News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Doctor denied residency due to Down syndrome son 

Doctor denied residency due to Down syndrome son

31 Oct, 2008 04:12 PM
The federal government must overturn an immigration department decision to deny Australian residency to a German doctor because his son has Down syndrome, the opposition says.

Bernhard Moeller moved with his family to rural Horsham, in central-western Victoria, two and a half years ago to help fill a doctor shortage.

Dr Moeller has a temporary 457 visa which is valid until 2010, but has been denied permanent residency because the department believes his 13-year-old son Lukas would be a drain on the health system.

Coalition disabilities spokesman Cory Bernardi says he has asked Immigration Minister Chris Evans to intervene in the case but continues to pass the buck to the department.

"Minister Evans has the discretionary powers to intervene and approve the residency application of Dr Moeller and his family, yet as media pressure has intensified he has chosen to hide behind the department," Senator Bernardi said.

"It is sad that in this modern day we are still viewing people with a disability, such as Dr Moeller's son, as a burden.

"While children with Down syndrome have some degree of intellectual disability, this usually falls within the mild to moderate range.

"They can and do make significant contributions to our society."

The nation should show Dr Moeller its gratitude, not discriminate against his son, Senator Bernardi said.

"I am sure the community at Horsham would agree with me that the benefits of allowing the Moeller family to stay outweigh what the Department of Immigration and Citizenship has deemed a burden to taxpayers."

The department insists its decision was made in accordance with the law.

The Australian Greens said Dr Moeller's case highlighted the need for cultural change within the immigration department.

"While Immigration Minister Evans has shown willingness to move forward from the regressive policies of the past, it is evident that some outmoded mindsets within his department remain," Greens Senator Sarah Hanson-Young said.

"The public outcry about the Moeller family's case proves not only their value to the region in which they live, but also that the department's decisions are out of step with community attitudes."

A spokesman for Immigration Minister Chris Evans stressed the minister had no power to intervene in the case until after the Migration Review Tribunal had upheld the department's decision.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size



comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Sack these fools in the Health system who beseige us with their bureaucratic stupidity - export them to some 3rd world country and experience what life is really all about!
Posted by Tixie, 31/10/2008 2:34:36 PM
Whilst any disability is sad, it shouldnt detract from the fact that the Government have restrictions for granting permanent residency. We should abide/accept the rules and not let any case to be excluded. Would that mean more cases highlighted by the media be given the chance to have the decision overturned? Then what is the use of having these 'Rules'. Why is this case different from all others looking for permanent Residency but having it refused on medical grounds?
Posted by LYN G [Perth], 31/10/2008 2:50:55 PM
What a joke! Can ANYONE explain how his son has ANY BEARING AT ALL on this man's skills as a doctor and his ability to offer help where it is urgently needed? Nope? I didn't think so. Sack these fools!
Posted by Appalled, 31/10/2008 2:54:30 PM
We are seething with indignation & shame for our country at the treatment of the Moeller family at the hands of the immigration dept. & Minister Evans. Dr. Moeller came to this country to fill a vital need, a critical shortage of M.D.s in rural areas & no doubt to make a fresh start for his family & this is his reward. Minister Evans must move quickly to correct an injustice & to update outdated laws which do not reflect a "fair deal " in the majority of australians opinions. NS&JW
Posted by NS & JW, 31/10/2008 3:35:00 PM
The range of disability covered by Downs Syndrome is huge and like Dr Moeller, we are blessed that our daughter is at the "100" end of the scale, or "High functioning". Anyone who has met her would, like us, have no doubt that she makes and will make a huge contribution to our community and will be a happy, funcitoning member of our society as she grows up. I think the most insulting thing is the concept of a childs "cost" to the Austrailan government. Are there any guarantees that one of my other "normal" and currently healthy children will not develope a condition requiring special treatment in the future? Absolutely not. Although one has to wonder at the madness of our beaureaucratic system rejecting a highly qualified Doctor who has committed himself to working in a rural area, another thing to consider in this issue is the outdated concepts of disability enshrined in the immigration legislation. For children with a range of conditions including DS, autism, Cerabal Palsy ect, their education, quality of life and work prospects are amazing compared to 15 years ago. It is a shame the government's outlook has not kept up with the progress and certainly time these outdated attitudes where reviewed
Posted by Pieta Manning, 31/10/2008 3:37:54 PM
this decision is so very wrong. This doctor came to help us with our huge shortage in doctors. This is how we repay him. This shows no respect for his son or his family. Our health system is in so much trouble and we can't afford to turn away decent hardworking doctors. Change the laws right now and this country retains another doctor we so desperately needs. Anyone who disagrees should visit any public hospital emergency room to see just how badly understaffed these hospitals are every single day.
Posted by kathy, 31/10/2008 3:45:34 PM
It seems just a question of how much a person will cost the state - so impersonal and cut throat. Also when adopting children, the government will not pay medical costs if you adopt a child with an existing disability - disgusting - who would wrought the system by adopting a child (usually from a developing country) simply to get money from the government! And it is not as if hundreds of these children are being adopted anyway. My husband and I would definitley consider adopting a child with a disability, but as development workers, we could not afford to pay the medical bills, it seem so heartless - but what can we do? Are we serious in this country about helping out those much less fortunate than we are? The law appears to suggest otherwise...
Posted by Emily, 31/10/2008 3:57:31 PM
This is mindless bureaucracy at its worst. A poor decision made by a poor minister, and an under-performing department, in serious need of reform.
Posted by Jeff, 31/10/2008 4:03:57 PM
I'm sure Dr Moeller will give more to Australian society than his family will ever ask of us. Some people in government need to step into the REAL world, and quickly. He and his family have our support I'm sure. Not all Australians are total morons.
Posted by DrD, 31/10/2008 4:24:11 PM
I can't believe that the old attitude towards DS is still alive and well. My 13 Y.O. reads at age, cares for his nieces and nephews better than anyone. I am shocked, amazed and saddened that our society sees the value of a human person as being measured in dollars. It isn't the first time this attitude has been shown but I hope it will be the last. The value of a person can't be measured in $ and cents. I feel upset and ashamed that Lukas and his family have been subjected to this in my country.
Posted by saddened, 31/10/2008 5:33:58 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Bernhard Moeller and his son Lukas. PHOTO: The Wimmera Times
Bernhard Moeller and his son Lukas. PHOTO: The Wimmera Times

MOST POPULAR

Yourguide to Your Toyota
University of Canberra - click here
 
Red Hot Deals at Eurobodalla! click now
 
James Bond Happy Hour at Flint - click now
 
 
Click here to read See Canberra online!
 
Ready, Set. Drive!
 
Classifieds
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...