JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

UN representatives criticise Abbott government's boat tow-back policy

Date

Michael Bachelard, Sarah Whyte

Australian customs officials and navy personnel escort asylum seekers onto Christmas Island on August 21, 2013. It has been four months since the last 'successful' people smuggling venture, Immigration Minister Scott Morrison says.

Australian customs officials and navy personnel escort asylum seekers onto Christmas Island on August 21, 2013. It has been four months since the last 'successful' people smuggling venture, Immigration Minister Scott Morrison says. Photo: Reuters

United Nations representatives have joined the criticism of the Abbott government's boat tow-back policy and called on Australia to process asylum seekers who reach Australian waters instead of returning them to Indonesia.

But Immigration Minister Scott Morrison has refused to change tack, saying he "completely disagrees" because the “policy is working”.

The “policy is working” ... Immigration Minister Scott Morrison has defended the Australian government's tow-back policy on asylum seeker boats.

The “policy is working” ... Immigration Minister Scott Morrison has defended the Australian government's tow-back policy on asylum seeker boats. Photo: Andrew Meares

The regional head of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees also revealed that Australia has refused to provide information to its inquiry about three asylum seekers who claim they had their hands deliberately burned during a tow-back mission in January.

And UNHCR senior regional protection adviser Tom Vargas criticised Australia’s proposal to send refugees to Cambodia, saying it was “not in the spirit of resettlement”.

The frank broad critique come after a two-day conference in Jakarta, attended by Australia’s deputy ambassador to Indonesia David Engel and representatives of 14 other countries, to discuss the protection of refugees in the region.

Critical of Australia's tow-back policy ... James Lynch (front, third from left), Regional Representative of the UNHCR for South East Asia Region shakes hands with Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa.

Critical of Australia's tow-back policy ... James Lynch (front, third from left), Regional Representative of the UNHCR for South East Asia Region shakes hands with Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa. Photo: AFP

UNHCR regional coordinator James Lynch said that with millions of people displaced around the world, solutions engineered by single countries alone would only work temporarily.

Mr Lynch said he understood the Australian government was worried about loss of life at sea, criminality in the people smuggling trade and economic migration dressed up as asylum seeking.

However, he said Australia’s policy of sending boat arrivals to Papua New Guinea or Nauru, and of returning boats to Indonesia even if people had entered Australian water or landed on Australian territory (as happened in a number of recent tow-backs) are against the refugee convention.

“If someone arrived in Australian waters, we’d expect as a requirement of the refugee convention that they be allowed to disembark and have access to asylum procedures … We’d expect [Australia] to honour their obligations,” Mr Lynch said.

Mr Vargas said: “If every state in the region decides they’ll close the door, then there will be nowhere safe for people to go.”

But the Immigration Minister was unmoved.

"I completely disagree," Scott Morrison told Sky News on Wednesday morning. "I'm not surprised, they have always opposed our turn-back policy.

"But I'll tell what Australia's national shame was when it comes to this issue, almost 1200 people dead," he said. "That's national shame. That's the regional shame."

Mr Lynch conceded that there had been no increase in asylum seeker numbers seen in either Thailand or Malaysia as a result of Operation Sovereign Borders.

The Jakarta office of the UNHCR has previously said the number of new people registering with them has dropped from 100 per day to 100 per week since Operation Sovereign Borders began.

Only 2 per cent of applicants now fail to appear for a second appointment — down from 50 per cent last year, when many were getting on boats rather than waiting for resettlement through the UN.

Mr Lynch said his organisation had written to Australia seeking information about allegations dating from January that three asylum seekers on board a wooden boat being turned back had their hands deliberately burned by sailors working for Operation Sovereign Borders.

The response from Australia had been: “We don’t need to do an investigation because we’ve done nothing wrong,” Mr Lynch said.

The UN is also yet to receive requested information from Australia about its proposal, outlined in February, to resettle refugees in Cambodia.

“From our point of view, resettlement is looking for durable solutions for refugees … who have had to flee their homes,” Mr Vargas said.

“A real solution is not to send them to a country that is still recovering from a horrible civil war that killed millions of its people … It’s not in the spirit of resettlement as far as I can tell”.

Opposition immigration spokesman Richard Marles said unilateralism was not meant to be a "long term sustainable answer in the flow of people coming by boat to Australia".

"We are worried about what this means in the context of our relationship with Indonesia in circumstances where they do not agree with this policy," Mr Marles said.

A spokesperson for Mr Morrison said on Tuesday that “the test of effectiveness for any policy, and for ongoing support of the Australian government, is whether that policy is working.

“After four months without a single successful people smuggling venture to Australia, and even longer since anyone has perished at sea on such ventures, the Coalition's strong border protection policies are clearly working … It is also pleasing to see that the inflow to Indonesia and the flow through from Malaysia has also been reduced, demonstrating that the Australian Government's strong stand is also benefiting the region.

“Australia will continue to employ the policies that have been so effective under Operation Sovereign Borders. Any venture seeking to enter Australia illegally will be met with the same measures that have prevented other such attempts to date.”

