JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Peter Siddle backs controversial resting policy: Geoff Lawson is wrong

Ryan Harris, Mitchell Starc, Peter Siddle, James Pattinson, James Faulkner and Jackson Bird of Australia on the Ashes tour in July. Starc, Pattinson and Bird are sidelined by injury for the summer Ashes series.

Ryan Harris, Mitchell Starc, Peter Siddle, James Pattinson, James Faulkner and Jackson Bird of Australia on the Ashes tour in July. Starc, Pattinson and Bird are sidelined by injury for the summer Ashes series. Photo: Getty Images

Australian stalwart Peter Siddle has defended the resting of fast bowlers ahead of a busy Ashes Test schedule, saying that critics of the decision don't understand the demands on modern pacemen.

Former Test greats Geoff Lawson and Glenn McGrath have attacked the resting of promising NSW paceman Josh Hazlewood from the just-completed Sheffield Shield match against Victoria, continuing calls from past players for quicks to bowl more in order to avoid the injuries that have sidelined fellow quicks Pat Cummins, James Pattinson, Jackson Bird, Doug Bollinger and Mitchell Starc.

Siddle and fellow Ashes lynchpin Ryan Harris will be rested from this week's shield games ahead of next week's first Test in Brisbane, and the 28-year-old Victorian says that makes sense.

Critics of rotation Michael Whitney, left, and Geoff Lawson in 1991.

Critics of rotation Michael Whitney, left, and Geoff Lawson in 1991. Photo: Steve Christo

"That's been the plan for a long time and . . . touch wood everything goes alright. It is a five Test series so to be backing up continuously throughout the summer . . . (you need) a bit of a break. Have that now and get ready."

Siddle says it is "disappointing" that Lawson, the NSW fast-bowling coach, does not understand why such rests are necessary.

"The simple thing is that the games have increased. There's a lot more games now than Geoff Lawson would have played," Siddle told SEN on Monday morning.

Peter Siddle (left) says it is 'disappointing' that Geoff Lawson doesn't understand why rests are necessary.

Peter Siddle (left) says it is 'disappointing' that Geoff Lawson doesn't understand why rests are necessary. Photo: Getty Images

"That's the thing that annoys me a little bit. He's had a long run of injuries throughout his career. It was said that his career lasted 10 years and Mitchell Johnson played Geoff Lawson's career in three and a half. That's a comparison of the games difference and where we're at."

In June, Cricket Australia chief executive James Sutherland said "you won't see any of that rotation policy" during this summer's Ashes series, although selectors would still "give players opportunities" in international limited overs cricket to see how they responded.

Criticism of the policy reached a fever pitch last summer after Siddle and Ben Hilfenhaus were left out of a series-deciding Test in Perth against South Africa, days after nearly bowling their team to victory in Adelaide, and Starc was stood down from the Boxing Day line-up the week after bowling Australia to victory against Sri Lanka in Hobart.

The same day that Sutherland made his comments, CA's high performance manager Pat Howard seemed to contradict his boss. "The workload management policy is still in place," he said. "The Ashes is obviously an extremely important series for us and the selectors will select the best players available for every Test.

"However, if players are injured or we are not confident a player will finish the match, the selectors will consider this. Ultimately a player needs to be able to perform for an entire match."

Whether it is labelled "rotation" or "workload management", the only thing that is agreed upon in the debate over fast bowlers is that they are vulnerable to injury until they are 24 or 25.

A recent Cricket Australia study found that "large increases in acute workload are associated with increased injury risk in elite cricket fast bowlers". It stated that "injury risk increases significantly in the week following sharp increases in acute workload".

Supporters of workload management see this as evidence for resting players who have recently experienced a large workload. Critics say it means fast bowlers have to be conditioned well enough to handle "spikes" in workload. And the only way to do that is to bowl lots of overs.

"We're limiting how much they can bowl because in the past the odd fast bowler was getting injured," fast-bowling legend Glenn McGrath told News Corp at the weekend.

"Now I think we've created problems by taking it too easy and not allowing the guys to bowl enough.

"At the start of the season you need to get overs under the belt to get up to the level you want.

"We're seeing the effects to a degree of trying to manage them.

"If you bowl 20 or 25 overs to me that's a good day in the office. I'd expect any bowler to be able to front up the next day and do the same. That's what Test cricket's about.

"I think they're going too far with this resting."

Earlier this year, a Victoria University journal article by Dr Rob Aughey and former Victorian and West Australian fast bowler (and PhD candidate) Mathew Inness concluded that "athletes tolerate constant workloads better than workloads with large variations over short periods".

"The ideal situation for an athlete would involve a steady progression in workload, combined with periods of slightly lower activity, thus allowing adaptation and therefore greater fitness and resilience to injury" Inness said when the report was released in January.

"We acknowledge the increasingly packed international schedule makes this extremely challenging – but the current rotation policy does not allow for this," Mr Inness said.

"The challenge for Cricket Australia is to strike a better balance between rest and regeneration and ensuring adequate and consistent load to build capacity and resilience in players young and old," he said.

While the debate rages around him, Siddle remains confident that going into the Ashes with a week off is necessary after a solid grounding in Ryobi Cup and shield matches over the past six weeks. "I'm feeling good," he said. "The bowling's coming along well and I've had good rhythm during the last couple of shield matches."

But he doesn't believe there is any quick answer to the fast bowling injury scourge.

"It is hard. I guess we're just probably blessed in a way that we've got such a young group of bowlers at the moment that one day hopefully will become superstars. But they're all around at the same time, so instead of having one player injured like a Brett Lee early in his career, we've got three or four players at the same age that are having those troubles.

"You've got blokes over in England – you've got Tim Bresnan and Jamie Overton – two young players that have both got stress fractures for them as well.

"We're not the only country and we're not the only people in the world having these troubles, it is worldwide, and hopefully one day we can eradicate it, but in the meantime it's just hard work."

14 comments so far

  • When you do not have full Petrol in Tank..?

    How you going to play for 25 Years.ohhhhhhi

    Commenter
    xdulkar
    Date and time
    November 11, 2013, 2:18PM
    • I don't really think it's a "sport science" problem as much as a team management problem.
      Shield cricket use to be the foundations of our national team, now it plays a distant fourth place to test, one day and twenty20 internationals, actually sixth if you consider IPL and big bash.

      Commenter
      Red
      Date and time
      November 11, 2013, 2:31PM
      • Don't understand the demands? What?

        Lawson made at least two - possibly three, I can't remember - Ashes Tours, when they played basically every county at least once as well as six Test matches, and in general the Test players were also the ODI players.
        How in God's name can someone like Lawson be accused of 'not understanding the demands?' Especially given that he's coached a Test side within the last decade.

        Commenter
        Phat Boy
        Date and time
        November 11, 2013, 2:44PM
        • Mitchell Johnson may have played Geoff Lawson's international career in 3 and half years. I am pretty confident that Geoff Lawson played Mitchell Johnsons Shield and first grade career in 2 years.
          I am pretty sure that Geoff Lawson bowled pretty quick in grade cricket (that was how you got picked for Shield teams in those days) rather than the rent seeking talent spotters and agents that pollute sport (particularly junior sport) these days.

          Commenter
          Ed J
          Location
          Petrie
          Date and time
          November 11, 2013, 2:45PM
          • and what about richard hadlee - 100 wicket / 1000 run county season and rolls up in november to roll 9 for against us .. while our managed pampered crocks cant last 2 tests on the trot

            Commenter
            8th grader
            Date and time
            November 12, 2013, 1:10PM
        • The key phrase here is "large increases in acute workload". What doesn't Howard and the boffins get - you can't keep their bowling to a minimum of 150 deliveries a week, and then get them to bowl 20 overs a day for 2 days straight. This is the "large increase" in acute workload! It's not rocket science but somehow the nineteen million scientists working for Pat Howard and CA can't see that. And what about the excess time in the gym? They look like rugby players not lean athletes that compete for days....

          Commenter
          Had Enough of Pat Howard
          Location
          Ascot
          Date and time
          November 11, 2013, 3:32PM
          • can i be had enough of Pat Howard #2? you said it all bro

            Commenter
            8th grader
            Date and time
            November 12, 2013, 1:12PM
        • its sport. you play to win. that means fielding your best and strongest team.

          if some fariy princess feels like he needs to be rested, then perhaps he is not mentally commited enough to fit into the best and strongest team. perhaps he should be playing for the local under 9s.

          youre a professional sportsman. build a bridge. get over it.

          Commenter
          Dave
          Location
          Brunswick
          Date and time
          November 11, 2013, 3:33PM
          • those mullets on Michael Whitney and Geoff Lawson are truly awe inspiring. they basically scream:

            "i am a real man. you are a softy soft marshmallow baby".

            Commenter
            Dippa
            Location
            Hawthorn
            Date and time
            November 11, 2013, 3:36PM
            • How do you feel, how do you feel? I feel like a Tooheys, I feel like a Tooheys, I feel like a Tooheys or two.

              Commenter
              Steve Rixon
              Location
              Hitting a six off the last ball
              Date and time
              November 11, 2013, 5:03PM

              More comments

              Make a comment

              You are logged in as [Logout]

              All information entered below may be published.

              Error: Please enter your screen name.

              Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

              Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

              Error: Please enter your comment.

              Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

              Post to

              You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

              Thank you

              Your comment has been submitted for approval.

              Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

              Related Coverage

              England not too old to win Ashes: Swann

              England spinner Graeme Swann insists the touring side aren't too old to reclaim the Ashes this summer.

              Phil Hughes to miss England's final tour match

              Usman Khawaja and Phil Hughes have been withdrawn from the Cricket Australia Invitational XI to play England in the tourists' final Ashes warm up match at the SCG.

              Lehmann turns to form and fitness as rotation gets a spell on the boundary

              Cutting through the jargon that turned the rotation policy into a national joke, new coach Darren Lehmann has decreed that only two things will influence the selection of Australian teams on his watch - fitness and performance.

              Rotation no help: Clarke

              Captain concedes that the lack of continuity in the Australian team is costing it momentum.

              We dropped ball on selling rotation: CA

              Cricket Australia emphatically endorsed the architects of its contentious rotation-based policy.

              Nine talks tough over cricket's absent stars

              CHANNEL Nine, one of Cricket Australia's key allies, has expressed displeasure at the sport's rotation policy after Sachin Tendulkar and Mike Hussey were rested from yesterday's one-day international in Adelaide.

              Even Lillee would need spell these days, says Charlesworth

              ONE of Australia's most versatile elite-level coaches, Ric Charlesworth, has emphatically endorsed Australian cricket's contentious rotation-based selection philosophy.

              Ponting backs rotation

              Former Australian captain Ricky Ponting has backed the controversial rotation policy and hit out at its critics.

              Arthur lashes out at critics of rotation policy

              Australian coach hits out at detractors, calling them "either naive or stubborn".

              Bowling rotation stirs up quicks

              ANGST is building over Cricket Australia's rotation policy, after fast bowler Mitchell Johnson suggested Tests should be exempt from the controversial practice and Mitchell Starc became unhappy about being rested, but national selector John Inverarity doesn't understand the fuss.

              Rotation rumours hit for six by coach

              Rotation policy - what rotation policy? Fast bowling coach Allister de Winter says Australia's Test pace attack will be picked on form and fitness.

              Rotation plan needed for quicks: Bracken

              NATHAN BRACKEN, the former Test quick suing Cricket Australia over a career-ending injury, believes Australia must consider adopting a rotation policy to get the best out of Ryan Harris, tyro tearaway Pat Cummins and rest of their portfolio of pacemen.

              Ashes 2013: Australian Test team picks itself, says Michael Clarke

              Michael Clarke says Australia's team for next week's first Ashes Test against England all but picks itself.

              Related Coverage

              Featured advertisers