JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Expenses scandal spreads

Date

Jonathan Swan, Daniel Hurst

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

RAW VISION: Rinehart, Joyce party at wedding

Barnaby Joyce billed taxpayers for a trip to India where he, two other Liberal MPs and Gina Rinehart watched the granddaughter of her business partner marry in a lavish wedding.

PT0M0S 620 349

Coalition MPs are endangering their reputations as economic managers by charging taxpayers for personal indulgences such as wedding travel, warns former leader John Hewson.

You'd be a mug if you didn't go to a shock jock's wedding if you're invited. 

Dr Hewson's call for higher standards follows a string of expenses scandals involving senior members of the Coalition, including Prime Minister Tony Abbott, billing taxpayers to attend weddings.

Claiming travel expenses: Minister for Foreign Affairs Julie Bishop and Prime Minister Tony Abbott.

Claiming travel expenses: Minister for Foreign Affairs Julie Bishop and Prime Minister Tony Abbott. Photo: Andrew Meares

Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull said MPs should use their judgment and err on the side of not making expense claims if they had any doubts. Dr Hewson said: "I don't believe in unlimited access to the public purse."

Fairfax Media can also reveal that a cycling enthusiast from Queensland, Labor MP Bernie Ripoll, enjoyed several stages of the Tour de France during a taxpayer-funded ''study tour'' to inspect the country's bicycle infrastructure. The study tour cost taxpayers $5474 but Mr Ripoll said he used five days of ''personal time'' to watch the cycling event, as he was entitled to do.

On Sunday, Fairfax Media revealed that three Coalition MPs - Julie Bishop, Barnaby Joyce and Teresa Gambaro - had claimed more than $12,000 in travel expenses to return from a lavish wedding in India where they were guests of billionaire Gina Rinehart.

"I don't believe in unlimited access to the public purse": Former Liberal leader Dr John Hewson.

"I don't believe in unlimited access to the public purse": Former Liberal leader Dr John Hewson. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

Mr Abbott also confirmed he repaid $1095 spent in travelling to the wedding of former colleague Sophie Mirabella seven years ago. The return of the money was prompted by media inquiries last week.

Dr Hewson, a former Liberal leader, said any new prime minister must set clear standards for the team as the ''fish rots from the head''.

Coalition MPs couldn't ''run on the line that [they] want to control government expenditure'' and at the same time waste taxpayers' money on their personal lives.

"I think it's ridiculous putting limits on where ministers can go": Former Howard minister Peter Reith.

"I think it's ridiculous putting limits on where ministers can go": Former Howard minister Peter Reith. Photo: AFR

''I think that in the early days of any government you need to set the standards,'' Dr Hewson said.

But former Howard government minister Peter Reith disagreed, describing the wedding expense scandals as ''petty'' and arguing that politicians should be entitled to unlimited travel.

''I don't understand how you can have a system which says that some things that ministers do are part of business and others aren't,'' Mr Reith said.

''I think it's ridiculous putting limits on where ministers can go.''

Expenses scandals marred the early days of the Howard government with seven cabinet ministers resigning after breaching rules that required ministers to divest shares in portfolios they oversaw and be truthful in Parliament.

As a minister Mr Reith racked up a $50,000 phone bill at taxpayers' expense, which he repaid.

Asked whether taxpayers should foot the bill for MPs to attend weddings, Mr Reith said: ''Since when is that not being part of being a politician, you know, going out for lunch with a shock jock or going to his wedding? You'd be a mug if you didn't go to a shock jock's wedding if you're invited.''

In the past week, Attorney-General George Brandis and Agriculture Minister Mr Joyce reimbursed taxpayers after Fairfax Media revealed they had used public funds to attend the wedding of their friend, broadcaster Michael Smith, in 2011.

Mr Joyce said on Monday that political opponents were trying to ''level the score'' after the Coalition won the federal election by exposing his past travel claims.

''That's what happens in politics,'' he told Fairfax Radio in Melbourne.

''We never did anything illegal. You did everything that you were basically entitled to do.''

Mr Joyce said his decision to take a study tour to Malaysia after the Indian wedding actually made it cheaper for the taxpayer since Ms Rinehart paid for half the trip.

He said the department could have also knocked back his claim and not approved his travel expenses.

''These things obviously happened years ago, not that that's an excuse,'' he said on Monday.

He said expense entitlements needed more clarity and reform.

''There's a grey area there,'' he said. ''I can understand why there needs to be a greater oversight about this and I've got no problems about that happening.''

