News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Plea to keep mother's place of peace 

Plea to keep mother's place of peace

29 Oct, 2009 08:22 AM
At the peaceful lakeside spot where their mother watched her last sunrise, Raff and Andre Poidomani have a simple message. Don't sell Clare Holland House.

The Poidomanis oppose the ACT Government's plan to sell Canberra's only hospice to the Catholic order the Little Company of Mary.

Their mother Franca spent the last three months of her life at the hospice last year, receiving palliative care after a battle with cancer.

Health Minister Katy Gallagher has been forced to defend the controversial plan in which the Government sells the hospice for $9million as part of a bigger deal to buy Calvary Public Hospital from the Little Company of Mary.

Catholic Archbishop of Sydney Cardinal George Pell weighed into the debate yesterday, saying the ACT Government's plans to buy Calvary were ideological and driven by anti-Christian elements.

Calvary already runs Clare Holland House for the ACT Government but the hospice will become fully privatised if the sale goes ahead.

Andre Poidomani said his mother received such excellent treatment she called the hospice her ''home away from home''.

Families of patients were worried that the high-quality care would suffer if Clare Holland House was sold.

''History proves that once you do privatise something, you do end up with staff cuts because it just comes down to the dollar sign at the end of the day,'' he said.

His brother Raff Poidomani was also concerned that the Little Company of Mary would impose Catholic values on the way patients were treated.

Mrs Poidomani was a devout Catholic but towards the end, her sons said, she would have chosen euthanasia if it was legalised.

Raff Poidomani said the proposed 30-year agreement between the ACT Government and the Little Company of Mary could also have an impact on patients who favoured euthanasia.

''Should laws come into effect in the next 30 years legalising euthanasia, then some patients just won't get that choice,'' he said.

The Poidomanis have turned to the web to rally supporters, setting up the Facebook group, ''Support Clare Holland House'', which has attracted 150 members. They've also formed an organisation, ''Supporters of Clare Holland House Young and Old'' to represent families.

The family had nothing but praise for the care Mrs Poidomani received in the hospice, saying staff always supported families as well as patients.

''They would give you a little bit of an update on how mum was ... just so we were one step ahead if she was having a bad day. So it was the whole family, not just the patient that the nursing staff looked after,'' Andre Poidomani said.

He attended a public consultation meeting on the sale and pressed MsGallagher on the need for a second hospice to meet demand for palliative care and offer a secular alternative to Clare Holland House.

''I think the south side needs to be accommodated with a second hospice or an expansion to the current hospice,'' he said.

''Unfortunately I don't see that happening with the Little Company of Mary.''

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Clare Holland was a lovely person, a dedicated nursing sister and one of the Woden Valley hospital "originals". Clare Holland was tragically taken from us at an early age by cancer. I don't think Clare Holland woud mind who owned Clare Holland House as long as its occpants received the same high level of care as is currently delivered!
Posted by John D, 29/10/2009 10:25:03 AM
What is wrong with this ACT governement? Selling off the hospice is just one of the many crazy decisions it is making. The plans to turn the historic homestead at Gold Creek into a nursing home is another. Purely driven by profits, this government is prepared to sacrifice the interests of the public. It would be a tragedy if Clare Holland House was sold off - it is a wonderful facility just as it is.
Posted by Angie, 29/10/2009 10:40:19 AM
The arguments are non-sensical. A Hospice is where people go to die once it is determined that no medical treatment is of any further use. If euthanasia was legalised, they would euthanise people in the hospital itself and not the hospice. If that were to occur, then those who object to euthanasia could still go to the hopsice while others would opt for euthanasia instead. The sale of the hospice would not make any difference where that is concerned.
Posted by Mary, 29/10/2009 2:15:03 PM
I say we have a mega protest, this government is getting away with blue murder. It's time for more protests, let's stand up and defend our selves. The government don't have any compassion or reality what so ever, it's all about the money, eventually there will be nothing to benefit our community, our needy, our sick, our homeless. The government tossers won't be happy until they sell everything off. Everything that really benefits our community and are special and unique service are always first to be taken away.
Posted by Tracey, 29/10/2009 5:16:28 PM
A very interesting debate. It is not hard to observe comments from those that have lost a family member in devastating circumstances and have had the luxury of the facilities and support of Clare Holland House versus those that espouse theoretical opinion. My only wish is that Clare Holland House stays just the way it is - keep up the good work guys, without you life (and death) would be so much harder for so many!
Posted by Michelle, 29/10/2009 9:59:35 PM
The purpose of a Hospice is to serve the COMMUNITY as a whole, it has no right to have a criteria one must meet to enter it. By your responce I take it that any person in support of euthanasia have no place in a hospice. I hope you are never in a position to have to make that choice, because we as a society seem very quick to make that choice for others, yet we do not know what we would do if we were in that situation. There are many issues in relation to the sale of CHH to the LCM that concern a lot of people. If you read the proposal it is flawed, and not even supported by the Catholics/Christians in our community.
Posted by Andre, 29/10/2009 11:04:48 PM
My father passed away at CHH last week. The level of care he received while there was fantastic. If privatised and the same level of care was not available to everyone it would be an abomination. Even though it was a terrible time for him and his family, if he'd had to spend his last days in a hospital or at home without the same level of care it would have made things much more traumatic for him.
Posted by Pepper, 30/10/2009 10:55:30 AM
My father passed away to Clare Holland House on 4 June this year. He spent his last 5 months in the care of the nurses and doctors at CCH. The level of care was fantastic and the nursing staff were all excellent in keeping my dads spirits up even though he was in his last days. The ACT governement is absolutely crazy to sell CCH to a private company. As we have seen in the past this only means budget cuts as well as staffing cuts. The team at CCH are amazing and nothing needs to change there.
Posted by Tigi, 4/11/2009 2:21:37 PM
A dear friend of mine died at Clare Holland House in September. She received excellent compassionate care. I am not sure the care would be of the same level if the Hospice is sold to a private company. One only has to look at the staffing levels in private hospitals in Canberra. Clare Holland House is to valuable a public asset to be sold off.
Posted by Don't, 12/11/2009 12:41:51 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Andre Poidomani, of Kaleen, and brother Raff, of Ainslie, outside Clare Holland House, which they want to remain public property. Photo: MELISSA ADAMS
Andre Poidomani, of Kaleen, and brother Raff, of Ainslie, outside Clare Holland House, which they want to remain public property. Photo: MELISSA ADAMS

MOST POPULAR

Yourguide to Your Toyota
 
Click here to read See Canberra online!
 
James Bond Happy Hour at Flint - click now
 
University of Canberra - click here
 
Red Hot Deals at Eurobodalla! click now
 
Ready, Set. Drive!
 
Classifieds
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...