News 
 National News 
 National 
 General 
 Voters divided over mining tax: poll 

Voters divided over mining tax: poll

25 May, 2010 09:55 AM
The mining sector pays significantly less company tax than the industry average, according to a Treasury analysis issued as the stoush over a super profits tax escalated.

The report published a month ahead of schedule comes as a poll shows Australians are divided over the 40 per cent tax on super profits from mining and the issue has dominated question time.

Opposition Leader Tony Abbott demanded yesterday the Government provide ''all Treasury and Tax Office modelling in relation to the great big new tax on mining''.

Resources Minister Martin Ferguson was ordered to withdraw his accusation the Opposition was against the tax because it was only interested in attracting ''grubby donations from certain sectors of the Australian community''.

And Treasurer Wayne Swan suggested the Opposition was doing the mining sectors' bidding by running an ''unprecedented, hysterical scare campaign which has been sponsored by those opposite and paid for by the Minerals Council ...''

A Treasury analysis circulated last night featured a chart that showed the mining sector's tax rate was 12 per cent below the average for all industries in 2004-05.

Over a decade, the mining sector's average company tax rate was 17 per cent compared with 26 per cent on average across all industries.

''The average tax rate is found to be relatively high in the finance and insurance industry and relatively low in the most capital intensive industries, such as electricity, gas and water, and mining,'' according to the Treasury paper.

The findings were similar to those in a paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research in the United States which Prime Minister Kevin Rudd described as ''credible'', but which Opposition finance spokesman Andrew Robb called ''the shonkiest piece of work''.

For more on this story, see the print edition of today's Canberra Times.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This is ludicrous...all the Fat Cats lined up squealing Armageddon and cessation of investment is an affront to the Australian people.The majority of executives have real form on the board...Rio Tinto Albanese danced with the Devil whilst his chief negotiator Stern Hu who made the company squillions was squandering his life in incarceration,placed there by a corrupt government who actually invented Bribery.Kloppers on the other hand has the similar Twang that originated from the land where greed is good and consequently we got the biggest financial meltdown in history.this is the simple fact...when the product is removed from the terra firma..Australians are left with just dust and pollution...nothing grows there again...4o% plus of all profits exit overseas and with the exception of a few..all those executives can calmly jump on a plane and leave the scene at will..they have another home to go to..We dont.Australians must be carefull that they do not end up selling their souls to outside clients..who in essence could not give 2hoots about Australia..so long as they can forfill their insatiable greed to benefit themselves..and finally..the miners are bluffing..watch this space.
Posted by cloak and dagger, 25/05/2010 10:16:34 AM, on The Canberra Times
The only value that counts is how much of the Net Presebnt Value of the free cash flow of a project will end up with tax payers - that is 37% now and will increase to 57% under the new system. Swan and Rudd are trying to confuse if they cannot convince. Use a simple cash flow model and you will see how tax is lower in the early years (as capital is depreciated) but increase significantly over the life of the project and that the government ends up with the bulk of the cash flow. No other industry (except petroleum) pay so much tax.
Posted by Hannes, 25/05/2010 2:16:45 PM, on The Canberra Times
Isn't it obvious that company tax does not include royalties? 17% excludes the royalties they pay and excludes payroll tax. Comparison of mining and insurance or other companies should be on "net tax paid" as a % of profits not just one tax element.
Posted by BleedingObvious, 25/05/2010 4:12:34 PM, on The Canberra Times
Mining Super Tax will cut Australian jobs,investment onto domestic mining industry and export of mining products. It's bad idea.Goverment should try to cut budget instead of increasing tax and introduce new tax. The most of mining companies pay less than 5% dividend per year or pay none dividnend for more than 10 years. Who will invest their money onto Australian mining companies in the future? Cancell the bad idea,please!~
Posted by Bad Politician, 3/06/2010 10:13:02 AM, on The Canberra Times
Who will invest in Australia in the future ? Same people that invest now do you people think minining resources grow on trees around the world ? They are scarse as it is these companies are getting billions shouldnt some of that come back to us after all i its Australias resources that they are exploiting and at a large rate what happens when the resources are gone and they pack up and leave ?? Sure lets not tax them anything lets not take a chunk out of that pie lets just let them have it all in case they leave and take jobs with them !! wouldnt it cost them more to leave and build somewhere else than to pay the tax ?? We are not scaring investors we are just taking whats fair they are exploiting our resources and are making billions this tax its just a tiny portion .
Posted by lou, 24/06/2010 2:06:23 PM, on The Canberra Times

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

LJ Hooker CIty

Feb Best Buys


The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...