News 
 National News 
 National 
 General 
 $900 safe regardless of court decision: expert 

$900 safe regardless of court decision: expert

02 Apr, 2009 10:05 AM
Millions of taxpayers will eventually receive cash bonus payments even if the High Court rules the stimulus measure invalid, a legal expert says.

The court is expected to rule on Friday whether the Rudd government exceeded constitutional powers in legislating for the payments - up to $900 each for eligible taxpayers - due to distributed from next Monday.

George Williams, a senior law lecturer at the University of New South Wales, says taxpayers will get their money "one way or another" because the government would use another vehicle to implement the measure.

"I don't think people should be worried," he told ABC Radio.

But they might not be receiving the cash bonus as quickly as next week if the High Court rules the payments invalid.

"It's possible it would be delayed, maybe even quite significantly."

If the court rules against the payments there would be a "massive shift of power and influence" away from the commonwealth to the states, Professor Williams said.

The academic who initiated the challenge agrees with Professor Williams that the tax bonus will be paid somehow.

"Tomorrow, if I'm successful the government could still give the bonus just through ... giving a rebate and letting the money flow through the PAYG system," Bryan Pape told ABC Radio.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
SHOW ME THE MONEY
Posted by Charity Box, 2/04/2009 10:25:43 AM
Whitlam had made his mistake why Rudd shouldn't do the same. Don' worry he won’t be kicked out, but instead he will come up with something else for stronger support in gambling industry. $900.00 is strictly to use on gambling, booze and drugs. Hey 'KO7' where are computers for high schools? Are they still in production in 'CHINGLISH' country? 'WHO IS SAFE RUDD OR TAXPAYERS?'
Posted by BB-Leo, 2/04/2009 10:28:39 AM
Well I'm a pensioner....and do a little casual work for the company I used to work for full time.Centrelink takes a 40% cut from these meagre earnings!I filled in my tax form last year,but had a rebate...meaning of course that I had paid no tax....so I don't qualify.....if my rebate had been just one dollar less....I would have been able to claim the $900.Pensioners are being treated really badly all along the line....especially married pensioners.Homosexuals should think carefully before wanting to be treated like married couples!!!!!Think about it!
Posted by Mr.Magoo, 2/04/2009 10:34:38 AM
Will a miserely $900 paid to each individual "really?" stimulate the Mining Industry, the Building Industry, keep Pac jobs onshore, keep the Big 4 Banks from reducing their labour needs, or even save Govt Dept jobs that seem to be sliced from one end to the other? When Credit cards are maxed out- safety is in the peoples minds, first and foremost, not babies disposable nappies or tourism spent in a 3 night 'Bargin Package in the Hunter Valley'. Uncle Kevin ??? can you come back down to earth and think like real people, please. This would be the World's most Stupidest Economic Solution to be written in history. And the recession has not yet been admitted- let alone in the middle of the lay-offs.
Posted by adaptapensioner.com, 2/04/2009 10:48:51 AM
Handing back some of the tax I paid last year so I can reduce my mortgage doesn't stimulate the economy. It does, however, take money away from the government that should have been used to fund the 'education revolution' and infrastructure spending that would stimulate the economy. Further to this, the govt has also decided to press ahead with its climate change agenda AND roll back work choices. Business groups have said this will cost jobs (and it is starting to happen). I suppose you can't blame them - it's been so long since they've been in power they don't know what to do. I think I might start producing some "don't blame me, I didn't vote for them" bumper stickers. That should stimulate the economy.
Posted by Ken, 2/04/2009 1:33:52 PM
I can't see this pay out helping the country. Instead all these handouts, will more than likely help to break the country more. Leaving it up to the little people (low wage earners) having to pay more taxes just to get the country back on it's feet.
Posted by Deborah, 2/04/2009 2:23:23 PM
NOT FOR ME! I earned $30 under the tax free threshold and as a result will not get the $900 from K-Rudd..... I support myself... TOTALLY and study full time. I work enough to get food and rent and no money for text books which I have not baught because of this. I DON'T QUALIFY FOR CENTERLINK BENEFITS BECAUSE I WENT STRAIGHT FROM SCHOOL AND NEVER EARNT THE REQUIRED $18000 in 18 months..... HOW THE HELL AM I SUPPOSED TO DO THIS>?>>>>>???? I ride a bike to work and to uni and even then I can't afford to get the bike fixed if it should stop working! WHERE'S MY STIM. package??? So people earning $70,000+ need this money more than I do??? Am I more likley to spend the money at an Australian company rather than a chinese company to get a big screen TV??? YESSS SHOW """"ME""""" the money! Thanks for nothing K-Rudd you hopeless bucket of refuse. P.s. Don't bother complaining to the ATO.... Its got nothing to do with them apparently!!!!
Posted by Dylan Parker, 2/04/2009 9:50:37 PM
Got it in one Deborah. Complete waste of our taxes.
Posted by Bear, 2/04/2009 10:49:27 PM
I'm not sure about you guys, but $900 is a lot of money to me. I'm unemployed with two little ones under 4. Sure my wife works and i did have a job before this 'storm' hit. I paid my taxes and $900 is a fraction of them back. If the government doesn't need it, i'll have it back because i can use to survive. If you don't agree with it or want it, then be honest with yourself, don't be hypocrites. Give it back, or to a charity but don't keep it!
Posted by flaxton bumpy, 2/04/2009 11:50:24 PM
Pensioners are being treated really badly all along the line....especially married pensioners.
Posted by jimmyJackson, 2/04/2009 11:56:13 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES

Most popular articles

Australian Running Festival

CIT - Business ad dec
 
Feb Buy Smart
 
multicumulticultural festivalltural festival


The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...