JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Sacrifice Redfern's grunge at your peril

Date

Sydney Morning Herald columnist, author, architecture critic and essayist

View more articles from Elizabeth Farrelly

<i>Illustration: Edd Aragon</i>

Illustration: Edd Aragon

On Anzac Day we stopped in Cullen Bullen for lunch, if lunch is not too kind a term for a toastie that seemed to be made of melted-down prostheses. A local, formerly of Campbelltown, heard we were from Redfern.

''Which part of Redfern?'' he wanted to know.

The subtext was clear enough; there is a good part and a bad one. You expect that sort of thing from country NSW. What did surprise me was hearing similar sentiments from SBS newsreader Ricardo Goncalves, who more or less argued in print the other day that Redfern should be cut in half.

In Goncalves's plan the good half of Redfern - his half, naturally, the eastern half - would be rebadged South Dowling. The bad half would quarantine all the public housing, rental shackery, old-style walk-ups, elderly first-generation immigrants and The Block. Oh, and quite a few ratbag professionals in their $1.5 million terraces. And me.

What's wrong with being thought to live in Redfern? Why, although the hipsters flock here nightly, do my children's east-burb friends say they're not allowed to catch buses here?

The same reason those teenagers riding their car onto a Kings Cross footpath were first said to be from Redfern, when in fact they were from Mount Druitt. Redfern has become a metaphor for all kinds of social dysfunction, and a euphemism for The Block.

Mr Goncalves's friends, boldly visiting him at home (in his shiny security residence), assure him that his part of Redfern, with its high-rise apartments, new shopping centres and cafes ''has a totally different feel, character and look. It's not the same suburb.'' Damn right. Real estate agents agree.

Perhaps what Redfern needs is a wall to keep all the clean, shiny people from polluting us grubby old poor ones.

For in truth, it's not just The Block. There are black people and poor people (not necessarily the same thing) and old people and ratbag professionals strewn throughout Redfern, as well as Waterloo, Surry Hills - and indeed, Campbelltown. To my mind, this is fine.

What's not fine - as the failures of modern planning so catastrophically showed - is to separate cities out into constituent parts. A city is not about separation, but about mix. And this mixing - this intricate urban dance of which citizens partake - enriches not just the poorer ingredients, but us all.

Multiculturalism has its flaws, god knows. But this simple, pluralist message has informed the last 50 years of thinking across every discipline from urbanism to anthropology, from fine arts to physics. Surprising, then, to hear this secessionist rhetoric from a reporter for Australia's only expressly multicultural TV station, even if the rest of the Sunday tabloid story did smell of a beat-up.

I've lived in Redfern 14 years. It's been a period of rapid gentrification, in which I'm clearly implicated - not only as a resident but as a paid-up member of the global reclaim-the-city push. I have evangelised urbanism for 20 years, as writer, academic and local politician, for reasons cultural, environmental and aesthetic. I'm not about to back down now.

And these oldies are part of what I loved. I'm sorry to see them go, the toothless drunks, the heaving hookers, the foetal alcohol boys and the rooming-house ladies. There was one lot - a drug dynasty specialising in rooftop intimidation and barbarous back-lane bonfires - that I was happy to see locked up. Broadly, though, these old-school Redfernites furnish our streets with a warmth and affection to which the hipsters and designerati contribute little.

As old Redfern has dwindled, it's been a standing joke with us how yuppies and real estate types yearn to classify our place as ''Redfern East'' when it's clearly plain old Redfern. When, equally clearly, plain old Redfern is vastly more real and vivid and interesting and, well, urban, than the brash shiny bit.

In a small way, of course, each of us changes the neighbourhood where we live. But it should still be understood that when you move in you take a city on its terms, not yours. Just as it's bad form for empty-nesters to move from Turramurra or Ku-ring-gai then start whingeing about late night noise, it's bad form to move into a city centre then whinge about the existing community because you somehow see it as lowering the tone, especially when it's the oldest urban indigenous community in the country. Very bad form indeed.

The Block is largely now a ghost-town. Over a decade, virtually all its 62 houses have been demolished by the Aboriginal Housing Company to whom the Whitlam government deeded them in 1973.

The idea is to redevelop.

A first scheme was approved by planning minister Kristina Keneally in 2006; a revised and enlarged scheme was submitted late last year, under the dreaded Part 3A, and awaits decision.

There were a few public submissions, mostly objecting to the height increase from three storeys to (maximum) six. Objectors noted incongruence with the two-storeyed environs. They worried about traffic generation and that the new buildings would overshadow their solar panels (an interesting new issue for planners; I see compensation coming). Some argued against designating the housing specifically for Aboriginal people, others against allowing commercial components that are not for Aborigines.

But if it's such new high-rise developments and shopping centres that are lifting Redfern East into Redfern Heights (where's Dame Edna when you need her?), how can the same be banned from The Block? Especially since the local RSL, two blocks away, is just now completing its Frank Sartor-approved tower of 20 storeys.

