JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Harrigan ruling on charge-down justifies Flanagan fury

Date

Brad Walter

Earning his stripes … West Tigers's Adam Blair steals the ball away from the Sharks' Anthony Tupou. Wests Tigers won thanks to a golden-point field goal from Benji Marshall.

Earning his stripes … West Tigers's Adam Blair steals the ball away from the Sharks' Anthony Tupou. Wests Tigers won thanks to a golden-point field goal from Benji Marshall. Photo: Steve Christo

REFEREES boss Bill Harrigan will confirm today that Cronulla should not have been penalised in extra time and is also expected to investigate whether video referee Steve Clark told the Sharks a disallowed try should have been awarded.

MATCH STATS

Controversy over the two decisions dominated post-match discussion at Leichhardt Oval yesterday after Wests Tigers five-eighth Benji Marshall kicked a 37 metre field goal to give his side 17-16 win in extra time.

Rugby League round 1 Wests Tigers v Cronulla Sharks  at Leichhardt Oval Click for more photos

Bend it like Benji

Rugby League round 1: Wests Tigers v Cronulla Sharks at Leichhardt Oval. Pictures by Steve Christo on Sunday, March 4th, 2012. Photo: Steve Christo

Cronulla coach Shane Flanagan believed the rulings had cost his team two competition points and said Clark had told him centre Colin Best should not have had a 63rd minute try disallowed as it was not a double movement.

''That is a try every day of the week to me, and the video referee is two boxes up from me, and he said it was a try,'' said Flanagan, who called for referees to refer rulings on tries upstairs if there is any doubt. ''He should have gone to the video ref, and he [Clark] said it was a try. You have got a a video ref, so use him. If you are not going to use them, get rid of it and save some money. Give it to the junior league or something.''

Sharks captain Paul Gallen said referee Jared Maxwell had told him he had no doubt it was a double movement but Best believed he had scored. ''It would have been nice to have it but that is the way it goes,'' Best said. ''He [Maxwell] just ruled straight away.''

The Sharks led 14-12 at the time, and with the scores level at 16-all after 80 minutes the match went into extra time. With Todd Carney's kick-off rebounding off the uprights, Cronulla gained possession on the Tigers' line and the new Sharks playmaker attempted a field goal on the second tackle.

However, Tigers forwards Chris Heighington and Aaron Woods charged down the kick, and Maxwell penalised Cronulla for offside after Marshall was tackled with the ball on his own line.

Harrigan, who was not at the game and had not seen a replay when the Herald spoke to him, confirmed Flanagan's view that a player can not be offside after a charge down.

''All I can say is that according to the rules, once a player has charged down the ball he puts everybody back onside,'' Harrigan said. ''Other than that, I won't make any comment until we have done our debrief.''

However, he is expected to ask Clark about the context of his conversation with Flanagan.

Asked if had approached Clark or the video referee had come to see him, Flanagan said: ''He was two boxes up, I could see them and they said it was a try.''

He said the refereeing decisions had cost his team two competition points, telling the post-match media conference: ''In the end it did cost us the game. Referees are under pressure but so is he [Gallen] and so am I.''

Tigers coach Tim Sheens didn't want to offer a view on either decision but he pointed out that a number of controversial calls had gone against his team.

''We are all going to be upset with the officials at some stage but I think we had plenty of chances on both side,'' Sheens said. ''I feel for Cronulla in that respect but we were pinged twice for offside and none for them, so I am a bit disappointed in those sort of things.''

Teammates praised Heighington and Woods for making the charge-down on Carney's attempted field goal. ''It was great work by Chris to get out there and just get a hand to it and push it wide,'' Gareth Ellis said. ''It was a great effort, particularly at that time of the game.''

Prop Keith Galloway said: ''I feel a bit for Cronulla. We probably got a bit lucky with what happened after that, but that's football and we will take the win.''

WESTS TIGERS 17 (B Ryan 2 B Marshall tries B Marshall 2 goals B Marshall field goal) bt CRONULLA 16 (C Best T Carney I De Gois tries T Carney 2 goals) in golden-point extra time at Leichhardt Oval. Referee: Jared Maxwell, Chris James. Crowd: 19,762

18 comments so far

  • The Sharks are wingeing again, gee what a surprise. They had plenty of chance to prevent the last try to Beau Ryan and should have made the most out of the getting the ball from the kick-off in extra time. Maybe Shane Flanagan should be complaining about their execution and composure.

    Commenter
    KP
    Date and time
    March 05, 2012, 7:41AM
    • First try from the sharks was a off a forward pass. Later in the first half Gardner clearly knock the ball on from a bomb just off his line and the scrum was awarded to the sharks. If these rulings were made correct the sharks should not have been in the game.
      Stop your winging Cronulla, it's the same every game you lose. Ref's make mistakes both ways it evens out in the end.

      Commenter
      RIW
      Date and time
      March 05, 2012, 8:12AM
      • well said mate!

        Commenter
        tigervicas
        Location
        balmain
        Date and time
        March 05, 2012, 10:44AM
    • I concur with RIW. I generally prefer to read Fairfax papers because of their reputation for unbiased reporting, but why is there no mention of a 1 metre forward pass for Cronulla's first try???

