JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Budget 2014 reply: Bill Shorten says Labor will block key Abbott government budget reforms

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Tony, what a big surprise!

Rocco Fazzari and Denis Carnahan present their musical analysis of the Budget. With apologies to Chicago.

PT0M0S 620 349

Key elements of the Abbott government’s economic strategy have been thrown into chaos after Bill Shorten declared its first budget a document based on lies and committed the Labor opposition to combine with the Greens in the Senate to block them.

The move signals Labor’s intent to replicate the Abbott opposition style of no compromises in an approach that could force the government into grinding line-by-line negotiations in the Senate both now and beyond July when the new senators alter the balance of power.

"The government forgot a lot of people on budget night": Bill Shorten.

"The government forgot a lot of people on budget night": Bill Shorten. Photo: Andrew Meares

Making his first post-budget address-in-reply speech as Opposition Leader, Mr Shorten rounded on Prime Minister Tony Abbott for breaking promises. He vowed  to block punitive changes to Newstart that would force some young unemployed people to exist without the dole, along with a shift in the pension age to 70, tightening of Family Tax Benefit Part B eligibility relating to children aged over six, and the move to restore twice yearly indexation to fuel excise.

The planned $7 per visit charge for seeing a  GP will also be blocked, with Mr Shorten slamming it as “ideological” and more akin to the hardline right-wing policies of the Tea Party in the US. However Mr Shorten declined to propose alternative savings.

In a hard-hitting speech emphasising what the opposition says were “wilful” lies told to the Australian people, Mr Shorten told Parliament Australians were both shocked and angry “at a prime minister who pretended he was on their side”.

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten acknowledges applause from the public gallery after delivering the budget reply.

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten acknowledges applause from the public gallery after delivering the budget reply. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

He also challenged the government over suggestions it could go to a double dissolution election, saying: "If you want an election, try us. If you think Labor is too weak, try us."

Mr Shorten said the government had produced a “tax it or cut it budget” where people would pay more for medicines, GP visits and petrol, while if they were young and unemployed or relied on a pension, they would be left behind.

“On Tuesday, the Treasurer quoted from Robert Menzies’ “Forgotten People,” he said. “But the government forgot a lot people on budget night.”

“This is a budget of broken promises built on lies, and not just lies, systematic and wilful ones.”

Citing economic modelling conducted by the Canberra-based National Centre for Social and Economic Modelling (NATSEM), he said Labor could not pass measures that  would strip $1700 from the household budget of a family with an income of $65,000 and two children  in school.

“Add in health costs and the Prime Minister is cutting nearly $40 from their weekly budget,” he said.

But the opposition said the cuts would become harder as time goes on, citing  modelling which takes the 2014 household cost of budget decisions from $1733 to well over triple that by 2016 at $5830.

The unusually strong action on budget legislation represents a political risk for the opposition and could even push the government into seeking a fresh election – something Prime Minister Tony Abbott toyed with in an interview on Wednesday but stepped back from on Thursday, adopting a more conciliatory tone.

“I’m not going to be absolutely unreasonable. I’m going to be respectful towards the Parliament and the Senate,” he said.

Earlier in the day, politicians from all sides were out arguing their respective cases over the budget, which has divided opinion like few in recent years.

Treasurer Joe Hockey hit back at critics of the proposed $7 per visit GP payment, likening it to the daily costs met by smokers and drinkers.

‘‘Some people are screaming about a $7 co-payment,” he said. “One packet of cigarettes costs $22. That gives you three visits to the doctor. You can spend just over $3 on a middy of beer, so that’s two middies of beer to go to the doctor.

‘‘Let’s have some perspective about the cost of taking care of our health.

‘‘Is a parent really going to deny their sick child a visit to the doctor, which would be the equivalent payment of a couple of beers or one third of a packet of cigarettes?’’

That brought derision from the opposition with critics lining up to argue the Treasurer was out of touch if he thought $7 could buy two glasses of beer, and worse, that he had failed to understand the importance of $7 per visit to many low income families – especially with  multiple children.

