JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

New feature Personalise your news, save articles to read later and customise settings View Demo

Hi there! Beta version

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

National Times

All-white Australian television fails the reality test

Melissa Phillips
February 17, 2012

Opinion

The cast of 1970s Australian comedy show Kingswood Country. Australian television has not travelled very far in representing our diverse society accurately and fairly.

The cast of 1970s Australian comedy show Kingswood Country. Australian television has not travelled very far in representing our diverse society accurately and fairly.

Recent comments by actors Jay Laga'aia and Firass Dirani about their experiences of racism when working in the mainstream media have been called offensive by commercial television representatives. What I think is offensive is that even today mainstream television hardly reflects Australia's true diversity. Outcries from actors within the industry need to be matched by outrage from viewers.

I grew up as a child of migrant parents in the early 1980s watching Kingswood Country, interestingly screened on the same channel that Laga'aia has accused of only wanting to cast white characters – Channel Seven. In Kingswood Country I learned that it was all right to laugh as the main character called his son-in-law a "bloody wog" or made racist comments about indigenous Australians. New migrants were parodied for their funny accents and different ways.

Australians of Anglo-Saxon backgrounds could be assured that their rough treatment of new Australians was merely tough love, an initiation into Australia's unique brand of mateship.

Luckily this was all turned on its head by Acropolis Now, also screened on Channel Seven, where "wogs" featured front and centre. No more comedic foils to a racist Ted Bulpitt of Kingswood Country, the team of Acropolis Now, who also made the stage show Wogs out of Work, parodied themselves putting Australians of Anglo-Saxon background in marginal roles for a change.

Growing up in Sydney's inner west, I revelled in seeing characters I could relate to on the small screen. Finally, I felt like I belonged in an Australian society where television held up a mirror and reflected back my reality. How naive I was to think that this was the beginning of a change in representing Australia's diversity in our mainstream media.

Fast forward two decades and what do we see on our television stations? Polar opposites of a few token ethnic characters in mainstream television shows and a whole channel devoted to diverse programming in SBS, with very little in between.

Carbo, the only non-Anglo Aussie character on Packed to the Rafters, could have been plucked straight out of Acropolis Now with his stereotypical Greek family – cue hysterical mother and Carbo's wog mansion house. The streets of Neighbours hardly look like any suburban city in Australia with its white families.

As the comedians Fear of a Brown Planet have pointed out, we would be puzzled if we entered a hospital like the one in All Saints and not see a single Asian-Australian doctor.

Beyond drama, the same accusations of failing to hire outside of narrow (white) parameters could be directed at news and current affairs programs. Of course this means limited employment possibilities for Australian actors and television journalists of all shapes, sizes and colours. But what about us, the television viewing public?

We are left to choose between shows that marginalise ethnic characters through ancient stereotypes or, if we want to view diversity, flick over to "our" dedicated channel SBS that we should be happy to have and stop complaining.

Yet diversity is commercially viable. We knew that when Acropolis Now and Wogs out of Work became huge successes with sell-out stage shows for many years. Dirani was voted by the public as Cleo magazine's Bachelor of the Year in 2010.

Multiculturalism and diversity is part of a brand that the state government of Victoria, for example, sees as its niche in attracting visitors and businesses to Melbourne. Most importantly, diversity is the reality of modern Australian society.

It is time for the viewing public to support such actors as Laga'aia and Dirani and get behind their demands for more ethnically diverse casting in the Australia media. We can do this by switching off shows that lazily feed us false images of Australia.

I'll confess to being slightly addicted to Packed to the Rafters, with its nuclear family, pronounceable names, nicely mowed lawns and white suburban characters. But I'm starting to feel that the guilty viewing pleasure is leaving too bad a taste in my mouth.

Like a lot of Australians I loved The Slap, where everyday Australia's cultural diversity was represented as ordinary. Television shows such as this, and their commercial success, have reassured me that a diverse Australia can be found in the mainstream media.

It is up to us, the viewing public, to let programmers and commercial television stations know our demands. Then it is hoped it won't take another 20 years for these changes to happen.

Melissa Phillips is a doctoral candidate at the University of Melbourne.

twitter Follow the National Times on Twitter: @NationalTimesAU

14 comments

  • Totally agree with you but does TV around the world represent the culture its audience is aimed at?
    I have spent the last 5 years working in Malaysia and the soaps there are all very mono-cultural. For instance, a Malay soap opera will have all Malays, a separate Chinese soap will be all Chinese. Occasionally, these soaps will have other ethnicities included in a story but usually as a negative and very stereotyped character.

    Commenter
    Gordie
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    February 20, 2012, 8:40AM
    • @Gordie - ...but Australia is the nation that shouts its multi-cultural success story from the rooftops to anyone within coo-ee. We should put our money where our mouth is and have our mainstream TV productions reflect the scope of diversity we proclaim to value.

      Commenter
      Lejuan
      Location
      Canberra
      Date and time
      February 20, 2012, 10:03AM
  • Nationally indigenous phenotypes represent about 2% of the population, Asians about 4.5% Therefore the 'face of Australia' remains essentially Anglo-Celtic.

    We are and seem to intend on being politically tied to the British Queen's apron strings in our 'constitutional monarchy' arrangement and we soak up whatever cultural trash the USA throws at us through commercial T.V.-CNN.

    Although my personal interests lie outside these blinkered world views, most Australians I would imagine are getting exactly what they want from the programmes they watch..The producers ultimately want to make money..don't they?

    Commenter
    Ima Sponge.
    Location
    Armidale,N.S.W.
    Date and time
    February 20, 2012, 9:25AM
    • Firstly, where do you get your statistics from?

      And no, producers don't necessarily give the audience what they want. I don't watch a single Australian-made TV show because none of them satisfy me. Perhaps my opinion doesn't matter to them?

      Commenter
      Bridget
      Location
      Melbourn
      Date and time
      February 20, 2012, 1:53PM
  • Shows like The Slap are very successful and mirror society as it really is, but commercial television is not interested.
    Home and Away and Neighbours are not supposed to be a real version of life as it is really is and so they really are just giving the kids want they want to see.
    That's why we have the ABC and SBS so as to cater for the more discerning viewers who are sick of so called "reality" shows and fluff.

    Commenter
    Al48
    Location
    Gippsland
    Date and time
    February 20, 2012, 9:35AM
  • Since many Aussie soaps make their money because fo English viewers, and more than one British actor has commented on how very white these soap-stars are, is it really Aussie racism or a combination of factors that promote this vision?

    And if we do get mixed races on TV, be prepared for negative portrayal of any minority group having the PC wolves howling at the moon.

    Curiously, multiculturalism and PC may help prevent mixed races appearing on scrren! Who wants the agro and the legal bills?

    Commenter
    Aelred
    Location
    Rievaulx
    Date and time
    February 20, 2012, 9:58AM
  • Yes, let's have more ethnically diverse actors on TV but Jay Laga'aia's complaints are interesting. He's done pretty well out of the Australian television industry. It seems he wasn't too worried about 'racism' while he had a gig.

    Commenter
    Space Monkey
    Location
    Melbourne
    Date and time
    February 20, 2012, 10:27AM
    • Read his comments again. Nowhere does he use the word "racist". The tv network said it, and now the media is saying it. "Racism" and all its derivatives are words that appear to be used to end an argument. But to claim someone is racist IS offensive and quite an accusation. I think Jay knows this, which is why he never said the word.
      All he did, is merely make an observation that is quite a valid one.
      However, multiculturalism is certainly bandied around as a hallmark of the Australian way of life, but to what extent do we all actually live it? In my experience - and certainly not always, and certainly not everyone - ethnic groups often stick together. Some suburbs and the schools in them have a larger concentration of ethnic groups than others, so it stands to reason that, for the most part, our friendship circles may include those from our own ethnicity and culture.
      I agree that our tv should reflect our diversity a lot more and in meaningful, non-tokenistic ways. But I would also argue that we shouldn't be as proud of our "multiculturalism" as we seem to be, because largely, it is something of a myth.

      Commenter
      Heisenberg
      Location
      Townsville
      Date and time
      February 20, 2012, 11:29AM
    • You're right Heisenberg - but I didn't call Jay racist. He was implying that there's not enough diversity on Aus TV because of ... what? My point is that he had nothing to say about lack of diversity while he had a job in the very industry he's complaining about.

      Commenter
      Space Monkey
      Location
      Melbourne
      Date and time
      February 20, 2012, 12:12PM
  • I agree that this is an issue worth debating, but I don't think Jay Laga'aia's comments should be the catalyst. He has had a very successful career in Australia and has been cast in two of our longest-running and most successful programs, Play School and Home & Away. As a New Zealander of Samoan heritage, you would think he would have more chance of representation on NZ television in that the Pacific Islander population of New Zealand is a far greater percentage of the overall population than it is in Australia. And yet, he has made a living here in "racist" Australia.

    I haven't watched Home & Away since childhood, but we do know it is the norm for soap characters to come in and out of these programs, while only a minority remain for years. Wikipedia says his character was a Reverend, a role that I can't imagine as a ten-year fixture of a teen program.

    I think we do see a much greater range of faces on television advertisements, reality tv programs, SBS and ABC. There is a last bastion of whiteness on some of the commercial dross, like soaps, but that too will change with time. Also remember that there are lots of biases in television: for instance, show me the female aged and overweight newsreader, as is acceptable for men. I think we can never expect television to accurately mirror a society as it is essentially there to sell us things and is presenting an ideal or a fantasy.

    Commenter
    Michelle
    Location
    Date and time
    February 20, 2012, 11:00AM

More comments

Comments are now closed