handsets that people really want. I was a Blackberry Pearl user and loved it - for many reasons. Every Blackberry since just hasn't suited my needs, so they've lost me a bit - and it's not just because the apps are lacking.

    The other point is that Blackberry used to have the edge in Enterprise - but they've lost that a bit now as the competitors are catching up... it's a fickle world out there in IT land - that's for sure.

    Genevieve Darnley
    Date and time
    May 07, 2012, 12:30PM
    • I think no question that BB is the most secure, but it has historically given CIOs/Admins too much control
      -- case in point the international firm I used to work for blocked Blackberry AppWorld, GPS and the MicroSD card via its policy setting, and I know many other companies who do the same
      -- This means no apps, no decent maps, no music, no video so unsurprisingly people view the device as behind the times... Indeed since OS6, BB has done music and vid well (if you can access the sd card).
      -- Now Blackberry Balance which is being rolled out and supposedly allows users to separate the Personal portion of the phone may fix this, but is too little too late, the perception is already there, and I suspect many IT admins will just cripple Balance as well...

      On the apps point.
      Too be honest most Apple 'apps' are useless timewasters or an expensive rendition of what could be achieved using HTML5 which would make it cross platform
      I have a Playbook (on which BBOS 10 is based) and it has a good selection of apps. Mainly missing is Skype and Australian financial and sporting apps, as well as a PDF markup program. Rest are either already there as native or android converted apps.

      Date and time
      May 07, 2012, 12:38PM
      • RIM would be best served by licensing their email and calendaering capability to the likes of Apple and Google. having full exchange capability on the iPhone would be welcomed by business users and genreate a massive revenue stream for RIM. Why do they still want to be in the hardware device market anyway????

        Date and time
        May 07, 2012, 12:46PM
        • Hmmmm this could be a make or break situation for RIM, however I think they are late to run in this race!

          Crazy Hayz
          Date and time
          May 07, 2012, 1:47PM
          • "To qualify for the $US10,000 an app must earn a minimum of $US1000 though the developer's own marketing efforts and have met RIM's quality threshold (so no fart apps)."

            I dunno, maybe BB needs fart apps? Hold it behind your boss in the boring meetings and let rip :)

            Mark Harrison
            Date and time
            May 07, 2012, 1:59PM
            • Its never too late, if you stop innovating in technology you wont last, Apple were dead 5 years ago almost into extinction, look where they are today. If they dont innovate for another 2 years they could be in a similar position, technology changes daily keep up or fall behind. Apple cant keep the same OS design forever it will get boring, in fact its already boring to me. Blackberry new OS supports yes although limited at the moment Android apps plus a growing Native App base, so they have a strong foundation to grow from. People do not take security seriously enough until it bites them. Apple and Android will get a wake up call eventually if they dont improve in that area.

              Date and time
              May 07, 2012, 4:16PM
              • The so called apps market is grossly over rated with 90% of them being absolutley useless from any perspective. You may spend hours, or days, trawling through rubbish, or even refine your search, only to find just about everything has no relevance. Apps is not what is driving the Apple market, and neither is it for Android, if one actual does enough research. But if you want a prediction, there is considerable concern with all things Google at the moment from personal security perspective, and I for one will not be buying an Android device because it is unlikely you can trust it. New web mails are being developed to provide additional security and stop the marketing of personal information by Google. I do have several BB's for business and there is nothing on the market that can compare. Are you just sucked in by the facarde of Android. Are you really confident you are not being spied on? I rather have a BB, or even Apple any day just for that reason alone.

                John Ralph
                Date and time
                May 07, 2012, 6:28PM
                • They simply dont get it - like Nokia
                  Its not just about the one device anymore, its called an ecosystem, which extends to integrate your TV, your tablet & phone as remote control devices, and a store that allows the purchase and management of apps and media.
                  The simplicity of Apples itunes is one of its greatest strengths, and both Nokia & RIM ignore it. Without this, your farting against thunder.
                  Equally, Apple have other low cost devices like itouch etc, that allow for kids to share a similar experience, hence, families embrace the ubiquitous nature of the ecosystem, so, you're all hooked in.
                  Funnily enough, the fart apps etc do generate a loyal following, you need to balance this out and have apps that suit all.
                  RIM, you need a few more devices both low end, high end and integrated with home entertainment.
                  Once Google TV get their act sorted, then we will have a genuine 2 horse race.

                  DG Akld
                  Date and time
                  May 08, 2012, 7:55AM
                  • I agreed with the ecosystem so i suggest RIM should just focus on an ecosystem for ENTERPRISE and business user. Consumer market is pretty much lost!

                    I need productiveness not 'fun and game' so don't worry about these fart apps people suggest. I don't mind not having Angry Bird on my BB.

                    Maybe focus on Apps for VPN and enhance an ecosystem with BB video messaging?

                    Now go and develop RIM!

                    Date and time
                    July 10, 2012, 12:00PM
                    Comments are now closed

                    HuffPost Australia

                    Follow Us

                    Featured advertisers