News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Marathon grilling leaves Henry steamed 

Marathon grilling leaves Henry steamed

23 Oct, 2008 10:00 AM
''Wrong that's W-R-O-N-G, exclamation mark.''

Treasury secretary Ken Henry spelt out yesterday his assessment of allegations that the Reserve Bank had raised concerns about the Federal Government's unlimited guarantee for bank deposits.

At times angry and agitated, the senior bureaucrat was grilled by Opposition senators when he appeared before the estimates committee.

One Liberal senator questioned Dr Henry's truthfulness during the fiery and prolonged hearing, with committee chairwoman Senator Annette Hurley struggling to maintain order during some exchanges.

The brouhaha was sparked by a report that Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens had voiced reservations about the Government's unlimited guarantee on bank deposits.

Dr Henry said the article was ''just plain wrong'' and ''not helpful''.

That remark prompted Liberal senator Helen Coonan to interject, ''but it may be right''.

Dr Henry's denial was emphatic. ''The members of the committee may think that's a matter of some mirth ...

''That is to say, and I'll say it again, the story on the front page of ... [The] Australian newspaper was wrong - that's W-R-O-N-G, exclamation mark.''

Undeterred, Liberal senators pressed on with questions about the governor's views on the banking measure.

Senator Coonan asked, ''Did Mr Stevens raise with you, Dr Henry, his strong concerns about market distortion if an uncapped guarantee was put in place?''

Dr Henry a veteran of Senate estimates hearings made an unusual move.

''Whilst I would not normally entertain questions such as this one, and in my 24 years of appearances before these committees never have, I think on this occasion there probably is a public interest in my confirming that in respect of the advice that was tendered to the Government, and that supported the decision that it took on Sunday the 12th of October, Mr Stevens and I were of one mind,'' he said.

The Opposition continued its line of inquiry, making only slight changes to the content of its questions.

Senator Coonan: ''Did the Reserve Bank governor express any reservations about the impact on the market from establishing an unlimited ... deposit guarantee at that time?''

As the hearing continued, the senior public servant was clearly frustrated at times.

When Liberal senator Eric Abetz challenged his recollection, Dr Henry erupted in anger.

Senator Abetz said, ''So the two of you were of like mind and said, 'Jinx'.''

Dr Henry replied, ''I've already said that.''

Senator Abetz continued, ''Each time you opened your mouth, 'exactly what I was going to recommend to the Government, exactly what I was going to recommend to the Government'. That to me doesn't sound to have the ring of truth about it.''

At this point, Dr Henry lurched forward and leaned across the desk.

''I'm sorry, senator, what are you suggesting?'' he said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Ken Henry was right to show such disdain for the hearing. He is a man of integrity and his being affronted by this was only to be expected.
Posted by 338RUM, 23/10/2008 11:51:35 PM
So old Henry (Another taxpayer highfunded Public Servant) has got himself all steamed up over a few questions--Advice---"If you cant stand the heat get out of the kitchen"
Posted by Old Dog, 23/10/2008 7:03:54 PM
Babbling on and on for 10.06 minutes by Mr Rudd to avoid the virus imbalance of national security granted on some banks and not on foreign frozen funds. Well concluded by Turnbull and Bishop in Question Time. What about Accountability Time Rudd/Swan and advisors? The truth must come out sooner than later and with the profit write-offs from NAB Westpac this morning 'our government' has lot's to answer for. Huge involvements in funny money is now on record. Yeh! lets protect them- from the world depression virus. Even Yahoo sheds labour! Ebay sheds and shreads it's labour force. Borrowed money is hardly an issue now, it's how to know if a family with two incomes can afford the commitment of job security to start to borrow money. Game, set & match. Some ships do sink. I'm sorry also for those in debt, I know how it feels to lose it all. Sincerely Stephen Johnson
Posted by adaptapensioner, 23/10/2008 3:27:24 PM
Well clearly there is compelling evidence that the RBA did not agree with the Government's unlimited deposit guarantee yet teh Government, and Henrey is being complicit in this, are trying to portray that the RBA was completely on board. Clearly they were not. Someone is not telling the truth.
Posted by DMC, 23/10/2008 1:43:02 PM
Those who are critical of the behaviour of Liberal Senators during committee hearings have short memories. In opposition the Labor Senators acted exactly the same!
Posted by Boscoe, 23/10/2008 12:43:32 PM
The reason 'we' pay and have an 'opposition' is to query proposals, debate new laws, ask for details before unseen mistakes are ignored or not considered, at all. I see 'being in opposition' is viewed by the Comment Submissions that 'being in opposition' is just to be a nuisence, in fact to say "Butt out". But. please view it as like having a second opinion, or as the father calls for a second autopsy as he finds reasons the Croations autopsy does not satisify his rational thinking, we say he's entitled to an Australian one, but deny the Opposition in Govt. the right to ask for clarification, ask for documentation, emails or warning supports. If Kevin had the history as Opposition Leader for 4 years then this would have qualified him better to respect the rights of open debate. This is why he decides and he will bear the results of that decision. Not Henry, not Stevens. But the Prime Minister.
Posted by adaptapensioner, 23/10/2008 11:59:29 AM
I tell you what, in terms of shear entertainment, watching Senate Estimates is up there with Parliament Question Time. Both are almost the games of children...
Posted by Kincuri, 23/10/2008 11:22:05 AM
After watching the Senate grilling yesterday, I have decided that the coalition senate members are a bunch of rabble and Turnbull should be included with them.
Posted by colindale, 23/10/2008 11:10:59 AM
Shame Senators, shame! Dr Ken Henry has always conducted himself and has lead Treasury with professionalism and integrity, regardless of the political influences constantly raging, from the smugness and arrogance of Costello to the incompetence and disdain of Swan. Dr Henry is the consummate public servant and frankly one of the few true leaders worth admiring in the public service today.
Posted by Fed up, 23/10/2008 11:01:03 AM
Malcolm Turnbull would not egree with anything Labour government suggested, as he's so fixated on becomming the prime minister one day. Egotistical, flip-flop, Mal, no pro bono publico for him.
Posted by peter, 23/10/2008 10:47:53 AM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
GIVE ME STRENGTH: Treasury secretary Ken Henry was visibly frustrated at yesterday’s Senate estimates hearing where he stressed that he and Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens backed the Government’s move to guarantee bank deposits. PHOTO: Andrew Meares
GIVE ME STRENGTH: Treasury secretary Ken Henry was visibly frustrated at yesterday’s Senate estimates hearing where he stressed that he and Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens backed the Government’s move to guarantee bank deposits. PHOTO: Andrew Meares

MOST POPULAR

Yourguide to Your Toyota
James Bond Happy Hour at Flint - click now
 
Click here to read See Canberra online!
 
 
University of Canberra - click here
 
Red Hot Deals at Eurobodalla! click now
 
Ready, Set. Drive!
 
Classifieds
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...