JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Method to alternative medicine madness

Date

Luke Malone

Traditional treatment ... evidence of cupping therapy on the back of Chinese Olympic swimmer Wang Qun at the 2008 Beijing Olympics.

Traditional treatment ... evidence of cupping therapy on the back of Chinese Olympic swimmer Wang Qun at the 2008 Beijing Olympics. Photo: AFP

We've all got one, that friend or work colleague who waxes lyrical about the benefits of alternative treatments every time someone presents with a physical ailment or concern. From olive leaf extract and Echinacea when you've got the sniffles to bathing arthritic joints in diluted kerosene or vinegar, they prefer home remedies to a pharmaceutical solution.

And it's not just illness that can be prevented or cured with natural therapies. These are usually the same people who recommend lemon and egg facials and replacing your conditioner with olive oil in a bid to circumnavigate the costs and empty promises offered by cosmetic companies.

While it can be easy to discount these suggestions as fanciful – or downright disgusting – Dr Brent Bauer, director of the Complementary and Integrative Medicine Program at the world-renowned Mayo Clinic, says they shouldn't be instantly dismissed.

"We in conventional medicine have done a great job in many regards – wiping out polio, developing antibiotics for infections that once killed millions, et cetera," he said. "But where conventional medicine hasn't had as many successes or cures, such as arthritis, fibromyalgia, anxiety, and so in, it shouldn't be surprising that folks would start looking for other options."

Though he warns that an individual should practise caution when embarking on any form of alternative therapy, when used in conjunction with proven conventional solutions they can sometimes prove to be quite effective.

"Of course, the internet opens up a world of choices – some safe and effective, and some silly or dangerous. The key is to separate the two," he added. "Good research has shown the benefits of acupuncture, massage and meditation, and we offer all of these to our patients at Mayo Clinic. Not as a replacement to their conventional care but as a complement. We integrate the best of both worlds and refer to that combined approach as integrative medicine."

But, outside of a hospital setting how do you differentiate between those that work and those that are little more than unfounded and potentially harmful opinions whose prolonged existence have given them false credence?

This is especially important when it comes to the more radical forms of alternative medicine and beauty treatments. From leeches and Reiki to urine therapy, here is an informed take on the methods that work and warnings against those that might do you more harm than good.

Leeches

Sometimes used to relieve congestion of blood and serum from around a wound – for example, after a finger is reattached – the application of leeches as a viable medical option gained speed when the US Food and Drug Administration officially approved their use in 2004.

But Dr. Danforn Lim, associate lecturer of medicine at the University of New South Wales, remains unconvinced and warns against home use on the grounds that they can cause infection and inflammation.

"Currently there is nil evidence to suggest that live leeches have any health benefits to treat any disease," he said. "However, use of live leeches can easily cause various infections through the microorganism Aeromonas... Aeromonas species cause a wide spectrum of disease syndromes among warm- and cold-blooded animals, including fish, reptiles, amphibians, mammals, and humans."

Reiki

Founded in Japan in 1922, the practice of Reiki relies upon the belief of an invisible energy that is transmitted from healer to patient through intention. Positive energy is transferred by placing the hands on particular parts of the patient's body with the aim of restoring imbalances and promoting healing.

"Reiki practitioners purport to be able to affect health of another individual by moving that person's energy field. Because these fields cannot be measured by scientific instruments, that premise has always been difficult for most scientists and doctors to accept," said Bauer. "The fact that there is a relatively small amount of research on Reiki compared to things like acupuncture doesn't help. But what does tend to come through in most of the studies is the fact that patients report stress reduction. Given the fact that reducing stress is probably helpful regardless of the condition or disease, the final word on Reiki's role in health promotion remains to be determined."

Cupping

Another mainstay of Eastern medicine, albeit one with a far richer history, is cupping. An ancient form of alternative medicine usually associated with China – though records indicate it was first practised by Egyptians as far back as 3000 B.C. – cups are placed on key parts of the body and heated to form a suction effect. It's believed that this helps mobilise blood flow, which, in turn, promotes healing.

"The theory about cupping is... [that] it can help promote the qi flow of the meridians. Thus, reduce the pain within that region," said Lim. "Despite the fact that China has performed a large number of studies in cupping many have methodological flaws. Cupping may have potential therapeutic effect on pain syndrome management but it is beyond doubt that we need a larger scale of population research study to elicit its true effects."

