News 
 National News 
 National 
 General 
 Body image panel 'too beautiful' 

Body image panel 'too beautiful'

28 Oct, 2009 08:18 AM
The fashion industry has been challenged to sign up to a voluntary code of conduct that will encourage the portrayal of realistic body images.

But Youth Minister Kate Ellis has been forced to defend her choice of advisers on the matter, who include supermodel Sarah Murdoch and columnist and former Cosmopolitan editor Mia Freedman.

The proposed national strategy on body image is designed to change practices in an industry notorious for choosing waif-like models and airbrushing imperfections.

The voluntary code calls for a standardised sizing system for clothes to discourage competitive weight loss, a ''positive body image checklist'' to be made available to school students and for organisations that choose to introduce ''positive body image practices'' to be publicly recognised.

But Ms Ellis was forced to defend the women she had chosen to advise her on body image issues.

''When I appointed this particular advisory group I did so on the basis of their backgrounds and their expertise and their passions in this area,'' she said.

''I saw that there was some sniping around the fact that they were incredibly attractive women at the same time that might be true, but they are also women who have worked in the magazine industry [and] in the modelling industry.''

Deakin University academic Ross King conceded the choice of body image advisers could send mixed messages to people concerned about their body image.

''I can see why people might say that. One would hope they had been chosen for other reasons, particularly their role in media as people who have been involved in the industry for a long time,'' he said.

Ms Ellis said the report would guide the Government on how to work with industry to promote acceptance of different sizes.

''Young people rated body image as their top concern in Mission Australia's National Survey of Young Australians in 2007 and at third in 2008. It can't be ignored,'' Ms Ellis said.

Freedman said she had chosen skinny models and had images re-touched during her time as editor of Cosmopolitan decisions she later regretted.

''This is what we want the industry to know there are economic benefits to this, this isn't just an altruistic community service. We believe the public are hungry for these products and these images of diversity and that their can be real economic benefits, too,'' she said.

''It [the fashion industry] can be a bit of a bubble, you can be a bit out of touch.''

Flinders University academic Marika Tiggemann defended the choice of advisers as ''not impossibly thin in the way that digitally altered images are''.

However, she said a mandatory code of conduct would be more effective than the proposed voluntary code.

''It's a start, it's a useful thing to do. Labelling digitally altered images makes people think about things rather than just seeing the images and accepting them,'' she said.

''It is well past time for something like this body image has become a major issue for many people. It used to be just for adolescent girls, but now younger and older people, boys and men too, are also more concerned about it.''

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Yup, i can see where the confusion is. At the same time i am a little concerned that an "acceptance" of differing body types may be blown out of proportion to the point in which being obese is "just another body type" while i do NOT think everyone will or should look like the current supermodels, we should also not swing to the other extreme, where it is acceptable to let go of your health. i have a few aunts that are on the jenny craig diet, and while they are never going to look like supermodels, they do look a lot healthier and happier for being a bit trimmer. i would appreciate seeing more fashion for the shorter, curvier (while not overweight) population too. anybody else see that report about aussie women getting shorter and curvier over the next 20 years? well its already happened to most of my family :-P
Posted by bec, 28/10/2009 8:33:57 AM
Well what do the critics want exactly? People deliberately chosen for the panel because they are ugly? If we're talking about 'sending messages', what message would that send?
Posted by Bellthorpe, 28/10/2009 9:49:36 AM
I can understand that these incredibly attractive women were chosen because of their experience in the industry, but they can thank their attractiveness for that experience. On the other hand, as soon as you put an older or less attractive woman, regardless of her experience and intelligence in the same position, the general public will assume that her opinion is based on envy and sour grapes.
Posted by Janny, 28/10/2009 10:24:56 AM
I would like to see more wrinkles and more curvy women, but I would be more worried about accepting even a slightly over-weight body weight as a normal thing. We need to be very careful that we don't swap the issues of poor self-esteem and eating disorders for issues arising from the obesity epidemic and diabetes. We need to backup the ideal of slim body image with information on calories and exercise. Sugar-free should become the norm. Advise people not to drink fruit juice. Support participation in sport and not the spectatorship. Reduce the serving sizes of foods. Add a tax if needed!
Posted by Paul, 28/10/2009 12:56:44 PM
Aah, the height of irony! A campaign striving for acceptance of the diversity of body images..being slammed because of their body image! It would seem they have a lot of work to do from the get-go, eh?
Posted by Nathan, 28/10/2009 1:29:56 PM
If you want to knock body image off the number one list of concerns for young people you need to fix the problem in the culture. The magazines aren't the problem. They are the symptom. The problem is that the focus of the culture is on individual. Young people think that they are the centre of the world. We need to give them another perspective. Let's organise school exchanges between city areas and Aboriginal outback areas. Let's take them to third world countries where they can learn what life is like for the other 3/4's of their peers. Then they will have an understanding of what a real problem is!
Posted by Paul, 28/10/2009 4:15:18 PM
people can we just be able to think for ourselves for once on this subject. Of course i prefer some curves, then again i ride a motorbike :)
Posted by The Bird, 28/10/2009 5:02:09 PM
This is getting out of hand. Yeah, I'm all for real women being models. Someone like Jessica Biel or something who have a nice figure. But fat women and men should not be models, it's a joke. What are they going to demand next? Models to wear clothes from Lowes because most people can't afford Gucci, Armani etc. It's pathetic, PC gone mad.
Posted by derp, 28/10/2009 7:34:38 PM
Obesity Epidemic! the greatest health problem of our generation. How many people are dying of this? We need more pressure to be thin because we are not getting it!
Posted by A, 2/11/2009 8:35:13 PM
Stick thin models don't even look healthly or happy. If you really look at them they have no shape about them. They are thin and have really no curves. The media should be encouraging men and women to be a healthy size and to love the curves that you have. Really there should be this much pressure on the models to be so thin, it really doesn't look to flash and they look unhappy.. Bring back some curves in the modeling industry
Posted by la, 13/11/2009 12:39:07 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Teenagers with Youth Minister Kate Ellis, left,and Mia Freedman, eating disorder survivor Danni Watts and Sarah Murdoch. Photo: GLEN McCURTAYNE
Teenagers with Youth Minister Kate Ellis, left,and Mia Freedman, eating disorder survivor Danni Watts and Sarah Murdoch. Photo: GLEN McCURTAYNE

MOST POPULAR

Yourguide to Your Toyota
Click here to read See Canberra online!
 
 
James Bond Happy Hour at Flint - click now
 
University of Canberra - click here
 
Red Hot Deals at Eurobodalla! click now
 
Ready, Set. Drive!
 
Classifieds
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...