JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Deans's Third XV faces a monumental battle but with a live chance to triumph against the odds

Date

Spiro Zavos

Backs to the wall … Wallabies coach Robbie Deans.

Backs to the wall … Wallabies coach Robbie Deans.

HOW about this line-up for a Wallabies side to play the Pumas at Rosario?

Adam Ashley-Cooper, Drew Mitchell, Rob Horne, James O'Connor, Lachie Turner, Berrick Barnes, Will Genia; Wycliff Palu, Ben McCalman, Dan Vickerman, James Horwill, David Pocock, Salesi Ma'afu, Stephen Moore, Sekope Kefu. You can choose the reserves from Christian Lealiifano, Dan Palmer, Joe Tomane, Rod Davies, Cooper Vuna, Ben Lucas, Bernard Foley, Matt Hodgson, Jake Schatz, Nic White and Matt Toomua. And if he condescends to pull on the "yellow" jersey, you can include Quade Cooper in this group as well. This collection of crocks would comfortably defeat the team of battered warriors that Robbie Deans has fielded to play a confident Pumas side.

Despite this, former Wallabies captain Andrew Slack recently gave ARU chief executive John O'Neill a dressing down for daring to make the claim that injuries have affected the Wallabies' win-loss ratio this season. But O'Neill's point is a valid one. It is not an excuse. It is more an explanation. The best Wallabies side is not on the field. Adding to the impact of the injury toll on the Wallabies is that Rosario is to Argentinians what Loftus Versfeld is to South Africans. The city has a revolutionary passion for rugby, as befits the birthplace of rugby tragic Che Guevara.

The Pumas drew 16-16 with the Springboks in their first home Test in the Rugby Championship. Last weekend the Pumas conceded seven tries to the All Blacks at La Plata. They won the approval of the rugby community, though, by trying to match the All Blacks in what may be described, using a tennis term, as an all-court attacking game.

The Wallabies, on the other hand, conceded five tries to the Springboks and were condemned. Throughout the Test, Wallabies went down like nine-pins in a bowling tournament. There were times when the Springboks' attacks were countered by a dozen Wallabies. In the circumstances, the Wallabies showed old-fashioned guts to hold the score to 31-8.

At the end of the season there needs to be a review of the injury toll. I offer these contrarian thoughts for consideration. The accepted wisdom is that the number of matches players contest should be cut. But throughout their careers, from schoolboys to first class, New Zealanders play more rugby than their Australian counterparts. Should Australia follow this model? Should the emphasis in Australia shift from the gym to more actual game time for players, at all levels? Is there too much building up of muscled contours and not enough aerobic work in the gym work?

Compare and contrast the body types and playing styles of David Pocock and Richie McCaw. New Zealand teams place a much higher emphasis on aerobic fitness than is applied in Australia. This shows up on the field and possibly in the injury lists. I was told before the June Tests by an insider (admittedly not a member of the coaching staff) that there was great concern in the Wallabies' camp about the lack of fitness of the Super Rugby players, especially those coming from the Waratahs. Are the franchises too accepting of the scientific and bio-mechanic theories and advice they are getting, when results and injuries suggests that the theories need to be challenged and perhaps adjusted?

Perhaps the most positive thing that can be said about the run of injuries is that what does not kill you makes you stronger. With 38 players used in 10 Tests, the injury toll has opened up chances for fringe players. Sitaleki Timani and Michael Hooper, for instance, should now be regulars in the Wallabies' pack for some years. Nic Phipps has shown that there is life after Will Genia. Kurtley Beale has the chance to entrench himself as the long-term playmaker in the back line.

For the Wallabies, nothing strengthens resolve and character quite like overcoming difficult times. In this context, a win tonight against the Pumas at Rosario will be one of the great triumphs of Australian rugby.

spiro@theroar.com.au

18 comments so far

  • How many NSW players in that team listed above???.....seems to be some truth...