Placenta

The placenta plays an important role in many cultures. The Māori and Navajo traditionally buried it to highlight the human connection to the earth, and it is eaten throughout many parts of the world. But the extract of animal placenta – usually sheep – is also used in hair and skin treatments and there are unverified reports of it being injected directly into the body to heal damaged muscle or connective tissue.

"Sheep's placenta have been used in many cosmetic products and is claimed to reduce facial winkles," said Lim. "Many studies have been performed using sheep's placenta for its claimed effect in cosmetic medicine. So far there is lack of convening evidence to prove its theoretical effect on skin. It may have a potential role in skin repair but once again this needs to be shown in larger scale studies."

Bird droppings

Referred to as a "Geisha facial" and reportedly used by celebrities such as Victoria Beckham, the faeces of a nightingale called the Japanese bush warbler has been used as a cosmetic treatment in Japan for centuries after being introduced by Koreans as a fabric stain remover. With a slightly musky odour, it's primarily used as an exfoliant that is left on the skin for several minutes before being rinsed off – with reports that its enzymes give you a warm glow.

"We know that a nutritious diet, daily exercise and stress management can improve telomerase – the enzyme that creates telomeres, the caps on our chromosomes," said Bauer, who remains unconvinced about the special properties of bird poo. "The healthier our telomeres, the healthier our cells. I'm going to stick with these three approaches and pass on bird droppings."

Urine therapy

Perhaps one of the most hotly contested forms of alternative medicine, urine therapy refers to the consumption and topical application of human urine. Proponents claim it's beneficial because it contains a chemical compound called urea – which, by itself, can be used to promote skin rehydration and treat psoriasis and eczema. Some say it's an anti-cancer agent, and that drinking your own urine can help promote meditation. However, research shows that it can spread bacteria and lead to high levels of sodium if ingested. With Bauer adding that any purported benefits attributed to urine therapy are scientifically baseless.

"Absolutely not – and some potentially serious risks if you do," he said when asked if there were any benefits to be gained. "This concept goes back several centuries and should have died out long before now. All of this reflects the importance of doing your homework. Just because something is touted as natural doesn't mean it is safe.

76 comments

  • It helps to understand alternate forms of healing if you start with the truth of what we indeed are at our core.. Sure our bodies and all matter appear material and solid, but as physics (and ancient knowledge beforehand) reveal matter is indeed condensed energy. Therefore it stands to reason that "energy medicine" that focus's on the underlying energetic nature of everything is a treatment worth pursuing. Research in this area is limited purely because most medical research is funded by pharmaceutical companies who need to be able to patent their findings in order to reap their rewards.

    Commenter
    nameRICHARD
    Date and time
    August 02, 2012, 12:25PM
    • There is a technical term for alternative medicine procedures which have been shown to work through the results of well-designed clinical trials.

      That technical term is "medicine".

      "physics (and ancient knowledge beforehand) reveal matter is indeed condensed energy"

      This makes no sense to me.

      ""energy medicine" that focus's on the underlying energetic nature of everything is a treatment worth pursuing."

      The phrase "energy medicine" sounds impressive (lots of sciencey words) but I suspect that it is New Age psychobabble.

      Commenter
      Dr Kiwi
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 12:49PM
    • @Richard.
      Please describe what this "energy" is and how the alternative medicine version of it is related to the quantum theory version of it.

      Alternative therapies and medicine suffer from the same problems as any other metaphysical belief system. Seriously, it is logically bunk to start with a position of belief in something and then go about seeking to support that belief. Alternative medicine that works has a name. It's called medicine.

      Commenter
      Reverse Concave Spoon
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 1:03PM
    • It is only worth pursuing if there is any credence to the practice. Despite most people's beliefs, pharmaceutical companies do not have a say about every single healthcare practice out there. Research in this area is limited because more focus is now given to regulating the alternative medicine field to back up their claims. We are becoming more discerning about the efficacy of our treatments, and as such we want to know that we are not being fleeced out of our money for an ineffective, and potentially dangerous, practice or treatment.

