JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Christopher Pyne blames journalists for government's apparent Gonski backflip

Date

Jonathan Swan and Dan Harrison

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Pyne abandons Gonski model

The government says it will retain Labor's funding levels for school education, but will introduce a new model for distributing the money from the 2015 school year.

PT0M0S 620 349

Education Minister Christopher Pyne has blamed journalists for getting confused about his school funding promises, amid growing anger over the Coalition's reneging on its pre-election commitments.

''It's not my fault if some people in the press gallery don't understand the complicated nature of the school funding model,'' Mr Pyne told ABC Radio on Wednesday.

Education Minister Christopher Pyne has defended his decision to scrap Gonski and reduce education funding.

Education Minister Christopher Pyne has defended his decision to scrap Gonski and reduce education funding. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

Asked whether the widespread confusion over the Coalition's education funding plans was because voters were just ''not very bright'', Mr Pyne replied: ''I didn’t say voters . . . I said members of the press gallery.'' 

The Abbott government is under increasing pressure for breaking its election promise to replicate Labor's Gonski school funding model for the next four years.

Only a fortnight ago, Mr Pyne said he would retain Labor's funding and the overall model.

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

But Mr Pyne is now refusing to repeat his pre-election assurance that ''you can vote Liberal or Labor and you'll get exactly the same amount of funding for your school''.

Mr Pyne has also said the government will be spending $1.2 billion less on education than pledged before the election, saying that money set aside before the election for states that hadn't signed Gonski had been spent.

Prime Minister Tony Abbott also declined on Wednesday to restate the pledge made by Mr Pyne in August that each individual school would receive the same amount of funding under the Coalition as under Labor.

''Our pre-election commitment was that there will be exactly the same quantum of funding under the Coalition as under the Labor Party,'' Mr Abbott told reporters in Melbourne.

''We are absolutely honouring our pre-election commitments.''

He did, however, say that the Coalition had decided to put $230 million of the $1.2 billion back into the program, which would be distributed to the states and territories that did not sign up to the Gonski funding model - Western Australia, the Northern Territory and Queensland.

''We will have a school funding system which is both national and fair,'' he said.

The Education Minister said Labor's plan was no longer possible and the Coalition would have to go back to the ''drawing board'' after the first year of Labor's model.

''What one government does, another government can undo,'' Mr Pyne said, suggesting that he would scrap Labor's six-year Better Schools plan and redesign the system.

The overall funding would remain the same but the Coalition might redistribute the money, leaving open the possibility that some schools and states would lose out.

As recently as November 17, Mr Pyne told Sky News: ''I said that we would keep the new school funding model but [only] over the next four years because we don't believe in Labor's claims things can be promised five, six, 10, 15, 20 years down the track.

''Over the next four years we will maintain the new school funding model, and the budget that went with that in the forward estimates.''

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten said that the government had "broken its promise" on schools funding, although when pressed, would not say that the Coalition had lied.

"Yesterday they were blaming Labor. This morning in Adelaide, they are blaming the media. Who are they going to blame tomorrow? Are they going to blame the parents or the kids?"

Talking to reporters in Melbourne, Mr Shorten said that the government was assuming that the "whole of Australia" had "amnesia" about the schools funding issue.

The Coalition's backflip has infuriated states that signed up for Labor's package.

Premiers from NSW, Tasmania and South Australia have attacked the Abbott government for reneging on its promise to ensure every school would receive the same funding under the Coalition as it would under Labor.

NSW Liberal Premier Barry O'Farrell said education funding had been poorly handled by the Abbott government. He has written to Mr Abbott to express his concerns.

''Can I just make this point to the federal Education Minister,'' Mr O'Farrell said. ''When you move into government, you have got to stop behaving like an opposition.''

Tasmanian Premier Lara Giddings contradicted Mr Pyne's assertion that Tasmania had not signed any agreement.

''What we have here is a heads of agreement that has been signed,'' Ms Giddings said. ''That is a deal. That is a contract. That in itself shows that Christopher Pyne and Tony Abbott are breaking an election promise.''

Victorian Premier Denis Napthine also responded on Wednesday, tweeting that his government would "fight for the agreement that was implemented & signed with the legitimate government of the day".

"We'll fight for the agreement that was implemented & signed with the legitimate government of the day"-Premier on #Gonski #SpringSt #auspol

South Australian Premier Jay Weatherill said the government had created the impression that there was no difference between Labor and Liberal when it came to school funding.

''Within 10 weeks of the election they’ve walked away from that promise,'' he said.