Mr Turnbull said the rules had been ''a little bit ambiguous at the time'' and it was not uncommon for politicians to reimburse money. ''The better course of action is to err on a more conservative side and if there is any doubt then don't make a claim,'' Mr Turnbull told the ABC's Insiders on Sunday.

Former prime minister Julia Gillard's office has previously defended her use of a VIP jet to attend the wedding of her press secretary in Byron Bay last March, saying Ms Gillard had other commitments in the area.

Last month documents released under freedom of information laws showed Ms Gillard repaid $4243 in 2007 when she was deputy opposition leader in relation to her partner Tim Mathieson's private use of a taxpayer-funded car.

 

fairfax subscriptions

566 comments

  • Peter Reith I think it's safe to say that your view makes most taxpayers feel sick to the stomach.
    Absolutely sick to the stomach.

    Commenter
    Davo
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    October 07, 2013, 6:48AM
    • I'd agree with Peter Reith on the provision that the ticket was one-way - and that they did not return!

      Commenter
      Vincent
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 7:04AM
    • Can't but agree. Its clear that going to a shock-jock's wedding would benefit your re-election, but how does it benefit the taxpayer? Go by all means, but use your money; that is what its for.

      Commenter
      engunear
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 7:09AM
    • No worries Peter Reith - as long as the same rules apply to every employee across the nation. No limits on travel or "work related expenses" when we file our tax returns each year. Sounds good to me.

      Commenter
      marcus
      Location
      west coast
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 7:33AM
    • Aren't these parliamentarian's allowances?
      Sure, provide expenses towards legitimate costs in representing the electorate, participating in parliamentarian committees and other official business (even the so-called "fact finding trips").
      But sucking up to a mud-slinging shock jock is pure party politics and should be funded by the Liberal Party, not the taxpayer.

      Commenter
      gobsmack
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 7:37AM
    • I would not think he have to worry about going to a shock jocks wedding for Alan Jones.

      Commenter
      King Chip
      Location
      Boronia
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 7:40AM
    • We have a government that wants to spend, spend, spend and charge, charge, charge to their expense accounts making them go up and up and up. This is nothing less than an EXPENSE EMERGENCY and we demand an election NOW!

      Commenter
      Up and up and up
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 7:45AM
    • Politicians should spend more time in their electorates and less time swanning around overseas.
      Their core duties within their electorates should come first.

      Most of these fact-finding tours are just BS and give politicians free holidays at public expense.

      Politicians are already overpaid and parasites on the taxpayer purse and it is time all of this ended.

      These LNP pollies caught out , including Abbott, should resign from the front bench.

      The LNP sets high standards of honesty for their opponents but low standards for themselves.

      Reith has an appalling attitude.

      Commenter
      Get Real
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 8:06AM
    • I totally agree about Mr Reith, Davo. The man thinks we have amnesia! Children overboard and his denial...bringing dogs to the waterfront strike...allowing his son to use his mobile phone overseas and share with his pack packer friends and having the audacity to expect the tax payer to pay. Of course he repaid it because he had no choice in the matter. Mr Reith should just slink away. He knows no shame.

      Commenter
      Maus49
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 8:27AM
    • Peter Reith. What a grubby attitude. Just who does he think he is? What he is endorsing is a mild form of treason, and a near cousin to corruption. And we know what would happen in China if found guilty of such charges....

      Commenter
      John Citizen
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      October 07, 2013, 8:33AM

More comments

Comments are now closed

Related Coverage

RAW VISION: Rinehart, Joyce party at lavish wedding (Thumbnail) RAW VISION: Rinehart, Joyce party at wedding

Barnaby Joyce billed taxpayers for a trip to India where he, two other Liberal MPs and Gina Rinehart watched the granddaughter of her business partner marry in a lavish wedding.

Sneaky or not, some expenses still reek

We can only imagine the bride-to-be, Mallika Reddy, running the rule over the guest list for her big fat Indian wedding.

MP explains tour de good luck

Labor MP and cycling enthusiast Bernie Ripoll enjoyed several stages of the Tour de France on a taxpayer-funded study tour to inspect the country's bicycle infrastructure.

Big bucks for MPs' Bollywood adventure

It was among the most lavish weddings in Indian history.

Tony Abbott refuses to bend the rules on MPs' entitlements

Tony Abbott is resisting demands from all sides of politics to rein in MPs' entitlements, with one of his colleagues saying taxpayer-funded weddings and sporting events failed the "pub test".

Related Coverage

Featured advertisers

Special offers

Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo