JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Old gripe about refs, same old result for Smith's plucky Roosters


Greg Prichard


Flightless bird ... Martin Kennedy of Sydney Roosters is taken to the ground in a tackle during yesterday’s match against Brisbane. The Broncos won 40-22, despite  several players being absent due to State of Origin duty.

Flightless bird ... Martin Kennedy of Sydney Roosters is taken to the ground in a tackle during yesterday’s match against Brisbane. The Broncos won 40-22, despite several players being absent due to State of Origin duty. Photo: Getty Images

To their credit, Sydney Roosters coach Brian Smith and captain Braith Anasta said controversial decisions by the match officials - the majority of which went against their side - didn't cost them the game.


It would be stretching it to make that excuse when you have been beaten by 18 points, but, hey, this is rugby league. Plenty of reasons have been thrown up to justify even bigger margins over the years.

Feeling the squeeze ... Dunamis Lui of the Broncos.

Feeling the squeeze ... Dunamis Lui of the Broncos. Photo: Getty Images

''It turned the game a bit, but we did that to ourselves way more often than the referees did it to us,'' Smith said of the try by second-rower Alex Glenn, which came in the 43rd minute and with the Broncos leading 16-12. Brisbane winger Lachlan Maranta stole the ball, after an eternity, from Roosters centre Joseph Leilua and raced away without the referees stopping play. Glenn scored on the next tackle.

Anasta added: ''I wouldn't say it's cost us the game, because we cost ourselves the game. But it doesn't help and it's frustrating, and I don't know how to approach it any more.''

We're hearing you, Braith. No one knows how to approach some of the decisions that were made by the match officials yesterday, but referees bosses Bill Harrigan and Stuart Raper are going to have to try to find some way of working it out.

But if the match officials didn't cost the Roosters the game, and they had only two players - halfback Mitchell Pearce and centre Shaun Kenny-Dowall - out compared to nine for the Broncos, then what does it say about how the Roosters are going with 12 rounds left before the finals? Nothing good, when it comes to their chances of doing something this season. They have lost four straight games and six of their last seven to fall to 14th place.

Asked if he thought the season was slipping away, Smith replied: ''Yeah, it feels like that. We've probably got to win seven games from where we are now, maybe eight. There's plenty of time left if we're good enough.''

But the next five rounds for the Roosters go like this: Wests Tigers away, Manly at home, bye, Cronulla away and South Sydney at home. On present form they would start as outsiders in each of those four games.

When the Roosters won four of their first six games this season, it didn't appear a true reflection of where they were at. Things looked more realistic when they lost the next two, leaving them with a win-loss record of 4-4, but now they are 5-8.

Brisbane put the heat on the Roosters early, and scored first to make it 6-0. The Roosters fought back to level things up, and then the Broncos made it 10-6. But the Roosters looked like going to the half-time break with the lead, 12-10, until Brisbane halfback Peter Wallace was awarded a controversial try when it appeared he may have been guilty of a double movement.

In the second half, the Broncos got away to a 22-12 lead that the Roosters cut to six, and a 28-16 lead that the Roosters also cut to six, so it is clear the Roosters kept trying. But two tries in the last five minutes to Brisbane finally blew the score out.

A Roosters fan could be heard making abusive comments directed at the Roosters' coaching box late in the game. Asked whether he had heard it, Smith said: ''I heard the abuse, but that goes with the territory. I don't think there was anything offensive, it's just what coaches commonly get when their teams aren't winning.''

BRISBANE 40 (G Beale A Glenn L Maranta C Norman J Reed B Te'o P Wallace tries P Wallace 6 goals) bt SYDNEY ROOSTERS 22 (T Arona J Friend J Leilua T Moga tries B Anasta 3 goals) at Allianz Stadium. Referees: Matt Cecchin, Adam Devcich. Crowd: 9738.


Related Coverage

Live: Sydney Roosters v Brisbane Broncos

Join sports reporter Chris Barrett as the Roosters host the Broncos.

This time it's personal: Queensland angered by Stuart's smug jibe

PROP Dave Shillington has made it clear Queensland will take added motivation into the second State of Origin game after NSW coach Ricky Stuart accused them of being smug and ungracious winners.

Debutants have a ball against Chooks

DESPITE the fact they were without three of their State of Origin players, Brisbane knew they had been poor in losing to Melbourne two rounds ago. Yesterday, they restored their reputation in their own eyes by beating Sydney Roosters - and they were without a lot more players this time than they were against the Storm.

Anasta baffled by more bizarre calls as coach struggles to come up with an answer

IT WAS as if Brian Smith was attempting to explain a UFO sighting. Little wonder Braith Anasta buried his melon on the desk he sat behind for last night's news conference at Allianz Stadium, exasperated to his core. ''I'm trying to do what the ref did to you, Braith,'' Smith said, turning to Anasta. ''He tried to come up with a reason.''

Five things we learnt from yesterday's match

Four points outside the top eight and with Wests Tigers, Manly, Cronulla and South Sydney to come in their next four matches, it is increasingly looking like a bleak campaign at Bondi Junction.

Marooned Blues need to muster Manly mindset to turn tables

Todd Carney was ''a bit of a mess'' before Origin I and appeared to be ''fighting something in his head'' but NSW teammates are confident the Cronulla five-eighth will not be as troubled by nerves on Wednesday night. Hopefully for the Blues, those predictions are right because Queensland are unlikely to play as badly as they did in the series opener - yet NSW still lost.

Stuart swears his Blue heart on his sleeve

The first time I tried to interview Ricky Stuart he told me to "f*** off"' - or words to that effect.

From Origin to no football in three weeks: blunder ref to be dumped

Under-siege referee Matt Cecchin is likely to complete an unceremonious fall from State of Origin and the top grade in the space of three weeks, with referees bosses Bill Harrigan and Stuart Raper set to give him a spell from the NRL this weekend.

Related Coverage

Follow Us on Facebook

Featured advertisers