JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Razor taken to CSIRO

Date

Noel Towell, Mark Kenny, Bridie Smith

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Science cuts savaged

Labor MP Amanda Rishworth says the Abbott government is behaving as though 'they know it all' with cuts to the CSIRO and the scrapping of advisory panels.

PT0M0S 620 349

Almost a quarter of scientists, researchers and workers at Australia's premier science institution will lose their jobs under the federal government's present public service jobs freeze.

The blanket staff freeze across the public service threatens the jobs of 1400 "non-ongoing" workers at the CSIRO and could paralyse some of the organisation's premier research projects, with a ban on hiring, extending or renewing short-term contracts effective immediately.

Tony Abbott: axing 12,000 jobs from the public service.

Tony Abbott: axing 12,000 jobs from the public service.

The impact of the freeze on the CSIRO follows fears expressed in the scientific community about the Abbott government's failure to nominate a dedicated science minister out of his cabinet or ministerial team. The concerns have been heightened by subsequent decisions, including the closure of the global warming advisory body the Climate Change Commission, and revelations on Thursday that Australia will not be sending its Environment Minister, Greg Hunt, or any ministerial stand-in to international climate change negotiations starting on Monday in Warsaw.

The freeze is part of the Abbott government's plan to cut 12,000 jobs from the public service.

On Friday, the government also confirmed the immediate dismantling of a number of government advisory bodies, expert panels and national steering committees, covering diverse areas including ageing, legal affairs, ethics and animal welfare. Federal cabinet this week signed off on the changes, which will see a dozen "non-statutory" bodies axed altogether, and several more amalgamated with other bodies or absorbed into existing departmental functions.

<i>Illustration: John Shakespeare</i>

Illustration: John Shakespeare

Prime Minister Tony Abbott repeatedly promised before the election that a Coalition government would dramatically reduce the size of the bureaucracy and would do away with thousands of regulations said to be clogging the economy.

"There are currently more than 50,000 Acts and legislative instruments, many of which are a handbrake on Australia's ability to get things done," Mr Abbott said.

The bodies scrapped are: Australian Animals Welfare Advisory Committee; Commonwealth Firearms Advisory Committee; International Legal Services Advisory Committee; National Inter-country Adoption Advisory Council; National Steering Committee on Corporate Wrongdoing; Antarctic Animal Ethics Committee; Advisory Panel on the Marketing in Australia of Infant Formula; High Speed Rail Advisory Group; Maritime Workforce Development Forum; Advisory Panel on Positive Ageing; Insurance Reform Advisory Group; and the National Housing Supply Council.

On Friday, the head of the advisory panel on positive ageing, Everald Compton, said his group had only six months of important work to go - and was not expensive.

"A few hundred thousand dollars a year, a couple of hundred thousand I think it is," he told ABC Radio. "We run a lean, mean operation. We don't go anywhere that we don't have to. We're not causing a financial disturbance in the government."

Mr Compton said that the group was on brink of presenting government with a blueprint on the legislative and financial changes that were needed over the next 25 years to turn ageing "into an asset rather than a liability".

"I find it a little hard to understand why, when we're so close to finishing something that we've had some years of work in, that it's chopped off and that the government does not appear to want a report on how ageing is going to hit Australia."

On Friday, Mr Abbott denied that his government was responsible for any potential job cuts at CSIRO.

"We haven't made any cutbacks to the CSIRO. The management of the CSIRO and the employment of staff inside the CSIRO and the management of contractors for the CSIRO is a matter for the CSIRO itself," he said.

At the CSIRO, staff leaders fronted their bosses on Thursday, demanding answers on the fate of the workers on contracts, which can often last up to 24 months.

CSIRO has an unusually high proportion of “non-ongoings” with 990 “term” workers and about 440 casual staff among its 6500 headcount.

"It's going to be a huge problem," said one staff member, who wanted to remain anonymous.

Staff were told last week of the decision, which will hit the organisation's 11 research divisions and 11 national research flagships, as well as critical support for frontline scientists.

In an email to staff, CSIRO chief executive Megan Clarke said: "I announce an immediate recruitment freeze covering the following: External recruitment; and, entering into any new, or extending existing term or contract employment arrangements."

Catriona Jackson, the chief executive of Science and Technology Australia, the peak lobby for the nation's scientists, said she was "concerned that cuts to the public service may fall disproportionately on scientists".

West Australian federal Liberal Dennis Jensen, himself a former research scientist at CSIRO, said the suggestion that the government had an anti-science bias was incorrect.

But he admitted the failure to have a dedicated science minister worried him.

"That does concern me," he said.

"If somebody wanted to raise a concern from one of the Cooperative Research Centres, often a bridge between academia and industry, then who would they write to? Do they write to the education minister or the industry minister, I think that is the major problem, that the focus and drive of a single minister is lost."

Assistant Treasurer Arthur Sinodinos told Sky News on Friday that only 500-600 support staff could go at the CSIRO but argued the new government needed to be able to choose where it allocated and prioritised resources.

''The new government has to have a capacity to do that,'' he said.

A CSIRO spokesman said the number of jobs under threat had been exaggerated by the staff association.