      I dont see any Tigers players or coaching staff whining about that 4 point gift to the Sharks in a such a tight contest!

      Commenter
      Chuckers
      Date and time
      March 05, 2012, 8:30AM
      • I'm neither a Tigers nor Sharks fan. Ref mistakes like fwd passes and incorrect try rulings happen. But wrongly interpreting rules such as the offside penalty for a charge down need to be subject to scrutiny, especially in golden point extra time where so many results are influenced by penalties. The fair outcome here would to give the two teams one point each.

        Commenter
        stevek
        Location
        Sydney
        Date and time
        March 05, 2012, 8:54AM
        • It's so typical of the insidious bias shown by referees toward the big name clubs. The rulings favour those that are perceived to be top 4 material about 80:20 and then there is the home ground syndrome. I could care-less about either of these clubs, but Cronulla were dudded.

          Commenter
          daffy
          Date and time
          March 05, 2012, 9:20AM
          • Yeah I notice Flanagan didn't mention the forward pass for the Sharks' first try.

            Referees make subjective calls, there is no way that the rules can be enforced in a manner that is 100% objective.

            In a game not too far in the future the Sharks will win a game based on a controversial decision, and Flanagan won't say "we didn't deserve to win".

            Commenter
            Alex
            Date and time
            March 05, 2012, 9:45AM
            • The referees were appalling but it went both ways. Cronullas first try had a forward pass, a dropped bomb by cronulla was deemed to give them the feed, a tigers player was punched on the ground and told it was just part of the game, the tigers were held down and never got a penalty but the Carney try came off a hold down penalty...it goes on and on. Cronulla won the penalty count and got all the 50/50 calls till refs realised they had cost the Tigers the game and went for the square up. Can Bill please investigate the whole game, he wont because he has always hated the Tigers.

              Commenter
              Greg
              Location
              Maroubra
              Date and time
              March 05, 2012, 12:11PM
              • Dodgy calls go both ways in the NRL. If you complain about it afterwards, then it makes you look like a sore loser. Suck it up Cronulla!!!

                Commenter
                Six Degrees
                Location
                Separation
                Date and time
                March 05, 2012, 12:29PM
                • The porch light is still on

                  Commenter
                  FROG
                  Location
                  MANLY
                  Date and time
                  March 05, 2012, 12:31PM

                  More comments

                  Make a comment

                  You are logged in as [Logout]

                  All information entered below may be published.

                  Error: Please enter your screen name.

                  Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

                  Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

                  Error: Please enter your comment.

                  Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

                  Post to

                  You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

                  Thank you

                  Your comment has been submitted for approval.

                  Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

                  Related Coverage

                  Rugby League round 1 Wests Tigers v Cronulla Sharks  at Leichhardt Oval  Sunday March 4th 2012. Pictures Steve Christo Bend it like Benji

                  Rugby League round 1: Wests Tigers v Cronulla Sharks at Leichhardt Oval. Pictures by Steve Christo on Sunday, March 4th, 2012.

                  Pritchard poleaxe a point of contention

                  BULLDOGS enforcer Frank Pritchard apologised to David Simmons after his controversial tackle knocked out the Penrith winger on Saturday night.

                  Toovey scoops the pot after aces leave him staring at first-up flop

                  BOTH rookie coaches were smiling, but if this were a game of poker, that couldn't be considered a ''tell'' on the part of Brian McClennan, for he and his smile are rarely parted.

                  Sheens keeps the faith as Tedesco's debut ends in tears

                  THERE will be a mountain of good wishes for rookie Wests Tigers fullback James Tedesco after his heartbreaking injury yesterday but, to reconcile himself with what has happened, he is best advised to listen to the words of his coach, Tim Sheens.

                  The charge down stand-down: referee and touch judge dumped after Sharks slip-up

                  Officials stood down over golden-point blunder that sparked Sharks fury

                  Related Coverage

                  Four Nations 2014

                  Round 1
                  Sat, 25 OctTimes shown AEDT
                  ENG 32 vs SAM 26 Stats
                  AUS 12 vs NEWZ 30 Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 2
                  Sat, 01 NovTimes shown AEDT
                  NEWZ 14 vs SAM 12 Report Stats
                  Sun, 02 NovTimes shown AEDT
                  AUS 16 vs ENG 12 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Round 3
                  Sat, 08 NovTimes shown AEDT
                  NEWZ 16 vs ENG 14 Report Stats
                  Sun, 09 NovTimes shown AEDT
                  AUS 44 vs SAM 18 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Final
                  Sat, 15 NovTimes shown AEDT
                  NEWZ 22 vs AUS 18 Report Stats
                  View All Fixtures
                  Four Nations 2014
                  Overall standings
                  Team P W L D +/- Pts
                  New Zealand 3 3 0 0 22 6
                  Australia 3 2 1 0 12 4
                  England 3 1 2 0 0 2
                  Samoa 3 0 3 0 -34 0
                  View all
                   
                  Featured advertisers