Labor’s shadow treasurer Chris Bowen challenged Mr Hockey to a live debate at the National Press Club next Wednesday in a fiery question time.

Mr Hockey declined the invitation, declaring instead: “If I turned up at the National Press Club, it’d double the audience”.

On Friday, Mr Hockey told a breakfast event in Melbourne that Mr Shorten's reply to the budget resembled someone standing over the twisted metal of a train crash and saying, "there's no problem here".

"His solution is no solution. It's just a political response, not a policy response," he said.

"I don't think Australians will take him terribly seriously. I'm not going to waste my time responding to him."

The government now faces stiff opposition from all sides  with states and territories angry over projected cuts to schools and hospitals worth $80 billion over 10 years, and seemingly no support for its measures from anywhere in the Parliament. That has increased the prospect of an early election, although that remains an unlikely outcome at this stage. 

Palmer United Party leader Clive Palmer tweeted on Friday morning that if Mr Abbott called a double dissolution election he would run candidates in all lower house seats and stand for prime minister.

Social Services Minister Kevin Andrews said on Friday that it was the Labor opposition that was in denial in response to a question that the basklash over Mr Hockey's budget indicated many measures were too high.

He shifted the blame to Labor and repeated the government's view that the country's finances were in a mess.

"Frankly, Mr Shorten is in total denial," Mr Andrews said.

"Elisabeth Kubler-Ross described denial as the first stage of grief and that is where Mr Shorten obviously is.

"He offered no solution last night to paying down Labor’s record debt."

Follow us on Twitter

387 comments

  • Is the Treasurer insinuating people would rather spend their limited finances on beer and cigarettes than sick children??

    Commenter
    Chocmunch
    Date and time
    May 16, 2014, 7:00AM
    • Thank you, Mark Kenny.
      From a political and strategic perspective, Bill Shorten has every right to hold Abbott to account regarding:
      (i) the thrust of the budget and (ii) not keeping to his election promises.
      Bill, what a lovely rhetorical flourish - characterising this budget as "akin to the hardline right-wing policies of the Tea Party in the US".
      Seize the moment, Bill.
      However, a word of caution; although this Budget is manna from Heaven for Labor - handle the gift with wisdom.
      Don't offer an alternative budget that is akin to the 'mad hatter's tea party' - yes, yes, I plead guilty to a wilfully indulgent flourish.
      Please, no 'Alice in Wonderland' budget answer from Labor - I suspect that, to a large degree, the electorate is now beyond any fatuous reassurances that we can 'blink' and our economic challenges will vanish. Time will not stand still for us - at 6.00pm.
      Most people are alert to the notion that we can no longer avoid tough decisions - in making necessary and inescapable 'structural adjustments'.
      Labor can quietly smile (away from the public gaze, of course) at the fact the Coalition has offered such a budget - at best crazy brave, at worst political suicide; what's not to celebrate for Labor (a wonderful opportunity to get back into the game).
      If I may continue the Alice analogy...
      Ultimately, the electorate will pass judgement on the Coalition:
      (i) Guilty of misleading the Australian people and lying - off with their heads;
      (ii) A terrible budget, and too much pain and suffering - off with their heads;
      (iii) A tough budget and 'bitter to swallow', but sound reasons for it; “we can't go back to yesterday because we were in a different economic situation then” (to paraphrase Alice).

      Commenter
      Howe Synnott
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 9:46AM
    • I find it insulting that the Treasurer insists I spend my money as it is on cigarettes and alcohol. Where will my $7 come from if it doesn't come from that? Actually out of my food budget?

      Commenter
      AussieA
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 9:49AM
    • Chochmunch - Joe's telling us we have to make choices, we can't have it all.

      Bill still thinks we can.

      Commenter
      Hacka
      Location
      Canberra
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 9:49AM
    • Yeah Shorten knows we're all a nation of bludgers, who love a hand out, if it wasn't for the industrious Chinese we would be a basket case.