    Commenter
    Captain & Tennille
    Date and time
    October 06, 2012, 10:00AM
    • Spiro I think you are spot on with the idea about injuries being caused by a lack of match play. The "science" must be questioned as we have so many players getting injuries that indicate a lack of match fitness. Lets' hope the Wallabies can win in Argentina but if they don't then it must be time to look for a new coach and management team...

      Commenter
      Les
      Date and time
      October 06, 2012, 10:16AM
      • If the Waratah players were not fit, why did the selectors continue to pick them in the first XV? Give the form players the chance. Who outside NZ had heard of Aaron Smith before the Rugby Championship? Unfit Weepu (big name) was put on hold.

        Commenter
        manomar
        Location
        kuala lumpur
        Date and time
        October 06, 2012, 10:58AM
        • "Tell him he's dreaming".
          Spiro, the wallabies were thrashed last weekend, and were lucky that the Springboks missed a number of real opportunities in conversions & tries.
          Comparing Timani to 'Big Kev', and Phipps as a ready replacement for Ginea is delusionary. Phipps was pedantic in his passing, which was evident when Sheens came on, and was not around when a quick ruck needed his presence. As for how many breaks he made.....
          I want the Wallabies to win, but I doubt they will.

          Commenter
          Emuarse
          Date and time
          October 06, 2012, 11:11AM
          • Absolutely agree with you about too much gym time and not enough time on the field playing the game. Problem is, how do you get this through to those who can make the changes. We desperately need a strong national competition equivalent to the Currie Cup. Union exposure in WA hopeless and we struggle to get a team up in my son's school. The future of Union in WA is bleak despite the support for the Force. Unless we increase the number of youngsters who want to play, the talented player depth for our national team will remain woeful.

            Commenter
            Alan
            Location
            Perth
            Date and time
            October 06, 2012, 11:54AM
            • Good place to start an enquiry into injuries would be to ask those who suggested the November Tour in 2011 to explain their reasoning. Then go and ask the NRL clubs how they manage to keep most of their players fit and healthy for most of the season including State of Origin.

              Commenter
              Bill
              Location
              Sydney
              Date and time
              October 06, 2012, 2:05PM
              • Not having access to fox TV I have started to watch NRL. Injuries not common at all. 2 referees helpful for the behind the play obstructions, late tackling almost non existent. Handling skills superb. Contact more controlled and rigorously policed. Suspect union could benefit from league.
                Current Wallaby injury toll is Royal Commission stuff!

                Commenter
                TJR
                Location
                WA
                Date and time
                October 06, 2012, 3:48PM
              • That's a no brainer Bill! they don't play the amount of footy the rugby kids do and they don't trip around overseas week in and week out, and the Mungo game is only half a rugby game anyway!

                Commenter
                kirky
                Date and time
                October 06, 2012, 5:35PM
              • or the all blacks

                Commenter
                tamaharry
                Date and time
                October 06, 2012, 5:38PM
            • Anyone notice the final of schoolboys game on fox 3????? NZ V OZ?? No?? What a surprise that is .......not
              I only spotted it while seeking out what ITM game was being telecast today!
              The (so called) marketing dept are the ones who should be shot. Last week I bought "The Australian" and there was not even a single column of rugby....so many other sports I will not detail them and some very "marginal"
              All week it is the ITM and Currie cup + French super 14. This is the real and BOG question not Deans or the turnstile cooper.........where is our middle competition and where is the marketing of rugby in this country.........or should we get a bigger deal from the punter sponsors?
              AS to Phipps........please, he is no replacement for Genia and Genia himself has been nullified by top teams. Timani is S15 standard no more.
              Wobblies main issues are 80% due to forward pack (other than Pocock and Sharpe putting in 100%) being an international joke......and that does include the injured beef.were they available
              Tonight the Aussies pride will be no greater than the Pumas BUT they will be massively "outpassioned" . After my first trip to Rosario a few weeks ago I was stunned by their "involvement". Being at a tahtahs game or wobblies test is similar to the funeral of a family favourite in comparison (actually make that Oz as a whole........very quiet village)

              Commenter
              headed off
              Location
              Guatavita, Colombia
              Date and time
              October 06, 2012, 3:16PM

              More comments

              Make a comment

              You are logged in as [Logout]

              All information entered below may be published.

