News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Study links music to teens' mental states 

Study links music to teens' mental states

5/08/2008 3:33:00 PM
Teenagers' taste in music is associated with antisocial behaviour, vulnerability to suicide and drug use, Australian researchers say.

University of Queensland School of Music senior lecturer Felicity Baker and Kids in Mind Research director William Bor investigated if music could trigger mental health problems among young people.

It came after 16-year-old friends Jodie Gater and Stephanie Gestier committed suicide in Melbourne.

''In the aftermath of the double suicide of two teenage girls in 2007, the media linked the themes of emo music and the girls' mental state,'' Dr Baker said in a paper published in Australasian Psychiatry.

''Emo music short for emotional music typically expresses the outpouring of emotions usually associated with relationship break-ups or other tragic events. But it is not just emo music that has been the subject of scrutiny by the media.

''Rap music, country and heavy metal have also been blamed for antisocial behaviours, including violence, theft, promiscuity and drug use.''

Dr Baker and Dr Bor reviewed the findings from several studies to determine if music could trigger drug use, violence, antisocial behaviour and suicide among young people. ''Preference for heavy metal music and rap music correlate with a range of antisocial and other behaviour,'' Dr Baker said.

''While the research does not suggest that music causes such behaviours, it may well be that music preference is indicative of an underlying emotional disturbance or vulnerability. In fact, the research found that those adolescents with antisocial behaviour who listened to heavy metal music felt disconnected, lacked a stable identity, and had low self-esteem.

''Anger, violence and misogyny were especially associated with rap music. Similarly heavy metal music, particularly for girls, was associated with self-harm or suicidal ideation.''

Dr Baker said more research was needed to determine whether music preferences of those with mental health issues differed markedly from the general adolescent population. For help, phone Lifeline on 131 114.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Oh, you've got to be kidding. They have to do a study to realise this?
Posted by Stace on 5/08/2008 4:46:46 PM
They had to do a study to prove it was more than just random speculation.
Posted by AmaranthineTroglydite on 5/08/2008 7:49:19 PM
For God's sake, and preference for bland, middle-of-the-road mush is probably correlated with a tendency to become mid-level paper pusher with no imagination and no drive. Quick, someone stop me putting on some more Cure and Joy Division while working from home earning my six figure salary with my perfectly well-adjusted wife and child. Clearly I'm about to top myself. Read the third to last para carefully -- correlation does NOT mean causation, so the research did NOT reveal whether music could "trigger" anything.
Posted by Dr J Parkinson on 5/08/2008 7:52:14 PM
This isn't always most kids are depressed or angrey before they listen to this so called "influencing" music im 15 and i listen to emo and it may be sad but it dosen't make me want to commit suicide or it could be angry but im not going to go throw stiff so i think this is a load of shit your not a teenager how do you know what they are thiking
Posted by Ashleigh Ruth on 5/08/2008 8:03:15 PM
As a researcher in this field I think it's irresponsible to suggest that certain musics trigger or cause mental illness (as this article does, despite the one line proviso that causality cannot be determined). The last thing vulnerable young people need is more scorn from their parent culture aimed at what, for most certainly, is a very positive means of dealing with emotional difficulties - their music. Surely it's better that they vent their emotional difficulties (and indeed talk to their peers about them through shared interests in music) with thier chosen music than act out very normal adolescent frustrations and angsts in more anti-social ways. I'm sure if you had contacted Dr Baker for a direct quote, instead of selectively quoting from the paper, these cautions may have been expressed.
Posted by dr dougie on 5/08/2008 8:12:24 PM
"Sex drugs and rock and roll". Another version of the same thing in this era? Impossible. Such things were unheard of prior to these genius researchers coming up with this new revelation. How much did they get paid for it? A waste of taxpayers money and just to state the obvious makes it vital research. Please either stop spending our taxpayers money on useless research like this or find these guys another job and let's get some value for money for reserach dollars for a change rather than just continue to let them research anything just to justify their own existence.
Posted by Mark on 5/08/2008 8:21:32 PM
we dont just have the musicians to blame... the labels that support them are completely aware of the message their music is sending and they are completely aware of who is listening to it. instead of targeting a more mature audience or even regulating the content they encourage both because it is making them plenty o moolah. i would recomend reading "the hidden messages in water." it discusses the effects of music, among other things, on water. amazing discoveries. anyway music has an effect on us all and as a musician i feel obligated to provide a positive experience through my music because the sustain of your message, your vision, your art will last for many years to come and there is enough of what we dont need out there... music is not supposed to provide it... the news is.
Posted by skip on 6/08/2008 12:06:14 AM
music has a MUCH bigger impact than this study gives it credit for. and yes Stace, unfortunately some people need "studies" to realize anything. lame but true.
Posted by Elquartue on 6/08/2008 12:18:21 AM
A little more information at: http://www.theage.com.au/national/musical-key-to-unlocking-t eenage-wasteland-20080804-3pxy.html?page=-1 (also a Fairfax publication). What I want to know is: what "genre" do these clowns consider to be an indication of a well-adjusted teenager? Classical? Country? Gospel, perhaps? Or are all teenagers just painted with the "troubled" brush? After all, a teenager listening to classical music has obviously watched A Clockwork Orange too many times; teenagers who listen to country music are obviously experiencing dangerous levels of sexual attraction to a sibling or cousin; and a teenager who listens to gospel? Weak-willed and brain-washed. You can make all sorts of claims and inferences about a person's state of mind based on their musical tastes. But just because you have a degree on the wall doesn't make you any less of an idiot.
Posted by WhatThe on 6/08/2008 12:38:44 AM
Okay wait a second now... how does country encourage those things? This article put country in the same category as rap and heavy metal in the 6th paragraph. I have to heavily disagree with this. I have mental issues but country makes me feel happier than most anything.
Posted by Lya on 16/11/2008 5:14:42 AM
1 | 2  |  next >

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Under their influence ... My Chemical Romance lead singer Gerard Way and top left, metal act Slipknot and bottom rapper 50 Cent
Under their influence ... My Chemical Romance lead singer Gerard Way and top left, metal act Slipknot and bottom rapper 50 Cent

1/12/2008 | A government budget going into deficit as an economy heads towards a recession should evoke no more than a yawn.
Yourguide to Your Toyota
For the latest in sport - click here
 
Babies of 2008 - click here to find out more
 
CT Home Delivery
 
Classifieds
 
Domain.com.au
 
Photo Sales - click here
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...