      Any intervention should try to at least prove that it can do what it says it can, and unfortunately, a lot of alternative medicine does not yet have that evidence behind it. As an example, homeopathy is widely used as an alternative therapy to traditional medicine, and yet, there is no credible evidence proving that it works. Sure, that may change, but at the moment it's looking sketchy. If the pharmaceutical companies were only interested in a quick buck, they want something that actually works. They are not going to invest time and money passing a drug through trials and approvals only to have it proven as pure hokum.

      I am very much of the belief that alternative therapies and traditional medical therapies can work side by side. I just believe that we should ensure that there is some reason for pursuing a treatment that can be substantiated by hard evidence.

      Commenter
      Woodchips
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 1:15PM
    • There are incredible alternative therapies that have not been mentioned here: sound therapy and sauna therapy. The latter can stop people from getting colds, the former has barely been tested and is profoundly useful. And remember there are many conventional therapies can kill and damage.

      Commenter
      Dean F
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 1:43PM
    • There has been a change in people - they are not seeking out doctors anymore for a "pill" to pop when they are unwell. They are looking at other avenues ... Dr Kiwi - "alternative medicine" maybe might threaten your lifestyle??? Is that why you and others in the medical profession "attack" any mention of "alternative medicine"? If you keep smudging the name of "alternative medicine and therapies" - you might ruin its reputation... I am thinking that there has been a huge shift in people and they are seeking out alternative therapies instead of running to a doctor every time something is wrong. It is about time people are looking at their bodies as more than just a machine...

      Commenter
      Paula the Pilgrim
      Location
      Ryde
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 1:44PM
    • @Paula the Pilgrim : No, they attack alternative medicines because they have to deal with the aftermath of people who USED alternative medicinal practices and came back sicker than they started.
      For example, I had a friend with cervical cancer who continually ditched medical advice in order to pursue an Eastern Medicine approach... lo-and-behold, those periods of time that she ignored medical advice resulted in her essentially remaining "untreated" for months at a time (up to the point where she'd need to be hospital-ridden).
      The "miracle cures" she was being sold should've been downright illegal and the sellers should be jailed for eternity. They're quite literally profiting at the expense of peoples' lives.

      I mean, think about it. Would you criticize medical science for the studies they've done to find links between cigarette smoking and lung cancer?

      Don't get me wrong, not ALL alternative medicines are bad... some are really just placebos and some are even beneficial. Quite a few are downright harmful and frankly criminal.

      Commenter
      UJelly?
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 2:12PM
    • Haha, thanks for the laugh Richard, "energy medicine". You can't know how the body works even if you know everything about atoms and what makes them up.

      Also there is plenty of money to be had in ripping off naive people with your 'alternative medicine' so don't try the old evil pharmaceutical company argument (although they do have some ethically questionable practices)

      Commenter
      cap'n crunch
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 2:18PM
    • @Paula,

      First of all, people have been swindled by quacks and snake oil salesmen for as long as currency has existed as a medium of exhange. There's nothing new going on there. You could argue that people's trust in science is being eroded by a number of things in recent history but that might be drawing a long bow connecting it to alternative medicine.
      Secondly, the people "attack" alternative medicine generally put some stock in empirical evidence before they try or even jump head first into full blown belief. Establish facts, then concepts, then beliefs. Doing it in reverse is utter delusion.

      Commenter
      Reverse Concave Spoon
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 2:46PM
    • @Paula the Pilgrim
      "They are looking at other avenues"

      I agree with the general point that you may be making here. There are many non-pharmaceutical ways towards living well; eating in a healthy way, regular exercise, don't smoke, drink alcohol, if at all, in moderation, etc.

      "Dr Kiwi - "alternative medicine" maybe might threaten your lifestyle???"

      Thank you for your concern about my lifestyle.

      While I appreciate your kindness, it is misplaced - the "Dr" in my screen-name is real but it is a PhD in biomedical science, not a medical qualification.

      Commenter
      Dr Kiwi
      Date and time
      August 02, 2012, 3:46PM

More comments

Comments are now closed
Featured advertisers

Horoscopes

Capricorn horoscope

Trust others to think for themselves. Don't be snobbish about what seems obvious. Everyone learns at their own pace, including you.

...find out more here