News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Hockey within reach 

Hockey within reach

27 Nov, 2009 12:03 PM
  • Who resigned, what they said

    The Liberals appear to be moving towards a deal that would make Joe Hockey leader, with Tony Abbott as shadow treasurer as a consolation prize.

    Under this scenario, Peter Dutton, who will be struggling in his marginal Queensland seat of Dickson, would become deputy.

    The emissions trading legislation would be delayed until next year. Mr Hockey today sent out a Twitter message canvassing feedback on the ETS legislation. ‘‘I really want your feedback’’.

    This arranagement would give the two broad strands of the party something. Mr Hockey is moderate and would have broader community appeal than Mr Abbott. The right would get the key jobs of deputy and shadow treasurer, as well as deferring the ETS bills.

    Being deputy might also help Mr Dutton hold his seat, or increase his chances of getting another one if anything comes up.

    Deputy opposition leader Julie Bishop has told Malcolm Turnbull that he must step down, according to media reports.

    The implosion of the Liberal Party this week has played out in part on the social networking sites Twitter and Facebook.

    Meanwhile, Tony Abbott has put new pressure on Mr Turnbull to change his mind on the emissions trading scheme or face a leadership challenge on Monday.

    ‘‘I will be talking to colleagues this morning. If there is no movement from the bunker then I’ll be calling a spill for Monday morning,’’ he told Macquarie Radio.

    The emissions trading scheme bill was due to be voted on in the Senate today. However, Senator Xenophon this morning said the revised but still "cumbersome" legislation was unlikely to pass.

    ‘‘But it really depends on on those seven or eight Liberals who are still stuck on Malcolm Turnbull,’’ he said.

    A bullish Mr Turnbull this morning attacked Mr Abbott and the party's climate-change sceptics, including Nick Minchin and Eric Abetz, who also quit the shadow cabinet yesterday after unsuccessfully attempting to cajole Mr Turnbull into delaying the legislation.

  • ‘‘We are at a turning point in the history of the Liberal party. We can either be seen as a party of tomorrow, a progressive party which believes in taking action on climate change, or we can go backwards.

    ‘‘The people that are opposing me within the party do not believe in climate change at all. They make John Howard look like a greenie,’’ he said.

    ‘‘They are turning back the clock and Australians will punish us very, very severely at the next election if these guys have their way and we go to the election as the ‘do nothing on climate change party’ ... we will get thrashed.’’

    And he attacked Mr Abbott, criticising him of flip-flopping on emissions trading.

    "Tony Abbott is letting down the whole Liberal Party," he said. "There is not a position on the ETS Tony has not held."

    Nine other senior Liberals had also defected from key roles by late last night, capping a disastrous week for Mr Turnbull that has virtually ensured his leadership cannot survive.

    Sources close to shadow treasurer Joe Hockey left open the option of him being a candidate - but only if Mr Turnbull was not in the field.

    Mr Turnbull last night told a news conference he was determined to get the emissions trading legislation through the Senate and that he believed he could muster the seven Liberal votes that were needed.

    While the legislation is due for a Senate vote this afternoon, the rebels may try to delay its progress until they can get a change of leader. It was unclear whether Mr Turnbull would have the numbers to gag the debate and push the legislation through.

    ''We agreed with the Government on this deal,'' he said. ''We must retain our credibility of taking action on climate change.

    ''And we also must be seen as men and women of our word. We entered into a bargain, there was an offer and there was acceptance.''

    He rejected suggestions he could not continue as leader after the mass defections. ''Nothing has changed as far as the leadership is concerned. My leadership was confirmed only yesterday but it is, as John Howard used to say, always something in the gift of the party room.''

    Mr Abbott and Senator Minchin jointly confronted Mr Turnbull in his office after question time yesterday. ''Malcolm was unprepared to reconsider,'' Mr Abbott said. ''I could no longer support the Opposition's policy and therefore could no longer be in the shadow cabinet.''

    He said his office had had ''an absolute deluge of emails, the phone lines have been in meltdown, with people saying that the Liberal Party would not be doing its job as an Opposition simply to pass this thing without the scrutiny [that] it demands''.

