JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Want a happy marriage? Find a mother-in-law from hell

Date

Sandy Smith

"For the record I am always lovely to my mother-in-law but if I wasn't in a relationship with her son I would never go near her without a hazard suit on."

"For the record I am always lovely to my mother-in-law but if I wasn't in a relationship with her son I would never go near her without a hazard suit on." Photo: istockphoto

Christmas is almost here and while some might be looking forward to spending the holidays with their in-laws, for others being trapped in the same house as their mother-in-law is enough to turn any festive cheer into yuletide misery.

Whether she is critical and interferes, spoils your children or has even tried to break up your marriage, anonymous stories about the mother-in-law from hell litter cyberspace. Paradoxically, finding anyone to talk about their personal experiences proved impossible. It seems that no-one is brave enough to risk a public falling out with their mother-in-law. Perhaps memories are still fresh of the spat last year between a mother-in-law to be who sent a scathing email to her son’s fiancé, accusing her of bad manners and "staggering uncouthness and lack of grace" following a weekend visit. The email became a worldwide sensation and, unsurprisingly, the mother-in-law from hell didn't get an invitation to the wedding.

A mother-in-law often finds herself the target of jokes but the problem is “deadly serious” says Dr Terri Apter, a psychologist and senior tutor at Newnham College, Cambridge. “I was stunned to discover the impact and influence of in-laws” says Apter while researching her book What Do You Want From Me: Learning To Get Along With The In-Laws. Apter used two decades of research to show the extent of the difficulties some daughters-in-law face. “Over 60 per cent of women said that their relationship with an in-law caused them long-term unhappiness and stress, and affected the quality of their marriage,” she says.

There's nothing new about a hellish mother-in-law. <i>Image: Cathy Wilcox</i>

There's nothing new about a hellish mother-in-law. Image: Cathy Wilcox

One victim of a mother-in-law from hell described her experiences at essentialbaby.com.au: "For the record I am always lovely to my mother-in-law but if I wasn't in a relationship with her son I would never go near her without a hazard suit on! She is a liar, terribly two faced and a drama queen — anyone else like that would not be in my life. But because she is the mother of the man I love, I smile, make charming conversation, try and steer her conversation away from the character assassinations of her other daughters-in-law and sons (a courtesy I hope is reciprocated!) and try not to sever my tongue from biting on it. Sometimes it is a power play — two women battling for supremacy in the eyes of the one man."

Quarrels can arise about anything that symbolises love, status or influence, says Apter and often conflict emerges as each feels the other is criticising or undermining her or challenging her special role in the family. “Although a daughter-in-law is an adult in her own household, a mother-in-law's maternal expertise is already established and she may expect deference. There then arises that tricky question about who is "mother" in the family, with final say over all those things women still assume charge over: housework and child care, meal times and children's manners.  The daughter-in-law is gatekeeper to her children, who are the mother-in-law’s grandchildren. That can be frightening.”

However, getting on badly with your mother-in-law could actually be good news for your marriage. A new study says those women who enjoy a positive relationship with their in-laws actually have a 20 per cent greater chance of separating.

Dr Terri Orbuch, a psychologist and research professor at the University of Michigan's Institute for Social Research and author of Finding Love Again: 6 Simple Steps to a New and Happy Relationship, studied 373 same-race couples over 26 years to come up with the findings which will be published in 2013 in the journal, Family Relations.

She believes there are two explanations for this. “When a wife gets close to her in-laws, this takes time away from bonding with her husband and family, especially early in marriage”, she says, and “when a wife gets close to her in-laws, she has a difficult time not taking what her in-laws say as personal or interference. In contrast, marriages in which husbands have a close relationship with in-laws are 20 per cent less likely to end in divorce. These family ties connect him to his wife."

So what should you do if relations between you and your mother-in-law are so tense that they threaten to derail not just Christmas but your own sanity?

“My best advice is to address the fears that underlie the problems” says Apter. “The key is to turn competition into collaboration. It’s much easier to set boundaries between you and your in-laws if you have also established connections. It’s easier to hear, 'That’s not a good time to visit' or 'We’re going to make this decision ourselves' if you’re not afraid of being totally cut off."

Orbuch says it is important to have realistic expectations. “Don’t try and change her or expect that this year things will be different. They won’t. Instead find some common ground between you and her. Try and remember that comments your mother-in-law might make about your parenting style, marriage or work are not about you, and all about them,” she says. “Usually, the most prickly issues across families are about who will have the most influence.” If there is still too much conflict and tension, she suggests that you ask your spouse for help.

