Click here to submit your sports results for The Canberra Times

Cricketers face sin-bin in discipline crackdown under new MCC trial laws

Show comments

Club cricketers in England could be sent off or banished to a sin-bin for 10 overs this summer as lawmakers try to address increasing levels of bad behaviour.

The Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC) is to launch a trial that will, in effect, bring red or yellow cards to club, university and schools cricket to stamp out excessive sledging and curb the increase of violent behaviour.

Up Next

Hayne: article soured relationship with Henry

Video duration

More Sports HQ Videos

Sport: The week's best plays

From turns on a sixpence to victory at the death, these are the most exciting, silly and downright crazy plays in the sporting world this week.

Five matches in England were abandoned last year due to violence and, after consulting umpire associations around the world, the MCC has decided action needs to be taken to support officials by introducing a code of conduct with four levels of offences.

Proposals include sending off a player for the rest of the match for the most serious level-four offences, such as threatening an umpire, assaulting a player, official or spectator, and racist abuse. If it is a batsman, he will be "retired out".

For a level-three offence, such as threatening and intimidating behaviour, or bowling a deliberate beamer, suggested sanctions include 10 overs in the sin-bin.

Lesser offences, including time-wasting, dissent or deliberate physical contact, such as shoulder-barging, would bring an immediate five-run penalty.


"We know anecdotally that player behaviour seems to be on the wane in cricket, certainly in this country," Fraser Stewart, the MCC's head of laws, told The London Telegraph.

"Statistics from leagues show there are increased numbers of players being reported. Last summer, five games had to be abandoned due to varying degrees of violence.

"That is an increase, for sure. It was felt that now was a good time to review this whole area."

The MCC, the guardian of the laws of the game, will be trialling these sanctions in its own matches this summer, which will include university cricket, although not games against county sides.

The MCC is hoping leagues will join in the trial with a view to the sanctions being introduced when it publishes redrafted laws of the game in 2017.

The decision to introduce the scheme to professional cricket would be made by the relevant national boards and the International Cricket Council, but they could follow suit if the MCC trial is deemed a success.

"Following a global consultation in 2015, the majority of umpires felt they would be better able to control player behaviour if they had more power to deal with the problem during the game, rather than through a reporting procedure afterwards," Stewart said.

"The benefit of this is that the offence has a consequence in that particular game, rather than in the following weeks, or the following season.

"The hope is the added deterrents will make players realise they can't behave in a poor way. We will trial it in MCC university games over the summer and hope various leagues and schools will help out and we can then examine end-of-season reports to judge its success.

"Reports show that behaviour at schools level is an issue, not violence but lots of chat and loud, persistent sledging. The umpires will have to make a call on what is sledging and what is banter."

Last summer, a man in his sixties was taken to hospital and a man in his forties arrested after a fourth XI match between Basildon and Pitsea and Stanford-Le-Hope in the Shepherd Neame Essex Cricket League ended in a punch-up.

A few weeks later a match in Pembrokeshire had to be abandoned when a fight developed between players from Saundersfoot and Kilgetty cricket clubs. Trouble was sparked by a sledging incident.

A bowler was punched unconscious and a man arrested when a match between Swindon Civil Service and Beanacre and Melksham descended into a fight.

In Shropshire, a match was abandoned when a dismissed batsman from Prees struck a bowler from Church Streeton.

The worst recent incident of violence happened in Bermuda, where a batsman was given a life ban after a horrific attack on a fellow player that was captured on film and published on the internet.

It is those kind of incidents that the MCC hopes will be curbed if the trial is a success and becomes part of the laws. Individual leagues will decide whether umpires actually brandish red or yellow cards.

"The issuing of red and yellow cards would be a major step for cricket and not one we will commit ourselves to now," said Stewart.

"Some people would be against it but, at the same time we feel, as happened in Bermuda, when a player is kicking someone on the ground, he should not stay on the field.

"Any steps taken, such as a player being asked to leave the field, would be handled through the captain."

In New Zealand last year, there was a trial of yellow and red cards and they were deemed a useful deterrent which led to a significant reduction in instances of bad behaviour.

Other areas being examined by the review of the law include the possibility of introducing a physical gauge to be carried by umpires to monitor the depth and size of bats.

'Mankading' is also on the agenda, with the possibility of introducing an official warning for a batsman before he is run out.

The Telegraph, London