    Mr Abbott said he and Senator Minchin had asked Mr Turnbull if the amended bill could be sent to a Senate inquiry and voted on in February. ''We put it to Malcolm that in light of the heavy criticism of industry groups … and in light of the meltdown which is currently taking place within the Liberal Party, that the matter should be reconsidered.''

    Senator Minchin and Senator Abetz, the party's leader and deputy leader in the upper house, told Mr Turnbull they would stay in their positions until Parliament rises.

    Others who resigned yesterday were Victorian shadow ministers Tony Smith and Sophie Mirabella, lower house Opposition whip Michael Johnson, Senate whip Stephen Parry and deputy Senate whips Judith Adams and David Bushby.

    Three shadow parliamentary secretaries - Mitch Fifield, Brett Mason and Mathias Cormann - quit on Wednesday.

    Victorian Liberal Petro Georgiou attacked the dissidents. ''The shadow ministers who resigned today because they couldn't accept the party room decision have done the Liberal Party incalculable harm. That harm will be measured by lost votes at the ballot box.''

    But Mr Johnson said it was time for Mr Turnbull to go.

    ''With a heavy heart I do say that … my leader's position is untenable,'' Mr Johnson said. ''He should respect the convention that when senior people have no confidence in the leader, they should quit. He said deputy leader Julie Bishop should ''go and see Malcolm, if she hasn't done so already, and tell him the shadow ministers are against you … This is about her protecting the party's interests for the future. We've had a terribly difficult time.''

    Senator Minchin said his resignation was ''in response to a groundswell of opposition from colleagues, the business community and constituents in relation to the position adopted by the Coalition to support the passage of amended legislation over the coming days''.

    A prominent climate sceptic, Senator Minchin received a round of applause as he entered a special meeting of Liberal senators last night.

    Ms Mirabella said she was prepared to demote herself so she could vote against the flawed legislation, and Senator Abetz said: ''I plead with the leader to accept the party room verdict on this issue.''

    Mr Smith said he could not vote for an emissions trading scheme without knowing what the rest of the world was doing. ''You can be fully committed to effectively combating climate change without supporting this ETS at this time,'' Mr Smith said.

    Controversial West Australian Wilson Tuckey said: ''At this point in time, the only person that can stop the demise of the Liberal Party is Malcolm Turnbull, and he should resign.''

    Key Turnbull ally Michael Ronaldson insisted Mr Turnbull need not blink and said the Coalition could not afford to vote against the legislation. ''For the Coalition to remain relevant, in my view, we must pass this legislation,'' he said.

    The manager of Government business in the lower house, Anthony Albanese, said the Government had an agreement with the Opposition for a vote in the Senate at 3.45pm today, followed by a sitting in the House of Representatives on Monday.