Apter agrees. “Get your spouse on side. The man’s role is crucial", she says. "He can head off problems if he reassures his parents that they are still an important part of his life, that he still feels connected to them, still loves and respects them, while at the same time showing them that his primary connection is now with his wife.”

But if you can’t see that the relationship will ever work, Orbuch advises to “focus on the fact that this woman raised the special man you married. If for nothing else, that deserves some respect.”

196 comments so far

  • Her. He has a Motherinlaw as well you know...

    Commenter
    Bean
    Location
    Beanville
    Date and time
    December 20, 2012, 9:14AM
    • You know what her name is...?

      Commenter
      Pilate
      Location
      Jawoosalem
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 12:30PM
    • This article is going to bring out some great stories. There are some freaky Mothers in Law out there. My soon to be ex MIL picked up my kids from school without telling anyone when my exwife and I were restricting access of the kids to her because of her terrible ways. I almost called the police because we didn't know where they were for a while. The ex MIL is one thing that I am not going to miss. Since I have seperated from my ex I have had sooooooooooooooooo many friends tell me that they can't believe how long I put up with that witch.

      Commenter
      JC
      Location
      Brisbane
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 12:53PM
    • I am a daughter in law as well as a mother in law times three. The dynamics between a daughter in law is so much different to a son in law. In the mother/daughter thing, there is a lifetime of history. In the daughter in law / mother in law thing there is only the life of the relationship.
      For a girl, you have the influence of your mother in the way that you live your life : there is housework habits, cooking and raising kids if they are a part of the family dynamic. You are more likely to defer to your mother for advice than your mother in law.
      My mother in law was born overseas in a very different culture. She has two daughters older than my husband, who is her baby. This is something that drove him out of home at the age of seventeen. I've lived with him for almost twice as long as he lived at home with her.
      Early in our marriage there was a lot of conflict between her and me. She loves to use passive-aggressive behaviours to get her own way. As someone that abhors this childishness I would dig my heels in. We seem to have come to an understanding after almost 32 years : butt out!
      My own mother was pretty even handed with both my husband and myself : she's always been the bitch from hell, so it has not been a biggie for both of us. For the sake of the kids, they had regular contact with my parents.
      For myself, I let my daughters-in-law do their own thing. If they ask, I'll offer. If they don't, no biggie. They're all great girls and know they are valued.

      Commenter
      Robyn
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 2:10PM
  • My mother in law is farken crazy. Lucky my beautiful wife knows that though.

    Commenter
    Franky
    Location
    Sydney
    Date and time
    December 20, 2012, 9:48AM
    • My mother and father were the most beautiful guenuine, honest people I can remember. My brother married a real Australian scrubber, my mother as polite as ever tried to welcome her into the family. My brother and his wife were real takers, made sure they got my mothers sapphire engagement ring, good furniture before she died, when they had a son my mother bought a cot in the hope of looking after her grandson, fat chance. When she was on her death bed, her beloved son and his wife were never seen because she had given them their inheritance early to pay off their house. No funds coming for her funeral I paid for everything. Women have a leave and cleave police with marriages and son's mothers. Think again I know my nephew missed out on the best family ever. Bad inlaws not always have a second look at your life partner. Sometimes what you can't see bad is right under your nose.

      Commenter
      Pickled Herring
      Location
      Frankston
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 2:33PM
  • More women arguing again!

    Commenter
    John Holmes
    Date and time
    December 20, 2012, 10:03AM
    • Yea, you would think they would give it a rest.

      Commenter
      J Walker
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 11:51AM
    • Simple don't get married!!

      Commenter
      State the Obvious
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 1:31PM
    • My mother in law is great, I have the Father in law from hell !!

      Commenter
      Joe
      Date and time
      December 20, 2012, 8:11PM

More comments

Make a comment

You are logged in as [Logout]

All information entered below may be published.

Error: Please enter your screen name.

Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

Error: Please enter your comment.

Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

Post to

You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

Thank you

Your comment has been submitted for approval.

Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

Featured advertisers

Horoscopes

Capricorn horoscope

Trust others to think for themselves. Don't be snobbish about what seems obvious. Everyone learns at their own pace, including you.

...find out more here