The conference was opened on Monday by the Indonesian foreign minister, Marty Natalegawa, who launched a veiled attack on Australian policy, saying the region should be looking at “shared responsibility" for the irregular movement of people, "not shifting responsibility”.

The rebuke from the UN has followed the publication of explosive footage by Fairfax Media showing Manus Island security guards attacking asylum seekers 24 hours before Iranian Reza Barati was killed.

Mr Morrison said the footage should be turned over to the independent investigation led by retired public servant chief Robert Cornall.

"I would say to anyone who has information of that nature: that's the place for it to be investigated," Mr Morrison said. "I want to get to the bottom of this. I want to make sure I know exactly what has happened."  

Follow us on Twitter

423 comments

  • This would be in one ear and out the other to the likes of Abbott and Morrison, staying in government is their number one priority.

    Commenter
    Crowey
    Location
    QLD THE POLICE STATE.
    Date and time
    April 23, 2014, 7:02AM
    • Actually a 'real solution' as the UN pointed out would be for them, the UN, to do their jobs properly in the first place so people didn't feel the need to flee their own countries in the first place. That is what we give them money and support for. Not junkets and talk fests.

      Commenter
      J Walker
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:01AM
    • This is exactly why Australians should be very cautious about The Greens ambitions to out source our national sovereignty to UN NGO's.

      In the end foreign bureaucrat s will make decisions best left to our elected representatives.

      Commenter
      SteveH.
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:03AM
    • @ Crowley. Your comment suggests that most Australians support the tow back policy and that's why the Liberal Govt. will keep doing it so they will be elected next election.

      Commenter
      Kingstondude
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:20AM
    • @SteveH - 'This is exactly why Australians should be very cautious about The Greens ambitions to out source our national sovereignty to UN NGO's.' Yes, Steve, we should be very cautious indeed - the UN might actually make criticisms of our vicious policies. Can't have that!
      @ J Walker - once again, a comment that indicates you know more than the rest of the world. You must be a very learned man. Have you ever talked to an asylum seeker?

      Commenter
      Lilian
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:32AM
    • This is one area where the government is making progress. There has been an increase in legal migrants and refugees from Sri Lanka but a decrease in boat people. That is a real solution and a sensible one too.

      Commenter
      Good Logic
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:39AM
    • what do you expect from the UN, they are only lowly but very overpaid public servants, who love parties, but don't want to get their hands dirty.

      The UN is worse than useless. Close it down & save billions a year.

      Commenter
      hurry up & slow down
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:45AM
    • If the existing refugees in detention centres were processed and the boats stopped coming, would those that currently oppose the existing policies then accept they are a good solution, particularly given the policies have no bearing on the quota of refugees we accept. If not, what are your objections?

      Commenter
      Flanders
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:45AM
    • Huh? The hypocrisy of the UN is breathtaking. Where was the UN when hundreds of people were drowning at sea? The lives saved alone vindicates the Australian Governments actions. Why doesn't anyone ever ask why the UN never does their job? All they do is sit on high spouting out various criticisms rather than actually doing something.

      Commenter
      Luke
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 8:55AM
    • Crowey, your thought-free, kneejerk partisan reaction shows why Labor is so out of tune with everyday Australians. In a few short months the Australian government has done what they promised. Three short words: Stop The Boats. Hundreds of lives have been saved by this simple policy. Most now realise that the UN is simply a bunch of bureaucrats pontificating about this or that and actually have never really done anything concrete to assist the boat situation. Hard decisions like these are best left to elected politicians directly answerable to the electorate rather than some ineffective, unnamed untouchable who has a job for life.

      Commenter
      l russell
      Date and time
      April 23, 2014, 9:00AM

More comments

Comments are now closed

Related Coverage

Scott Morrison dismisses UN criticism of boat turn-backs

The immigration minister Scott Morrison has defended his government's controversial boat turn-back policy after it was heavily criticised by the United Nations, saying that he was "not surprised" by their opposition.

Sleepless nights until the Manus nightmare ends

In my day job in the construction industry, I specialise in alternative dispute resolution in the thriving gas pipeline sector in Western Australia. By night though, I get to follow my true passion as a human rights advocate.

Reza Barati death: Papua New Guinea nationals attacked asylum seekers on Manus Island

PNG nationals employed as security guards at the Manus Island detention centre turned violently on the asylum seekers more than 24 hours before Iranian Reza Barati died in a night of shocking violence, new footage obtained by Fairfax Media shows.

Labor and Greens call for report on Manus violence to be released immediately

Labor and the Greens have called for the immediate release of the federal government's report into the fatal violence on Manus Island after graphic images surfaced showing Papua New Guinea guards attacking asylum seekers.

Cambodia resettlement deal for asylum seekers moves closer

Australia is moving closer to a Cambodia solution as the Immigration Minister is pushing to expand his regional resettlement "club" despite poor social and economic conditions in the Pacific region.

Related Coverage

Featured advertisers

Special offers

Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo