JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Battle heating up for Wallabies' five-eighth spot

Date

Paul Cully

TIGHT FIVE

15. Jesse Mogg (Brumbies) Click for more photos

Australian team of the week - February 24, 2013

Paul Cully picks the best performed Australian players from the weekend Super Rugby games. Photo: Getty Images

1. Quade Cooper has work to do to challenge the sceptics.

There was a hint of the 2011 swagger returning as the Reds five-eighth probed for spaces and sought to expose lazy defenders with the inside ball, but that is only part of the modern No.10's portfolio. The Reds' decision to shield him from defensive duties underscores his continued lack of tackling clout and some of his less judicious distribution is still as likely to put the recipient in hospital as into a gap. Curiously, the man who occupies the Wallabies' No.10 come June might not have even played at five-eighth in the first two rounds for his franchise, although Matt Toomua's brutal defence on Kurtley Beale to set up the Brumbies' first try is the sort of work that will attract approving nods. If the Wallabies do go down the path of naming an initial, protected list of players for Lions duty, Cooper's first challenge is to make sure he is on it.

 

Work to do ... Quade Cooper.

Work to do ... Quade Cooper. Photo: Getty Images

2. Selection at No.15 emphasised Folau's vulnerabilities rather than his strengths.

His athletic gifts are undeniable, but at fullback Israel Folau looked like he had been set a particularly taxing multiple-choice test in a foreign language. Dom Shipperley was not even thinking about scoring when he was put into space by Quade Cooper early on, but Folau's passive defence presented the winger with an opportunity impossible to ignore. He will improve, but his education might be best continued from the wing, allowing the promising Ben Volavola to occupy the No.15 jersey.

 

3. The result was the same but the problems were new.

Although there were some familiar failings in the Waratahs' performance - NSW were lucky Michael Harris was standing at No.10 when stray throws from Tatafu Polota-Nau set up Reds counter-attacks - it was the very newness of the game plan that caused the most problems. The Tahs committed 16 handling errors as the demands of the uptempo style took its toll. There is a lot to like in the approach although dropped ball can be a nasty habit that is hard to shake if it takes hold in the early rounds. But the Rebels, next weekend's opponents, looked worryingly vulnerable against the Brumbies when the visitors turned up the physicality and should present Michael Cheika's men with an opportunity to make those offloads stick.

 

4. Liam Gill was the pick of the Australian No.7s.

It suits the Reds to portray Gill as somewhat overlooked, but no one would hold any other opinion of Gill except a high one. He won a crucial turnover with about 10 minutes to go and in the last meaningful act of the game there he was again, hard over the ball and taking the physical punishment that goes with his trade to secure another penalty. The Reds - with valuable contributions from substitutes Jarrad Butler, James Hanson and Albert Anae - were excellent in this area when it mattered: body positions low and legs driving. Their extra week of match hardness probably told.

 

5. Ben Mowen is quicker than you thought.

The Brumbies captain would have heard the talk - he isn't athletic enough, he isn't physical enough - but he has answered those critics. He showed Scott Higginbotham and Kurtley Beale a clean pair of heels for his try in Melbourne, and is bringing impact to the breakdown. Bigger tests await in the New Zealand and South African back-rowers, but he has started ably.

TEAM OF THE WEEK

1. Ben Alexander (Brumbies)

2. Stephen Moore (Brumbies)

3. James Slipper (Reds)

4. Scott Fardy (Brumbies)

5. Rob Simmons (Reds)

6. Ed Quirk (Reds)

7. Liam Gill (Reds)

8. Ben Mowen (Brumbies)

9. Nic White (Brumbies)

10. Matt Toomua (Brumbies)

11. Digby Ioane (Reds)

12. Christian Lealifaano (Brumbies)

13. Ben Tapuai (Reds)

14. Dom Shipperley (Reds)

15. Jesse Mogg (Brumbies)

24 comments so far

  • Israel Folau is still defending space trying to shut down the forward attacking option of a hand pass or a cross kick towards goal.
    He needs to spend a season playing Brisbane club rugby, and an ITM cup campaign with whoever Tana Umanga coaches later this year.

    When did the offside rule change from being behind the last foot to half a metre in front of the last foot when you're defending in the oppositions half. And that applies to every game in the comp not just the Australian conference.

    If the Wallabies can play with the intensity and speed of the Brumbies we're in for a ripper Lions series. Every game will be worth watching

    The Waratahs haven't changed I'll still be recording and fast forwarding through the numerous, catch your breath, injury breaks.

    Reds needed to recruit better in the forwards. For all his yellow cards and brain explosions Higgenbotham kept the opposition on their toes and will be missed.

    I haven't watched the Force v Kings yet but based on last weeks performance against the Rebels they looked "light" in the forwards and they don't have the close to the ruck Sharpe fall back option this year so the Kings result wasn't unsurprising. The West is in for a long season littered with hope and disappointment.

    Re: Vinny Munro and Frank Halai. Has the penalty try changed the wording from "probably have been scored" to "might have been scored"?

    Commenter
    stojo01
    Location
    Zeadney
    Date and time
    February 24, 2013, 9:49PM
    • I would personally choose James O'Connor at 10 and Jesse Mogg at 15. I would also have Falau in the Wallabies team, but I'd put him on the wing and use him where he's most effective, under the offensive high balls.. Not sure why they put him at full back, and if they're gonna do that they should have him chasing all the high balls in attack and have Mitchell hanging back. Not sure what the 'tahs are up to!

      Commenter
      GlobalView
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      February 25, 2013, 10:26AM
      • Buddy on the weekends performance neither JOC or Folau played well enough for selection

        Commenter
        David101
        Date and time
        February 26, 2013, 8:26AM
    • Folau looks to me to be more suited to a centre role,watching the game on TV it looked as though he was out of his depth at fullback
      His positional play will improve if he remains at fullback but I think he would be a wonderful attacking force from outside centre,especially as the Tahs appear to want to run the ball this year.
      His defensive lapses were surprising given his league background and handling errors were
      un characteristic ,maybe it was nerves in a first up appearance and wanting to do well.
      He will be a great asset to the ARL by years end.

      Commenter
      Circling buzzard
      Date and time
      February 25, 2013, 10:59AM
      • @ Circling buzzard

        Folau instead of Carter maybe.....possibly....oh yes yes, please !

        That bit about....'a great asset to the ARL...'. I would think it would be more correct to say he'd be a 'diminished asset' to the ARL.
        Once bought then sold, then to buy again is always to the buyers advantage ?

        Commenter
        Machooka
        Location
        inner west sydney
        Date and time
        February 25, 2013, 12:58PM
    • I'm not sure Folau should shoulder too much blame for Shipperley's try. Understandably, he seemed to be expecting that the highly overrated AAC would live up to his undeserved hype and make the tackle somewhere in the preceding 20 metres.

      And, stojo01, I'm with you - what a disgraceful decision by Vinny Munro. These are the moments that cause people to start possibly believing that match fixing is a reality. Unfortunately Vinnie also had plenty of those moments when he had the whistle or flag, and he seems to be continuing in the same vein with the remote - let's hope its only incompetence.

      Commenter
      Interested Bystander
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      February 25, 2013, 11:19AM
      • Yeah... see when I watched that decision, I could see their point. You can't 'bat' the ball over the deadball line like you can in League. We all know that. The defender did nothing but swing his arm at the ball. He didn't attempt to ground it or catch it. Seems similar to deliberately knocking the ball down when the ball is passed in front of you (which is a clear penalty). If you did that within five metres of the tryline with a player in the clear, it would also be a penalty try.

        Therefore, if he had not done that, the ball would have been sitting (or rolling) in the in-goal, with the attacker free to pounce on it. Very high chance he would have manged to land on it, even I could have done that.

        At first it looked like a howler. But I am comfortable that it was the right decision. I have the luxury of saying that as it didn't influence the outcome. Bear in mind also that we don't want a grey area surrounding shovelling the ball out in goal to deny tries. I think this decision will make it pretty clear. Kick it sure... but don't just throw an arm at it and hope for the best like League.

        Commenter
        Lizzar
        Location
        Qld
        Date and time
        February 25, 2013, 12:11PM
      • My main beef is that I don't think the action of the defender could uncategorically be deemed deliberate. From the head on shot it appeared that he was reaching for the ball then got knocked and made a hash of it. If the attacker made contact first (and his hand was only centimetres away) would he have been penalised for a deliberate knock on?

        Commenter
        Interested Bystander
        Location
        Sydney
        Date and time
        February 25, 2013, 12:50PM
      • Agreed, but his actions never looked like an attempt to ground the ball. Only ever looked like he wanted to knock it away. Hard to force the ball or catch it with one hand, facing sideways.

        Anyhoo, all done and in the book now. Doesn't come up very often so hopefully won't see it again. BTW, think a penalty try AND a yellow card is way too much.

        Commenter
        Lizzar
        Location
        Qld
        Date and time
        February 25, 2013, 2:17PM
      • Halai is a big unit and he is faster and ahead of Savea, Savea puts a shoulder into him but doesn't budge him off the line of the ball.
        If Frank Halai didn't illegally bat the ball over the deadball line but made a legal play to ground the ball for a 22 dropout Savea would still have had to get around or ahead of Halai and ground the ball. Clearly it's a case of "might have scored".
        When I last looked the penalty try wording was "probably have scored"

        Stupid play by Halai, but we've all done things equally as stupid on a footy field, it deserved a yellow card and a penalty, but a penalty try? no way. Poor decision, if they don't agree with me on Reunion i give in.

        Commenter
        stojo01
        Location
        Zeadney
        Date and time
        February 25, 2013, 6:33PM

    More comments

    Make a comment

    You are logged in as [Logout]

    All information entered below may be published.

    Error: Please enter your screen name.

    Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

    Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

    Error: Please enter your comment.

    Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

    Post to

    You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

    Thank you

    Your comment has been submitted for approval.

    Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

    Related Coverage

    Rugby Internationals 2014

    Round 1
    Sat, 07 JunTimes shown AEST
    SAM 18 vs TGA 18 Report Stats
    FJI 25 vs ITA 14 Report Stats
    NZL 20 vs ENG 15 Report Stats
    AUS 50 vs FRA 23 Report Stats
    Sun, 08 JunTimes shown AEST
    RSA 47 vs WXV 13 Report Stats
    ARG 17 vs IRE 29 Report Stats
    USA 6 vs SCO 24 Report Stats
    CAN 25 vs JPN 34 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 2
    Sat, 14 JunTimes shown AEST
    SAM 15 vs ITA Report Stats
    FJI 45 vs TGA 17 Report Stats
    NZL 28 vs ENG 27 Report Stats
    AUS 6 vs FRA Report Stats
    Sun, 15 JunTimes shown AEST
    RSA 38 vs WAL 16 Report Stats
    CAN 17 vs SCO 19 Report Stats
    ARG 17 vs IRE 23 Report Stats
    USA 29 vs JPN 37 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 3
    Sat, 21 JunTimes shown AEST
    ARG 19 vs SCO 21 Report Stats
    FJI 13 vs SAM 18 Report Stats
    JPN 26 vs ITA 23 Report Stats
    AUS 39 vs FRA 13 Stats
    NZL 36 vs ENG 13 Report Stats
    Sun, 22 JunTimes shown AEST
    RSA 31 vs WAL 30 Report Stats
    USA 38 vs CAN 35 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 4
    Sun, 29 JunTimes shown AEST
    RSA 55 vs SCO 6 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 5
    Sun, 02 NovTimes shown AEDT
    BAR 36 vs AUS 40 Report Stats
    USA 6 vs NZL 74 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 6
    Sun, 09 NovTimes shown AEDT
    ITA 24 vs SAM 13 Report Stats
    ENG 21 vs NZL 24 Report Stats
    WAL 28 vs AUS 33 Report Stats
    FRA 40 vs FJI 14 Report Stats
    IRE 29 vs RSA 15 Report Stats
    SCO 41 vs ARG 31 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 7
    Sun, 16 NovTimes shown AEDT
    ITA 18 vs ARG 20 Report Stats
    ENG 28 vs RSA 31 Report Stats
    WAL 17 vs FJI 13 Report Stats
    SCO 16 vs NZL 24 Report Stats
    FRA 29 vs AUS 26 Report Stats
    Mon, 17 NovTimes shown AEDT
    IRE 49 vs GEO 7 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 8
    Sun, 23 NovTimes shown AEDT
    ITA 6 vs RSA 22 Report Stats
    SCO 37 vs TGA 12 Report Stats
    IRE 26 vs AUS 23 Report Stats
    WAL 16 vs NZL 34 Report Stats
    ENG 28 vs SAM 9 Report Stats
    FRA 13 vs ARG 18 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
    Round 9
    Sun, 30 NovTimes shown AEDT
    ENG 26 vs AUS 17 Report Stats
    WAL 12 vs RSA 6 Report Stats
    View All Fixtures
     
    Featured advertisers