News 
 Opinion 
 Letters to the Editor 
 General 
 Two-state treaty essential for Middle East peace 

Two-state treaty essential for Middle East peace

01 Jan, 2009 01:00 AM
The approach taken by The Canberra Times in publishing two opposing ideas about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as the cases for and against Israel perpetuates an unfortunate view about the conflict.

This idea, that the fault and responsibility for conflict lies exclusively on one side, is misleading and has poisoned diplomatic efforts. While terrorism is never a legitimate tactic, many Palestinians have resorted to it due to widespread disillusionment with negotiations and diplomatic options.

The failure to resolve such problems as settlements in the West Bank, Jerusalem, the treatment of Palestinians across the nation and, recently, the military blockade of the Gaza strip, has made many feel that negotiations are incapable of producing results.

As a stateless people scattered across the world (much as the Jews once were) they have little political power and no real ability to influence the Israeli Government. The resulting terrorism and targeting of civilians, however, must be condemned.

If Israel does continue the bombing raids or launch an invasion of Gaza, all that will result is the deaths of hundreds of people, many either civilians or just police recruits who just wanted a stable job, and the further polarisation of the region.

As many commentators, including The Canberra Times, have pointed out, the only thing that will bring lasting peace and security is not a military offensive, but a workable peace treaty establishing two viable independent states.

Polarising the issue as just the cases for or against Israel won't help achieve this.

Joshua Smith, Gordon

The Australian Government's response to the massacre in Gaza is despicable.

As one-and-a-half million people crowded in the small strip of Palestinian land were being pounded with Israeli bombs, Julia Gillard called on Hamas and other militants to cease shelling Israel shells which generally fell harmlessly in fields, although one Israeli was reported killed.

So apparently it is acceptable to our Government for the Palestinians to be under siege and to have a third of their land occupied by Israel, and to face death daily from starvation, lack of clean water, childbirth, while being detained needlessly at checkpoints, facing home demolitions and Israeli bullets and shells, but if they respond even modestly with homemade rockets, one of the few options open to them, then they are inviting this onslaught, one that is 400-fold more lethal, on themselves.

David Bastin, Nicholls

It was a nice touch for The Canberra Times to publish the case for, and the case against, Israel (''Deep chasm in Gaza bloodbath'', December 30, p11), and to balance the two points of view with an editorial which emphasised that diplomatic initiative, not confrontation and defiance, was the only way to solve the Palestinian problem (''Israel plays into hands of Hamas'', December 30).

However, rather than search for a solution for the Gaza and the West Bank Palestinians by marginalising Hamas, the two leaderships should be persuaded by their oil-rich neighbours that their peoples' dream would only be realised if they were to cast aside their differences.

In return, Saudi Arabia, the Gulf States and Iraq would undertake to use their powerful bargaining card, as major oil-producing countries, to inform America the only nation that has any influence in Tel Aviv that the flow of oil is conditional on there being a solution to the Palestinian issue.

If the Arab nations truly believe in the Palestinian cause, they should stop looking to the outside world for a solution that is within their grasp.

Sam Nona, Burradoo

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Most popular articles

Australian Running Festival



The Canberra Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...