              Error: Please enter your screen name.

              Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

              Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

              Error: Please enter your comment.

              Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

              Post to

              You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

              Thank you

              Your comment has been submitted for approval.

              Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

              Rugby Internationals 2014

              Round 1
              Sat, 07 JunTimes shown AEST
              SAM 18 vs TGA 18 Report Stats
              FJI 25 vs ITA 14 Report Stats
              NZL 20 vs ENG 15 Report Stats
              AUS 50 vs FRA 23 Report Stats
              Sun, 08 JunTimes shown AEST
              RSA 47 vs WXV 13 Report Stats
              ARG 17 vs IRE 29 Report Stats
              USA 6 vs SCO 24 Report Stats
              CAN 25 vs JPN 34 Report Stats
              View All Fixtures
              Round 2
              Sat, 14 JunTimes shown AEST
              SAM 15 vs ITA Report Stats
              FJI 45 vs TGA 17 Report Stats
              NZL 28 vs ENG 27 Report Stats
              AUS 6 vs FRA Report Stats
              Sun, 15 JunTimes shown AEST
              RSA 38 vs WAL 16 Report Stats
              CAN 17 vs SCO 19 Report Stats
              ARG 17 vs IRE 23 Report Stats
              USA 29 vs JPN 37 Report Stats
              View All Fixtures
              Round 3
              Sat, 21 JunTimes shown AEST
              ARG 19 vs SCO 21 Report Stats
              FJI 13 vs SAM 18 Report Stats
              JPN 26 vs ITA 23 Report Stats
              AUS 39 vs FRA 13 Stats
              NZL 36 vs ENG 13 Report Stats
              Sun, 22 JunTimes shown AEST
              RSA 31 vs WAL 30 Report Stats
              USA 38 vs CAN 35 Report Stats
              View All Fixtures
              Round 4
              Sun, 29 JunTimes shown AEST
              RSA 55 vs SCO 6 Report Stats
              View All Fixtures
              Round 5
              Sun, 02 NovTimes shown AEDT
              BAR vs AUS 01:30Twic
              USA vs NZL 07:00Soldier Field
              View All Fixtures
              Round 6
              Sun, 09 NovTimes shown AEDT
              ITA vs SAM 01:00Stadio Del Duca
              ENG vs NZL 01:30Twic
              WAL vs AUS 01:30MilS
              FRA vs FJI 03:45Stade Velodrome
              IRE vs RSA 04:30Lansdowne Road
              SCO vs ARG 04:30Murrayfield Stadium
              View All Fixtures
              Round 7
              Sun, 16 NovTimes shown AEDT
              ITA vs ARG 01:00Stadio Comunale Luigi Ferraris
              ENG vs RSA 01:30Twic
              WAL vs FJI 01:30MilS
              SCO vs NZL 04:30Murrayfield Stadium
              FRA vs AUS 07:00StdF
              Mon, 17 NovTimes shown AEDT
              IRE vs GEO 01:30Lansdowne Road
              View All Fixtures
              Round 8
              Sun, 23 NovTimes shown AEDT
              ITA vs RSA 01:00Stadio Plebiscito
              SCO vs TGA 01:30Rugby Park
              IRE vs AUS 03:30Lansdowne Road
              WAL vs NZL 04:30MilS
              ENG vs SAM 06:00Twic
              FRA vs ARG 07:00StdF
              View All Fixtures
              Round 9
              Sun, 30 NovTimes shown AEDT
              ENG vs AUS 01:30Twic
              WAL vs RSA 01:30MilS
              View All Fixtures
               
              Win an iPad mini by entering our Sport survey
              Featured advertisers