Twenty storeys would not suit The Block - especially not since they share the RSL's architect, Nordon Jago. But Moore Park Gardens (over in Redfern east) shows how height can be achieved with grace and street-making charm.

Redfern is rightly a metaphor - for the beating black heart at the centre of Australia's oldest city and for authentic urban grunge. This we sacrifice at our peril.

twitter Follow the National Times on Twitter: @NationalTimesAU


39 comments

  • It seems to be OK to knock 'hipsters', but is this just another form of generationalism by baby boomer journalists?

    Commenter
    hygienic_lily
    Location
    Newcastle
    Date and time
    May 03, 2012, 7:55AM
    • Good on you for calling it! The racist term East Redfern is just another way of saying "we are as far away from the Block/black fellas as we can get". And the irony is that the inhabitants of the towers in Waterloo cause more trouble anyway.

      The new RSL could be a nightmare but the old one wasnt the Ritz either. It is huge- cant wait to see how many pokies they will cram in there. But I just cant believe the new building (Dei something)- who would want an apartment in the middle of a wind tunnel and with another high rise apartment block (Urba) being built right next to it.

      Last thing I wanted to say is that the best thing about Redfern in the 5 years that I have lived there is that it is bogan free! And happy hour at Railz at 10 am on a Saturday- beat that Vacluse!

      Commenter
      James
      Location
      Redfern
      Date and time
      May 03, 2012, 7:56AM
      • So the eastern half of Redfern is the nice part, the recommendation of a name change, presumably by real estate agents as well as Mr. Goncalve is not unusual. How about Redfern Heights, that should have the punters rushing to buy.

        Commenter
        comment
        Date and time
        May 03, 2012, 8:36AM
        • What about Redfern Grove? That should suit the yuppies and Meriton.

          Commenter
          5612
          Date and time
          May 03, 2012, 10:10AM
      • Oh Liza dear Liza,
        Aks the architexts bout captol gains vs captol punshment.
        He don't wanna stay 'ere!
        Makem money dats all.
        Quik buck.

        Commenter
        Dino not to be confused with
        Location
        suburban utopia
        Date and time
        May 03, 2012, 8:40AM
        • My sympathy, Elizabeth. Reminds me of the passengers directing me towards Surry Hills and naming a street south of Cleveland St., some of them visiting there and when I politely mentioned that it was Redfern they replied - "oh no, my friends live in Surry Hills, they told me so". Check the post code. The best one I recall was - "Take me to Phillip St., Surry Hills". Huh? There is none but I proceeded towards the one I knew, dividing Redfern from Waterloo. That's where he lived, on the southern side of Phillip St.

          Commenter
          Ex-Cabbie
          Location
          Campsie
          Date and time
          May 03, 2012, 8:52AM
          • Redfern has one of the highest crime rates in NSW. I don't really get why Farrelly thinks this is a positive thing?

            Commenter
            lacebug
            Date and time
            May 03, 2012, 8:54AM
            • I live in Moore Park Gardens and as an apartment complex, it i amazing! The apartments are sound, the gounds are landscaped and beautiful and it has a great community vibe about it. These apartments, (despite being built over a decade before the Meriton mess that now infests most of redfern/waterloo) are still more desirable than Harry's lego blocks... Do it right!!

              Oh, and i too like redferns rough side, i just wouldnt want to live in it...

              Commenter
              Daniel
              Location
              Sydney
              Date and time
              May 03, 2012, 9:03AM
              • Agree Daniel. I also live in MPG (12 years). Happy to say I live in Redfern. Never had problems with personal safety. I like the diversity.

                Commenter
                Screengem
                Location
                Sydney
                Date and time
                May 03, 2012, 10:04AM
            • I recently had the pleasure of an unusual passenger from St. Vincent hospital. He was three weeks into a lung transplant and living far away was offered a housing commision abode in Redfern to complete his rehabilitation visits in Darlo.
              We picked up the keys and feeling vulnerable he asked me to come inside to inspect the place.
              Naturally we found a bunch of junkies hanging around the entrance. Broken lives as he called it. On our way back down the lift was full of smoke, my passenger holding his breathing for 10 floors for us to be greeted with another bunch of junkies in the foyer.
              Needless to say, my poor passenger asked me to drive back to NSW housing to hand back the keys.

              Bit of a long story Liz, but it hits the nail right on the head when it comes to living in Redfern. I have serviced this suburb for far longer than you have lived there and seen many changes, including an influx of yuppies who saw Redfern as the last cheap bastion into the inner City housing market.
              But the dysfunction that plaques this suburb is more evident then anywhere else. Do yourself a favour and cruise through Moorehead, Walker, Pitt and George street on pension day and see what you find.

              The only thing that will safe Redfern is the dislocation of people like the ones I described above, and best of luck to the suburbs they are moved on to.

              Commenter
              Rainer the cabbie
              Location
              Darlo
              Date and time
              May 03, 2012, 9:17AM

              More comments

              Comments are now closed
              Featured advertisers

              Special offers

              Credit card, savings and loan rates by Mozo