News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 'Stay and defend' policy backed by CFA 

'Stay and defend' policy backed by CFA

10 Feb, 2009 10:59 AM
The Country Fire Authority (CFA) has defended the "stay and defend" policy in the wake of Victoria's deadly fires.

CFA Chief Fire Officer Russell Rees said the stay and defend policy, under which homeowners remain on their property to protect it from fire, was based on sound evidence.

"It is the application of that policy and a lack of an alternative that we need to work on," Mr Rees told reporters.

"People need to understand that a late departure is the most deadly.

"We have said, and it is clearly evident, that fires can come without warning and very rapidly, and that you may not receive a warning and that you may not have a fire truck at your front gate.

"The (stay and defend) policy has to be to empower people - if you put in a directive policy to people you will get resistance.

"The clear evidence is that the most dangerous place to be is on the road."

He said emergency services had warned last week that Victoria was facing a threat unprecedented in its history.

"The fire service planned for this day - their planning was meticulous and detailed - it was a thorough plan put into place with efficiency and effectiveness, but the fires, as you all know, were enormous," Mr Rees said.

"Our emergency services worked well together and I am enormously proud of their efforts - they did everything possible they could in the circumstances but they are ready, and stand ready, to learn and further improve.

"Our people can hold their heads up high and I ask you to help them to do that."

Victoria Police Chief Commissioner Christine Nixon said some devastated communities, where the fires were believed to have been deliberately lit, would remain sealed from the public while forensic teams carried out their investigations.

"The CFA in some cases have shut the road because of trees falling or fire that may still be occurring, in some cases the roads are damaged, and for us, people have died on the side of the road or footpaths, so we are investigating that and protecting the crime scenes," she said.

"We are trying to clear these locations as fast as we can, but we need to remember these are mothers and fathers, sisters and brothers ... and we need to treat them with dignity in the way that we go about this process."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Chief Fire Officer Russell Rees defends 'stay&defend' on "sound evidence", yet admits of a "lack of alternative that we need to work on" demonstrates the residents capability, training and 'drilling' filming needed to aquire pre-evacuation timing. A 'Work Safety' training for residents to equip each is badly needed. Falling trees, embers, wind drive, smoke inhalation, bushfire central alarms 'red-button alert' - all this communication has been ignored by Bushfire Control. 'Stay&defend' is a right- but based on responsibility of Officer education awareness and residents capabilities pre-assessed. He is defending 'a right' without qualifications of the abilities of the residents to respond eg age, time of day, heat, warnings and alerts. I think he is wrong and displays other factors, being overlooked.
Posted by adaptapensioner.com, 10/02/2009 12:14:52 PM
Stay and Defend is based on sound evidence from bushfires of the past. Like Canberra in 2004, this wasn't your 'average' bushfire. More like a fire storm that generated its own micro-climate - winds, heat and movement etc. Something like we haven't normally seen in the past, but are starting to now. If it was anything like Canberra's experience, warnings of the magnitude of these fires is often not possible until the last minute, if at all. Whilst no expert, this appears to be 'the perfect bushfire' in that the conditions were ripe for this to occur; the area is extensively timbered, suffering from the effects of an extended drought, on a very hot and dry day with high winds. Add to this a lightening strike or arsonist and you get the 'perfect storm' with devestating results. Interestingly, where are the greenies and do-gooders now with their 'no burn or clear' policies etc for parks and bushland?
Posted by PKA, 10/02/2009 1:32:11 PM
I agree PKA but I would like to add one more thing. This is clearly a tradegy and one we must try to ensure never happens again. Lets learn from the mistakes and the experiences. The thing that frustrates me so much is since the 2003 Canberra fires we appear to have learnt nothing. Look at Uriarra Village. In 2003 the vast majority of the homes there burnt to the ground. Much of this was caused from the surrounding pine forests. What is there now post 2003 - the SAME forests replanted and 3 times as many houses. Why on earth are those responsible for the fires still there? The Coroner sought fit to blame those in charge and they are all still there because - get this - "they have learn't from their mistakes' - What on earth is wrong with this place! My thoughts are with the victims and their families.
Posted by BB, 10/02/2009 3:36:11 PM
'Interestingly, where are the greenies and do-gooders now with their 'no burn or clear' policies etc for parks and bushland? ' So we should clear national parks and burn them each and every year, just so people on the border can feel safe? Alternatively we could clear around houses, stop houses being built near reserves, and build houses with proper materials. Houses built correctly have a 95% chance of surviving fire. Why should our reserve pick up the slack for our bad design?
Posted by Brett, 10/02/2009 7:45:58 PM
"Stay&Defend Policy has worked for us for the past 20 years" said Premier John Brumby last night on Lateline interviewed by Tony Johns. So have school pedestrian crossings- until ... thinking beyond the well trodden path of the past needs to see further than the end of one's own nose. At least HE is now listening!
Posted by adaptapensioner.com, 11/02/2009 11:13:14 AM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Australian Running Festival

Feb Best Buys


The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...