    With AAP, TOM ARUP, DAN HARRISON

    The Age

    Print
    Increase Text Size
    Decrease Text Size

    comments


    Date: Newest first | Oldest first
    What the Liberal Senators and others don't understand is that Nick Minchin and Joe Hockey are representing the VIEWS of their constituents, and that's the way it should be. Ignoring your constituents because party leaders say "do what i say now" just shows that certain liberals are taking their ELECTED positition as though its a dictatorship. By the way look up who the ALP is a member of... Socialist International.....who claim they can dictate to members on everything from economic matters to environmental action. This group is NOT an elected part of the Australian government but the ALP are willing to take directions from it as shown in their Presidents report. Who feels like a wally now you pathetic labour supporters (you don't even understand that your party isn't run by Rudd, it's run by a guy who's name is...George Papandreou!!!! Yep that's right, the GREEK Prime Minister!!!!!!!!), then again, people who don't bother to look at the fine print before joining political parties are usually idiots anyway.
    Posted by Rex, 27/11/2009 2:01:31 PM, on The Canberra Times
    I don't think that Joe Hockey, looking quite pleased with himself (pictured) doesn't realise how thin that branch really is. There it had to be said...
    Posted by snap, 27/11/2009 4:24:51 PM, on The Canberra Times
    The ALP doesn't need to dictate to its constituents, because the ALP's constituents are not absolute cretins
    Posted by crackle, 27/11/2009 5:21:22 PM, on The Canberra Times
    The only reason Rudd is so keen to get the ETS legislation through and is spending more time in other countries than in his own country is because he is hoping to pave the way for a position for himself in the UN eventually. After all he is an ex-PS. His own agenda and personal ambitions are more important than the welfare of Australia. ALP is a security risk has socialist policies.
    Posted by Rita, 27/11/2009 5:37:57 PM, on The Canberra Times
    There the emission traders & carbon tax promoters go again...name calling and cursing anyone with a different view than theirs...that is the tactics of a desperate and credibility lacking opponent...they should realise that people with a different view are called...voters.
    Posted by dusty, 27/11/2009 5:41:20 PM, on The Canberra Times
    Wow, back to the future, eh? Hockey will no doubt try to cultivate a nice guy image, but he's a thug and I don't think there's anyone who doesn't already know it. He's Mark Latham with a nicer smile.
    Posted by KD, 27/11/2009 6:51:54 PM, on The Canberra Times
    No Joe what don't you know. Hasn't been good in any job he's been given so far. And leader that's a bigger joke than Joe is. :-)
    Posted by Big Tas, 27/11/2009 8:42:02 PM, on The Canberra Times
    The Libs so often accused Labour of gutter politics, but this Liberal in-fighting has to be set in a sewer. Malcolm (got any new goss there Godwin?), Tony (tongue engaged when brain elsewhere), Joe (where are my political advisors when I need them?) Eric (give me the questions you want me to ask Godwin), Nick (I will not impede the passage of the bill) and so it goes....if we get the politicians we deserve I am damn sure I don't deserve that little lot.
    Posted by terry, 28/11/2009 5:29:45 AM, on The Canberra Times
    The issue at hand in the current schism in the Coalition rank is that too many in the coalition ranks oppose Malcolm Turnbull's agreeing to sign on the CPRS/ ETS legislation BEFORE knowing what the other countries agree to do about climate change and/or emission of pollutants at the Copenhagen Meeting. Their view is derived from the many "polls" that have been carried out in their constituencies, i.e. their position is dictated by what their constituents tell them that they expect of them. It is a people's representative DUTY to represent people's will, even when by doing so one might be in disagreement with what one believes. However, if a people's elected representative does not want to bend to the will of the people because that would be against his/her own beliefs or "principles" , the only honorable alternative is to resign from that POSITION OF TRUST that the people have put him/her in.
    Posted by Mario of Melbourne, 29/11/2009 1:09:06 PM, on The Canberra Times
    The only issue in the current schism in the Coalition is that too many in its rank and file oppose Malcolm Turnbull's willingness to sign on the CPRS/ ETS legislation BEFORE knowing what the other countries agree to do about climate change and/or emission of pollutants at the Copenhagen Meeting. Their view is derived from the many "polls" that have been carried out in their constituencies, i.e. their position is dictated by what their constituents tell them that they expect of them. Therefore, if Malcolm Turnbull or Joe Hockey change their views about the CPRS/ETS legislation based on this self-evident need (i.e. to represent the will of the people who have elected them) and if such courageous decision is clearly and objectively presented to the Australian public by the Coalition and the media, they will succeed in uniting the Coalition rank and file like never before. As well, this would be the worst nightmare for the government, as calling an early election would no longer be a tempting idea!
    Posted by Mario of Melbourne, 29/11/2009 7:06:11 PM, on The Canberra Times

    post a comment


    Screen name  *
    Email address  *
    Remember me?
    Comment  *
     
    We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
    Joe Hockey looks set to challenge for the Liberal leadership. Photo: Andrew Meares
    Joe Hockey looks set to challenge for the Liberal leadership. Photo: Andrew Meares

    Most popular articles

    Australian Running Festival

    Feb Best Buys


    The Canberra Times







    Weather brought to you by:

    Weatherzone

    Classifieds

    Front Page

    Current Issue
    Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
     SEND...
     SAVE...
     SHARE...