News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Traffic chaos drives light-rail push 

Traffic chaos drives light-rail push

30 Aug, 2010 09:03 AM
The recent bridge collapse in Canberra's north and the ensuing traffic chaos has highlighted Canberra's unsustainable dependence on cars, according to Gungahlin Community Council's president.

Alan Kerlin said the incident highlighted the need for a light-rail network in the capital.

The half-built Gungahlin Drive Extension bridge over the Barton Highway collapsed on August 14, injuring 15 workers.

Mr Kerlin said the ACT Government was missing the point by maintaining it can't afford to build a light rail.

His comments come after a story published in the Sydney Morning Herald on Saturday about the success so far of a light rail from Lilyfield to Dulwich Hill, which is being carried out on time, and may even come in well under budget estimates.

The article hailed the progress as an unusually positive story for public transport, one that shed light on how much such projects really cost.

Mr Kerlin said yesterday that the ACT Government, on the other hand, had put in a bid for funding from the Federal Government that seemed destined to fail, because it was an all-or-nothing proposal.

''The ACT Government funded PriceWaterhouseCoopers to do the cost-benefit analysis on light rail it came out overwhelmingly in the positive, with a return on investment of 14.92 per cent,'' Mr Kerlin said.

''That's a positive return in anyone's maths. [But] there was a problem with the PWC cost-benefit analysis: it didn't include increased revenues from land sales and rate revenues. As in, if you've got permanent infrastructure in there for public transport, people will pay more for the land - that's a proven fact.''

For more of Mr Kerlin's comments, see the print edition of today's Canberra Times.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
The keyword here is UNSUSTAINABLE. When will Canberrans learn what the word means? Oh no, I'll drive my 4WD until I die...
Posted by Jordiet, 30/08/2010 9:22:43 AM, on The Canberra Times
YAY! Let's build light rail! Next ACT elections let's get the Greens in so light rail can begin
Posted by billy, 30/08/2010 1:05:25 PM, on The Canberra Times
I think light rail is a fantastic idea, and if they're going to start off small to see how it goes they should put a connection between Civic and the airport. Heaps cheaper and quicker then getting a taxi, especially for businesses that require their staff to travel.
Posted by Tegs, 30/08/2010 1:27:58 PM, on The Canberra Times
Much as there are the Howard-haters in the ALP, I think there must be just as many Light-Rail-haters. It took a public campaign by SMH and a ground swell of public opinion, threats from Independents, pro-LR policy from the opposition and finally local ALP MLAs' mutiny to see the writing on the wall for the Carr/Iemma/Rees/Kenneally govt to finally comit to it. Camberra needs and can have LR now! You can even run LR over heavy rail track to Queanbeyan and Bungendore!
Posted by Liberte, 30/08/2010 1:59:39 PM, on The Canberra Times
A light rail connecting all suburbs to all schools to all shopping centres to all government offices - that should suit everyone.
Posted by Long Memory, 30/08/2010 2:18:02 PM, on The Canberra Times
A light rail system would end up be a costly white elephant which very few would utilise, like our bus service.
Posted by No Thanks, 30/08/2010 4:06:07 PM, on The Canberra Times
Dear 'No Thanks', there are four reasons ACTION is underutilised: it doesn't go where people want it to go (e.g. neither Deans nor Action go directly from Jerrabomberra into town); when they want to go and for a 'reasonable' cost - these three are of the Govt and the bus union's making - the final one is 'You!' If all three above a fixed, we still have to get Canberrans unwedded from their cars for daily work commuting.
Posted by Liberte, 30/08/2010 10:50:25 PM, on The Canberra Times
If a light rail system becomes a white elephant as claimed by "No Thanks", it will be a no poorer use of public finance than the shambolic GDE. The GDE was a farce from the moment MLA's of most colours fought tooth and nail for it, even when the Feds imposed the sub optimal eastern alignment as the only acceptable option. It's latest folly is the south bound lane onto the Tugg Pkwy from Parkes Way requiring a merge to the right when southbound vehicles exiting onto Lady Denman Drive will have to exit to the left. The traffic will crawl. This is the same mess as turning left off Hindmarsh Drive north on the Monaro Hwy and highway drivers want to exit to the left onto Canberra Ave. Why was the south bound Parkes Way lane not be brought under this new road and made the centre lane for the Tuggeranong Pkwy? Southerners on Parkes Way don't want to go onto Lady Denman Drive, as they could have done that 2-3km back. I cetainly would have preferred the hundreds of millions wasted on the GDE and it's subsequent bandaid rehashes to have been allocated to giving Gungahlin a head start in having a fast and efficient rapid transit system, something our meandering bus routes just can't provide.
Posted by Fine Whine, 30/08/2010 11:06:52 PM, on The Canberra Times
How about the taxpayer builds a commuter rail service from Yass,Cooma,Braidwood and Goulburn to Canberra/Qbn bus interchanges...it would only cost sqillions but a few motorists would probably use it...people drive cars because it's cheap,fast,on-demand 24/7 and the best way to travel short distances point to point...why build light rail system in Canberra when ACTION buses go more places and do a better job and still can't make a buck?
Posted by dusty, 31/08/2010 2:19:14 AM, on The Canberra Times
Great contribution " Fine Whine". If they could get thr Parkes way traffic onto the bridge-to-nowhere that would solve your problem.
Posted by Long Memory, 31/08/2010 10:45:22 AM, on The Canberra Times
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

LJ Hooker CIty

Feb Buy Smart
 
Feb Best Buys


The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...