      Commenter
      Who cares what my name is
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 9:52AM
    • what an excellent rebuttal to the sneaky Sir Tony and Hockey One Hockey Two (you're pucked), and what an excellent interview with Ms Sara, despite her best efforts to emulate her performance on the embarrrassed hapless Joe

      Commenter
      rod steiger
      Location
      toukley
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 10:03AM
    • "I'm not going to waste my time responding to him." - the overt arrogance of this government is stunnning considering the nose dive their stocks have taken in the polls - no engagement, just "do what I say, we were born to rule"

      Commenter
      rod steiger
      Location
      toukley
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 10:05AM
    • I think we all wish we never voted for KRUDD and created this mess.

      Commenter
      Who cares what my name is
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 10:17AM
    • Snouts back in the trough Australia, just elect Shorten and you can all get your snouts back in the trough.

      Commenter
      Who cares what my name is
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 10:19AM
    • Alcohol and Cigarettes are a discretionary expense that you can forgo. They are a want.

      Visiting the Doctor when you're sick is necessary. It is a need.

      The mere fact that the Liberals doesn't understand this shows just out of touch they really are.

      Commenter
      Tone
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      May 16, 2014, 10:25AM

More comments

Comments are now closed

Related Coverage

Tony what a big surprise! (Thumbnail) Tony, what a big surprise!

Rocco Fazzari and Denis Carnahan present their musical analysis of the Budget. With apologies to Chicago.

Bill Shorten's budget reply promise: I'll be as negative as Tony Abbott

Bill Shorten’s blunt message for Tony Abbott in his budget reply is that he intends to be every bit as negative as the man whose negativity tore down two prime ministers and a government.

Tony Abbott rains down blows in budget blitz

Far from restoring faith in the political process, the PM has followed magic-pudding election promises with unsavoury cutbacks.

Middy-economics: you can't have your ale and visit too

Joe Hockey prefers to use units of measurement the public can easily understand: the middy

Income equality a matter of fairness for all

US President Barack Obama said that income inequality is one of the most serious problems of our time. Former Treasurer Wayne Swan claimed that the rise of the wealthy threatens Australia’s tradition of a ''fair go''.

Childcare subsidy cuts to hit middle and low income families, warns Early Childhood

The federal government is under fire for a budget change that will deprive families of $230 million in childcare subsidies over the next four years.

Upping pension age is the clear way forward

Those outraged by pensions at 70 should think again. We can make this change now amidst growth or during a genuine debt crisis down the track.

Health Minister Peter Dutton says Medicare fees will improve health outcomes

Health Minister Peter Dutton has predicted the introduction of a fee to visit the doctor will improve health outcomes by making it easier for patients to get an appointment and for doctors to spend more time with patients.

Student fees set to double as funding cuts take their toll

Fees expected to more than double for environmental studies and communications students when they are deregulated in 2016.

Loophole makes it 'easy' to avoid the debt levy

People earning over $180,000 will have nine months to salary-package and avoid the debt levy, because of a loophole in the budget, tax experts said.

Bill Shorten's call to arms (Thumbnail) Bill Shorten's call to arms

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten slams the government's cuts to health, welfare and education in his budget reply speech and says Labor is ready for an election.

Tony Abbott rounds on Bill Shorten for 'picking fights' on the budget

Prime Minister Tony Abbott has accused Opposition Leader Bill Shorten of picking fights and of having no positive vision for Australia's economy.

States pushing ahead with emergency meeting on budget cuts despite efforts from Tony Abbott to calm ...

The premiers are pushing ahead with a crisis meeting on Sunday despite Prime Minister Tony Abbott's efforts to calm them over budget cuts.

Government's public sector redundancy budget is missing millions

The federal budget appears to have a gaping hole: it has failed to set aside enough funds for what is likely to be a record public sector redundancy bill.

Independence of Speaker Bronwyn Bishop again compromised after she takes direction from Christopher ...

The independence of the Speaker has again been compromised after the government was caught directing her to bring applause for Bill Shorten's budget reply speech to an end.

Related Coverage

Featured advertisers

Special offers

Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo