JavaScript disabled. Please enable JavaScript to use My News, My Clippings, My Comments and user settings.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

If you have trouble accessing our login form below, you can go to our login page.

Wests Tigers back-rower Simon Dwyer is the NRL's forgotten man

Ignored: Former Wests Tigers back-rower Simon Dwyer.

Ignored: Former Wests Tigers back-rower Simon Dwyer. Photo: Brendan Esposito

Sunday  is all about the celebration of Alex McKinnon, and his amazing fight and attitude, but think for a moment of another young footballer whose career was taken away.

‘‘I don’t want to take anything away from Alex ... I really feel for him,’’  Simon Dwyer said.

You may not instantly remember the name. So many have forgotten about him, most notably the players’ association. He is one of the reasons why changes need to be made so professional athletes are covered by workers compensation laws.

Dwyer was the young Wests Tigers back-rower who flattened Jared Waerea-Hargreaves in one of the great tackles of the past decade.

He played City-Country and then his career came to a shuddering halt when he went in for a tackle on Bulldogs prop Michael Hodgson.

‘‘I just remember voices in my head saying, ‘I can’t move my f---ing legs’, and I couldn’t move them at all at first ... but then I got helped up and started to get movement, but I never got it in my arm,’’ he said.

As we sat in a cafe, Dwyer looked a long way from the powerful forward with the world at his feet. His right arm sat there in a sling – it hasn’t moved after that tackle.

‘‘It can be tough sometimes ... you know, just day-to-day things,’’ he said. ‘‘I had lunch with some of the boys yesterday and I ordered a steak ... I had to get Todd Payten to cut it up for me ... that’s not really what a 25-year-old bloke wants to deal with ... but I don’t want to whinge ... it was just a freak thing. I tore the nerves off my spinal cord.

‘‘They said it was the type of injury you might find with one of those high-speed skiers in the Olympics.’’

As we talked, the man on his right championing his cause was Brad Fittler. The former Roosters great has taken Dwyer on almost like a younger brother. Fittler was listening to Dwyer talk about his arm and he stopped the conversation in its tracks. ‘‘Mate, have you ever thought about chopping it off?’’  Fittler said.

Dwyer didn’t blink: ‘‘No, I’m not going to chop my arm off, mainly because I live in the hope that one day down the track they may come up with some kind of science that can help me out. I live in hope when it comes to that.’’

He also has seen a reason not to. ‘‘My dad Paul had gangrene in his leg and he faced that kind of decision and decided to fight on and now he is making real progress ... so you never know. I just need to stay positive to the best of my ability.’’

He is doing that. ‘‘I’m not speaking so people feel sorry for me. I’m over feeling sorry for myself. I’m not speaking out because of the attention that Alex is getting. I think that it’s great and Alex is in a far more challenging situation than I am in.

‘‘What I want is for all players who have had injuries that affect them for the rest of their lives to be looked after. When the Alex thing happened ... I thought that I’d like to speak to him.’’

As well as the game has responded to the McKinnon situation, it dropped the ball when it came to Dwyer. His plight was brought to the attention of the players’ association through the media, and the driving force was Fittler.

‘‘It was pretty awful that he was ignored for three years,’’  Fittler said.

‘‘It was pretty bad that the last collective bargaining agreement was negotiated without anyone taking into account the insurance for players. It doesn’t make sense that the bloke selling the hot dogs outside of the ground has better insurance than the players who are playing the game. It’s mind-boggling.

‘‘What is even harder to cop is that Simon continues to be ignored by the players’ association ... they know about his situation and they hardly make an effort to help him out. He’s been given lip service at best.

‘‘I find it hard to believe the level of neglect. It simply is not good enough. If it wasn’t for blokes like Alex McKinnon and Simon Dwyer ... I’d lose faith, but to see their attitude in adversity is what makes this game.’’

 Fittler – who has been working hard on a fundraising night for Dwyer at Wests Leagues Club on August 1 – doesn’t want credit. Instead, he said that should go to leading player agent Wayne Beavis.

‘‘When I look at what is good about the game, it’s the actions of Wayne,’’ he said. ‘‘He is not Simon’s manager, but he has been working hard for no financial gain to make sure that the night happens and that we raise money for Simon.’’

The aim is to raise $100,000. When you consider that the injury has cost him a career which could have netted him some $4 million, it is a huge financial hit for a kid who grew up in modest surrounds in Macquarie Fields. Dwyer may need the money.

He has been earning a modest salary, believed to be $60,000, working at the Tigers. It was a job that was negotiated when his new three-year deal was made redundant because of his injury. Instead of being left with 25 per cent of his contract, which was the standard settlement, the Tigers gave him a gig for the length of the contract.

‘‘That deal is up in a few months and I don’t know what I’m going to do just yet,’’  Dwyer said. ‘‘The club said it may depend on who is coaching the team. I suppose I have to start to look around. I’m not sure who would employ me, so I may need to try and start my own business. It’s a bit uncertain.’’

McLean lies low

One area  has been off limits in interviews with Alex McKinnon and those associated with him – Jordan McLean. The media around McKinnon has been brilliant – but controlled – and there is a reason for it. 

 Melbourne  are staying in close touch with McLean this weekend through their three-member counselling team. He also has his teammates to lean on as he copes with the groundswell of support for McKinnon.

 It has been relayed to this column that McLean is a huge supporter of the fundraising activities. The NRL has pulled so many right reins in this  but this column is hoping enough is being done for McLean.

 There is still an undercurrent of anger about this tackle, mainly from those close to McKinnon and his teammates. And there is disdain for the tackling technique the Storm have employed for years. 

The NRL made a big error by putting Cameron Smith up to promote the week on the day before Origin. 

His media conference was awkward as he was asked whether he had been in touch with Alex,  given he is Australian captain. He had to say no. 

Smith was criticised by this column for being over the top in arguing with the referee when McKinnon was lying injured on the ground. 

He didn’t respond then and didn’t want to deal with the matter when reporters were asking about the incident on the field, saying he’d dealt with it.

Warner’s advice

Dave Warner says fatherhood will give him an even greater reason to succeed for the rest of his career  and he is more determined then ever to be a role model once his fiancee,  Candice Falzon, gives birth in September. 

‘‘What I really want for my child is to know that there is more to life than sport,’’ he said. ‘‘I put all my eggs in the sports basket and it worked out for me, but I wish that I had gone down  the education route more. And that’s what I want for our kid. 

‘‘I’ve managed to get by. I want to help kids get to places that they want to get to. I hope I can do that by pushing the importance of being rounded and educated. 

‘‘I think it’s important to get outside of the bubble of sport. I’m not the sharpest tool  ... I grew up housing commission  ... everyone talks about it being rough. 

‘‘I sort of escaped in sport. That’s what I found interesting, but I would not encourage that. I want to see my kids hit the books and I want them to excel in that way. I’ve got around not being well educated, but I am learning on the run.’’ 

As far as being a dad, ‘‘My commitment will become a lot more  ... I’ll be even more determined and it will give me even greater reason to succeed.’’ 

Being a dad won’t make him change his approach to cricket. ‘‘I’ve got this far playing the way I do and I won’t change that,’’ he said. ‘‘You can’t be someone else out on the field and I won’t be.’’  

The couple have done a magazine deal to tell the story about their baby. Plans have begun for a wedding. ‘‘We’ve set a date ... and it’s after the World Cup final,’’ Warner said. ‘‘I’d be shot if I did it before that time.’’ 

Wolfman worry

David Williams’s welfare has been of  concern to his teammates since he was banned for betting on Manly games. 

‘‘If you know Wolfie, his highs are high and the downside of that is that his lows are really low,’’  Anthony Watmough said. 

‘‘As a group we were concerned because he was the face of it all ... which is not really fair. 

‘‘Why is he splashed all over the place and forced to wear it all when the officials who were betting were not named? I find that difficult to comprehend and to me, it’s what is good for the players should be good for the officials of the game. The good thing is Wolfie is back at training and he seems a lot better.’’ 

Testy Tigers

Wests Tigers players are fed up being painted as the instigators in the demise of coaches at the club. There is a growing feeling they are being used as scapegoats for management decisions. 

There is no doubt some players had misgivings about the appointment of Mick Potter, however the feeling among the group is they are being used to divert attention from management. 

As for Potter being responsible for retaining several star players, this column has been told Potter is minimally involved in negotiating to keep stars at the club.

17 comments so far

  • Thanks for reminding us of Dywer.There is also the young Curtis in worse state than Alex in hospital.I think the "Rise' round should have been for all players from any grade who have suffered life changing longterm injuries(in particular spinal injuries).The NRL and Players Assoc need to get this sorted smartly not leave it guys like Fittler to get things done.

    Commenter
    Jacko
    Location
    Warriorville
    Date and time
    July 20, 2014, 11:41AM
    • I was thinking the same thing. I'm glad that Alex McKinnon is receiving help and will be able to resume life as close to normal as possible. But the appeal shouldn't just benefit Alex but all players. Fund a mandatory education program aimed at school children that teaches them to avoid or not cause debilitating or life-threatening injuries.

      Commenter
      stevek
      Location
      Sydney
      Date and time
      July 20, 2014, 1:30PM
    • Thank you Danny for a timely reminder about Simon as I had assumed that the NRL had a plan to help him out and have been doing so since his injury. It seems that WT has to some extent helped but this help may be coming to an end soon. This clearly is not enough. However, the NRL is responsible for managing the game and their attempt to use Rise for Alex as a means to show that they care is rather disgraceful. Their intent is clearly to promote the NRL as a caring organisation when it appears they may not have been helping those that have suffered serious injuries playing for the NRL over the past 10 years. Not good!!!

      Commenter
      Akari
      Date and time
      July 21, 2014, 7:13PM
  • Never shy away from a good cause but let's all try and keep some perspective here.
    On any give day in Australia there are 1 million people living with similar injuries. And they, like or sports heroes, just get on with it.
    Because this level of disability can come form accidents, assults, virus or diseas there is no single charity to support. I would welcome more free publicity for some of these charities and supprt groups.

    Commenter
    Bob
    Location
    Lisarow
    Date and time
    July 20, 2014, 12:36PM
    • I've often wondered how Simon was going. I remember him well, and that famous tackle. He had a great career in front of him, and I'm shocked to read about his experience, and that he still cannot use his arm at all. That's a devastating injury which, if it happened in any other workplace, would have entitled him to financial compensation and medical care.

      Come on NRL, get your act together. There aren't so many players who suffer injuries like this that you can't take care of them like other employers do.

      Commenter
      Roger
      Location
      Surry Hills
      Date and time
      July 20, 2014, 1:02PM
      • If the NRL were genuinely concerned about player welfare, all players forced out of their game-and the only means of earning a decent living for many of them-they'd have insurance or some such in place to compensate the likes of Simon Dwyer, Taniela Tuiaki and Jharawal Yow Yeh-but they are all talk and only take action when embarrassed into it by the media, clubs et al. And just to demonstrate how shallow these cretins really are, I gather Smith's mob are telling the Wests Tigers they must include any payout of the last 2 years of Liam Fulton's contract in next years salary cap notwithstanding the fact that he's had to retire because of repeated concussions and will have to be replaced by another player whose salary will no doubt also be included. Imbeciles!

        Commenter
        curaeus
        Date and time
        July 20, 2014, 1:36PM
        • There are a lot of forgotten league stories particularly at lower levels. On Sunday Sept 6 2013 , a wonderful young guy named Andre Tuhaka took a high shot , was carried off and they turned his life support off at 11.30pm the following night. Too young to die playing a game- Val eAndre - you are missed.

          Commenter
          shane@jayfish.com.au
          Location
          Brisbane
          Date and time
          July 20, 2014, 1:45PM
          • Disgusting to try and drag the Storm tackling technique, and more to the point Cameron Smith himself into this.

            In any given game, a dozen times a captain will talk to and usually argue with a referee about a penalised tackle. Smith is a footballer, not a doctor. Has anyone had a crack about Gallen and Bird whinging to the ref in Origin about the Tate tackle and a couple of others that involved lifting? What garbage.

            Commenter
            Phat
            Date and time
            July 20, 2014, 2:04PM
            • Nope, it was poor form for Smith to try to defend his player after the incident. It was a horrific injury, McLean was put on report and you wouldn't expect the ref to reverse the decision would you?
              As for the technique, well let's not forget how many the tackling methods that have the potential to injure the player that were introduced by the Storm and are now outlawed: the chicken wing, the crusher, the grapple tackle. Have I missed any.
              As for Smith not talking to McKinnon since the incident, that's a matter for Smith.

              Commenter
              stevek
              Location
              Sydney
              Date and time
              July 20, 2014, 7:42PM
            • I agree. Perhaps some of this articles focus should be placed on the NRL and it's judicial system and the role of clubs. The performance of the Bulldogs CEO after the suspension of their player after the Tate incident in SOO was overturned was nothing short of disgusting.

              Commenter
              Ian
              Location
              Brisbane
              Date and time
              July 21, 2014, 10:46AM

          More comments

          Make a comment

          You are logged in as [Logout]

          All information entered below may be published.

          Error: Please enter your screen name.

          Error: Your Screen Name must be less than 255 characters.

          Error: Your Location must be less than 255 characters.

          Error: Please enter your comment.

          Error: Your Message must be less than 300 words.

          Post to

          You need to have read and accepted the Conditions of Use.

          Thank you

          Your comment has been submitted for approval.

          Comments are moderated and are generally published if they are on-topic and not abusive.

          Featured advertisers