The spokesman said that no more than 550 casual and “term” workers were facing contract renewals this financial year.

CSIRO's executive and senior staff have been frantically seeking explanations from government as to how the edict is to be interpreted.

Labor has come out swinging against the cuts.

Acting Labor leader Tanya Plibersek told reporters in Sydney that its CSIRO research had a real impact on the choices and decisions that Australians made, pointing to its famous Wellbeing Diet.

She added that it also did important research underpinning industry developments and scientific breakthroughs.

Finance spokesman Tony Burke labelled both moves as an ''unprecedented attack on expert opinion''.

''Not only has Prime Minister Abbott refused to appoint a Science Minister, he has now fired a quarter of the nation’s CSIRO scientists and researchers – endangering Australia’s future as a smart, innovative nation,'' Mr Burke said in a statement.

Labor's spokesman for the environment, climate change and water, Mark Butler, said he wasn't surprised that scientists were being sacked by the government, say Mr Abbott does not respect scientists' work, particulary on climate change.

''And I don't think it's a coincidence that the experts being sacked by this government have previously pointed out the serious flaws in the Coalition's direct action con,'' Mr Butler said.

''If the government consulted independent scientists and researchers instead of Wikipedia, they would know their direct action policy will do nothing to tackle pollution and will end up costing households more.

''The government is sacking the experts and shutting out anyone who doesn't agree with them. It's a disgraceful act.''

fairfax subscriptions

881 comments

  • in 1633 the inquisition found Galileo "gravely suspect of heresy", sentencing him to indefinite imprisonment. This was subsequently commuted to house arrest, under which he remained for the rest of his life.

    ;;;;;;;later

    Many religions and politicians ban stem cell research.

    some Politicians and media organisaitons denounce climate change

    An Abbott slashes Science at CSIRO

    The world is NOT flat, we do not need another Dark Ages.

    Commenter
    stoney
    Date and time
    November 08, 2013, 6:44AM
    • What do you expect from a mob of dolts?

      Commenter
      n720ute
      Location
      North Coast NSW
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:02AM
    • Even Hilter believed in science.

      Commenter
      Eggbert47
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:05AM
    • How is anyone surprised by this? Everyone knew the dark ages was just around the corner if this guy was elected. No shock right? So far we have jumped back in time. I didn't believe in time travel but now I do. Welcome to the 1900's. (laughing stock to the world)

      Commenter
      The Other Guy1
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:12AM
    • And the pattern emerges . . . never believe what coalition governments say . . observe what the do and dont forget.
      Shackling the public service is a permanent conservative agenda . . apparently if its not business its not important and this includes regulators that protect consumers.

      Commenter
      Danger Ranger
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:14AM
    • Exactly what Rupert recommended. Who woulda thought?

      Commenter
      Oldfootyhead
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:19AM
    • The dumbing down of Australia. Well I suppose if you want to create an elite class, this is where you start.

      Commenter
      Jendy
      Location
      Hornsby
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:31AM
    • Research often contradicts faith and is therefore dangerous to the quaint European equivalent of the dream time, but I suspect his real motive is that they stand to provide facts about the activities of the mining, fishing and carbon based industries.

      Tony hates facts that do not suit his retirement fund and the retirement funds of his close associates. If he think removing information will remove obstacles then he is wrong, I am looking for the Greenpeace brochure now.

      Commenter
      Bruce
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:38AM
    • "..galileo.." "..The world is NOT flat.." "Dark Ages"

      It's an urban myth that people in the middle ages thought the earth was flat, and it certainly wasn't a feature of the Galileo affair.

      Commenter
      John
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:47AM
    • Thank you for using Galileo in the right context - too often Galileo is used by anti-science fiends to show they are not only ignorant of science, but history.

      Commenter
      ST
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      November 08, 2013, 7:52AM

More comments

Comments are now closed

Related Coverage

CSIRO cuts will impact Australia's ability to combat deadly bushfires: staff

Job cuts at Australia's frontline science agency will hurt the nation's ability to combat the threat of deadly bushfires, according to CSIRO staff.

Amanda Rishworth, campaigning in Adelaide's southern suburbs. She is the  ALP candidate for  marginal seat of Kingston. Friday 7th of September 2007. THE AGE INSIGHT Picture by David Mariuz. Science cuts savaged

Labor MP Amanda Rishworth says the Abbott government is behaving as though 'they know it all' with cuts to the CSIRO and the scrapping of advisory panels.

Coalition turns back on UN climate summit

Australia will not be represented by an senior elected member of the Abbott government at next week's major round of international climate change negotiations starting Monday in Warsaw.

Watchdog warns business on power cheating

The head of Australia's consumer watchdog insists that electricity bills should drop quickly after the repeal of the carbon tax - warning businesses not to claim they are unable to pass on the full savings to consumers.

Abbott government announces $522m in research projects

The Abbott government will award $522 million to 1177 new research projects including studies on eruptive bushfires, what factors influence indigenous sporting performance and how to reduce incorrect disease diagnosis.

Related Coverage

Featured advertisers

Special offers

Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo