On a recent winter day in New York when the sun was shining, Andrew Scott rushed into a coffee shop between recording sessions for an upcoming series.
Subscribe now for unlimited access.
$0/
(min cost $0)
or signup to continue reading
"I'm scheduled tighter than a teenage pop star," he said, beaming.
The interview had been postponed once, and the location was switched at the last minute to save Scott some time in traffic. But he sat down fully engaged and eager to start talking. Immediately, though, a passerby tapped on the storefront glass and asked for a photo. Scott, without a grumble, sprinted out to oblige, even though the gesture seemed more like a command ("You're under arrest," joked Scott) than a polite request.
Scott, the 47-year-old Irish actor, is in demand like never before. That's partly due to accrued goodwill. A regular presence on stage in the West End, Scott is known to many as the "Hot Priest" of Fleabag or the cunning Moriarty of Sherlock. Soon, he'll play Tom Ripley in the Netflix series Ripley, adapted from the Patricia Highsmith novel.
But the real reason Scott's time is short right now is Andrew Haigh's new film, All of Us Strangers. In it, Scott plays a screenwriter working on a script about his childhood. The film is gently poised in a metaphysical realm; when Adam (Scott) returns to his childhood home, he finds his parents (Claire Foy, Jamie Bell) as they were before they died many years earlier.
At the same time, the movie, loosely adapted from Taichi Yamada's 1987 book Strangers, balances a budding romance with a neighbour (Paul Mescal), a relationship that unfolds with profound reverberations of family, intimacy and queer life. In a dreamy, longing ghost story, Scott is its aching, shimmering soul.
"The challenge of it was to try to go to that place but not gild the lily too much," Scott says.
"As an actor, I have to be in touch with that playful side of myself and that part of you that's childish. I was actually quite struck by how vulnerable I looked in the film."
Scott's acutely tender performance has made him a contender for the Academy Awards. He was named best actor by the National Society of Film Critics. At the Golden Globes on Sunday (Scott wore a white tux and t-shirt), he was nominated for best actor in a drama.
Scott has long admired actors like Anthony Hopkins, Judi Dench and Meryl Streep - performers with a sense of humour who, he says, "are able to understand what you feel and what you present". Scott, too, is often funny on screen (see Lena Dunham's medieval romp Catherine Called Birdy). And even in quiet moments, he seems to be buzzing inside at some discreet frequency. Something is always going on under the surface.
He's been acting since he was young; drama classes were initially a way to get over shyness. Scott's first film role came at age 17. He has often spoken about seeking to maintain a childlike perspective in acting. In that way, All of Us Strangers is particularly fitting. On Adam's trips home, he sort of morphs back into the child he was. In one scene, he wears his old pyjamas and crawls into bed with his parents.
"So many of the things that are required of you as an actor are a sense of humour and some ability to be able to put yourself in a situation. Because it's all down to imagination," says Scott.
"For me, that's the thing you need to keep. That's the thing - because I started out when I was young - I don't want to move too far away from. Like when kids go, 'OK, you be this and I'll be this.' That ability doesn't leave us. What does leave us is a lack of self-consciousness. Our job is to hold on to that."
Haigh, the British filmmaker of 45 Years and Weekend, began thinking of Scott for the role early on. They met and talked through the script for a few hours.
"He's a similar generation to me. He's a tiny bit younger than me, but he's from the same generation," says Haigh.
"He understands that experience."
Scott came out publicly in 2013, but his natural inclination is to be private.
"I feel like I've given so much of myself in the film, you think you don't want to give it all away," he says. He describes All of Us Strangers - which Haigh shot partly in his childhood home - as personal, but not autobiographical in its depiction of the alienation that can linger after coming out.
"Mercifully, I feel very comfortable for the most part. But it stays with you that pain, and it actually makes you more compassionate, I think. Because we shot in Andrew's childhood home, that sort of threw down the gauntlet in relation to how much of his own personality he was giving," says Scott.
"I wanted it to be sort of unadorned, unarmored and raw. That's why I think there's such tenderness in the film."
Scott has sometimes recoiled from how sexuality is talked about in the media and in Hollywood. He recently said the phrase "openly gay" should be done away with. As of late December, Scott hadn't yet watched All of Us Strangers with his parents, though he planned to.
"The best way to express it is to say I'll be very sensitive to how they watch it and how they feel about it, and how it makes me feel, them watching it," Scott says.
The tenderness in the film is also owed in part to Scott's chemistry with Mescal. On-screen chemistry is an amorphous quality that the film industry has long tried to turn into a science with camera tests and marketing that flirts with real-life romance.
But for Scott, it's something different. He and Phoebe Waller-Bridge had chemistry, overwhelmingly, in Fleabag, but that didn't have anything to do with sexual attraction. Pinpointing that quality is something Scott pondered during Simon Stephens and Sam Yates' recent staging of Chekhov's Uncle Vanya at the National Theatre. Scott played all eight roles, meaning he essentially had to have chemistry with himself.
"Chemistry isn't just about sexual chemistry. It's something to do with listening, and I think it's something to do with playfulness," Scott says.
"Your ability to listen to someone and take note of what someone is doing is chemistry. You have to wait and see what the other actor is doing."
A few moments later, Scott will have to rush out just as quickly as he arrived. But before that, he leaned back, naturally lit by the winter sun, and pondered whether All of Us Strangers, in the nakedness of his performance, had taken him somewhere he hadn't before been as an actor.
"Yeah, I think so," says Scott. "Or else to return to something that perhaps I've been before."