''It's outrageous, and we will be extracting a political penalty for every day this federal government remains in breach of the promise it made before the election.

''Mr Pyne will reverse his decision on this and we will be campaigning against him until he does that.

''These are just weasel words. He made it absolutely clear he was on a unity ticket, there was no difference between him and Labor on the question of Gonski funding, and the reason he did that was because Labor won the political argument about the importance of these reforms.

''This is, I must say, an extraordinary federal government . . . This was a government that used to bang on about sovereign risk, and they actually breach agreements that have been solemnly entered into and people have acted on to their detriment.

''The policy chaos that’s occurring at the national level now is extraordinary.''

Mr Shorten said the Abbott government was breaking its election commitment.

"They said there would be a unity ticket before the election,” he said.

"Now what's happened is they've reneged. But there's a deeper issue here. It goes to trust. Ten weeks in, the Coalition government cannot be trusted to keep their election promises they made before the election.”

with Mark Kenny, Anna Patty, Gareth Hutchens

418 comments

  • He's a tricksy little .......

    Commenter
    ElectionNow
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    November 27, 2013, 11:28AM
    • Ah yes, I can see Pyne in one of those old western movies, where he is on a paddle steamer heading down the Mississippi river, he plays the crooked card shark

      Commenter
      bud
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 11:47AM
    • See what happens when you fools vote Liberal??!!!

      Commenter
      bubbles
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 11:48AM
    • The press has got it wrong and misunderstood, they are absolutely honoring their election promise, just not the one they spoke out loud.

      Commenter
      BuffAndroid
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 11:52AM
    • this is just straight up deception of voters. he neutralised Gonski as an election issue by promising to implement it, then invented excuses post fact. anyone who can't see that unsophisticated deception for what it is, is blind.

      Commenter
      eddy the cannibal merckx
      Location
      melb
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 11:58AM
    • Pyne by his own standards set in the last parliament is a liar! And what's with the Clark Kent glasses he put on at the presser? Didn't he want to be recognised while he was doing the backflip?

      Commenter
      The Hood
      Location
      Fitzroy
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 12:01PM
    • OK, now class - everyone put their hand-up if they'd like to change their vote from the last election.

      Good - you can all go home early.

      Commenter
      JTHooker
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 12:08PM
    • I voted Liberal and still like what TA is doing, but this Pyne idiot is seriously messing things up in a big way.

      Say what he will about reporters 'getting it wrong', it is HIS responsibility to get his message across and if he made a promise, to stick to it.

      We don't want the LNP to end up behaving like the ALP.

      Commenter
      Enraged Sock-puppet
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 12:08PM
    • No tricks here. This was a calculated election tactic designed to nullify the vote winning gonski package. They knew then as they announced their "Unity Ticket" that they were running a deception. Now we all know and kids in disadvantaged schools are the real losers. This brings great shame onto an already shambolic government. "Who can we trust?" - not these liars.

      Commenter
      Weed Man
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 12:09PM
    • Hold on Hold on, I think you guys have got it all wrong.

      Pyne's election promises are called "gonski" and he just want's to give the education reform a new name.

      Give him time. Everything will be the same it's just that it takes a long while to come up with a new name for all of this. So much kerfuffle......................

      Commenter
      Hacka
      Date and time
      November 27, 2013, 12:09PM

More comments

Comments are now closed

Related Coverage

Education policy hand grenade pulls the pin on Barry O'Farrell's patience

''What the hell is going on?'' NSW Premier Barry O'Farrell thundered on Tuesday.

States furious over double backflip on Gonski funding

The debate over the Gonski school reforms has caused a serious rift between governments after Premier Barry O'Farrell blasted his federal colleagues for abandoning the funding agreement he struck with the former Labor government.

NAPLAN anxiety hits students but parents like the tests

Many parents are noticing their children are stressed and anxious as a result of NAPLAN testing, with symptoms such as sleeplessness, sickness and crying.

Prospect of Gonski funding review met with dread and agreement

The NSW Secondary Principals Council president and Merrylands High School principal, Lila Mularczyk, described the threat of a Gonski backflip as a blow to fairness in education funding.

Pyne abandons Gonski model (Thumbnail) Pyne abandons Gonski model

The government says it will retain Labor's funding levels for school education, but will introduce a new model for distributing the money from the 2015 school year.

ACT anger over Gonski 'back flip'

ACT government and education groups up in arms over federal Education Minister’s “complete back flip” over Gonski.

Related Coverage

Featured advertisers

Special offers

Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo