JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

All diet customers are losing is their dignity, possums

Date

Kasey Edwards

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Video will begin in 5 seconds.

Video settings

Please Log in to update your video settings

Dame Edna cakes it off

Barry Humphries talks about himself and Dame Edna Everage becoming ambassadors for Jenny Craig.

PT0M0S 620 349

It's hard not to laugh at Jenny Craig's latest attempt to convince us to buy its products.

In the past week, as foreshadowed in the Sydney Morning Herald's PS column last month, the weight loss giant has launched an advertising campaign featuring Dame Edna.

But on this occasion it's not the comic genius of Barry Humphries that is so hilarious. The joke is on Jenny.

The face of Jenny Craig's new advertising campaign ... Dame Edna.

The face of Jenny Craig's new advertising campaign ... Dame Edna.

After a succession of PR disasters with its female celebrity weight loss ambassadors, it seems the Jenny Craig company - owned by Nestle´, the same company that makes Kit Kats, Life Savers, and Drumstick ice creams - has taken a break from using women to promote its brand and has resorted to using a man pretending to be a woman.

Last August, the actress Magda Szubanski and Jenny Craig parted ways awkwardly. She no longer gets a mention in the Friends of Jenny section on its website.

Days later, MasterChef Julie Goodwin turned down a potentially lucrative offer. ''There are more important things going on in the world than losing a few kilograms … And besides, I'm happy with how I am,'' Goodwin said. Then, in December, the radio personality and magazine columnist Chrissie Swan declined to renew her contract with the company after having her second child.

Echoing Goodwin, she wrote in her Sunday Life column, ''I'm overweight and happy''. This is tantamount to heresy to the high priests of weight loss, in whose litany the equation ''fat = miserable'' is an article of faith.

Last month, Jenny Craig hit the headlines again when the company's CEO, Amy Smith, was invited to speak at the Alliance of Girls Schools annual conference, provoking super-sized servings of outrage.

Critics savaged the decision to invite the head of a company that thrives on fuelling body insecurity to a conference attended by educators of girls.

But perhaps we're being too cynical and too harsh on poor old Jenny. She's only trying to help, right? After all, look how well it turned out for US actor Kirstie Alley, who is now better known for yo-yo dieting than for her glory days in Cheers and Look Who's Talking.

The problem, of course, lies not with any of these weight loss ambassadors. It lies with the product. If there is one clear and unambiguous message from this list of celebrity ambassadorships gone awry, it's that Jenny Craig and products like it do not work in the long term.

It doesn't work if you're a celebrity. And it doesn't work if you're just an average Kath, Kim or Sharon.

Fifty years of scientific research tells us that only 5 per cent of people can maintain their weight loss from dieting. Yes, there are some success stories, but for every five people who succeed, 95 people fail.

With such damning rates it is extraordinary that we still blame individuals for ''failing'' at weight loss programs rather than accusing the diet companies of selling snake oil. Can you imagine buying any other product with a 95 per cent failure rate and then blaming yourself when it didn't deliver on its promise?

A 2008 Monash University study found participants blamed themselves for being unable to maintain their weight loss or ''stick'' to diets even though they also said that they were ''seduced'' by the consultants' ''spiel''. Some said the expense and the time they would need to be on the program to lose a substantial amount of weight was unrealistic.

More shocking is evidence that some diet companies know their product doesn't work. In her book Bodies, for example, the British psychotherapist Susie Orbach recounts a story in which a former manager of WeightWatchers in Britain said she was dismayed at how unsuccessful the company was in helping people to keep the weight off. Orbach notes that the failure of these products shouldn't surprise us. After all, if they were truly effective, it would be disastrous for the companies' bottom lines. ''Their profitability depends upon failure and their programs ensure that failure happens.''

It's very hard to find any independently verified data about success rates. A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association in 2010 found 92 per cent of women stayed with the Jenny Craig program and lost more weight than those without it, but the research was funded by the company, which also provided packaged foods and counselling free to study participants - hardly a real world test.

Given such ''evidence'', it's no surprise diet companies resort to a stream of celebrity ambassadors to sell the fantasy that their tailored eating and exercise plans are a path to permanent weight loss and happiness.

With such a poor industry record, and in the wake of a series of public relations disasters, it's perhaps fitting that the market leader is now putting its hopes in a brilliant comic actor who gets about in drag.

Good luck to you, possum. With Jenny Craig's success rate, you're going to need it.

Kasey Edwards is the author of Thirty-Something and the Clock is Ticking (Random House) and the forthcoming Kill the Fat Girl: A Girl's Own Manual to breaking free of bad body image and living a full life.

www.kaseyedwards.com

twitter Follow the National Times on Twitter: @NationalTimesAU


233 comments

  • Of course Jenny Craig's programs don't work! They and all the other weight-loss industries are based on the faulty and deliberately misleading science pioneered by Ancel Keys!

    Ditch sugar and abandon processed seed oils. That's how you lose weight. See David Gillespie's books for more on why.

    Commenter
    staticsan
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    April 30, 2012, 7:40AM
    • Nice to see this information is spreading! Brilliant book.
      Just under 3 weeks off sugar, and I've lost 2 kilos. Waiting for the sugar addiction to go completely, then I'll start on the seed oils. Hot chips are much harder to give up than chocolate.

      Just like nicotine patches/gum etc, how can anyone believe a company like Jenny Craig when they make MORE money from your failure?? Common sense people!

      Commenter
      aro
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 9:15AM
    • "Jenny Craig's miracle cure doesn't work. Here, buy David Gillespie's miracle cure instead".

      Hilarious

      Commenter
      kate
      Location
      sydney
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 9:21AM
    • Kate, you don't have to spend a single cent to follow David Gillespie's advice. "If it tastes sweet, don't eat it."
      11 kilos gone, cravings, and I'm eating anything I like.

      Commenter
      Joe
      Location
      Bathurst
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:10AM
    • "Don't listen to Jenny Craig and their fad diets!! Listen to David Gillespie and his fad diet!!!"

      Eat less. Move more. Lose weight. End of story.

      The only reason Jenny Craig (or any eating program that simply promotes portion control and healthy eating) doesn't work for most people is because, shock horror, most people who try it are fat lazy slobs who return to their fat lazy slob lifestyles.

      As to the "I'd rather be fat and happy" brigade.... stop and think about how many fat 70 year olds you've seen about. I guarantee its lower than the amount of 70 year old smokers.

      Commenter
      Andrew
      Location
      Caringbah
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:10AM
    • I haven't heard so I'm only guessing that maybe sugar is the reason why people are big these days. We are all 10 or 20% bigger than 100 years ago and I can't think of anything else that's altered so much in diets.
      Are all diets a crock, well maybe, maybe what we all need is more exercise and more reasons and opportunities for exercise.

      Commenter
      .bg
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:16AM
    • I lost 25kg by changing my diet to meat and veg. You don't need some new miracle diet, you just need old fashioned healthy food.

      Commenter
      John
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:18AM
    • @kate...agreed. It amazes me that people don't see the irony in their comments.

      No fad diet will work long term yet people are always looking for the quick fix, miracle cure that will tell them the one thing they NEED to do so they can live happily ever after.
      Apparently the old adage of "everything in moderation", including regular exercise is too much like hard work so it's easier to read a book and blame one food group for their weight problem.

      Whenever someone tells me they're about to start a fad diet, one question I ask is "would you put your child on it?".
      If not, why not? If it's not healthy for them, why is it healthy for you?

      Commenter
      Paddy_Irish_Girl
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:31AM
    • @ .bg: household purchases of sugar have plummeted since the fifties. I grew up with a diet absolutely loaded with sugar. We had sugar on cornflakes, sugar in milo, dessert every single night, frequently home preserved fruit loaded with sugar.

      The difference now is the household purchase of sugar is low, but the 'average' consumption of sugar is much higher due to processed foods.

      Commenter
      bornagirl
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:34AM
    • Let's see: a lot of people lose weight using Weightwatchers, Jenny Craig (etc), but then can't keep it off because they don't have the discipline and willpower....and we are blaming the weight loss companies ??? So typical of where we are at as a society. If I'm fat because I can't stick to a succesful program, then it is a diet company's fault, even though they DID help me lose weight at one point...

      Commenter
      Aussie Expat
      Location
      Hong Kong
      Date and time
      April 30, 2012, 10:39AM

More comments

Comments are now closed
Featured advertisers