News 
 Local News 
 Sport 
 Rugby League 
 Furner proves video killed the Raiders 

Furner proves video killed the Raiders

28 Jul, 2009 03:44 PM
The Canberra Raiders believe they are being victimised by video referees and they've got the statistics to prove it.

In the wake of match official Phil Cooley's decision to deny a Josh Dugan try in the Raiders' 25-4 loss to the Wests Tigers last Sunday, Canberra released figures yesterday showing it was the worst treated club in the NRL over the past five seasons.

Since round one this year, 20 decisions have been sent to the video referee, with the Raiders awarded tries just eight times or on 40 per cent of occasions.

In stark contrast, teams playing against Canberra have been favoured in 86 per cent of decisions involving the third official. Opposition teams have been denied four-pointers just three times this year.

The NRL average for tries awarded when a decision is sent upstairs is 64 per cent.

It's a statistic the club can't explain. Is it a lime green hoodoo or simply bad luck?

Canberra coach David Furner admits it's not the only factor working against his team, blaming too many poor team performances for the Raiders' plight. They sit in 14th place on the ladder after finishing sixth last season.

But the rough run of decisions including the one where Cooley ruled Bronson Harrison had obstructed Tigers defender Garteh Ellis in the lead-up to the Dugan ''try'' has left the coach baffled.

''I can't change the result, but what I can do is air my grievance with the decision,'' Furner said.

''That decision was made and it wasn't the reason why we lost that game. I'll never look at it that way.

''But I am a little bit annoyed that we aren't getting those sort of [close] calls. The frustration for me is that I know how much it changes a game where it's a try or a no try.

''When those incidents happen in a game it does take a bit out of the players and you can't be naive and say it doesn't.''

More Raiders news in today's Canberra Times

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
EVEN RIVAL CLUBS PLAYERS AND SUPPORTERS KNOW THE RAIDERS ARE GETTING A ROUGH DEAL . WHY IS IT SO.
Posted by BALDY, 28/07/2009 8:58:05 AM, on The Canberra Times
although i agree that the raiders do get the harsh calls against them, lets be realistic. the team has 1. a bad style of play that mirrors furners time at the raiders (straight through the middle) 2. no winning mentality 3. No dummy half 4. no experience in the coaching staff 5. no leaders on the field to put the bad calls behind them and put their head up. again yes we have had some bad calls but id be more concerned about the poor style of play with no direction. nobody can honestly say that the raiders deserve to be in the finals or any higher then were they are and i saw the stats in the telegraph last week that also said furner is the worst coach in the NRL.
Posted by wow, 28/07/2009 9:03:15 AM, on The Canberra Times
I can prove that the raiders are playing poorly. just watch the last home game
Posted by hahaha, 28/07/2009 9:26:35 AM, on The Canberra Times
This would not excuse the other 20 odd points the Tigers scored.. The Raiders should look at the Bulldogs or Storm's attitude, they have bad decisions aginst them but they hold firm, stick together and fight back as a team,.. not whinge & sook about the ref's. I agree we get the stiff calls,.. but always have & always will. However Neill Henry wasn't making this point last year because when you play well you take the refs out of the game. Suck it up Furner its 1st grade!!...
Posted by Reality, 28/07/2009 9:29:38 AM, on The Canberra Times
Stop whinging and blaming the officials, Furner! You are not NRL coaching quality, you cannot get the same team consistently on the paddock and they just don't perform well enough. No Home-game membership from me next year, in fact, I've sent my pass back already!
Posted by John D, 28/07/2009 9:45:52 AM, on The Canberra Times
It wasnt the video ref that lost the tigers game for them. it was dry weather game plan during constant rain, the continual one wide of the ruck then turn it back for an inside runner attacking plan, playing back rowers like trev and washed up players like turner in the front row, and the endless persistance with marc herbert that cost us that, and many other games this season, and there is one man responsible for that. So David Furner need to sort his own stuff out before he starts criticising others....
Posted by upset, 28/07/2009 9:50:13 AM, on The Canberra Times
Things might change if we take the blinkers off the coach and get rid of Stevie Wonder as half back
Posted by Bob, 28/07/2009 10:04:12 AM, on The Canberra Times
After he finishes having a look at the Video Ref, Lets hope he has a hard look at himself..
Posted by Worm, 28/07/2009 10:04:45 AM, on The Canberra Times
Phil Cooley, The same ref that gave the "no try" against Melbourne, The same Phil Cooley that crucified us against the eels early in the year & the same Phil Cooley that denied us against Souths for a couple of blatant tries this year... there is a pattern forming here... He hates the Raiders!! Maybe Furner should request not to have him do our games from now on..
Posted by Reality, 28/07/2009 10:08:17 AM, on The Canberra Times
As Phil Gould would say 'NO NO NO NO NO NO NO!' Who cares about the decisions of the referees, its something too easy to get hung up on, and something that you can never change. The fact is, you ask anyone playing any sport and they will tell you the ref was ordinary. It's time the Raiders did some soul-searching and look inwards instead of blaming things out of their control. There is no hunger there in the players at all!
Posted by ppp, 28/07/2009 10:13:31 AM, on The Canberra Times
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
The Raiders look dejected waiting for a video referee decision. Photo: ANDREW MEARES
The Raiders look dejected waiting for a video referee decision. Photo: ANDREW MEARES
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles

Australian Running Festival

Feb Best Buys


The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...